Back to MOHELA

Steven Adams

Should I start PSLF buyback now after making remaining payments or wait?

So I hit what I think is my 120th qualifying payment last month and I've been going back and forth on whether to start the PSLF buyback process right away or sit tight for a bit. My situation is a little complicated — I had some months in forbearance that I'm trying to get counted through buyback, and I want to make sure I'm not jumping the gun before MOHELA has fully processed my recent employer certification form. My qualifying payment count on my account was last updated about six weeks ago and hasn't moved since, even though I submitted a new PSLF form in the spring. Part of me wants to call MOHELA and ask them directly whether it makes sense to initiate the buyback now vs waiting for the count to refresh first. Has anyone actually gone through the PSLF buyback process and timed it well? Did you start it while your payment count was still pending or did you wait until everything was settled?

Claimyr got me through to a MOHELA agent in about 20 minutes when I was stuck in the same kind of limbo — trying to figure out timing on my PSLF stuff and couldn't get anyone on the phone after waiting forever. The site is claimyr.com and basically it holds the line for you so you're not sitting there listening to hold music. I finally got someone who actually walked me through where my count stood and what I'd need to do next. For something as big as buyback timing that really needs a live person, it was worth it.

0 coins

Tried calling the regular way three times last week and got disconnected twice, so I'll definitely look into this. Did they let you ask multiple questions or did it feel rushed?

0 coins

Got through the whole list of questions, the rep seemed patient. Definitely not rushed on my end.

0 coins

Bookmarking claimyr.com for when I finally hit my count and need to sort this stuff out. I'm about 18 months away still but good to know.

0 coins

Waited on the buyback question myself and kind of wish I hadn't. Here's what I learned the hard way: submitting your PSLF application and the buyback request aren't the same step, and doing them out of order can slow things down. What worked for me was making sure my payment count was finalized — meaning MOHELA had processed my most recent employer certification and the count reflected it — before I triggered the buyback. Starting buyback while a certification form is still processing created a weird overlap in my account where nothing moved for almost two months.

0 coins

That overlap issue is exactly what I'm afraid of. My current cert form shows as approved on StudentAid.gov but the qualifying payment count hasn't updated yet. So you'd say hold off until that count reflects the new form?

0 coins

Yeah, confirmed by the rep I talked to: wait for the count to update first, then submit your PSLF application and buyback request together if you're eligible. Doing it piecemeal adds processing time.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a coworker of mine, she had two open requests at once and nothing moved for three months. Once she withdrew one and resubmitted after the count updated it went faster.

0 coins

Forbearance months are tricky for buyback because not every forbearance type qualifies the same way. My understanding — and a MOHELA agent confirmed this for me — is that buyback applies to months that would have counted toward PSLF if you'd been making payments instead of being in forbearance, but the key is what kind of forbearance it was. Administrative forbearance while MOHELA was processing a transfer or application is different from a forbearance you requested yourself. The agent told me to look at my payment history on my MOHELA account on StudentAid.gov and note specifically which months show as forbearance and which forbearance type appears in the detail.

0 coins

Mine were administrative forbearance months from when my loans transferred to MOHELA — the account just sat there for a few months while they set everything up. So those should be eligible for buyback if I meet the other criteria?

0 coins

That's exactly the scenario where buyback was designed to help, based on what I was told. Still worth confirming with MOHELA directly because they'll look at the actual codes on your account rather than just the general type.

0 coins

Didn't realize there were different forbearance types that mattered for this. My account just says 'forbearance' and doesn't break it down further that I can see. Where do you find the detail?

0 coins

On StudentAid.gov under your MOHELA account, go to your payment history and click into individual months — sometimes the detail shows up there. If it doesn't, that's another good reason to call and ask them to read you the codes.

0 coins

My PSLF buyback approval came through about 11 weeks after I submitted everything, for reference. But I'd started from a clean state — count was finalized, employer certification was current, and I'd already received my PSLF eligibility letter before I submitted the buyback request. The sequence seemed to matter. What I did: got the count to settle, confirmed it was right, then submitted PSLF application and buyback together as one package essentially.

0 coins

11 weeks is actually faster than I'd heard from some people. Did you have to follow up at all during that time or did it just process on its own?

0 coins

Followed up once around week 8 just to make sure nothing was stuck. The rep confirmed it was in review and nothing was missing. No other pushback.

0 coins

11 weeks sounds amazing honestly. Mine has been sitting for going on 5 months. What kind of loans did you have, all Direct?

0 coins

All Direct, yes. Had consolidated earlier so they were already the right loan type going in. That might make a difference in timing.

0 coins

Honestly the timing question is secondary to making sure your employer certification is airtight. My first cert form came back with an error — employer EIN was slightly off — and by the time that got fixed I'd lost almost three months. Everything submitted on StudentAid.gov through the PSLF Help Tool now, and the Tool flags some issues before you even submit, which helps. But if your most recent form was submitted manually or through an older process, worth double-checking that it matches what your employer has on file.

0 coins

Mine was submitted through the PSLF Help Tool and my employer signed digitally, so I think the EIN issue is avoided. The form status on StudentAid.gov says approved, so at least that part looks clean.

0 coins

Approved form status is a good sign. The delay between form approval and count update is normal — just annoying. Once that count moves you should be in good shape to move forward.

0 coins

Had an EIN mismatch too and it was a nightmare to untangle. The employer had recently rebranded and the EIN on file with StudentAid.gov was an old one. Took forever.

0 coins

Before I figured out how to get a live person at MOHELA, I went months just guessing at my buyback eligibility and second-guessing every step. Claimyr (claimyr.com) changed that completely — got me to an actual agent who pulled up my account and told me exactly which months were flagged as buyback-eligible and what I still needed to do. For a decision like whether to start buyback now vs later, you really need someone reading your specific account codes, not general forum advice.

0 coins

Forums are good for getting the general picture but yeah, your actual account is what determines your specific situation. Makes sense to get a rep on the line for the final call.

0 coins

Every time I've tried calling MOHELA I end up on hold so long I give up. Good to know there's another way to get through.

0 coins

The hold times are brutal without help. I'd been trying for weeks before I found Claimyr.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up: I thought making my 120th payment meant I was automatically done and forgiveness would just happen. Turns out you still have to actually submit a PSLF application after the payments are made. It doesn't trigger on its own. And buyback is a separate additional step on top of that — it's for specific months that weren't counted but should have been, and you request it through MOHELA specifically. So the full sequence is: get your count right, submit your PSLF application, and if you have buyback months, request buyback either at the same time or as a follow-on.

0 coins

Wait, I didn't realize you have to actively submit the PSLF application separately after the payments are done. I assumed submitting the employer cert forms regularly was the application. So there's a final application step I haven't done yet?

0 coins

Yes — the PSLF employer certification forms are for tracking, not applying. The actual forgiveness application is a separate form on StudentAid.gov. Easy to miss that distinction because the forms look similar.

0 coins

This is the exact thing that confused me for months. The certification forms and the application are two different things and the help tool handles both but you have to know to look for the application step specifically.

0 coins

Thank you for saying this clearly. I've been submitting cert forms every year thinking that was the application. Going to check my account right now.

0 coins

Skipped buyback entirely in my situation because I was nervous about the extra complexity and just wanted forgiveness to go through cleanly. In hindsight I probably left some months on the table. The agent I eventually talked to said I could have requested buyback for three months of administrative forbearance and gotten forgiveness a little sooner. If you have buyback-eligible months, don't be like me — just request it.

0 coins

How did you find out after the fact that you'd left months on the table? Did MOHELA flag it or did you figure it out yourself?

0 coins

Figured it out myself by going back through my payment history month by month after everything was processed. The agent confirmed it when I called asking if there was anything I could do at that point, and there wasn't — forgiveness had already gone through.

0 coins

This is a good cautionary tale. Going through the payment history manually seems tedious but sounds like it's worth doing.

0 coins

What counts as a 'qualifying month' for buyback tripped me up for a while. The month has to be one where, if you had been making a payment, it would have counted — so you have to have been employed full time at a qualifying employer during that month too. The forbearance itself isn't what makes it eligible, it's whether the underlying employment was qualifying during that time. My loans were in administrative forbearance for four months during a transfer and I was still working full time for a government employer the whole time, so all four months were eligible.

0 coins

Good clarification. I stayed at my same employer through the whole forbearance period so I should be fine on that front. It's a 501(c)(3) nonprofit so it qualifies.

0 coins

That's a solid scenario for buyback eligibility then. Nonprofit qualifying employers plus administrative forbearance is pretty much the textbook case.

0 coins

Worth mentioning — Claimyr helped me get through to verify my employer qualifying status when I wasn't 100% sure my organization still qualified after a merger. The rep checked the PSLF employer database right on the call with me. That kind of real-time account-level lookup is hard to get any other way. claimyr.com if anyone needs it.

0 coins

The merger point is real, organizations can change status and it's not always obvious when it happens.

0 coins

My experience with the buyback timing: submitted everything when my count still showed 117 qualifying payments even though I believed I'd made 121 total (the gap being the forbearance months). MOHELA put the buyback months in review simultaneously with my PSLF application and it worked out fine — but I was explicitly told on a call that this was the right way to do it in my case. I'd say get a rep on the phone to confirm the right sequencing for your specific account rather than assuming what worked for me will work the same way for you.

0 coins

So in your case you submitted even though the count didn't yet show 120+, and they handled the buyback as part of the same review process. That's reassuring but I get what you mean about confirming it for my specific situation.

0 coins

Exactly. The rep was clear that my situation allowed simultaneous submission. Different account histories can have different requirements.

0 coins

This is why I hate that there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Every account seems to be slightly different.

0 coins

Missing a payment count update is so stressful when you're this close. Mine sat at the same number for 11 weeks before it jumped. I kept refreshing my account on StudentAid.gov like it was going to change between Tuesday and Wednesday. It did eventually update correctly, it just took way longer than the timelines MOHELA's website suggested.

0 coins

11 weeks of refreshing sounds exhausting. Did you end up calling at any point or just waiting it out?

0 coins

Called twice. First time the rep said it was in processing and there was nothing to do but wait. Second call, different rep said the same thing. Eventually it just updated. No rhyme or reason that I could see.

0 coins

The inconsistency in timelines is the most maddening part. Identical situations seem to take wildly different amounts of time.

0 coins

Deferment and forbearance get mixed up constantly in these discussions and it actually matters for buyback. Deferment months generally don't count toward PSLF and aren't eligible for buyback the same way. Forbearance — specifically certain administrative forbearance types — is the category that buyback targets. If your months show as deferment in your payment history, the buyback rules are different and you'd want to confirm with MOHELA what applies.

0 coins

Mine definitely show as forbearance not deferment, confirmed when I looked at the payment history detail. So I should be in the right category.

0 coins

Good — that's an important distinction to have clear before you start the process.

0 coins

Always confused these two terms. Forbearance vs deferment has different implications depending on what you're asking about. Wish the terms were more intuitive.

0 coins

The simplest way I think about it: forbearance is usually a pause the servicer initiates or approves for processing reasons, deferment is usually tied to a qualifying life situation like returning to school or economic hardship. For PSLF purposes the specific type code is what actually determines eligibility, not just the word on the screen.

0 coins

Something no one warned me about before I started: once you submit your PSLF application, your loans move into a processing status and regular payments stop being required. But if for some reason the application doesn't go through — missing info, employer issue, something — you need to know about it fast so it doesn't hurt you. Set up email notifications on your StudentAid.gov account and check it regularly during processing.

0 coins

Good point on the notifications. I have them set up but haven't checked the actual email address attached to my StudentAid.gov account in a while. Going to verify that's still current.

0 coins

That's the thing people forget — the contact info on StudentAid.gov is what MOHELA communicates through, so if that email is old you might miss something critical.

0 coins

Just checked mine and it was an old email from grad school. Updated it. Thank you for this.

0 coins

The buyback process requires a voluntary payment to cover those months — it's not free, you're essentially paying the amount you would have paid during those forbearance months. For some people depending on what their IDR payment was at the time, that could be a meaningful amount. Worth knowing what you're committing to financially before you initiate. Your MOHELA account or a rep can tell you what the buyback payment amount would be for your specific months.

0 coins

I did see that noted somewhere but hadn't thought through the actual dollar amount. My IDR payment during those forbearance months was low since I was on SAVE — or whatever it's called now — so hopefully the buyback total is manageable.

0 coins

Worth verifying the specific amount on your account before you commit. For people on lower IDR payments it's often pretty manageable but always good to confirm first.

0 coins

The buyback payment amount for my four months was actually much less than I feared. For anyone anxious about this: check your actual account rather than imagining a scary number.

0 coins

Filed the PSLF application and buyback request together in my case about nine weeks ago. Currently in processing status and no update yet. Following this thread for any insight on what a typical timeline looks like for simultaneous application and buyback.

0 coins

Nine weeks is still within the range I've seen quoted. Mine took 11 weeks total. Hopefully yours moves soon.

0 coins

Trying to stay patient. The processing status at least means nothing is stuck or rejected, right? No news is good news I keep telling myself.

0 coins

Processing status usually means it's in queue, not flagged for a problem. If there was something wrong it typically generates a notice asking you to respond.

0 coins

Went through the PSLF Help Tool again recently to double check my submitted forms and noticed one of my older employer certification forms from a few years ago was showing a different status than I expected. Worth going back and auditing all your past forms in the tool, not just your most recent one, before you submit the final application. Historical form issues can sometimes resurface.

0 coins

I hadn't thought to go back and audit the older forms. I've been focused on the most recent one. Going to do a full review in the PSLF Help Tool tonight.

0 coins

Glad that's helpful. It took me maybe 30 minutes to review five years of forms and I found one that had been approved but showed a slightly different end date than my records. Nothing that derailed me but I wanted to have it documented.

0 coins

This is good advice. The audit step before submitting the final application is something I wish I'd done more carefully.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — does the PSLF buyback work if your loans aren't Direct Loans? I consolidated specifically to make my old FFEL loans eligible a couple years ago, they're Direct now, but wondering if that affects the buyback calculation at all.

0 coins

Consolidation resets the qualifying payment count on the consolidated loan, so the payments made before consolidation on the old FFEL loans don't count directly — it's the payments after consolidation on the new Direct loan that count. Buyback is for months after consolidation where you were in forbearance instead of making payments. So if the forbearance months happened after your consolidation, you're in the right territory.

0 coins

My forbearance was all after consolidation so that sounds like I'm fine. But confirming this is exactly the kind of thing where I need to just call MOHELA and have them look at my actual account.

0 coins

Consolidation and buyback together is a common combination because a lot of people consolidated specifically to get into PSLF, and then had some early forbearance while the new loan settled in. MOHELA sees this a lot.

0 coins

For anyone struggling to even get a rep on the phone during this process: used Claimyr a few months back when I was trying to sort out exactly this kind of question — whether to start buyback and what my current count actually reflected. claimyr.com held the line for me and I got through without the usual hang-up-and-try-again cycle. The rep confirmed my buyback eligibility on the call. Feels like a small thing but when you're dealing with something this important and time-sensitive, actually talking to a human makes a huge difference.

0 coins

Added claimyr.com to my notes for when I hit this stage. I've had too many calls where I waited 45 minutes and then got a 'we're experiencing high volume' and the line dropped.

0 coins

The dropped calls after a long wait are genuinely demoralizing. Good to have an alternative approach.

0 coins

Exactly the experience I had before finding it. The hold-and-disconnect cycle is frustrating when what you need is a 10-minute conversation.

0 coins

Just want to summarize what I've pieced together from this thread since I'm in a similar situation and this is all really helpful: (1) make sure your most recent employer cert form is fully processed and your count has updated before submitting your PSLF application, (2) if you have administrative forbearance months that were during qualifying employment, those may be eligible for buyback, (3) submit the PSLF application and buyback request together if your situation allows, (4) confirm the specific sequencing for your account with a MOHELA rep because individual account histories vary. Did I get that right?

0 coins

That's a solid summary. The only thing I'd add is to audit your historical employer cert forms in the PSLF Help Tool before you submit the final application, just to make sure nothing has a flag you're not aware of.

0 coins

Added that to my notes. Thanks.

0 coins

Also check that your contact info on StudentAid.gov is current so you don't miss any processing notices. That was mentioned upthread and it's easy to overlook.

0 coins

Really glad this thread came together the way it did. Summary is accurate from my read as the OP. Going to wait for my count to update, audit my old forms, then call to confirm sequencing before I pull the trigger on the application.

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure