Unemployment eligibility guide for employers - Arizona DES breakdown
So I manage HR for a mid-sized logistics company and we just got hit with our third unemployment claim appeal in six months. I realized I actually don't understand the rules anywhere near as well as I thought I did when it comes to what makes a former employee eligible or not. We've been contesting claims on instinct basically and I think we've been doing it wrong. I've been trying to piece together an unemployment eligibility guide for employers from the Arizona DES website but honestly their documentation is scattered everywhere and half the links lead to PDFs that look like they haven't been updated since 2019. What I really need to know is the stuff that actually matters during an appeal hearing - like what counts as misconduct versus just poor performance, whether a voluntary quit can still result in the employee getting benefits, and how our responses to DES affect our tax rate going forward. Anybody here who's been through the employer side of this? Either HR folks or business owners who've dealt with Arizona DES unemployment appeals? I feel like I'm showing up to a chess match not knowing how the pieces move.
85 comments

Keisha Williams
Employer side? Good, this doesn't come up enough here. The voluntary quit piece is actually where most employers get burned - they assume if someone quits, that's the end of it. My company lost a claim two years ago because we had no documentation showing the employee left without good cause. Arizona DES will grant benefits to someone who quit if they can show they had a legitimate reason tied to working conditions, pay disputes, or something the employer did or didn't do. We learned that the hard way.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorWait, so even if they handed in a resignation letter it doesn't automatically disqualify them?
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Exactly right. The letter means nothing if they can argue the conditions forced them out. DES calls it a constructive discharge situation sometimes. Document everything on your end.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
This is so true and nobody tells employers this upfront. We had someone quit over scheduling and DES sided with the claimant because we couldn't show the schedule change was communicated properly.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Misconduct is the big one to understand. I fought a claim for about four months before realizing I was using that word wrong the whole time. What I thought was misconduct - stuff like being late a few times or not hitting targets - Arizona DES doesn't necessarily see it that way. For DES, misconduct has to show the person deliberately disregarded their duties or the company's rules in a way a reasonable employer couldn't tolerate. Poor performance alone usually isn't enough to disqualify someone.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorSo attendance issues wouldn't count as misconduct?
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Depends entirely on whether you had a written policy, warned them in writing, and they kept doing it anyway. Without that paper trail showing willful disregard, DES tends to side with the claimant.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
This matches what our employment attorney told us. The word 'willful' is doing a lot of heavy lifting in how DES evaluates these cases.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
we got burned on exactly this. three verbal warnings, nothing written down. DES approved the claim same week we contested it
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Honestly the hardest part of dealing with DES as an employer isn't even the rules - it's actually getting someone on the phone who can explain how a specific claim is being processed. I spent three weeks trying to reach their employer line and kept getting dropped or hitting a full voicemail. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically works the hold queue so you end up talking to a live DES agent without sitting on hold yourself. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see how it goes. Got my questions answered about our appeal response deadline the same day.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorHad no idea something like that existed. The DES employer line is genuinely terrible.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
Is it just for claimants or can employers use it too?
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Employers definitely can use it - I'm on the employer side and it worked fine for me. The DES agent I reached had access to the claim details and could actually walk me through the timeline.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Bookmarking this, our company has been playing phone tag with DES for weeks on a contested claim.
0 coins
Malik Davis
Can I ask something that might be dumb - does the reason we put on the separation notice actually affect what DES decides? We've been writing 'position eliminated' for layoffs but also for some situations that were more performance-related because HR told us it looked cleaner. Now I'm worried that's been hurting us.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Not a dumb question at all - yes it matters a lot. What you write on that separation notice is basically your opening statement to DES. If you write 'position eliminated' but then try to argue misconduct in an appeal, DES is going to notice the inconsistency and it won't help you.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorThis is exactly the kind of thing I didn't know. We've probably been inconsistent on these notices.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
The separation notice and your response to the initial DES fact-finding questionnaire should tell the same story. If they contradict each other, you're starting the appeal already behind.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Something else that trips up employers is the base period earnings requirement from the employee's side. Employers sometimes try to dispute claims by saying the person didn't work there long enough but that's not really how Arizona DES calculates eligibility. DES looks at wages earned during a specific base period that usually covers the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before the claim. So someone who only worked for you three months might still be eligible based on earnings from a previous employer.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorSo we can't argue they weren't there long enough to qualify?
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Right, tenure with your company specifically isn't the eligibility test. The base period pulls from across employers. Your company's wages just count toward what they earned total.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
This one surprised me when I first learned it. Former employee worked for us four months, got let go, filed a claim and DES approved it because of wages from their job before ours. We had no grounds to contest it at all.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
What about when someone gets fired for cause versus laid off? I always assumed fired for cause means they can't get benefits and that's why we've been pushing to document things as termination for cause when we let people go. Is that actually protecting us?
