Back to Arizona Unemployment

Lucy Taylor

Is the withholding account number the same as the unemployment account number on Arizona DES?

Okay so I'm filling out some tax paperwork for my employer and they're asking for a withholding account number. I've been receiving unemployment benefits through Arizona DES and I pulled up my CACTUS portal to find my account number, but now I'm second-guessing myself because I see multiple numbers on there and I genuinely don't know which one applies to what. Is the withholding account number the same as the unemployment account number? Like are these two different things entirely or is there some overlap? I work in construction and my employer switched payroll systems so they're asking everyone to verify these numbers and I really don't want to give them the wrong one and mess something up. Any help would be appreciated.

Two different accounts, full stop. Your employer's withholding account number is what the Arizona Department of Revenue assigns to businesses so they can remit income tax withheld from employee paychecks. Your unemployment account number through Arizona DES is a completely separate identifier tied to your UI claim specifically. They're issued by different agencies and serve different purposes entirely. The confusion makes sense because both relate to taxes in a roundabout way, but you should not give your DES UI account number to your employer for withholding purposes.

0 coins

Wait so my employer needs a number from the Department of Revenue, not from DES at all? I think I've been looking at completely the wrong thing this whole time.

0 coins

Payroll departments ask for this constantly and confuse employees every single time. Your employer already has their own withholding account number from ADOR - they're probably asking you to verify your SSN or state ID for their records, not for you to provide some separate number. Worth double-checking exactly what document they sent you.

0 coins

This. My construction company did the exact same thing when they switched to a new payroll software last spring. The form looked like they were asking employees for account numbers but they actually just needed us to re-verify our W-4 info. Read the instructions on whatever form they gave you really carefully.

0 coins

Honestly the number of times I've seen people mix these up is wild. Speaking of trying to get clear answers though - when I had a confusing situation with my own DES account last year I could not get anyone on the phone to explain anything. A coworker told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - basically it handles the hold time for you so you actually end up talking to a live Arizona DES agent instead of sitting on hold for three hours. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see how it works. For account number questions specifically, talking to an actual agent is so much faster than guessing.

0 coins

Three hours on hold sounds about right from what I've heard from friends who've dealt with DES. I'll check out that video, thanks.

0 coins

Tried phoning DES myself six times in one week before I finally got through. Would have been useful to know about something like that earlier.

0 coins

My sister had a similar phone situation - kept getting disconnected after waiting forever. She eventually got through by going super early in the morning but it took multiple days of trying.

0 coins

30 days into dealing with an adjudication hold was when I finally learned this lesson the hard way - the two numbers are completely separate systems. Arizona DES assigns your UI claimant ID, which shows up in your CACTUS portal and is specific to your unemployment claim. Your employer's withholding account number comes from ADOR and is basically their business license to hold back state income tax from wages. If your employer is somehow asking YOU for a withholding account number to give to THEM, that's genuinely a strange request because they should already have that number from when they registered as a business in Arizona.

0 coins

Adjudication hold for 30 days sounds awful - hope that got resolved. And yeah I'm starting to think maybe my employer worded their form really poorly and they don't actually need me to look anything up.

0 coins

Honestly employers mess up these forms all the time. HR departments put together templates and half the time the fields don't even apply to half the employees. Worth just emailing your payroll department and asking them specifically what number they need and from what document.

0 coins

This is the right answer. I emailed my HR person when this happened to me and she was like 'oh sorry, that field is just for vendors not employees, ignore it.' Ten second email saved a ton of confusion.

0 coins

Okay wait I'm confused about something related - when I filed my Arizona DES claim they gave me a claimant ID number and also there's some kind of employer account number that showed up in my portal. Are those the same thing or different things too? Sorry to hijack the thread but I'm having the same type of number confusion.

0 coins

Your claimant ID is yours as an individual filing for UI benefits. The employer account number you're seeing might be your former employer's DES account number - Arizona DES assigns those to employers separately so they can track wage records and tax contributions. They're definitely not the same number.

0 coins

Ugh okay so there are like four different numbers floating around and none of them are the same. This system is not intuitive at all.

0 coins

DES portal honestly looks like it was designed in 2003 and never updated. The labels on half the fields tell you nothing about what the number actually is for.

0 coins

Honestly the first time I logged into CACTUS I had no idea what I was looking at. Spent like an hour just figuring out which section had my actual claim status.

0 coins

Something that helped me - I called ADOR directly (not DES) when I had a tax account number question and they were actually pretty easy to reach compared to DES. If your question is specifically about state income tax withholding for your employer, ADOR is the right agency, not Arizona DES at all. The two agencies handle completely different things even though both acronyms sound government-y and confusing.

0 coins

Good point - I think I've been going to DES for everything unemployment-and-tax-adjacent when really these are separate agencies. That distinction actually helps a lot.

0 coins

ADOR's website is also way easier to navigate than DES in my experience. Their search function actually works.

0 coins

Agreed on ADOR being easier to reach. Got someone on the phone in like 20 minutes when I had a question about employer withholding. DES is a whole different story when it comes to phone wait times.

0 coins

my employer asked me something similar last month and I completely panicked thinking I had done something wrong with my unemployment claim lol. turned out they just needed my arizona state tax ID which is literally just tied to my SSN. not a separate number at all. so it might be even simpler than everyone is making it sound depending on what exactly your employer needs

0 coins

Ha - the panic is real. Good to know it might be simpler than I think. I'm going to actually read the form more carefully and probably just ask HR what specific number and document they want.

0 coins

Yep. Nine times out of ten when an employer asks for 'account numbers' from employees it comes back to SSN or EIN-related stuff that the payroll system already has. The form just uses confusing language.

0 coins

Had a similar account number mess when I was switching jobs and still had an open DES claim at the same time. I ended up using Claimyr to get through to Arizona DES and finally got an agent who explained exactly which numbers in my CACTUS portal corresponded to what. Claimyr is at claimyr.com - cleared up weeks of confusion in one phone call.

0 coins

Weeks of confusion in one call is exactly what I need right now honestly. I'll look into it.

0 coins

Same situation for me - open claim plus new job paperwork at the same time is a recipe for number confusion. Having an actual agent walk you through your portal is so much more useful than trying to decode it yourself.

0 coins

The agents do actually know their stuff when you can get one on the phone. That's always been my experience - the problem is just getting to that point.

0 coins

The employer side of DES is actually a totally separate portal from the claimant side. Employers log into the Unemployment Tax and Wage System (UCTS) to manage their tax account with DES. When you log into CACTUS as a claimant you're in a completely different system and your account number there has nothing to do with your employer's withholding setup. So there's not just two different numbers - there are literally two different systems with two different sets of numbers.

0 coins

UCTS is a name I've never heard before and I've been dealing with DES stuff for two years. Good to know that's a thing that exists.

0 coins

Yeah the employer-side of DES is surprisingly robust but most claimants never see it because they only ever interact with CACTUS. The withholding account numbers your employer uses are completely invisible to you as an employee.

0 coins

Wait so when my employer was contesting my unemployment claim, they were doing that through a totally different portal than the one I was using? That explains why the communication felt so disjointed.

0 coins

Something I learned when my adjudication dragged on forever - if there's ever a discrepancy between what your employer reports to DES and what you've claimed, it can create these weird gaps where nobody can figure out whose number is whose. When you're talking to DES always use YOUR claimant ID from CACTUS, not anything your employer gave you. The agents use your claimant ID to pull up your specific file.

0 coins

My adjudication being mentioned scares me a little - hoping this withholding number situation doesn't somehow affect my claim status. Though based on this thread it sounds like they're completely separate systems so probably fine.

0 coins

Completely separate. What happens in CACTUS with your UI claim has zero connection to your employer's withholding setup through ADOR. You're good.

0 coins

The fear of anything affecting your claim while adjudication is pending is REAL. I checked my portal three times a day during mine. But yes these are genuinely different things that don't talk to each other.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the EIN your employer uses is the same as their DES employer account number? Because my new employer asked me about their own EIN and I told them to check their DES account but now I'm worried I sent them in the wrong direction too.

0 coins

EIN is a federal number from the IRS - it's different from the state-level DES employer account number. So technically different numbers again, though employers often have all of these on file together. Your employer's accounting department should have both readily available without needing to look at DES at all.

0 coins

Of course they're different. Why would anything ever be the same number. I'm going to start a spreadsheet just to keep track of which government number does what.

0 coins

A spreadsheet is genuinely a great idea. I keep one with my claimant ID, my SSN, my ADOR state tax ID, and my employer's EIN all in one place. Saved me multiple times during job searching when different apps and forms asked for different combinations of these.

0 coins

Can't believe I've never thought to do this before. Usually I'm scrambling through five different portals trying to find the right number when I'm filling out forms under a deadline.

0 coins

Okay genuinely asking - when I was on standby status with DES my employer asked for my 'state unemployment account number' on some form. I gave them my CACTUS claimant ID. Was that wrong? Nothing bad happened but I never knew if I gave the right thing.

0 coins

Standby situations are interesting - there might actually be a scenario where your employer legitimately needs your claimant ID if they're coordinating with DES on your standby status. So it may have been exactly right. If nothing went wrong, it was probably fine.

0 coins

Phew. The standby period was already stressful enough without thinking I may have handed out wrong numbers everywhere.

0 coins

Standby status coordination between employers and DES is a whole thing that most employees don't understand. If your employer was actively communicating with DES about keeping you on standby, your claimant ID is exactly what they would have needed.

0 coins

EVERY SINGLE PIECE OF GOVERNMENT TAX PAPERWORK should just come with a glossary explaining what each number is and where to find it. I have been employed off and on for 20 years and I still cannot reliably tell you off the top of my head which number goes where on which form. The fact that this thread exists proves the system is broken.

0 coins

20 years of experience and still confused is honestly validating to hear. I thought it was just me not being smart enough to figure this out.

0 coins

It's genuinely not intuitive. I have a college degree and I regularly have to look up which tax number does what. The government has had decades to make this clearer and they just... haven't.

0 coins

The IRS website actually has decent explanations now but good luck finding the right page. Arizona state agencies are a lot harder to navigate online for plain-language explanations.

0 coins

For what it's worth, your Arizona DES CACTUS account should have a 'Contact Us' message option in the portal itself. I used that once to ask about which identifier I needed to reference when calling in about my claim. Got a response in about three days. Slower than a phone call but at least it's in writing so you have documentation of what they tell you.

0 coins

Three days is actually not bad - I've heard of people waiting weeks for portal messages to get answered. I might try that route just to have something in writing.

0 coins

In-writing responses are underrated. I saved a message from a DES rep that basically confirmed my claim was in adjudication for a specific reason and that documentation ended up being super useful later in my appeal.

0 coins

Exactly - when you're dealing with something that might affect your benefits or your employment, having a written record of what an official told you is worth the wait.

0 coins

Came across this thread while dealing with my own account number confusion and want to add - when I finally got a live agent at Arizona DES on the phone via Claimyr (claimyr.com), she specifically told me to never share my CACTUS claimant ID with anyone other than DES itself. Employers don't need it, payroll systems don't need it, and giving it out unnecessarily is just bad practice. Worth knowing.

0 coins

That's actually a really useful thing for an agent to have told you. I'm glad to know not to give that number to my employer just because they asked for 'an account number.

0 coins

Makes sense from a security standpoint too. The fewer random people and systems that have your government benefit account numbers the better.

0 coins

Good policy. Your claimant ID combined with other info about you could potentially be used to interfere with your claim. DES agents are the only ones who need that specific identifier.

0 coins

Just want to summarize what this thread has established for anyone who finds it later: 1) Your DES CACTUS claimant ID is for YOUR unemployment claim only. 2) Your employer's DES account number is a separate number they got when they registered as an Arizona employer. 3) Your employer's withholding account number is from ADOR (Arizona Department of Revenue) not DES. 4) Your SSN or federal EIN are different from all of the above. These are four completely separate things. If a form is confusing about which one it wants, ask HR to clarify specifically.

0 coins

This is the clearest thing I've read all day. Bookmarking this comment. Thank you.

0 coins

Someone should pin this. The number of times this confusion must come up for people dealing with both active employment and unemployment benefits at the same time is probably enormous.

0 coins

Good summary. The only thing I'd add is that if you're in adjudication or have an active appeal with DES, your claimant ID is the most important number to have memorized because every DES agent you speak to will ask for it immediately.

0 coins

I did not know my claimant ID mattered that much. Writing mine down right now.

0 coins

Random but related - when I filed my taxes last year TurboTax kept asking for Arizona state withholding info and I genuinely went to my CACTUS portal looking for it before realizing that my W-2 from my employer had everything TurboTax needed. The DES portal had nothing to do with my income tax filing at all. The mental overlap between 'unemployment' and 'taxes' makes our brains go to DES for everything when really DES is only for one very specific slice of the tax world.

0 coins

This happened to me too. Spent 45 minutes in CACTUS convinced I was missing some document before my partner pointed out the W-2 was sitting on my desk.

0 coins

The W-2 situation is actually worth flagging for OP - if you received unemployment benefits in a tax year you should also get a 1099-G from DES for those benefits. That IS a DES document relevant to taxes, but it still has nothing to do with your employer's withholding account.

0 coins

Oh great point on the 1099-G. That confused me the first year I got one too. It comes from DES but it's about reporting your unemployment income, not your employer's withholding setup.

0 coins

OP - one more thing worth checking. If your employer is asking about withholding specifically in the context of garnishing wages or some kind of income withholding order, that's a completely different situation that would involve the courts or potentially a child support agency, and would have nothing to do with either DES or standard payroll withholding. Just flagging because 'withholding account number' can mean different things in different contexts and construction industry payroll can get complicated.

0 coins

No nothing that complicated thankfully - it was definitely standard payroll system migration stuff. But good to know that phrase can mean different things in different situations.

0 coins

Good catch raising that. Income withholding orders have a whole separate paper trail and involve a totally different set of agencies and account numbers again. Glad that's not what OP is dealing with.

0 coins

Is there any situation where your DES account number and your withholding account number WOULD be the same? Like is there some edge case where these overlap or is it always going to be different numbers?

0 coins

No scenario I know of. They're assigned by completely different agencies using different numbering systems - DES and ADOR don't coordinate their account number formats with each other. The chance of them being the same number by coincidence would be astronomically low, and even then they'd still represent completely different things.

0 coins

Okay good. I was worried there was some weird exception I'd stumble into. Sounds like the answer is just always going to be 'different numbers, different agencies, different purposes.

0 coins

Exactly. The only connection between DES and withholding is that employers pay unemployment insurance tax to DES AND withhold state income tax for ADOR - but these are two separate obligations they have as employers, tracked in two separate systems, with two separate account numbers.

0 coins

Just want to say I went through almost this exact situation six months ago and was totally lost. Found my way through eventually but it took way longer than it should have. If you're ever unsure about anything related to your actual DES claim specifically, being able to talk to an agent directly is the fastest path. I've heard people mention Claimyr as a way to get to an agent without spending your whole day on hold - seems worth knowing about if the portal messages aren't cutting it and you need answers fast.

0 coins

Six months ago and still navigating it - respect. And yeah at this point I think my situation is sorted enough that I don't need to call DES, but I'm saving that info for the next time something comes up with my actual UI claim.

0 coins

The 'spending your whole day on hold' part is not an exaggeration. I once had a half-day off work specifically to try to reach DES and still didn't get through before I had to log back into my job.

0 coins

Half a PTO day just to attempt a phone call to a government agency is genuinely absurd. The system makes it really hard to get basic questions answered in any reasonable timeframe.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure