
Arizona Unemployment
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I manage HR for a mid-sized logistics company and we just got hit with our third unemployment claim appeal in six months. I realized I actually don't understand the rules anywhere near as well as I thought I did when it comes to what makes a former employee eligible or not. We've been contesting claims on instinct basically and I think we've been doing it wrong. I've been trying to piece together an unemployment eligibility guide for employers from the Arizona DES website but honestly their documentation is scattered everywhere and half the links lead to PDFs that look like they haven't been updated since 2019. What I really need to know is the stuff that actually matters during an appeal hearing - like what counts as misconduct versus just poor performance, whether a voluntary quit can still result in the employee getting benefits, and how our responses to DES affect our tax rate going forward. Anybody here who's been through the employer side of this? Either HR folks or business owners who've dealt with Arizona DES unemployment appeals? I feel like I'm showing up to a chess match not knowing how the pieces move.
So I'm currently in week 6 of collecting UI through Arizona DES and something really unexpected just came up. My former employer apparently contested my claim AND I just found out I may have grounds for an EEOC complaint against them for how I was let go. I didn't quit - they pushed me out in a way that felt discriminatory based on my age (I'm 55 and was replaced by someone 28 years old with half my experience). Now I'm trying to figure out how these two things interact. Does filing an unemployment EEOC complaint affect my benefit eligibility with Arizona DES? Like if the EEOC process results in some kind of settlement down the road, does DES claw back my UI payments? I've been getting my weekly payments fine so far but I'm terrified something is going to blow up on me. I work in the construction management sector and had been with my employer for 11 years before this happened. Any insight from people who've navigated both systems at once would be really appreciated.
Halfway through week 8 waiting and I want to circle back to something OP mentioned about being replaced by someone significantly younger. For the EEOC side, that replacement evidence is actually some of the strongest evidence in an age discrimination case - it's direct comparator evidence. For the DES side, it's largely irrelevant except potentially as context showing the separation was truly involuntary. Worth understanding which evidence serves which process.
Exactly. 'Involuntary separation not due to misconduct' is the DES standard. Everything else is EEOC territory. Keep those tests mentally separate and you'll navigate both processes much more clearly.
Just got my adjudication notice yesterday so I'm brand new to all this. Reading this thread has been incredibly educational. Quick sanity check - if I've already filed a DES claim and THEN discover I have EEOC grounds, do I need to amend my DES application or add anything to it?
Exactly that. Keep your weekly claims current, keep meeting your job search requirements, and handle the EEOC process separately with appropriate legal counsel. Don't let one distract you from the other.
So my appeal tribunal hearing didn't go the way I needed it to. The judge ruled against me and said I was disqualified from benefits because of a 'misconduct' finding from my former employer, but honestly the whole thing felt rushed and I don't think half of my evidence even got properly considered. My former supervisor made statements that were flat-out wrong and I had documentation to counter them, but the hearing was over in like 25 minutes. Now I'm trying to figure out how to file a petition for review with the Arizona DES Appeals Board. I've looked around online and can't find any kind of template or sample petition that explains how to structure what I'm writing. I work in landscaping and have never dealt with anything like this before. Do I just write a letter? Does it need to follow some formal legal format? I've seen references to 'petition for review of appeal tribunal decision' in the Arizona DES documents they sent me but nothing that actually shows me what one looks like. The notice I got says I have 15 days from the mailing date to file the petition. That date is coming up fast. What exactly needs to be in this document and how formal does it need to be?
How long after you file does the appeals board acknowledge receipt? I filed mine 11 days ago and haven't gotten any confirmation that they received it. Starting to wonder if something went wrong.
Two weeks by mail and I'm at 11 days so I'm probably fine but the lack of any confirmation is nerve-wracking.
The whole appeals board petition process feels like it was designed by people who never had to actually navigate it themselves. No form, no sample, no clear instructions - just a 15-day deadline and good luck figuring out the rest.
Agreed and it's especially rough when the whole situation already has you stressed about money and you're supposed to also figure out how to write a legal-ish document with no guidance.
So I've been going back and forth trying to figure out exactly what I'm even entitled to here. Lost my warehouse supervisor job about six weeks ago when the company decided to consolidate two facilities and eliminated my entire department. No write-up, no performance issues, just a letter saying my position was 'redundant.' Filed with Arizona DES pretty much immediately but I honestly don't understand half of what I'm reading on the portal. The CACTUS system shows my claim is active but I keep seeing different statuses and I don't know what any of it means. Like what actually IS an unemployment benefit in terms of what I should expect to receive? I know there's a weekly amount but I have no idea how they calculated mine or if it's even right. I worked at that warehouse for about 4 years making decent money and I'm worried they calculated it based on old pay periods or something. I also don't know if I'm supposed to be applying to jobs every week or if there's some minimum number. My determination letter had all this language I didn't fully understand. Can someone who's actually been through this explain what the weekly payment process looks like and how the whole thing works from a regular person's perspective? I feel like I'm flying blind here.
One thing nobody has mentioned yet - if your former employer contests your unemployment claim, which some employers do even for legitimate layoffs, you'll get a notice from DES about an employer protest and your claim goes into a more involved adjudication review. This isn't common with straightforward eliminations but it does happen. If it happens to you, respond to every DES request for information within the timeframe they give you, provide documentation of the layoff circumstances (your termination letter, any HR communications), and do not miss the response deadline. Employer protests that go unresponded to by the claimant often result in disqualification by default even when the claimant would have won on the merits.
That letter is gold. A written statement from the employer acknowledging this was a business decision rather than anything performance-related is exactly what DES looks for in a layoff case. Employer protest becomes very hard to sustain when there's documentation like that.
Reading back through this thread I realize there's a lot of good info scattered around so let me try to summarize the key things for OP and anyone else who finds this later: 1. 'Eligible' status is good - means your layoff was accepted as a valid separation 2. First payment is usually delayed by the mandatory unpaid waiting week - this is normal 3. File weekly certifications every Sunday/Monday without fail, never skip 4. Document every job contact - date, employer, position, method - keep it in a spreadsheet 5. Report all earnings during certification weeks including gig work 6. If you need to reach DES about a payment issue or flag on your account, phone is the only real option 7. If you get a disqualification notice, 30 days to appeal and don't miss it 8. Keep your termination/layoff documentation safe forever
Saving this whole thread. I'm new to this process too and there's so much here that I didn't know. The weekly certification thing alone probably saved me from a major mistake.
So my situation is kind of unusual and I've been trying to figure out how my payments get calculated. I picked up a part-time gig driving for a local catering company - only work Saturdays, so basically once a week for maybe 5-6 hours. The rest of the week I'm still job hunting and I filed my initial Arizona DES claim about three weeks ago. Here's what's confusing me: when I log into the CACTUS portal and fill out my weekly certification, there's a section asking about any earnings. I reported my Saturday pay but I genuinely have no idea how DES calculates what I still receive in UI benefits after they see that income. Like is there a formula? Do they just subtract dollar for dollar? Or do I still get something decent? My weekly benefit amount was set at $240 based on my previous full-time job in restaurant management. I'm making about $80-90 on a typical Saturday with the catering gig. I want to keep doing this work because it helps with groceries but I'm scared it's going to wipe out my entire unemployment check and then some. Anybody gone through this and can explain how Arizona DES handles partial week earnings? I don't want to mess up my claim by doing something wrong.
One more thing worth flagging for anyone in a similar spot: if the part-time job eventually becomes more than part-time and they start offering you regular full-time hours, you're generally expected to accept that work. Turning down an offer of suitable full-time work from your current part-time employer could potentially result in a disqualification from UI benefits. Claimyr helped me get clear on where that threshold was for my situation when my catering gig started increasing my hours significantly.
Suitable work factors include the wage (should be comparable to your previous job eventually), commute distance, and whether it matches your skills. An agent can explain how DES evaluates that for your specific previous wage level.
Just scrolled through this whole thread and want to say this is probably the most useful partial-earnings discussion I've seen on here. Quick summary for anyone who finds this later: - Disregard = 25% of your weekly benefit amount - Report earnings in the week you earn them not when you get paid - File your weekly cert even when you expect $0 payment - Three job search contacts still required even with part-time work - Quarterly wage reconciliation happens so report accurately - Cash earnings count exactly the same as payroll
Good summary. The only thing I'd add is that if anything about your specific situation seems different from the standard rules, talking directly to an Arizona DES agent is worth the effort to sort it out.
Omar Fawaz
Has anyone dealt with a situation where a former employee was on standby status during a layoff? We had a seasonal workforce reduction and told employees to expect to be called back when volume picked back up. Some of them filed claims immediately. DES approved them, which I understood, but then when we tried to bring people back and a few refused to return, I wasn't sure how that affected their benefit eligibility going forward.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Verbal offers that go undocumented are very hard to act on. Going forward, any offer to return should be in writing - email is fine - with the position details, start date, and wage spelled out clearly so there's a record DES can reference.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
DES takes refusal of suitable work seriously when it's properly reported. We did this once with three employees and two of the claims were stopped based on our documentation. The third one DES determined our offer wasn't quite comparable enough in hours.
0 coins
StarStrider
For anyone newer to this - the fact-finding stage is actually where most claims get decided, not the appeal. DES contacts both sides, reviews the responses, and makes an initial determination. The vast majority of cases never reach a hearing. So putting your effort into that initial questionnaire response is way more important than preparing for a hearing that probably won't happen.
0 coins
Malik Davis
I wish someone had framed it this way for us years ago. We didn't understand that the initial response carried that much weight.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Agreed. And if you do end up at a hearing, your fact-finding response becomes part of the record. Contradicting yourself between the two stages is something hearing officers notice.
0 coins