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Firing for cause doesn't automatically block benefits - it depends on whether the reason meets DES's standard for disqualifying misconduct. If the documented cause is performance-based rather than conduct-based, DES may approve the claim anyway. 'Termination for cause' on its own isn't magic language.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
So I had it backwards basically. I thought cause meant cause.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Lots of employers think this. What actually matters is whether the specific behavior crossed into the willful misconduct zone, not just that you called it a termination for cause.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
we went through this exact situation last year. fired someone for repeated policy violations, documented everything correctly, and DES still did a full fact-finding before they disqualified the claim. the documentation saved us but the process was not quick
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Following this thread closely because we're a small business and I've been handling our unemployment responses myself without really knowing what I'm doing. Quick question - when DES sends us that initial questionnaire after someone files, how much detail do we actually need to provide? I've been writing one or two sentences and I wonder if that's why we keep losing these.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
More detail is almost always better. That questionnaire is your chance to establish the facts before DES makes their initial determination. One or two sentences leaves DES filling in gaps, and they'll tend to fill them in favor of the claimant.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
That explains a lot honestly. I've been treating it like a form to get through rather than an actual argument.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
Think of it like this - if you don't tell DES your side of the story completely, the only story they have is the claimant's. Write out the full timeline, include policy references, attach any relevant documentation you have.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorWe've been doing the same thing. Short answers, minimal documentation. I think we've been handing these appeals to the claimants before the process even really starts.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Side note on the phone situation with DES employer line since it came up earlier - I had a really frustrating stretch trying to follow up on a claim determination that seemed wrong. After getting nowhere for over two weeks, someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. Ended up speaking with a DES employer representative who actually pulled up the claim and explained why the determination went the way it did. Would not have figured that out from the portal alone.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Two weeks of nothing then resolved in one call?
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Pretty much. The issue was that our fact-finding response had arrived but wasn't attached to the claim properly on their end. The agent flagged it internally. Never would have known that from just checking the employer portal.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The employer portal is so limited compared to what agents can actually see. This is why getting a live person matters.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
I want to flag something nobody's mentioned yet - your UI tax rate as an employer in Arizona is directly tied to your claims history. Every approved claim against your account affects what DES calls your experience rating, which then affects the tax rate you pay on wages. So beyond winning or losing individual claims, there's a financial incentive to understand the system well enough to contest the ones you actually have grounds to contest.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorI knew the tax rate was connected but didn't understand the mechanics of it. So losing claims we could have won is literally costing us money every quarter?
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Yes, your reserve ratio and benefit ratio feed into how DES calculates your rate. Employers with higher approved benefit payouts relative to their taxable wages pay higher rates. Fighting valid appeals correctly can protect your rating over time.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
This is the part I wish someone had explained to us three years ago when we first started getting claims. Would have invested in proper HR documentation way sooner.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
The rate calculation is published on the DES website if you want the actual formula. It's worth understanding even roughly so you know what's at stake with each contested claim.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
Does anyone know what happens if an employee files a claim and we just don't respond to DES at all? We had one situation where the deadline slipped by us and I've always wondered if that defaulted to the employee winning or if DES still investigates.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Not responding is basically forfeiting your side. DES makes their determination with whatever information they have, and if that's only the claimant's account, they're almost certainly approving the claim. You can still appeal a determination after the fact but you lose the advantage of shaping the initial decision.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
I had assumed there was some automatic investigation. So the initial determination really is based mostly on what gets submitted.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
DES does do some fact-finding on their own but they're not going to research your side of the story for you. The questionnaire response is your input into that process.
0 coins
StarStrider
missed a deadline once. cost us an approved claim we definitely had grounds to contest. now we have a calendar reminder for every DES notice we receive within 24 hours of getting it
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Something I figured out after a painful loss on an appeal - the distinction between able and available matters for employers too even though it sounds like a claimant-side thing. If a former employee files and you have evidence they weren't actually looking for work or had a side business they were running, that can sometimes be raised during the appeal process. DES requires claimants to be genuinely able and available for work to keep receiving benefits.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorCan employers actually raise that kind of issue? I didn't think we had standing to challenge anything beyond the separation reason.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
You can raise it in the context of your appeal response if you have direct knowledge. Like if the person told you they were starting their own business right before they left. It's not always actionable but it's worth mentioning in your documentation if relevant.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Worth being careful here though - you need actual evidence, not just suspicion. Making claims without documentation in an appeal can undermine your credibility on the parts you do have good evidence for.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The appeal hearing itself is where employers get the most nervous I think. We had our first one last year and walked in thinking it would be like a court case. It's actually more of a structured phone interview with a DES hearing officer who asks questions of both sides. The key thing is to have your documentation organized and your timeline straight because the hearing officer moves fast and you don't get a lot of time to find things.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorHow much preparation time did you have before the hearing?
0 coins
Diego Vargas
We got about three weeks notice. Used that time to organize all our written warnings, the separation paperwork, and email records. The hearing itself was under an hour.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
we had ours over the phone too. honestly the most stressful part was the claimant showing up with an unemployment advocate we didn't know about. they knew the DES process way better than we did and asked very precise questions.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
This is a good reminder that claimants can bring representation to hearings. Some employers bring their employment attorney or HR consultant for the same reason.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
just want to say this thread has been more useful than anything on the actual DES website for employers. their employer resources section is barely functional on mobile and half the guidance documents are out of date
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorFully agree. This conversation has taught me more in an hour than three days of trying to navigate their site.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
The DES website for employers feels like it was built as an afterthought. The claimant side gets a portal, weekly claims, all of that. Employers get a few PDFs.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
If you need actual up to date guidance, the Arizona Revised Statutes Title 23 covers unemployment insurance and is at least searchable. Dry reading but it's the actual law.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
One more thing on the job search requirements since it relates to eligibility from the employer side - claimants in Arizona are supposed to be conducting at least one job search activity per week to maintain eligibility. Some employers don't realize that if you have documented evidence a former employee wasn't meeting this requirement, it's potentially relevant in certain appeal situations. It's unusual to come up but it's worth knowing the full picture.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorHow would an employer even know if a former employee wasn't job searching?
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Usually you wouldn't, but sometimes situations come up - like if they told a current employee they weren't looking, or social media posts contradict their claim, or they openly started a competing business. It's rare but it does happen.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
DES audits job search logs on their own as well. The employer angle on this is minor but good to know it exists as part of the full eligibility picture.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Going back to something earlier - the base period earnings thing really matters for how employers think about their liability. When I realized claims could be charged to our account for employees who had significant earnings elsewhere, I started understanding why our tax rate was climbing. We were getting charged on claims where our portion of the base wages was actually small.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
There's actually a process to prorate charges based on base period wages across employers. If someone only earned 20% of their base period wages at your company, only 20% of their benefits should technically be charged to your account. Worth verifying with DES that claims are being charged correctly.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
I had no idea that proration existed. This is exactly the kind of thing that never gets explained clearly.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Definitely verify this directly with DES. The portal doesn't always reflect the charge allocation clearly and I've heard of employers getting overcharged on shared claims.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Late to this thread but adding one more Claimyr note since it came up - when our company was trying to get clarity on a charge allocation question like what's being described above, the portal was no help and emails to DES sat unanswered. Used Claimyr to reach a live DES employer line agent and got the allocation corrected within a few days of that conversation. Sometimes a phone call with the right person is the only thing that actually moves these issues.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Charge allocation is exactly the issue I need to resolve. Going to try this.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
The agent I spoke with could see our account history and the specific claims in question. It's the kind of conversation that just can't happen through the portal.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
Three separate people in this thread recommending the same tool is pretty convincing. Adding it to our HR toolkit.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Something that got me - when DES sends a determination and you disagree with it, you have 30 days to file an appeal. I always thought the window was two weeks so I nearly missed it on a claim last year. The 30 day clock starts from the date on the determination letter, not the date you receive it, so factor in mail time if you're not checking your DES employer portal regularly.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Author30 days from the letter date, not receipt - that's crucial to know. We've been slow about checking the portal.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Setup portal notifications if you haven't. We get emailed when anything new appears in our employer account now. That two or three days of mail time can eat into your window fast.
0 coins
StarStrider
Also worth knowing - if you do miss the deadline there's a process to request a late appeal but you need a really solid reason why you missed it. 'We didn't check our mail' typically doesn't cut it with the hearing officer.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
Has anyone dealt with a situation where a former employee was on standby status during a layoff? We had a seasonal workforce reduction and told employees to expect to be called back when volume picked back up. Some of them filed claims immediately. DES approved them, which I understood, but then when we tried to bring people back and a few refused to return, I wasn't sure how that affected their benefit eligibility going forward.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
When an employee refuses a suitable offer to return to work, that's a potential disqualifying event under Arizona DES rules. 'Suitable' has a specific meaning though - the work has to be comparable to what they were doing before in terms of wages and conditions. If you can document the offer and the refusal, you can report it to DES.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
We didn't document the return offers at all. Just phone conversations with supervisors. I'm guessing that's a problem.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Verbal offers that go undocumented are very hard to act on. Going forward, any offer to return should be in writing - email is fine - with the position details, start date, and wage spelled out clearly so there's a record DES can reference.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
DES takes refusal of suitable work seriously when it's properly reported. We did this once with three employees and two of the claims were stopped based on our documentation. The third one DES determined our offer wasn't quite comparable enough in hours.
0 coins
StarStrider
For anyone newer to this - the fact-finding stage is actually where most claims get decided, not the appeal. DES contacts both sides, reviews the responses, and makes an initial determination. The vast majority of cases never reach a hearing. So putting your effort into that initial questionnaire response is way more important than preparing for a hearing that probably won't happen.
0 coins
NebulaNova
AuthorThis reframes how I've been thinking about the whole process. We've been treating the questionnaire as a formality.
0 coins
StarStrider
It is the ballgame for most claims. A complete, well-documented response at the fact-finding stage either gets you a favorable initial determination or at minimum gives you a foundation to work from if it does go to appeal.
0 coins
Malik Davis
I wish someone had framed it this way for us years ago. We didn't understand that the initial response carried that much weight.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Agreed. And if you do end up at a hearing, your fact-finding response becomes part of the record. Contradicting yourself between the two stages is something hearing officers notice.
0 coins