My MOHELA rap repayment plan payment schedule letter PSLF count forbearance situation is a mess — anyone dealt with all of this at once?
Ok so I'm going to try to explain this whole situation without losing my mind because there's genuinely like four things happening at the same time and I can't tell if they're related or if I'm just unlucky. Background: I work for a county health department so I've been chasing PSLF for years. I consolidated to Direct Loans, got on an IDR plan, certified my employer every year. I was at 89 qualifying payments last time I checked, which felt close enough to actually believe in. Then about six weeks ago I got a letter from MOHELA — an actual paper letter — that looked like a repayment plan payment schedule letter. It showed a new monthly payment amount that was noticeably higher than what I'd been paying. No explanation for why it changed. I hadn't recertified my income recently but my recertification wasn't supposed to be due for another few months. Then I noticed my PSLF qualifying payment count on my MOHELA account dropped from 89 down to 84. DROPPED. I haven't done anything differently. My employer certifications are current. AND on top of all that, my account also shows I'm in some kind of forbearance right now that I never requested. My loans just went into forbearance status at some point and nobody told me. I don't know if forbearance months are going to mess up my PSLF count or what. I've tried messaging through MOHELA's portal three times and gotten back responses that basically say 'we're looking into it' and nothing else. I need to actually talk to someone who can explain why my count went backward, what triggered the payment change, and whether these forbearance months are going to hurt me. Has anyone had their PSLF count go DOWN? And has anyone gotten a repayment plan payment schedule letter out of nowhere with no explanation? I'm genuinely confused and a little scared.
71 comments

Eli Butler
The count going backward is unfortunately something I've seen come up here before. Sometimes MOHELA does a review of your payment history and finds months that were previously counted but then determined not to qualify — usually because of a payment amount discrepancy, a period where you were in the wrong repayment plan, or an employer certification issue. It doesn't always mean you did something wrong. Did your letter come with any detail about which payments were removed or why?
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorPulling up the letter again right now — honestly it doesn't say anything about which payments were reviewed or removed. It's formatted like a standard repayment schedule, shows my new monthly payment amount, and that's basically it. No explanation for the count change anywhere in the letter or in my portal messages.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
The letter and the count drop might actually be separate things. Like the letter could be about your IDR payment recalculation and the count drop could be from a totally different review process MOHELA did on your account. They tend to arrive around the same time but not always for the same reason.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
While you're waiting on MOHELA's portal messages to go nowhere — I was in a similar spiral last year trying to get someone on the phone to explain a forbearance I didn't ask for. I spent like three weeks getting disconnected or waiting forever. Someone on a different thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. It basically holds your place in the MOHELA phone queue so you're not sitting there for an hour and then getting cut off. I got through to an actual agent who could pull up my account and explain what triggered the forbearance. The site is claimyr.com if you want to check it out. For something this complicated — count going down, payment change, unexplained forbearance all at once — you really want a live person.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorChecking out that site now. My portal messages are genuinely getting me nowhere and I need someone who can actually see my account history.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Seconding this — when you have multiple things wrong at the same time, the portal message system is basically useless because each reply comes from a different rep who hasn't read the whole chain.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Claimyr worked for me too when I was trying to sort out a payment that got taken from my bank but didn't post to my account. Got through way faster than trying on my own.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
First thing I'd do in your spot is screenshot your complete payment history from your MOHELA account before anything gets changed. When a count drops, you want a record of what it was showing before. Beyond that — the way this works is that MOHELA can go back and do a payment-by-payment review when something triggers it, like a form submission or a system update. Each payment gets checked against whether your plan was qualifying, your employer was qualifying, and whether you were full time. If any of those were flagged, that payment gets pulled from the count. The drop doesn't mean those months are gone forever necessarily — sometimes a corrected employer certification or a plan correction can bring them back. But you need a rep to walk you through which specific months were affected.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorTaking those screenshots right now actually. I hadn't thought about documenting the current state before anything changes again.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
This happened to my cousin — her count dropped after MOHELA did a review and it turned out two of her employer certifications had an overlap issue with dates. Once her employer resubmitted a corrected form the counts came back. It took a few months but they were restored.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Worth noting too that if you submitted a new employer certification form recently, that can sometimes trigger a re-review of your whole history. It's supposed to help but it can temporarily cause this kind of confusion.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
