Unemployment denied not enough earnings base period wages from another state - Arizona DES situation
So my claim just got flat out denied and the reason they gave me was that my earnings don't meet the minimum threshold for Arizona. Here's the thing though - I only moved here about eight months ago from out of state, and the bulk of my work history and wages are from my previous state. I worked a pretty solid construction job there for almost two years before my company relocated me to their Arizona office, then laid me off four months later. The Arizona wages alone are nowhere near enough to qualify me apparently. I filed thinking they'd look at my whole work history but the denial letter just references Arizona wages only. The letter mentions something about a 'base period' but doesn't explain what happens when most of your earnings came from somewhere else before you moved. Did I completely waste my time filing here? Is there any way to get them to count what I earned before I moved? I have all my W-2s and pay stubs from both states. Really frustrated because I actually worked consistently for years and now I'm being told I don't qualify like I never worked at all.
70 comments

Katherine Hunter
Combined wage claims are exactly what you need here and most people have no idea this option exists until after they've already been denied. What happened to me was similar - I got a denial letter, assumed it was final, and almost gave up. The process is called a combined wage claim and it lets Arizona DES pull in your wage records from other states to beef up your base period earnings. You have to specifically request it though, they don't automatically do it.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorGoing to look into this right now - do I request it through my CACTUS portal account or do I have to call?
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Same question actually, I never saw any option like that on the portal when I went through my denial last year
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Portal doesn't have a direct option for it in my experience. You basically have to reach out to Arizona DES directly and ask them to initiate the combined wage claim process. The other state's agency will get contacted and they verify and transfer your wage records over.
0 coins
Donna Cline
your base period matters a LOT here. Arizona calculates your base period as the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. so if you only had four months of AZ wages those might all fall in just one quarter and that's rarely enough to hit the earnings floor on its own
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorThat explains why the number looked so low on my denial paperwork, I was confused about what quarters they were even looking at
0 coins
Harper Collins
wait does the base period work the same way for combined wage claims or does it recalculate somehow
0 coins
Donna Cline
Same base period quarters apply, they're just pulling wages from multiple states that fall within those same quarters. So if you had wages in that other state during those quarters they get added in.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
this is actually really helpful I always thought the base period reset if you moved states lol
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Calling Arizona DES to get a combined wage claim started is genuinely painful, I spent three days hitting busy signals and getting disconnected before I tried Claimyr. You go to claimyr.com, there's a video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y showing how it works, and they basically get you connected to an actual DES agent without you sitting on hold for hours. Got my combined wage claim initiated in that one call after I'd been spinning my wheels for days trying to reach someone on my own.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorSaving that link, the phone situation has already been a nightmare just trying to get basic answers
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Had a similar experience trying to reach DES about an adjudication issue last month, the hold times are brutal
0 coins
Gianna Scott
does claimyr work for all DES stuff or just certain claim types
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Worked for my combined wage claim situation specifically but I'd assume it connects you to general DES agents who handle all claim types
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Few things worth knowing about the combined wage claim process from when I went through it. First thing that tripped me up - Arizona has to be the state you file through, which you've already done correctly. Second, the other state doesn't just hand over your wages automatically, they have to verify employment and confirm those wages are transferable. Took about two to three weeks in my case before my claim status updated.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorTwo to three weeks is longer than I was expecting but at least there's a resolution at the end of it
0 coins
Sydney Torres
mine took closer to a month because one of my former employers was slow responding to the wage verification request from my old state
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
employer response time is a real wildcard in this process, if you have your W-2s and paystubs ready it can help speed things along if DES asks for supporting docs
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
DONT GIVE UP just because of that denial letter!! I literally threw mine away thinking it was over and my sister had to talk me into calling back. the denial is not final if you request the combined wage claim within the appeal window, which I believe is 30 days from the date on that letter so check the date NOW
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorChecked the letter, I have 22 days left so I need to move fast on this
0 coins
Caleb Bell
yes please move fast on it, that 30 day window is not flexible in my experience
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
glad you caught it in time, I almost missed mine by like a week
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Something that confused me for a long time was the difference between appealing a denial and requesting a combined wage claim - they're not the same thing even though both involve responding to a denial. An appeal contests the decision Arizona DES already made. A combined wage claim request is you saying hey, here are additional wages you didn't have access to, please reconsider with this new information. I mixed these up and filed a formal appeal when I should have asked for the combined wage process first.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorThis is genuinely useful because I was about to file an appeal thinking that was the right path
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
Went through almost the exact same confusion last year. My denial was for the same reason yours sounds like, not enough AZ-only wages. After about a week of getting nowhere with appeals paperwork I found out about Claimyr and used it to actually get a DES agent on the phone who explained the combined wage option to me directly - claimyr.com if you haven't bookmarked it yet. Night and day difference having an actual person walk through it with me.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
having a real agent explain it makes a huge difference, the DES website language around this is not particularly clear
0 coins
Lucas Parker
the portal really should flag this automatically when you file from another state recently but it doesnt, found that out the hard way when my claim got denied same as yours
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorMakes no sense that the system doesn't catch it during filing
0 coins
Lucas Parker
right like they have your address history and SSN wage data, should be obvious
0 coins
Abigail Patel
agreed the system is kind of built to let you fail quietly and figure it out yourself which is frustrating
0 coins
Daniel White
Quick clarification on something that gets mixed up a lot - base period wages from your previous state have to actually fall within the Arizona base period quarters to count. If your main job in the other state ended way before you moved and those wages fall outside the base period window, the combined wage claim won't help as much as you'd hope. Sounds like yours might be okay since you worked there recently but worth confirming which quarters your wages fall in.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorLooking at my pay stubs now - looks like my last full year at that job would overlap with the base period quarters, so fingers crossed
0 coins
Sydney Torres
that's the key thing to check before you get too far into the process
0 coins
Daniel White
if even two of those quarters show wages above the quarterly minimum you should be in decent shape for qualification
0 coins
Nolan Carter
My denial letter had the same 'insufficient base period wages' language and I panicked thinking I did something wrong on my application. Spent like four days assuming I was just ineligible before someone in a different forum thread mentioned combined wage claims. Wish this information was more visible somewhere official.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
the DES website buries this information pretty deep, took me forever to find any official page about it
0 coins
Nolan Carter
literally searched for like an hour and ended up learning more from random forum posts than from the official site
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
same honestly the official FAQ is not particularly helpful for edge cases
0 coins
Caleb Bell
Worth double-checking your alternative base period eligibility too while you're at it. If your wages still don't hit the minimum even after combining, Arizona allows an alternative base period that uses more recent quarters. It's a fallback option and not everyone qualifies but if the standard base period calculation comes up short it's worth asking about.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorDidn't even know that was a thing - will ask about both options when I reach a DES agent
0 coins
Donna Cline
alternative base period is underused because people don't know to ask for it, good call mentioning it
0 coins
Caleb Bell
exactly, DES won't necessarily bring it up on their own so it helps to ask specifically
0 coins
Gianna Scott
went through this process and honestly the hardest part is just getting DES on the phone to start anything. once you have an agent they're actually fairly helpful about combined wage claims, it's just getting to that point
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorThat tracks with everything I've been reading - the contact barrier seems to be the biggest obstacle
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
100% true, once I had someone on the line they knew exactly what to do and walked me through every step
0 coins
Gianna Scott
the system itself when you get in it works fine it's just the access problem that kills you
0 coins
Natalia Stone
Used Claimyr a second time actually when my combined wage claim stalled out and I needed a status update - claimyr.com again, same easy process. The agent I reached confirmed my other state had submitted the wage verification and my claim was in final review. Knowing that saved me a week of anxious checking on the portal. For something time-sensitive like a 30-day appeal window I'd use it again without hesitation.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Good to know it works for follow-up calls too not just the initial contact
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorBookmarked it, especially given my timeline is tight at this point
0 coins
Natalia Stone
yeah for a 22-day window I wouldn't rely on leaving voicemails and hoping, worth using something that actually gets you through
0 coins
Sydney Torres
One more thing that caught me off guard - when Arizona contacts your previous state's unemployment agency to request wage records, that state may contact your former employer to verify. If you left that job on bad terms or there's any dispute about your separation, that can complicate things. Not saying it will, just that it's good to know so you're not blindsided if there are questions.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorLeft on decent terms, company-wide layoff so no disputes there - but good to flag for others reading this
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
employer verification step is where things slowed down for me too, former employer took their time responding
0 coins
Sydney Torres
a layoff with documentation is usually the cleanest situation for wage verification, you should be okay
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Does anyone know if there's a way to check whether your previous state has already reported your wages to the federal system? I know there's some kind of national wage database but I never figured out how to access it or if that speeds up the combined wage process
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Wage records get reported through ICON which is an interstate data network but claimants can't access it directly, it's agency-to-agency. What you can do is request your wage statement from your former state's unemployment agency which at least tells you what they have on file.
0 coins
Daniel White
never knew that database existed, good info
0 coins
Abigail Patel
thanks, didn't realize it was restricted but makes sense to request the wage statement from the other state just to have it
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
filing the weekly claims while all this is processing is something people forget about - if your combined wage claim gets approved retroactively they typically only pay weeks where you filed a continuing claim, so keep certifying every week even while your claim is under review or in this transition process
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorReally glad someone said this, I was going to pause my weekly claims until this got sorted out
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
don't pause them, that's one of the most common and costly mistakes people make during adjudication or any kind of review
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
yes this is so important, file every week no matter what is happening with your underlying claim
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
just want to say this thread is exactly what i needed to find, literally in the same situation with wages from two states and got the same denial letter last week. been freaking out thinking i had no options
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorHang in there - from everything in this thread there's definitely a path forward, check your denial date and move on the combined wage request quickly
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
will do, calling tomorrow morning and gonna try that Claimyr thing if I can't get through
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
you got this, just don't let that 30 day window slip
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Ran across this thread while searching for the same issue. Mine resolved last month through the combined wage process. Quick note on timing - the whole thing from initial contact to updated claim status took me about five weeks total. Used Claimyr about midway through when I hadn't heard anything for two weeks and needed to know if my claim was actually moving - worth it just for the peace of mind of knowing it hadn't fallen through the cracks somewhere.
0 coins
Emma Morales
AuthorFive weeks is good to know so I can set realistic expectations instead of panicking at week two
0 coins
Harper Collins
knowing it actually resolves and doesn't just hang forever is reassuring
0 coins
Tasia Synder
it does resolve, just takes some patience and staying on top of it - good luck to everyone in this thread
0 coins