Back to UCC Document Community

Emma Wilson

UCC search services - which ones actually catch all the lien variations?

I'm drowning in UCC search services and honestly don't know which ones are worth the money. My company does asset-based lending and we've had TWO deals this quarter where our search service missed existing liens that should have been obvious. One was a debtor name variation (John Smith vs J Smith) and another was a filing number transposition that didn't get caught. We're currently using a major provider that shall remain nameless, but their search results keep missing stuff that shows up when I manually dig through the SOS database. The problem is I can't manually search every deal - we process 40+ transactions monthly. Anyone have experience with UCC search services that actually do comprehensive name variation searches? I need something that catches: - Common name abbreviations and variations - Previous business names - Spelling variations - Related entity searches The missed liens cost us serious money when we had to negotiate subordination agreements after the fact. Can't keep happening.

I feel your pain on the name variation issue. We switched services last year for the exact same reason. The one we use now does pretty good cross-referencing but you still gotta be careful with how you input the search parameters. What kind of collateral are you typically dealing with?

0 coins

Mostly equipment financing and some inventory. The John Smith thing was on a $2.8M equipment deal where the existing UCC-1 was filed under 'J Smith' but our search only looked for exact matches.

0 coins

Ouch, that's expensive. Yeah equipment deals are tricky because the collateral descriptions can vary so much between filings too.

0 coins

This is why I always run searches through at least two different services for anything over $500k. The cost of redundant searches is nothing compared to a missed lien. Have you considered the issue might be more about verification than just the initial search?

0 coins

What do you mean by verification? We get the search results but reviewing dozens of potential matches manually takes forever.

0 coins

I mean actually verifying that the documents you pull match your debtor properly. I've been using this tool called Certana.ai that lets you upload your documents and it cross-checks everything automatically. You just upload the UCC search results and your loan docs and it flags any inconsistencies.

0 coins

That sounds interesting. Does it handle the name variation stuff too?

0 coins

Yeah, it picks up on name discrepancies between documents that you might miss. Really handy for catching those J Smith vs John Smith situations.

0 coins

Honestly the whole UCC search industry is broken. These companies charge premium prices but their databases are only as good as what the individual state systems feed them. And don't get me started on the lag time for new filings to show up...

0 coins

The lag time is brutal. I've seen new UCC-1s take 3-4 days to show up in search results in some states.

0 coins

Exactly! And by then your deal could already be closed. The whole system needs an overhaul.

0 coins

We use a service that does fuzzy matching on debtor names and it's been pretty solid. Still not perfect but catches most variations. The key is setting up your search parameters correctly from the start.

0 coins

Can you share which service? I'm open to switching if it means fewer missed liens.

0 coins

I'll DM you the details. Don't want to turn this into a sales pitch thread.

0 coins

The real issue is that most lenders don't verify their search results properly. You get back 50+ potential matches and just skim through looking for obvious ones. But the tricky liens are the ones with slight name variations or weird collateral descriptions that don't immediately jump out.

0 coins

This is so true. We had a case where the existing UCC had 'equipment and fixtures' as collateral but our new loan was for 'machinery and equipment'. Took forever to figure out if there was overlap.

0 coins

Those collateral description overlaps are nightmares to parse manually. Need better tools for document comparison.

0 coins

Actually that's exactly what I was talking about with Certana.ai earlier. It would flag that kind of collateral overlap automatically when you upload both UCCs.

0 coins

Been doing UCC searches for 15 years and the technology has barely improved. Still feels like we're using tools from 2005. The search algorithms are primitive and the user interfaces are clunky.

0 coins

The interfaces are terrible! Half the time I can't tell if a search failed or just returned zero results.

0 coins

And don't get me started on the mobile versions. Completely unusable.

0 coins

What's your process for handling continuation filings that might affect your searches? We've had issues where UCCs show as active in searches but the continuation was actually rejected for some technical reason.

0 coins

Good point. We usually check the filing status directly in the SOS system if it's a material lien. But that's more manual work.

0 coins

Yeah, the status checking is critical. A lapsed UCC-1 doesn't perfect the security interest anymore but some search services still show it as active.

0 coins

This is where having a good verification tool helps. Certana can check the filing status and dates automatically so you know if continuations are current.

0 coins

I switched to doing my own direct searches in each state's SOS system for deals over $1M. It's more work but I trust the results more than third-party aggregators.

0 coins

How do you handle multi-state searches though? That seems like it would take forever.

0 coins

It does take longer but the peace of mind is worth it. Plus you catch filings that the aggregators sometimes miss.

0 coins

The time investment for manual searches kills your deal flow though. There's gotta be a better balance.

0 coins

Have you considered the problem might be with your search strategy rather than the service? Sometimes being too narrow with search terms causes you to miss legitimate variations.

0 coins

Possibly, but when I broaden the search terms I get hundreds of irrelevant results to sift through.

0 coins

True, it's a balancing act. Wide enough to catch variations but narrow enough to be manageable.

0 coins

The bottom line is UCC searches are just one piece of due diligence. You still need good document review processes to catch what the searches miss. No search service is going to be 100% perfect.

0 coins

Agreed, but when you're doing volume lending, the document review has to be scalable. Can't manually review every single filing.

0 coins

That's why automated verification tools are becoming more important. Technology needs to fill the gap between comprehensive searches and manual review.

0 coins

Exactly. The future is probably AI-powered document analysis that can spot the inconsistencies humans miss.

0 coins

UCC Document Community AI

Expert Assistant
Secure