ok wait the forbearance thing is what's getting me. i went through something similar and nobody told me my loans were in forbearance either. i only found out when i noticed my payment wasn't coming out of my bank. does it say anywhere in your account what TYPE of forbearance it is? because there's a difference between the kind MOHELA puts you in while they process something vs the kind you request yourself and that matters a lot for whether the months count
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorGoing back into my account to look at the forbearance details more carefully — it does say something about 'administrative' but I didn't dig into what that means for PSLF.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Administrative forbearance is usually what servicers use when they're processing something on your account — like an IDR application or a transfer or a form review. The question of whether those months count toward PSLF or IDR depends on the specific situation, so your notices and your account details are the place to look, not just general rules.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Had a nearly identical situation with MOHELA — forbearance I didn't ask for, payment schedule that changed without explanation, and I couldn't get a straight answer through their messaging system for weeks. I actually used Claimyr to get through to MOHELA by phone and the rep I reached explained that my loans had been put in administrative forbearance while MOHELA was processing a form I'd submitted months earlier. Apparently the processing backlog was really long. The rep was able to tell me exactly which months were in forbearance and what the status was for each one. If you go to claimyr.com it handles the hold time for you so you're not just sitting there getting cut off.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorReally glad to know someone got through and actually got real answers. The forbearance explanation you got sounds exactly like what might be happening with mine too.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
This is consistent with what I've seen — when MOHELA is processing an employer certification or an IDR form, they sometimes put the account in administrative forbearance in the meantime. The problem is they don't always communicate that it's happening or why.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Yeah the communication gap is the most frustrating part. The forbearance happens, the letter either doesn't come or comes late, and then you're staring at a status you didn't expect with no explanation.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
I want to push back a little on the idea that the payment schedule letter and the count drop are definitely separate things. I went through something where my IDR plan recertification got processed early — I think because MOHELA received updated income info somehow — and that changed my payment amount AND triggered a review of my payment history at the same time. The two events happening together isn't always a coincidence.
0 coins
Eli Butler
That's a fair point. If MOHELA received anything that triggered an IDR recalculation — a tax transcript, a new application, anything — that can kick off a cascade of reviews on the account. It's worth asking the rep specifically whether a recalculation happened and what triggered it.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorHadn't thought about the tax transcript angle — I do have my taxes set to auto-fill on some forms. Could that have fed into MOHELA without me realizing?
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
If you authorized income-driven recertification to use your tax info automatically through StudentAid.gov, it's possible your payment was recalculated based on updated income without you manually submitting anything. Worth checking your StudentAid.gov account for any recent activity.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
Let me walk through what I'd actually do in your situation, step by step. First I'd log into StudentAid.gov and look at your loan details there — sometimes the information on StudentAid.gov and what shows on MOHELA's side don't perfectly sync and you can spot a discrepancy. Second I'd look at your most recent employer certification form status. If it was recently processed, that's often what triggers a payment-by-payment review. Third I'd look at whether there's been any IDR application activity on your account that you didn't initiate. The reason I'd check all three before calling is so that when you DO get a rep on the phone, you can tell them specifically what you're seeing and ask targeted questions rather than just saying 'something changed.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorThis is exactly the kind of checklist I needed. Going through all three of those right now before I try calling.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
The IDR activity check is a smart one. I had an IDR processing note show up on my account that I genuinely don't remember initiating and it changed my payment amount.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Also worth downloading your full payment history as a PDF if MOHELA gives that option — having the complete record before you call means you can reference specific months while talking to the rep.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
MOHELA LOSES MY PAYMENTS AND NOBODY EVER EXPLAINS ANYTHING. I had a count drop too and when I finally got someone on the phone they told me it was a 'system update' and that my payments would be 'restored in due time.' That was eight months ago. EIGHT MONTHS. The idea that these things resolve themselves is a fantasy. You have to push and document everything and escalate.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorEight months is genuinely horrifying to read when I'm already at 89 qualifying payments. How did you end up escalating?
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Filed a complaint with the Federal Student Aid Feedback Center and also contacted the FSA Ombudsman. The Ombudsman is the one that actually moved things. It took another two months after that but my count was eventually corrected.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
For people hitting walls with MOHELA through portal messages — I'd also recommend just getting on the phone first before going to the Ombudsman, because sometimes the issue is fixable with a live rep who can actually see the full account. I had the same exhaustion trying to reach someone and finally used Claimyr at claimyr.com to hold my place in the queue. Got through, rep fixed the issue in one call. Ombudsman is the right move when phone calls don't work, but sometimes they do work if you can actually get through.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
One thing worth understanding about how PSLF counts work — your 120 qualifying payments don't have to be consecutive. So even if some months got removed, those months might be fixable. The question is always whether each individual payment met all four things: qualifying employer, qualifying repayment plan, on time and in full payment, and full-time employment. If MOHELA flagged something for one of those four, that's the specific thing to address. Getting a rep to tell you WHICH months were removed and WHY is the most important call you can make right now.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorKnowing they don't have to be consecutive is actually reassuring. I was panicking that I'd have to basically start over.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
This helped me too when I was spiraling. The count going down doesn't mean you're back to zero, it means specific months were flagged and those months can potentially be addressed.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
The 'why' is really the critical piece. Without knowing which months were flagged and for what reason, you're just guessing at how to fix it.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Something nobody's mentioned yet — did your payment go up because you got bumped off your IDR plan? Because if for some reason MOHELA switched you to a standard repayment plan, that would both raise your payment AND those months wouldn't count toward PSLF. I'd check your account for what repayment plan it's currently showing.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorLogging into my account right now to check the repayment plan status — honestly I assumed I was still on the same plan but now I'm not sure.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
This is a real thing that has happened to people. If your IDR recertification lapsed or there was a processing gap, some accounts got temporarily moved to a different plan. It's supposed to be correctable but it creates a mess with the payment count in the meantime.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
If your account is showing a different plan than you enrolled in, ask the rep to document when the plan change occurred and whether any of the months on the new plan can be corrected. Sometimes they can backdate a plan correction.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
My PSLF journey had a similar detour — not a count drop but a forbearance I didn't ask for right around the time I was close to 100 qualifying payments. I was devastated thinking those months were wasted. What I found out when I finally talked to a rep was that some types of administrative forbearance actually do count toward PSLF, specifically ones that MOHELA placed while processing certain forms. My account notices had the details but I hadn't read them carefully. Check every single notice in your MOHELA account — they're sometimes buried but they explain what triggered the status.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorGoing through every notice in my account now — I hadn't looked at all of them carefully. Found one from about seven weeks ago that mentions 'processing status' but I need to read it more closely.
0 coins
Julia Hall
The notices are genuinely where the detail lives. The dashboard and the letter sometimes don't have the explanation but the notices section in the portal often does.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Glad you found something — a notice mentioning processing status around the time your count changed is probably a lead.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Just want to flag that if the repayment plan payment schedule letter showed a new monthly amount that you haven't been billed for yet, don't just sit on it. If that's your new IDR payment, you'll want to know before the bill comes. And if your plan is wrong, you want to fix it before you make payments under the wrong plan. Time matters a lot here when you're close to 120.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorReally good point — I've been so focused on the count drop that I haven't even thought about whether the new payment amount in the letter is what I'll actually owe on my next bill.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Check your upcoming payment due date in your account. If you're in forbearance your payment might be paused but that forbearance won't last forever and when it ends you want to know what plan you're on.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Something I want to add from going through IDR recertification confusion — when your payment goes up unexpectedly, it's worth checking whether MOHELA used the right income information. If they used an older or different tax year than you expected, the payment calculation can come out different. When you get a rep on the phone, ask them specifically what income figure was used in your payment calculation and what tax year it came from.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorThat's a really specific question to have ready — writing it down so I don't forget when I finally get through to someone.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
This is a good one. Also ask what discretionary income calculation they used and which IDR plan the new payment is based on. All of those feed into the payment amount and any one of them being off can explain a sudden increase.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
my payment went up once because they used my income from two years ago instead of last year and the difference was significant. definitely worth asking.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Just dropping in to say I followed this thread because I had almost the exact same thing happen last year — unexplained forbearance, count that looked wrong, payment change letter that made no sense. It took me about two months of persistence but everything eventually got sorted. The employer certification review had triggered a chain of events that MOHELA hadn't communicated well. Hang in there.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorReally needed to hear that it's resolvable. Two months is a long time when you're anxious but knowing it has a resolution helps.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Employer certification reviews causing cascades of changes without explanation seems to be a pretty common pattern based on what I've seen in this forum.
0 coins
Sofia Price
For the record once I got through to MOHELA by phone the rep was actually really thorough in pulling up my payment history month by month. Phone reps have more access to account details than what shows in the portal. The portal messages you get back are often from people who can only see summary info. The phone rep could actually see notes on my account going back years.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorThis is motivating me to push harder on actually getting through by phone rather than waiting for portal messages.
0 coins
Eli Butler
The access level difference between phone reps and portal message reps is real and it matters a lot for complicated multi-issue situations like this one.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Phone is the only way to actually resolve something with this many moving parts. Portal messages are fine for simple questions but not for untangling a count drop plus forbearance plus payment change all at once.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Late to this thread but wanted to share — I had a similarly confusing situation with MOHELA where my account had three separate issues happening and I couldn't get through on the phone for weeks. I found Claimyr through someone else's recommendation and it was genuinely the thing that broke the logjam. You go to claimyr.com, it manages the MOHELA hold for you and calls you when a rep is on the line. I know it sounds too simple but it actually worked. The rep I reached had my account open, could see all three issues I was dealing with, and walked me through each one. Took one call. Months of portal messages hadn't gotten me anywhere close to that.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorMultiple recommendations for the same thing is convincing me — going to try it today.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
The fact that you resolved three separate issues in one call is exactly what OP needs. When you have this many things happening on your account you really need a rep with full access.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
yeah portal messages are basically useless for anything complicated. they come back with generic answers that don't address your actual account.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Something that might also be relevant — if your loans were ever transferred to MOHELA from a previous servicer, there can sometimes be payment history gaps or discrepancies from the transfer that don't get caught until a review happens later. If you consolidated or transferred within the last few years, worth asking the rep to check whether your pre-MOHELA payment history imported correctly.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorMy loans were actually with a different servicer before MOHELA — I hadn't thought to connect that to this current issue but it's worth asking about.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
Transfer discrepancies are real and sometimes they don't surface until a form review or a system audit years later. The rep can run a comparison between what was imported and what your previous servicer has on record.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Circling back to the original question about the letter — in my experience the repayment plan payment schedule letter MOHELA sends when your payment changes is supposed to explain the reason for the change, but in practice the letters are often generic and don't give you the actual explanation. The explanation lives in your account notices or in a conversation with a rep. The letter itself is kind of useless for understanding what happened.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorThat tracks completely with what I got. The letter showed me the new number but told me nothing about why it changed. I kept re-reading it looking for an explanation that wasn't there.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
The gap between the information in the letter and the information you actually need is one of the most consistently frustrating things about dealing with MOHELA.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
The letter is apparently a legal notice requirement so they have to send it, but the actual account management conversation has to happen by phone or through the portal. The letter is the beginning of the process, not the answer.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Final thought from me — when you do get through to a rep, have three specific questions ready: why did my qualifying payment count drop and which payments were removed, what triggered my payment amount to change and what income info was used, and what is the specific type of forbearance on my account and does it affect my PSLF eligibility. If you go in with those three questions you'll get way more out of the call than if you just explain the situation and hope they guide you through it. Reps respond better to specific questions than to general confusion.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
AuthorSaving this comment right now. Having three specific questions is exactly the right frame — I've been thinking about it as 'explain everything' which is probably not how to approach it.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
Adding one more to the list — ask them to document the conversation and the resolution in your account notes. That way if you call back or escalate later there's a record of what was discussed and what they said the resolution would be.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Documentation request is crucial. I cannot stress enough how much it helps to have a note in your account from a previous call — it means the next rep can see the history and you don't have to re-explain everything from scratch.
0 coins