Back to Arizona Unemployment

Emily Thompson

Unemployment eligibility fired after giving four week notice - what happens with Arizona DES?

So I'm in a situation I really didn't see coming and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. I work in logistics and gave my employer a four-week notice back in mid-January because I had a potential job lined up. The new job fell through during week three of my notice period, so I went to my manager and said hey, I'd actually like to stay if that's possible. They said no, we already started the transition, and then - here's the kicker - they handed me a termination letter and officially fired me before my notice period was even up. So I didn't quit, technically they let me go while I was still an active employee during my notice window. I filed with Arizona DES about a week after this happened and now I'm just sitting here wondering if they're going to count this as a voluntary quit or as a termination. My claim is still processing. Has anyone been through something like this where the employer kind of used your notice against you? Really not sure how Arizona DES is going to look at this.

Week two of waiting on my own claim and I stumbled onto this thread - your situation is actually way more common than people realize. The key thing Arizona DES looks at is what actually ended the employment. If your employer issued a formal termination letter before your notice date was up, that is documented proof that THEY severed the employment relationship, not you. The fact that you expressed a desire to stay and they said no actually works in your favor because it shows your intent was not to leave voluntarily at that point. Keep that termination letter somewhere safe, it's your most important document here.

0 coins

Gather every email and text from that last week before they handed over that letter. My sister had something similar - she asked to rescind her notice and they refused in writing. Arizona DES sided with her because there was a paper trail showing SHE wanted to keep working.

0 coins

does the termination letter actually matter or can the employer just tell DES whatever they want anyway

0 coins

The letter matters a lot. Arizona DES will contact your employer and they'll have to explain why they terminated you during your notice period. If you have documentation that you asked to stay, that tells a very different story than a simple voluntary quit.

0 coins

Day 19 waiting on adjudication and I just want to flag something for OP that might save some time - if your claim gets flagged or adjudication drags on, getting an actual human at Arizona DES on the phone is brutal right now. I finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and they have a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y - it got me connected to an agent way faster than anything I'd tried before. For your situation specifically you might want to call in and make sure Arizona DES has the termination letter on file before an adjudicator makes a decision without seeing it.

0 coins

Bookmarking this, thank you. I'm worried they might just see 'gave notice' in the employer's response and close the case without digging deeper.

0 coins

claimyr worked for me too, got through in like 45 min when i'd been trying for days on my own

0 coins

Thirty-one days into my own adjudication nightmare so I feel this thread deeply. The part about your situation that actually matters legally is whether you had a firm quit date that hadn't arrived yet when they terminated you. If you gave notice for April 15th and they fired you on April 1st, you were still an employee on April 1st and that IS a termination, full stop. It's not a gray area, it's just that some employers try to frame it as accepting your resignation early.

0 coins

Mine was exactly like that - I had a specific end date and they cut me off 11 days before it. I didn't even clean out my desk voluntarily, they walked me out.

0 coins

Honestly this is such a predatory thing for employers to do. They get to push you out and then try to claim it was your decision. Arizona DES really needs to scrutinize these cases harder.

0 coins

The frustrating part is some adjudicators do get it right and some don't. That's why appealing if you get denied is so important - you can present the actual timeline.

0 coins

My claim got approved last month after a similar mess and what I'd tell you is this: 30 days is the window you have to appeal if Arizona DES denies you, so keep track of that date the moment you get any determination letter. I almost missed that deadline because I thought I had more time and my neighbor had to basically yell at me to file the appeal paperwork. Don't sit on a denial.

0 coins

File your weekly certifications too even while you're waiting on the initial determination. If you get approved retroactively you want those weeks on record.

0 coins

Already doing the weekly certifications, good call. And noted on the 30-day appeal window, I didn't realize it was that short.

0 coins

yeah the appeal window sneaks up on people, the DES letter buries it in like page 2

0 coins

Exactly, it's not in bold or anything, it's just kind of there. Set a phone alarm the day you get any determination letter.

0 coins

Just got off the phone with Arizona DES this morning after three weeks of trying, so I'm feeling practically giddy. Your case sounds like what they sometimes call an 'accelerated separation' - when an employer decides to cut a notice period short. The tricky part is that Arizona DES will look at your original intent when you filed the notice. They'll ask: were you leaving for work elsewhere, and did that reason still exist when they fired you? Since your new job fell through and you asked to stay, your original reason for leaving was actually gone. That's a big deal.

0 coins

Wait, so does it matter that OP was originally planning to leave voluntarily? Like does that original intent count against them?

0 coins

It can be a factor but the stronger argument is that by the time they fired OP, OP no longer had any intention of leaving. The employment relationship only ended because the employer chose to end it.

0 coins

This is the right read. I work in HR and this is a standard situation where the employer basically converts what could have been a quit into a termination by not accepting the rescinded notice.

0 coins

Three weeks post-determination on my own claim and I want to add something nobody has mentioned - when Arizona DES contacts your former employer, the employer is going to characterize this however benefits them. Probably as 'employee resigned.' You need to make sure Arizona DES has YOUR written statement in the system before that employer response comes in. Log into your CACTUS portal and look for a way to upload documentation or add a statement to your claim.

0 coins

Logging into CACTUS right now to check if there's an upload option. I didn't realize I could add a statement proactively.

0 coins

i thought the adjudicator just calls you if they need more info?

0 coins

They might call but they also might not, or they might call at a time you can't answer. Don't wait for them to come to you, put everything in the portal.

0 coins

This is good advice. I've seen people lose straightforward cases just because the employer submitted their version first and it took the narrative.

0 coins

My determination letter finally showed up yesterday - four weeks of pure silence before that. Wanted to come back and say that for anyone stuck trying to reach Arizona DES to check on a claim like this one, Claimyr (claimyr.com) is worth looking at. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that explains what they do. I used it when my adjudication was dragging and I needed to know if they were waiting on documentation from me - turns out they were and I had no idea.

0 coins

Does it matter what time you try to reach DES through that? Or is it the same as calling in yourself?

0 coins

In my experience it worked better than any time I tried calling on my own. I'd been getting disconnected constantly before that.

0 coins

Starting to think I need to do this, my portal hasn't updated in 9 days and I have no idea if they need anything from me.

0 coins

The employer argument in these cases is almost always going to be 'voluntary quit' because that way they don't get a UI charge on their account. Something that might help - $3,500 is about what a quarter of UI benefits runs in Arizona, and employers fight these cases because those charges add up for them. That's not your problem but knowing why they'll push back helps you prepare.

0 coins

wait so the employer actually has to pay into something when someone collects unemployment? i never knew that

0 coins

Basically yes, it affects their tax rate. So employers definitely have a financial reason to contest claims and argue it was a voluntary quit.

0 coins

this explains SO much about why my old boss was so aggressive about fighting my claim lol

0 coins

Just hit week six of my claim sitting in adjudication so I'm deep in this stuff. Something that tripped me up early on - there's a difference between 'quit with good cause' and 'discharged for misconduct' and what you're describing is actually neither of those. You're describing a situation where the employer made the final call to end employment. If Arizona DES tries to code it as a voluntary quit, that's actually the wrong code for what happened. Ask specifically what separation code they used if you talk to an agent.

0 coins

Didn't even know separation codes were a thing. That's really helpful to know what to ask.

0 coins

Separation codes matter a lot. Some adjudicators flag certain codes for deeper review automatically.

0 coins

And if the wrong code is in there it can delay everything because the questions they ask you are based on that code.

0 coins

About halfway through what feels like a decade-long wait on my claim. OP - one practical thing nobody has said yet: when you file your weekly certifications, in the section that asks about your work separation, be consistent with how you describe it every single week. Say the same thing each time: your employer ended your employment before your notice period was complete. Don't word it differently week to week because inconsistency can flag your claim.

0 coins

This is something I would not have thought of at all. I think I've been phrasing it slightly differently each week.

0 coins

Consistency is huge. I had an adjudicator point out that I described my separation two different ways and it added two weeks to my review.

0 coins

Two letters into this process (a questionnaire and a request for more info) and I wanted to push back gently on something. A few people here are saying this is a clear-cut case but it really depends on how Arizona DES interprets 'voluntary separation.' Some adjudicators will look at the original decision to give notice as the initiating event and see the whole thing as voluntary. OP should be ready to argue that their circumstances materially changed during the notice period and that they made a good-faith effort to remain employed.

0 coins

That's fair, it's not guaranteed. The 'changed circumstances' argument is exactly the right frame though. OP's reason for leaving no longer existed and they communicated that.

0 coins

So I should explicitly say that my reason for leaving (the other job) no longer existed when they terminated me. Got it, that's the framing I'll use.

0 coins

And document that you communicated this to your employer - even a text saying 'I'd like to stay if possible' is evidence that you tried to rescind.

0 coins

Got my adjudication interview scheduled for next week and reading this thread obsessively. This might be a dumb question but - when Arizona DES contacts you for an interview about your separation, do they tell you in advance what they're going to ask? I keep second-guessing how I'll explain my situation.

0 coins

They usually ask basic chronological questions: when did you tell your employer you were leaving, what was your last day supposed to be, what happened to change that. Practice walking through the timeline out loud.

0 coins

Thank you, actually going to record myself explaining it tonight just to make sure I don't ramble.

0 coins

They'll also ask if you have any documentation. Have your termination letter, any emails about asking to stay, and your original notice letter all pulled up and ready.

0 coins

Adjudication interview done, waiting on my determination - sharing what I know while I'm here. The job search requirement doesn't pause during adjudication. You still need to make your three employer contacts per week and log them. If you get approved you don't want any gaps in your job search record.

0 coins

Three contacts per week is the current requirement right? I want to make sure I'm hitting the right number.

0 coins

Yes, three verified contacts per week in Arizona right now. Keep your log detailed - job title, company, how you applied, date.

0 coins

i thought it was two contacts lol good thing i'm reading this

0 coins

Finally received my payment yesterday after almost six weeks - for anyone still trying to reach Arizona DES to get updates on a situation like OP's, I want to put in a word for Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video of how it works is at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. Used it at week three when my claim had gone completely dark and I needed to know if they'd received my employer's response. Got connected and found out there was a simple documentation issue I could fix same day. Would have been longer without that call.

0 coins

Try this tonight because I've been leaving voicemails for two weeks and nothing.

0 coins

The voicemail thing is basically a black hole in my experience. Actually reaching someone is what moves things.

0 coins

Real question - what do you even say when you get through? I never know what to ask for.

0 coins

Ask for the status of your claim, ask if they're waiting on anything from you, and ask what the current expected timeline is for your adjudication. That's it. Keep it short.

0 coins

On my third weekly certification and already getting nervous about my claim status. Reading through this whole thread - OP, your best outcome here is if Arizona DES finds that your employer discharged you, not that you quit. Everything in the thread about preserving documentation is right. One thing to add: if you're able to get through to an agent, ask them to note in your file that you have documentation of a formal termination letter and documentation of your request to rescind your notice. Getting that noted proactively can sometimes flag the right person to review it.

0 coins

Makes sense to have it in my file verbally too, not just uploaded documents. I'll ask them to note it when I call in.

0 coins

Pull together everything chronologically before you call too. Date of notice, date you asked to rescind, date of termination letter. Having the exact dates ready makes the call go way faster.

0 coins

Letter from Arizona DES sitting open in front of me right now asking me to explain my separation - just got it today. OP, something from my own experience: the initial questionnaire they send has very limited space and the questions can feel leading. Don't just answer yes or no. Use every bit of space they give you to explain that you gave notice, the reason for the notice became invalid before the notice period ended, you requested to remain employed, and your employer chose to terminate you anyway. Full story, every time.

0 coins

The leading questions thing is a real concern. I'll make sure to give full context and not just check a box.

0 coins

Attach a separate page if needed. Arizona DES will accept additional documentation and adjudicators do read it.

0 coins

Yes, I stapled a one-page timeline to mine. Clear, dated, factual. Adjudicators are processing a lot of claims so making it easy to understand your situation helps.

0 coins

Deep in week four of my claim with nothing but a 'pending' status. This thread is making me feel less alone but also more stressed. Does anyone know if Arizona DES is slower than usual right now? My CACTUS portal has not moved in literally 17 days.

0 coins

Adjudication timelines have been stretching to 5-6 weeks on cases with any employer dispute, which anything involving notice periods usually has.

0 coins

17 days without movement is not unusual right now unfortunately. The employer response period alone can take up to two weeks.

0 coins

Okay so I'm probably not falling through the cracks, it's just slow. That's slightly reassuring I guess.

0 coins

Just passed the 40-day mark waiting on my own claim - solidarity to everyone in this thread. OP, I just want to say the detail about you walking back to management and asking to keep your job is probably the strongest thing in your favor. That's not what someone who wants to quit does. Make sure Arizona DES hears that specific detail because it shows your intent had changed.

0 coins

I actually have a text message where I said 'is there any chance we can reconsider, the new position fell through.' That's pretty direct evidence of my intent.

0 coins

Screenshot that and get it uploaded to CACTUS immediately. That text is gold.

0 coins

Seriously, that text message changes your case significantly. That's the kind of thing that makes an adjudicator's decision very clear-cut.

0 coins

Just starting this whole process for the first time - honestly the whole DES system is confusing to me. Can you even file unemployment if you gave notice at all? Like does that automatically count against you?

0 coins

Giving notice does not automatically disqualify you. What matters is what actually ended the employment. If the employer fires you, lays you off, or discharges you during or after your notice period, you can absolutely be eligible.

0 coins

Think of it this way - plenty of people give notice, finish their two weeks, and then file unemployment when their next job doesn't work out or falls through. The notice period itself isn't disqualifying.

0 coins

oh okay that makes way more sense. i thought giving any kind of notice meant you were automatically counted as quitting

0 coins

That's a really common misconception. Voluntary quit means YOU decided to end employment on a specific day. If the employer intervenes and ends it earlier, or on different terms, that's on them.

0 coins

Coming back with an update since this thread helped me so much. My claim came through as ELIGIBLE. The adjudicator determined it was a discharge, not a voluntary quit. The text message where I asked to stay was specifically mentioned in the determination letter as evidence that I had rescinded my intent to leave. For anyone reading this later: document everything, upload it to CACTUS, stay consistent in your weekly certifications, and hit your job search contacts every week. And seriously, if you're stuck trying to reach DES, use whatever tools you can to get a human on the phone because sometimes one conversation can clarify something that would otherwise drag for weeks.

0 coins

This is such a good outcome and a perfect example of documentation actually making the difference.

0 coins

Congrats!! So happy for you, this thread was helpful for my own claim too even though my situation was different.

0 coins

Great result and really important for others in similar situations to see. The text message rescinding your intent to quit was the key piece.

0 coins

This thread should be required reading for anyone who gets fired during a notice period. Everything that helped OP is replicable - document, upload, stay consistent.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure