Back to MOHELA

Natasha Volkova

IBR over 300 payments glitch wait for fix switch to ICR forgiveness — anyone else stuck in this mess?

Ok so this is kind of a nightmare situation and I need to know if anyone else is dealing with the same thing. I've been on IBR for years — way more than 20 years worth of payments at this point, well over 300 qualifying payments showing on my account — and I should have hit forgiveness already under the 25-year IDR count. But my MOHELA account is just... sitting there. No forgiveness, no notice, nothing processed. I called and they told me there's a known glitch affecting some accounts where the payment count is way over what it should be at forgiveness and the system hasn't triggered the discharge. The rep said to wait for the fix. Here's my problem: a friend suggested I just switch to ICR instead and that might force the forgiveness through on a different track. Has anyone actually done that — switched from IBR to ICR when you had a glitch like this — and did it work? Or did it make things worse? I really don't want to mess up 300+ payments of history chasing a workaround that blows up in my face.

Ugh, is this the same glitch that's been going around? I swear I've seen three people post about this in the last month. My count was showing weird numbers too for a while but mine eventually just corrected itself after a few weeks. Did they give you any kind of timeline for when the fix is supposed to happen?

0 coins

Calling them again today to push for a timeline because

0 coins

Same thing happened to me — count looked totally off for about six weeks then one morning it just updated. No explanation, no notice from MOHELA, just suddenly correct. So annoying.

0 coins

Have you actually been able to get a live person on the phone consistently? Because when I was fighting my own IDR count issue last year I could not get through for weeks — constant busy signals or getting dropped after 45 minutes on hold. Someone in another thread pointed me to Claimyr (claimyr.com) and honestly it was the thing that finally got me in front of an agent. It works by basically holding your place in the queue so you're not just sitting there with your phone glued to your ear. That's how I finally got a supervisor to flag my account for manual review instead of just being told to wait.

0 coins

Trying to get through has been genuinely terrible — got disconnected twice already this week. Looking up Claimyr right now.

0 coins

seconded on the phone situation. mohela hold times have been brutal this year for anything IDR related. getting a real person is half the battle

0 coins

Does Claimyr work for MOHELA specifically? I've used it for other stuff but wasn't sure about student loan servicers.

0 coins

Yeah it worked for me with MOHELA, that's exactly what I used it for. Got through to an actual agent who could pull up my account and put notes in the file.

0 coins

Ok so the ICR switch question — went through something adjacent to this last year with my own IBR account. The way my MOHELA rep explained it to me: switching plans mid-glitch doesn't fix the underlying count issue, it just moves the problem to a new plan. The forgiveness trigger is based on your payment history in the system, and if the system is currently miscounting or stuck, changing to ICR doesn't reset or fix that — it just starts you on ICR's separate track. What actually cleared my situation was getting a supervisor to submit a manual review request. The automated system wasn't going to catch it on its own.

0 coins

Wait, so the supervisor can actually flag it for manual review separately from just waiting for the system fix? That's the first actually useful thing I've heard — asking specifically for that on my next call.

0 coins

This is really good info. I had no idea a manual review was even an option. I just assumed you had to wait for whatever MOHELA decides to do on their end.

0 coins

Yeah the manual review path is real. I went through it for a PSLF count issue (different program obviously but same idea) — you have to specifically ask a supervisor, the front-line reps often don't offer it.

0 coins

Switching to ICR when you've got 300+ payments on IBR sounds risky to me honestly. ICR forgiveness is also at 25 years but it's a different calculation for the payment amount and your history doesn't just carry over seamlessly the way people assume. I'm not saying don't ever switch but doing it specifically to try to trigger a glitchy system seems like a bad reason to change plans. What does your account actually show as your forgiveness-eligible date?

0 coins

Navigating to that section of my account now — it shows a forgiveness date that's already passed, which is what makes this so maddening. The date came and went and nothing happened.

0 coins

If your shown forgiveness date already passed and nothing triggered, that's actually a stronger case for escalating than just a count discrepancy. That's worth documenting — screenshot everything with dates.

0 coins

oh wow if the date literally passed that changes things. that's not really a 'wait for the system' situation anymore, that feels more urgent

0 coins

Not to derail but can I ask something adjacent — does the IBR glitch affect PSLF qualifying payment counts too or is it just the IDR forgiveness counter? I'm on IBR targeting PSLF and now I'm paranoid my count is wrong for a totally different reason.

0 coins

Different systems — your PSLF qualifying payment count lives in a separate tracker tied to your employer certifications, not the IDR forgiveness counter. A glitch in one doesn't automatically mean the other is off. Check your PSLF payment count separately on your MOHELA account under the PSLF section.

0 coins

Pulling up my account to check the PSLF section right now, haven't looked at it in a while. Thank you.

0 coins

Also worth knowing — if you do need to call MOHELA to verify your PSLF count and you can't get through, Claimyr at claimyr.com helped me get a live agent when I was stuck in hold loops forever. I know that's a little off your original question but figured I'd drop it here since we're talking about actually reaching someone.

0 coins

I work in a university financial aid office (not a loan servicer, so take this for what it is) and I've seen a few borrowers come to us with this exact situation described differently each time. The pattern I keep seeing: people assume switching plans is a workaround but IDR forgiveness discharges are processed by the servicer after a review that's supposed to happen automatically — when the automatic part breaks, the fix is on MOHELA's end, not yours. Switching plans doesn't wave a magic wand. Document everything — your payment count screenshots, the date your forgiveness was supposed to trigger, any reference numbers from your calls — and if MOHELA doesn't fix it in a reasonable window you can escalate to the FSA Feedback Center.

0 coins

Screenshotting everything today and noting the rep reference numbers from my previous calls. FSA Feedback Center is going in my back pocket if this drags on.

0 coins

the FSA feedback center escalation is underrated. I used it for a different issue and got a response within two weeks that actually moved things. don't wait forever before going that route

0 coins

Does the FSA Feedback Center actually contact MOHELA directly or does it just log your complaint? Genuinely curious how that chain works.

0 coins

From what borrowers have told me and what I've read, Federal Student Aid follows up with the servicer — it's not just a complaint log. The FSA Ombudsman is a step further up if the Feedback Center doesn't resolve it.

0 coins

Can I be real for a second — the fact that MOHELA told you there's a 'known glitch' and to just wait feels completely unacceptable when we're talking about forgiveness someone has earned after 25 YEARS of payments. TWENTY FIVE YEARS. And the answer is 'wait for the fix'?? I've been dealing with MOHELA for years and this is exactly the kind of thing that makes people lose their minds. You shouldn't have to chase this down yourself.

0 coins

Honestly yes, that's the part that gets me the most — I did everything right for over 300 payments and now I'm the one who has to fix their system problem.

0 coins

the frustration is completely valid. 25 years is not a small thing to just 'wait on

0 coins

Something I'd double-check before doing anything else: make sure all 300+ of those payments are actually showing as qualifying for IDR forgiveness and not just as payments made. Some payments during certain deferment or forbearance periods don't count toward the IDR forgiveness clock even if they show up in your payment history. I had a chunk of payments that were in a forbearance I didn't ask for and those months didn't count — took me a while to figure out why my count looked weird.

0 coins

Going through my payment history line by line to flag any forbearance months that shouldn't count — honestly hadn't thought to separate those out. Good call.

0 coins

This is a really important point. Administrative forbearance months are sometimes counted and sometimes not depending on the type of forbearance and when it happened. Your MOHELA account should show the status of each payment period but it can be hard to read.

0 coins

wait how do you even tell which forbearance months count and which don't from the account view? the payment history on mine just shows a status code that doesn't explain anything

0 coins

Has anyone had experience with what happens to your IDR forgiveness timeline if you switch servicers in the middle of this? I transferred to MOHELA from a different servicer about two years ago and I'm paranoid the transfer messed up some of my earlier payment history.

0 coins

Transfers can and do cause payment history import errors — it's one of the more common issues. Your old servicer's records should have been transferred to MOHELA but it's worth pulling your full payment history and cross-referencing it against any old statements you kept from your previous servicer. If there are gaps, that's what you'd flag in a call or in a Feedback Center complaint.

0 coins

Digging out my old statements from before the transfer — hadn't thought to compare them side by side like that.

0 coins

Circling back to the ICR question specifically since that's kind of the core of what OP asked — my situation was different (I was considering switching from SAVE to ICR during all the SAVE plan uncertainty) and the rep I finally reached after using Claimyr to get through the hold queue actually walked me through what a plan switch would and wouldn't preserve. What she told me was that your payment count history follows you but the forgiveness clock resets to the new plan's terms. So if ICR's terms aren't better for you than IBR's already-vested 25-year clock, you're not gaining anything and potentially resetting progress. That made me decide to stay put and wait out the fix instead.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of specific answer I needed — the idea that the forgiveness clock could reset on a plan switch is what I was most worried about and no one at MOHELA spelled it out that clearly for me.

0 coins

Yeah that's the key thing people don't realize. 'Your history follows you' and 'your forgiveness timeline stays the same' are two different things. Good rep who explained that clearly.

0 coins

the fact that you had to use a third party service just to get clear information from your own loan servicer is itself a whole thing but glad you got the answer

0 coins

Quick logistical question — when you're documenting everything for a potential escalation, are screenshots of your MOHELA account actually useful or do you need to request something more official? Like a formal payment history document?

0 coins

Screenshots with timestamps are useful for your own records and for reference when you're talking to a rep. If you escalate to the FSA Feedback Center they can pull official records directly from the servicer — you don't have to provide the documentation yourself, though having it helps you describe the issue precisely.

0 coins

Requesting an official payment history from MOHELA through their secure message center too, just to have something in writing from them directly.

0 coins

I did both — screenshots for me and an official payment history request submitted through MOHELA's message system. The message center request created a paper trail which turned out to be useful later.

0 coins

ok genuine question that might be dumb — if the glitch is 'known' does that mean MOHELA actually has a list of affected accounts or is 'known glitch' just what reps say when they don't know what else to say? Because those are very different things and it matters a lot for how long you'd actually wait.

0 coins

Honestly, from my experience, 'known issue' from a front-line rep can mean anything from 'we have an active ticket on this' to 'I've heard other people mention something like this.' Ask specifically whether your account has been flagged in the system and whether there's a ticket number associated with it. If they can give you a ticket or case number, that's real. If they can't, push to speak to a supervisor.

0 coins

that is a very important distinction I had not considered. ticket number = real. 'known issue' with nothing attached = maybe not so real.

0 coins

Asking for a case or ticket number on my next call — that's a concrete thing I can follow up on. Really hadn't thought to ask for that specifically.

0 coins

Something that might be worth flagging: the IDR forgiveness process went through a lot of changes over the past few years with the one-time account adjustment and various court stuff. Is it possible your 300+ count includes months that were added through the account adjustment and MOHELA's system is having trouble processing a forgiveness that's partially based on adjustment-added months vs. payments you made directly? I'm not sure if that's a thing but it feels like the kind of edge case that would cause exactly this kind of stuck situation.

0 coins

That's actually a really plausible theory. The one-time account adjustment added months to a lot of people's counts all at once and the systems weren't all fully ready to process forgiveness for accounts that hit the threshold through adjustment months. I'd specifically ask MOHELA whether the adjustment-added months are what's causing the processing hang.

0 coins

Flagging this exact question for my next call — the adjustment did add a significant chunk to my count so this could absolutely be the reason. Really helpful angle I hadn't considered.

0 coins

Let us know what they say — genuinely curious if that's the cause because I've seen other people in similar situations and it might explain a lot.

0 coins

I went through something frustrating with MOHELA a few months back that isn't exactly the same but similar enough — my IDR recertification wasn't processing and I was stuck in limbo for weeks. The thing that finally moved it was getting a live agent on the phone who could actually put a note in the system. I'd been trying to call during normal hours and kept hitting full queues. Eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get into the queue without sitting on hold — got through to someone within a couple hours and they were able to push my recertification to the right team manually. If you're still not getting through, it might be worth trying.

0 coins

Does it work if you're calling during peak times? That's when I always seem to need to call and can never get through.

0 coins

That's actually when I used it — it was mid-morning on a Tuesday which is probably the worst time to call a loan servicer and I still got through. The whole point is it handles the queue waiting so you're not just hitting redial.

0 coins

ok adding this to my toolkit. I have a recertification question coming up and I dread calling MOHELA for anything

0 coins

Does switching from IBR to ICR affect your monthly payment amount significantly? Because if the glitch is a temporary thing and you switch plans to try to force it, you might end up with a higher payment in the meantime while the fix takes longer than expected.

0 coins

ICR and IBR calculate differently — IBR caps at a percentage of your discretionary income and ICR is a different percentage with a different definition of discretionary income. Depending on your income and family size one might be higher or lower for you personally. You'd want to run the numbers on StudentAid.gov's loan simulator before making any switch, not just assume ICR is comparable.

0 coins

Running the loan simulator on StudentAid.gov before doing anything — hadn't thought to use that tool for this scenario but makes total sense.

0 coins

Using the loan simulator is a good call regardless — even if I don't switch I want to understand what I'd be getting into. Adding that to my research list.

0 coins

This whole thread is making me want to screenshot my entire MOHELA account right now just as a baseline. Is that paranoid or is that just smart at this point?

0 coins

Completely smart, not paranoid at all. Payment histories can change after account adjustments or system updates and having a dated record of what your account showed at a given point is actually useful if you ever need to dispute something.

0 coins

Screenshotting everything tonight — payment history, qualifying payment count, forgiveness date shown, all of it. Better to have it.

0 coins

do it. i wish i had done this earlier with my own account. i had to reconstruct a timeline from memory when i was disputing something and it was a nightmare

0 coins

Has anyone gotten MOHELA to put anything in writing about the glitch — like a secure message or anything that acknowledges your account is affected? I feel like verbal 'wait for the fix' from a phone rep is not something you can use later if this drags on for months.

0 coins

Sending a secure message through the MOHELA portal asking them to confirm in writing that your account has been flagged for the known processing issue is 100% the right move. A written response from them creates a paper trail that a phone rep's verbal assurance doesn't. They may respond with something vague but even that is better than nothing documented.

0 coins

Sending a secure message specifically asking for written confirmation of the glitch — hadn't thought to do it that way but that's exactly the kind of paper trail that could matter.

0 coins

Doing this tonight. Even a vague written response is something. Great idea.

0 coins

I'm kind of late to this thread but wanted to add — did anyone mention the FSA Ombudsman specifically? That's a step up from the FSA Feedback Center and from what I understand it's specifically for situations where you've tried the servicer and normal complaint channels and nothing has resolved. If MOHELA acknowledges a glitch that's preventing your forgiveness from triggering and doesn't fix it within a reasonable time, that feels like exactly the Ombudsman situation.

0 coins

Yes the FSA Ombudsman is specifically for unresolved disputes — they can advocate directly with the servicer on your behalf. It's not a first step but if you've got documentation, a ticket number from MOHELA, and a Feedback Center complaint that hasn't resolved things, it's the right escalation.

0 coins

Writing down this whole escalation path: secure message → Feedback Center → Ombudsman. That's the clearest roadmap I've gotten in this whole thread and I really appreciate it.

0 coins

Good luck — come back and update us if you get this resolved. I feel like a lot of people must be dealing with something similar and it would be good to know what actually worked.

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure