Back to Arizona Unemployment

GalaxyGuardian

Can you get unemployment if you quit? My Arizona DES situation explained

So I walked off my job at a distribution warehouse about six weeks ago and honestly didn't think I had any shot at unemployment. My hours had been getting slashed every week for two months, dropping from 40 hours down to like 18-19, and my supervisor kept telling me 'it's temporary' but nothing changed. I finally hit a wall and put in my two weeks. A coworker told me flat out that quitting means you get nothing from Arizona DES, so I didn't even file right away. Then my landlord texted me about rent and I figured I had nothing to lose by trying. Submitted my claim on the CACTUS portal and now I'm sitting here wondering if I made a mistake waiting so long and also whether this is even going to go anywhere. The adjudication status is showing but no explanation of what they're actually looking at. Did anyone else quit and still manage to get approved? What made the difference?

Hours cut like that — did you document any of it? Text messages, pay stubs, anything showing the reduction?

0 coins

Yeah I have my pay stubs showing the weekly hours and I kept a few texts from my supervisor saying the schedule was 'subject to change.' Not sure if that's enough.

0 coins

That's actually solid. Arizona DES adjudication officers look for exactly that kind of paper trail when you're claiming a quit was forced by conditions. The pay stubs especially.

0 coins

Same thing happened to my brother-in-law, he had pay stubs and they still denied him first round. So don't get your hopes too high before adjudication finishes.

0 coins

Okay so I went through almost this exact thing last spring. My hours got cut and I quit, filed with Arizona DES, and my claim went into adjudication for like five weeks. The thing that ended up mattering in my case was something called 'good cause' — basically Arizona DES has to decide whether a reasonable person would have quit under the same circumstances. Dramatic hour cuts that change your financial situation can count. It's not automatic but it's not impossible either. Keep filing your weekly claims while adjudication is pending, that part is really important.

0 coins

Five weeks — that's a long time to wait. Did they contact you at all during that period or did it just suddenly change status?

0 coins

Mine just flipped status one day with no warning. Got a letter in the mail a few days after the portal updated. No phone call or anything during the wait.

0 coins

This is right about the weekly claims. I made the mistake of stopping mine during adjudication thinking there was no point. Lost out on weeks of benefits even after I got approved.

0 coins

What counts as good cause though? Like is there an actual number where hours have to drop to?

0 coins

Honestly the adjudication wait is the worst part because you can't get anyone at Arizona DES on the phone to explain what's happening. I burned through three days of redials trying to reach someone about my own quit situation last year. My sister actually told me about Claimyr — it basically stays on the line with Arizona DES for you until a live agent picks up, so you don't have to sit there hitting redial. I ended up talking to an actual DES rep who walked me through exactly what documentation they needed for my good cause claim. Site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see it before trying.

0 coins

Three days of redials — I cannot do that right now mentally. This is good to know, I'll check out that video.

0 coins

I've heard of people using that for adjudication questions. Did the agent actually tell you useful stuff or just generic 'wait for a letter' answers?

0 coins

The agent I talked to was actually specific. Told me they needed written documentation of the hour reduction and to upload it through the portal. Generic stuff from the automated system would not have helped me figure that out.

0 coins

Calling DES has been a nightmare for me too. Couldn't get through for two weeks straight on my claim.

0 coins

My neighbor quit her retail job over unsafe conditions and filed with Arizona DES. They denied her the first time and she appealed. During the appeal she brought in photos, an incident report she'd filed with the store, and written statements. She won on appeal. So even if adjudication doesn't go your way, it's not over.

0 coins

The appeal process — is that something she did on her own or did she get help?

0 coins

She did it herself. The appeal form on the CACTUS portal walks you through it. She said the hardest part was the actual hearing where you present your case, but the appeals board was fair.

0 coins

Appeals take a while too. Mine took about eight weeks from filing to hearing. Worth it though, I won and got all my back weeks paid.

0 coins

Hearing?? Like in a courtroom?? I'm freaking out now reading this.

0 coins

Let me break down the quit rules the way my adjudication officer explained it to me when I went through this. I had quit a call center job because they moved my shift without notice and it conflicted with my kid's school schedule. The officer told me Arizona DES looks at whether the reason you quit was something the employer caused or allowed to get bad enough that staying wasn't reasonable. Hour reductions that are severe and prolonged can hit that threshold. What matters is: how much did they cut, over how long, did you tell anyone at work about the problem before quitting, and did you try to resolve it. That last one tripped me up — I hadn't put anything in writing to my supervisor before I left. I still got approved but it was close.

0 coins

Did not put anything in writing — that's me too. Should I be worried about that?

0 coins

Not necessarily a dealbreaker. The pay stubs showing the reduction are strong evidence on their own. If you talked to your supervisor about it verbally, mention that in any adjudication interview they schedule.

0 coins

The 'did you try to fix it first' question is so important and nobody tells you about it ahead of time. I wish I'd known that before I quit my job.

0 coins

wait so you can actually get unemployment for quitting?? I thought that was just automatic disqualification no matter what

0 coins

That's the most common misconception about Arizona DES. Quitting creates a presumption against you but it's rebuttable if you had good cause tied to working conditions.

0 coins

Wow okay so I may have messed up not filing when I quit my old job six months ago

0 coins

Yeah the 'quitting = no benefits ever' thing is not how it actually works. Arizona DES evaluates the circumstances.

0 coins

My situation was way different — I quit because my commute went from 20 minutes to over an hour each way when they moved locations. Filed with Arizona DES and got denied. The adjudication officer said commute changes alone usually don't meet good cause unless they're extreme or you have health issues that make long commutes a problem. Just sharing because not all quit reasons are equal.

0 coins

An hour commute each way seems pretty significant to me. Did you appeal?

0 coins

Nah I didn't. By the time I got the denial I'd already found a new job. Looking back I probably should have at least tried.

0 coins

That's wild, an hour commute change feels like it should count. The rules seem really inconsistent.

0 coins

Still in adjudication after four weeks and couldn't get any answers from Arizona DES by phone on my own. Used Claimyr last week and got through to an agent same day. She told me my claim had a flag on it because my former employer contested it — something I had no idea about from the portal. That info changed everything about how I prepared my case.

0 coins

Employer contested it — I hadn't even thought about that possibility. How do you find out if yours did?

0 coins

The agent told me directly. I don't think there's a way to see that on the CACTUS portal itself, at least not on mine.

0 coins

Employers contesting is really common when someone quits. They argue you quit voluntarily without cause, which protects their unemployment tax rate.

0 coins

This is so frustrating. The whole system feels designed to make you give up.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet — make sure you're meeting the job search requirements while your adjudication is pending. Arizona DES requires you to report job search activities every week even if your claim hasn't been decided yet. Missing those requirements can affect your claim separately from the quit issue.

0 coins

How many job contacts per week are required? I've been applying but didn't realize I needed to log them.

0 coins

Right now it's typically two employer contacts per week minimum reported through the CACTUS portal when you file your weekly claim. Keep records of every application, company name, date, contact method.

0 coins

This is a really important point. I was laser focused on my adjudication issue and almost forgot to file a weekly claim one week. Don't let that happen.

0 coins

THREE MONTHS waiting on adjudication for my quit claim and Arizona DES never once reached out to me. Not a single letter, not a note in the portal. I finally got approved but only after I figured out how to reach an actual human at DES. Spent weeks trying to get through on the phone. When I finally did, using Claimyr because nothing else was working, the agent told me my claim had been sitting waiting for a document I never knew I needed to upload. THREE MONTHS. That document took me ten minutes to find and upload.

0 coins

Three months without any communication — that's terrifying. So they can just sit on a claim indefinitely?

0 coins

Apparently yes. And when you can't get anyone on the phone you have no idea that's what's happening. The portal just says adjudication pending forever.

0 coins

This is exactly why talking to an actual agent matters so much. The portal tells you almost nothing useful.

0 coins

Three months and a ten-minute fix. That's genuinely infuriating. I'm sorry you went through that.

0 coins

Okay so I want to push back a little on the idea that good cause is easy to establish. I had my hours cut too — from 36 to 28 hours — and Arizona DES denied me. Said the reduction wasn't substantial enough to constitute a material change in employment. I appealed and lost. So 'hours got cut' by itself isn't magic, it really does depend on how much and for how long and what your financial situation looked like.

0 coins

36 to 28 is still a big cut percentage wise. What did they say the threshold was?

0 coins

My adjudication officer didn't give me a specific number. It seemed like they looked at the whole picture — my prior wages, what 28 hours covered, whether I'd communicated the hardship to my employer. I hadn't done that last part.

0 coins

This matches what I understand — there's no bright-line hour number. It's a totality analysis. The OP going from 40 to 18-19 over two months is a much steeper reduction, which might be more persuasive.

0 coins

Has your employer responded to the DES yet? That's often the thing that determines how long adjudication takes. If your employer fights it, it drags on. If they don't respond, it usually moves faster.

0 coins

No idea how I'd find that out from the portal. It just shows 'adjudication in progress.

0 coins

Yeah the portal doesn't really tell you that. That's one of the things an agent can tell you if you can get one on the line.

0 coins

My employer fought my claim and adjudication took almost seven weeks. Former coworker who quit the same week as me, employer didn't respond, her claim resolved in two weeks.

0 coins

i quit my job in january over harassment and filed and mine got denied. they said i should have reported the harassment through internal channels first before quitting. now im appealing and its so stressful i dont even know if its worth it

0 coins

The 'exhaust internal remedies first' requirement is real but it has exceptions — if reporting internally would have been futile or if the harassment was severe enough that your safety was at risk, those are grounds to argue you couldn't be expected to try internal channels first.

0 coins

i did actually report it once to HR and nothing happened. does that count as trying?

0 coins

Yes, one documented report to HR with no meaningful action taken can satisfy the 'tried to resolve it' requirement. Put that in your appeal and get any evidence of that HR report you can find.

0 coins

Document everything for your appeal. Any email, any HR ticket number, any witness who knew about the harassment. Appeals boards take documentation seriously.

0 coins

What happens if adjudication decides against you? Do they want money back or just deny future payments?

0 coins

If they deny the claim during adjudication, they typically won't have paid out anything yet, so there's nothing to pay back. The overpayment situation usually comes up differently — like if they initially pay you and then determine later you weren't eligible.

0 coins

Okay that's slightly less terrifying. So adjudication denial just means no benefits going forward unless I appeal?

0 coins

Right, and you have 15 days from the determination notice to file an appeal if you want to challenge it.

0 coins

15 days goes fast. Mark your calendar the day you get any determination letter.

0 coins

took me forever to realize i could appeal anything with arizona des. thought the first decision was just final and that was it. lost out on probably months of benefits because nobody told me there was an appeal process

0 coins

How did you eventually find out about appeals?

0 coins

Someone in a Facebook group told me. Definitely wasn't anything DES communicated clearly to me.

0 coins

The appeal rights are listed in the determination letter but in small print. Easy to miss when you're stressed and just reading the denial part.

0 coins

My hearing was actually over the phone, not in a room anywhere. Lasted maybe 25 minutes. The hearing officer asked me questions, my former employer was also on the line, and I got to respond to their claims about why I quit. It felt intimidating but it was much more low-key than I expected going in.

0 coins

Phone hearing — okay that's way less scary than I was picturing. Did you have to have a lawyer?

0 coins

No lawyer. You can bring one but it's not required. I prepared by writing out a timeline of events and had my documents open on my laptop during the call.

0 coins

Did your former employer say stuff that wasn't true? That's what I'm scared of happening in mine.

0 coins

They did say some things I disagreed with. The hearing officer let me respond each time. Having documentation meant I could point to specifics rather than just saying 'that's not right.

0 coins

Just wanted to circle back and say Claimyr actually saved me during my own adjudication wait last fall. I'd been trying to get through to Arizona DES for two weeks, nothing was working, tried every time of day. Used Claimyr and had an agent on the line within the same morning. She confirmed my claim was fine and just waiting on employer response — I had no idea and was spiraling thinking I'd done something wrong. The peace of mind alone was worth it.

0 coins

Peace of mind is exactly what I need right now. The not-knowing is honestly the hardest part of this whole process.

0 coins

The CACTUS portal is so vague. 'Adjudication in progress' tells you nothing about whether you're close to a decision or whether something is stuck. An actual human can tell you that in two minutes.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying and same morning with that — yeah I'd say that's worth it.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later — quit situations that have the best shot at Arizona DES approval based on what I've seen in these forums: significant hour/pay reductions that you documented, unsafe working conditions you reported, medical necessity to leave, domestic violence situations, and following a spouse who relocated for work. Random personal reasons, commute inconveniences, didn't like the job, quit for a better opportunity that fell through — those tend not to work.

0 coins

This is a really useful summary. My situation is the hours reduction one so I'm hopefully in the better category.

0 coins

40 hours to 18-19 over two months with pay stubs is a genuinely strong fact pattern. I'd be surprised if that didn't at least get serious consideration.

0 coins

The domestic violence one is worth highlighting. Arizona DES has specific provisions for that and claimants often don't know it applies.

0 coins

what counts as unsafe working conditions? like how unsafe are we talking

0 coins

Update request — OP what happened with your claim? I've been following this thread and want to know how it resolved.

0 coins

Still pending as of two days ago. I uploaded my pay stubs through the portal and I did end up getting through to an agent who confirmed my employer responded but didn't say what they said. At least I know it's moving. Trying to stay patient.

0 coins

Getting through to an agent and knowing it's moving is honestly progress. Hang in there.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for you. The documentation you have sounds solid for a good cause argument.

0 coins

Keep filing those weekly claims no matter what. Even if adjudication takes longer, you want those weeks on record so you get paid for all of them if approved.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure