Back to MOHELA

Kingston Bellamy

Is MOHELA PSLF buyback calculated on SAVE plan payments net income or something else?

Okay so I've been going down a rabbit hole trying to figure out the buyback program and I'm hitting a wall. I work for a county health department and have been on the SAVE plan for the past couple years. I have some months from before I consolidated where the payments were technically zero because my income was low enough that SAVE calculated them that way — not because I was in forbearance or anything, just because the formula landed at zero. Now I'm trying to figure out whether those zero-dollar months can count toward PSLF buyback and if so how MOHELA actually calculates what I'd owe for them. Like is the buyback amount based on what my payment WOULD have been under the SAVE formula using my actual net income, or is it tied to something else like my adjusted gross income, or some other calculation entirely? I've looked at the StudentAid.gov info and it's vague. My qualifying payment count is at 97 and I really want to get to 120 without waiting another two and a half years. Has anyone actually been through the PSLF buyback process with SAVE plan zero-dollar payment months specifically? What did MOHELA tell you?

Three weeks into waiting on my own buyback inquiry and I feel this post in my soul. Filed the request, got an acknowledgment email, and then... nothing. No movement on my qualifying payment count. No follow up. The silence from MOHELA has been deafening. I don't have zero-dollar months exactly — mine were months where I was in an income-driven plan but my employer wasn't yet certified so they didn't qualify — but I'm watching this thread for anything useful about how the buyback math actually works.

0 coins

Waiting on MOHELA to proactively update you is basically a part time job. You almost have to call them and ask specifically about each piece of your file to get any real information about where things stand.

0 coins

Call first thing Monday, that's what I'm doing. I've been putting it off but this thread reminded me I need to just do it.

0 coins

Six months ago I went through a buyback request and I want to lay out what I actually learned because there's a lot of confusion out there about how the calculation works. So what tripped me up before I figured it out was assuming the buyback amount was tied to my take-home pay — it's not. The way the buyback is supposed to work is that you pay the amount you would have owed during those months under the IDR plan you were on. So for SAVE, that means the formula they use for your SAVE payment is what determines the buyback amount for each month you're buying back — it's based on your discretionary income as calculated under SAVE rules, which uses your adjusted gross income from your tax return, not your net or take-home. The zero-dollar months are the tricky part because if the formula legitimately calculated zero, you might actually owe zero per month to buy those back, though MOHELA may have a minimum. I'd contact them directly and ask them to run the numbers for your specific situation before you assume anything.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed. So it's the AGI-based SAVE formula, not actual take-home. That changes my math completely. Did you have to submit anything special to get them to calculate it for you or did they just do it when you filed the buyback request form?

0 coins

Seconding the question about what to submit — the StudentAid.gov info on buyback is really thin on the actual steps and what documentation they want from you.

0 coins

Pull your old tax returns for the years covering those months — that's the documentation that drives the SAVE calculation. When I filed I sent those along with a written explanation of which months I was requesting and why they should count. MOHELA asked for clarification once and then processed it.

0 coins

Eight months into my own PSLF journey and I hit a point where I had to actually talk to a person at MOHELA — not just submit forms and hope. The hold times were brutal, like multiple hours, and I kept getting disconnected. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. It basically holds your place in the MOHELA phone queue and calls you when an agent picks up instead of you sitting there for two hours. Got through the same day. Site is claimyr.com if you want to look into it. For something as specific as how the buyback calculation works for your SAVE months, you really do need to hear it from a MOHELA agent directly because the written info is too vague.

0 coins

Had no idea that existed. Going to try it this week because I've been dreading the call situation. Did the agent you reached actually know about buyback specifically or did you have to get transferred?

0 coins

Got transferred once to someone in the PSLF unit who was much more helpful. The key was actually getting through the first layer.

0 coins

Same experience with the hold times. I've called three times in the past month and twice just gave up after 90 minutes. It's genuinely terrible.

0 coins

Just got a letter last week about my buyback request so I can share what it said. The letter confirmed the months eligible for buyback and listed a dollar amount owed per month. Mine were months I was on IBR, not SAVE, but the concept is the same — they calculated what my payment would have been under IBR for each of those months based on my income at the time. For anyone with SAVE zero-dollar months, I'd imagine the same logic applies: they calculate what SAVE said you owed, and if SAVE said zero, theoretically the buyback amount is zero per month. But call and confirm because I don't want to steer you wrong.

0 coins

The letter thing is interesting — did you get that before or after the payment was due? I'm trying to understand the sequence of events so I know what to expect.

0 coins

Got the letter explaining the amounts first, then had a window to pay, then the count updated after MOHELA confirmed payment. The whole thing took longer than I expected from first request to count update.

0 coins

How long total from filing to count updating? Asking for my own sanity.

0 coins

Somewhere around four months start to finish, which I know is not what anyone wants to hear but it was what it was.

0 coins

Last Tuesday I finally submitted my buyback request after procrastinating for literally six months because the instructions are so confusing. I work for a state university so I'm definitely qualifying employer territory. What I still haven't figured out is whether the SAVE plan months where I owed zero are going to cost me anything or if the buyback really is zero dollars for those. I called my tax person and even she didn't know how to answer the PSLF buyback question.

0 coins

Your tax person is probably great but PSLF buyback is really servicer-specific — it's MOHELA you need to talk to for the actual calculation, not a tax professional.

0 coins

Ask MOHELA directly, got it. I've been avoiding the call but sounds like I just have to do it.

0 coins

The zero-dollar question is real and I've seen people get different answers. Some report being told the buyback is literally zero for those months, others report a minimum amount. Get it in writing or at least write down the name and ID of the agent who tells you.

0 coins

Somewhere around month three of my buyback wait I discovered that the PSLF buyback program and regular PSLF have some overlapping but separate requirements, and confusing the two was causing me to misread the guidance. The buyback is specifically for months that would have counted toward the 120 except they were in a period that didn't qualify for some reason — like being in the wrong forbearance type, or an employer wasn't certified yet, or you were between IDR plan conversions. It's not a way to pay back any random old month. If your zero-dollar SAVE months happened during certified qualifying employment and under a qualifying IDR plan, the buyback request should be valid, but MOHELA will verify all of that.

0 coins

Mine were during certified employment — I've had continuous employer certification for three years — so that part should be fine. The question really is just the dollar amount calculation.

0 coins

Then you're in the best position to get a clean answer from MOHELA. When you call, ask them specifically to confirm eligibility for each month first before you get into the calculation question.

0 coins

This distinction between what qualifies for buyback vs regular PSLF is something I had completely wrong in my head. Good clarification.

0 coins

Two calls and a secure message in and I still don't have a clear answer about my own buyback situation, so I feel you OP. The secure message response I got was copy-pasted boilerplate that didn't address my actual question at all. Sometimes I think nobody at MOHELA is actually reading what you send.

0 coins

The secure message system is basically a black hole. I got three generic responses in a row before I gave up and called.

0 coins

Switch to calling, I know that's what everyone says but it really does seem like the only way to get someone to actually engage with your specific file.

0 coins

The PSLF unit specifically tends to be more knowledgeable than general customer service. If you get someone who doesn't know what buyback is, ask to be transferred.

0 coins

Finally getting movement on my count after months of being stuck — I want to share what actually got things moving because it might help others here. After weeks of secure messages going nowhere, I tried Claimyr to get through to MOHELA without camping on hold, and it worked. The agent I reached was actually in the PSLF unit and she walked me through exactly how they were calculating my buyback months. For my situation on IBR, it was the payment formula applied to my AGI from the relevant tax year. She confirmed that SAVE zero-dollar months could also legitimately be zero-dollar buyback if the formula produces that. That answer came directly from a MOHELA PSLF agent. Claimyr is at claimyr.com.

0 coins

Zero dollar buyback confirmed by an actual MOHELA agent — that is incredibly useful. So it really does follow the formula, not some minimum they just decide.

0 coins

She said as much, though she added that I should get the written confirmation of my specific months and amounts before assuming anything, because individual situations vary.

0 coins

This is the most concrete information in this whole thread honestly. Really appreciate you sharing it.

0 coins

Month four of my buyback request being 'in process' and I'm starting to wonder if I should follow up or if following up would somehow reset the clock. Has anyone had experience with what happens when you inquire about an existing buyback request?

0 coins

Calling to ask for a status update shouldn't reset anything — it's just a status check. I called twice during my request and each time the agent just looked at the notes and told me where it was in the queue.

0 coins

Call Monday and ask for a status, that's the plan. I've been scared to rock the boat but four months seems long.

0 coins

Four months is on the longer end but not unheard of. When I called for a status check they were actually able to flag it for review which I think did speed things up slightly.

0 coins

Something I had completely backwards before someone set me straight on another forum: I thought SAVE plan payments and PSLF buyback were two separate tracks and you couldn't combine them. That's not right. If you were on SAVE, making qualifying payments toward PSLF, and some months slipped through without counting for whatever reason, those are potentially buyback-eligible months. The plan you're on doesn't disqualify you from buyback — the question is whether those specific months meet the other requirements.

0 coins

I was confused about this too — thanks for spelling it out. So being on SAVE is fine, the question is just whether those particular months meet the buyback criteria individually.

0 coins

Exactly right. Each month is evaluated on its own — was it qualifying employment, qualifying plan, right loan type. The plan being SAVE doesn't automatically help or hurt.

0 coins

The loan type piece is one people miss — only Direct Loans qualify for PSLF, so if someone has FFEL loans that weren't consolidated they won't count even with perfect employment.

0 coins

Finally sent my secure message to MOHELA yesterday asking about my specific zero-dollar SAVE months after reading this thread. We'll see what comes back. I have 89 qualifying payments and have been in SAVE for three years so I have a lot riding on whether these buyback months clear.

0 coins

Watch for the boilerplate response and if you get it, call. The specific question about zero-dollar SAVE months and buyback calculation is detailed enough that you really need a phone conversation.

0 coins

Get ready to call if the response is useless — yeah, that's probably where this is headed.

0 coins

89 payments is SO close. Hope the buyback comes through for you.

0 coins

Somewhere in the middle of trying to track all my own qualifying months I realized I had been confusing administrative forbearance with a deferment in my own records — those months I thought were potentially buyback-eligible turned out to be in a deferment which has different rules. Just flagging it for anyone else who might be miscounting months from years ago.

0 coins

This is a genuinely important thing to check. The loan status codes on your payment history in your StudentAid.gov account will show you what each month was actually designated as, which is the ground truth for figuring out what might be buyback-eligible.

0 coins

Check StudentAid.gov payment history not just MOHELA's summary — that's what I should have done first. My whole count was off because I was working from memory.

0 coins

Going to pull my full payment history from StudentAid.gov before I call so I can go in with actual documentation of which months I'm asking about.

0 coins

Two employer certifications, one recertification, and now a buyback request filed — I've been in this PSLF process for years and the buyback addition feels like yet another thing that should be simple but isn't. My specific question going in was whether my SAVE months where I owed zero would require me to pay anything. What I eventually heard from MOHELA was that the calculation goes back to what the SAVE formula would have produced for each specific month. Zero SAVE payment generally means zero buyback payment, but they verify income documentation for those months.

0 coins

Verify income documentation — so they want your actual tax returns from those years? That makes sense but good to know in advance.

0 coins

Exactly that. Have your tax transcripts or returns for each year that includes months you're requesting. It made my request go faster when I included them upfront rather than waiting for them to ask.

0 coins

This thread has basically become the most useful PSLF buyback resource I've found. Someone should pin it somewhere.

0 coins

Step one of actually calling MOHELA about this is figuring out which department handles buyback requests because general customer service doesn't always know the specifics. When you call, ask specifically for the PSLF unit or PSLF team. The agents there have more training on the buyback process than general CS and are more likely to give you a real answer about how the SAVE calculation feeds into the buyback amount.

0 coins

Ask for the PSLF unit by name — I've been getting transferred after the fact every time I call and it wastes like 20 minutes each call.

0 coins

Say it right at the start when the agent first picks up. Something like 'I have a question about a PSLF buyback request and I want to make sure I'm speaking with someone in the PSLF unit.' Most of the time they'll transfer you immediately if they're not the right person.

0 coins

The number of times I've had to explain from scratch what PSLF buyback even is to the first agent who answers is too many. This tip about asking for the unit upfront is going to save me so much time.

0 coins

Nearly at the end of my own buyback saga and looking back, the thing that finally cracked it open was getting a real conversation with a MOHELA PSLF agent. For anyone hitting walls on the phone, I used Claimyr — found it at claimyr.com — after I saw someone mention it in a different student loan thread. Got connected to MOHELA without sitting on hold for two hours and reached the PSLF unit that same day. For the SAVE calculation question specifically, the agent confirmed the buyback uses the same income-based formula that produced your SAVE payment in the first place, so if SAVE said you owed zero, the buyback amount for that month is effectively zero, subject to them verifying your income documentation for that period.

0 coins

Subject to income verification — so it's not just automatic, they actually check the tax records for those years and confirm the zero is correct?

0 coins

Right, they don't just take your word that the payment was zero. They verify it against your income documentation. If your SAVE payment was correctly calculated as zero based on your AGI, the buyback reflects that.

0 coins

This thread has given me more clarity on the SAVE buyback calculation than anything I found on StudentAid.gov. Thank you all. Calling MOHELA this week with my tax returns in hand.

0 coins

Just want to add for anyone reading this later: if MOHELA doesn't resolve your buyback issue or you get conflicting information from multiple agents, you can file a complaint through Federal Student Aid's Feedback Center. I had to do that once for a different issue and it did eventually get escalation. It's not fast but it's an option when you feel stuck.

0 coins

The FSA Feedback Center is something I didn't know existed until recently. Good to have as a backup option.

0 coins

Keep notes of every call — date, time, agent name or ID if they give it, and what they told you. That documentation matters if you end up needing to escalate to the Feedback Center or the FSA Ombudsman.

0 coins

Notes on every call, documentation saved — I've started doing this and it already helped me catch when two agents gave me completely contradictory information about my count.

0 coins

One week post-buyback payment and my qualifying count hasn't updated yet which I know is probably normal but it's nerve-wracking to send money and see nothing change on your account. How long after the buyback payment does the count typically update?

0 coins

Mine took about six weeks after payment confirmed before the count updated. It's genuinely painful to wait but it did eventually move.

0 coins

Wait six weeks before panicking — okay, setting a reminder.

0 coins

Six to eight weeks seems to be the range from what I've seen people report. If you're past that window with no update, that's when I'd call to check.

0 coins

Reading through this whole thread from the start, the clearest summary of what OP and others have confirmed: for PSLF buyback when you were on SAVE, the amount owed per month is based on the SAVE formula applied to your AGI from that period. Zero-dollar SAVE payments generally produce zero-dollar buyback amounts but MOHELA verifies the income documentation. The buyback request process involves filing through MOHELA, providing relevant tax documentation, waiting for their review, receiving a letter with amounts, paying, and then waiting for the count update. The whole thing can take several months.

0 coins

This is basically exactly the summary I needed. Really appreciate everyone who shared their actual experiences here.

0 coins

Good luck on the call this week — come back and report what they tell you, it'll help the next person who searches this question.

0 coins

Bookmarking this thread. This is genuinely one of the better discussions of PSLF buyback with SAVE I've seen anywhere.

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure