< Back to Washington Unemployment

Tyler Lefleur

Quit due to workplace harassment - ESD denied claim but items still in adjudication?

I'm so confused about my ESD claim status right now. After enduring 3 years of workplace harassment (documented with HR multiple times!), I finally quit when someone egged my car in the company parking lot. That was the last straw. I filed for unemployment 6 weeks ago, and today got a letter saying I'm denied benefits. But when I check my eServices account, it shows all weeks as "disqualified" BUT ALSO shows 3 items still in adjudication. How can they deny my claim while things are still being investigated? Do I wait for the adjudication to finish or should I file an appeal now based on the denial letter? The timing makes no sense to me. Anyone dealt with this kind of mixed message from ESD before?

You need to file your appeal right away. You only have 30 days from the date on that denial letter to submit it. Don't wait for the adjudication to finish - that could be a system glitch or they might be investigating different aspects of your claim. The appeal process is separate and has a strict deadline. Make sure you include all your HR documentation about the harassment when you submit your appeal. Since you quit, you'll need to prove it was for "good cause" related to the work environment.

0 coins

Tyler Lefleur

•

Thank you! I was worried about that 30-day window. Do you know if I can submit the appeal online through eServices or do I need to mail it in? And should I mention the ongoing adjudication items in my appeal letter?

0 coins

Max Knight

•

omg this happend to me 2!! they denied me but had stuff still in adjudaction. its so stupid how they do that. i talked to my friend and she said its cuz they decided on the main reason u quit but still looking at other stuff. but yeah do the appeal thing fast!!

0 coins

Tyler Lefleur

•

It's so frustrating! Did you end up appealing your denial? How long did that process take?

0 coins

Emma Swift

•

THE SYSTEM IS RIGGED AGAINST US! They automatically deny people who quit and make you fight through appeals. I had DOCUMENTED HARASSMENT too and they still denied me initially. You have to appeal and be super specific about why you had NO CHOICE but to quit. Document EVERYTHING. Dates, names, incidents, when you reported to HR, copies of emails. They make it confusing on purpose with the "adjudication" stuff still showing!!! It's just to confuse you and hope you miss the appeal deadline!!!

0 coins

While I understand your frustration, the system isn't designed to automatically deny claims. ESD has to follow specific legal guidelines. For voluntary quits, the burden of proof is on the claimant to demonstrate good cause, which is why documentation is crucial. The adjudication items still showing could be related to different eligibility factors that are evaluated separately.

0 coins

This is actually fairly common with voluntary quit situations. ESD typically makes an initial determination on the main separation issue (your quit) while potentially still investigating other aspects of your claim (like ability to work, availability, etc). You should definitely file your appeal within the 30-day timeframe if you believe your quit was for good cause. Make sure your appeal specifically addresses: 1) The harassment was work-related, 2) You reported it to your employer, 3) The employer failed to resolve it, and 4) You had no reasonable alternative but to quit. Documentation from HR will be crucial here.

0 coins

Tyler Lefleur

•

That makes sense. I do have email trails and copies of my HR reports. For the appeal, should I also get statements from coworkers who witnessed the harassment? Or is documentation from HR sufficient?

0 coins

Jayden Hill

•

when i quit my toxic job last year they denied me too... but i never appealed cuz i didnt think id win. now i regret it. definitely appeal!! and yeah the whole adjudication thing is weird, mine sat like that for months even after i gave up on the claim

0 coins

LordCommander

•

I went through something similar with workplace harassment in 2024. Had to appeal after initial denial. The key is having documentation ready. Since you reported to HR multiple times and have statements, you're in a better position than I was. One thing that really helped me was being able to actually speak with an ESD agent to understand what was happening with my claim. After days of trying, I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent in about 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3. The agent explained exactly what was happening with my different adjudication items and gave me specific advice for my appeal.

0 coins

Max Knight

•

omg never heard of that service before! did it actually work? i spend like 4 hours trying to get thru last month!!

0 coins

LordCommander

•

Yes, it worked for me! Much better than sitting on hold for hours or getting hung up on. The agent I spoke with was able to see exactly why there were still items in adjudication even after the initial denial and explained what specific evidence I needed for my appeal.

0 coins

Lucy Lam

•

One important thing to understand is that ESD evaluates different eligibility factors separately. They may have made a determination on your separation issue (the quit) while still investigating other aspects like your ability to work or availability. Here's what I recommend: 1. File your appeal immediately - you have 30 days from the date on the determination letter. 2. In your appeal, focus specifically on proving you had good cause to quit due to harassment. 3. Include ALL documentation: HR reports, emails, witness statements if possible. 4. Continue to file your weekly claims during the appeal process. 5. Be prepared for a hearing where you'll need to explain your situation. For workplace harassment cases, you need to show you made reasonable efforts to resolve the situation before quitting (your HR reports help with this). The fact that the harassment escalated to property damage (your car being egged) strengthens your case for good cause.

0 coins

Tyler Lefleur

•

Thank you for the detailed advice! I didn't realize I should keep filing weekly claims during the appeal. As for the hearing, is that typically in person, over the phone, or can it be done virtually? I want to be prepared.

0 coins

Lucy Lam

•

Most hearings are done by phone now, though some are virtual. You'll get a notice with all the details. Make sure to prepare a timeline of events to reference during the hearing, and have all your documentation organized and ready. The judge will likely ask you specific questions about why you felt you had to quit and what steps you took before quitting. Be concise but thorough in your answers.

0 coins

Since you mentioned filing statements with HR multiple times, make sure to include copies of ALL of those with your appeal. For voluntary quit cases related to harassment, ESD is looking for evidence that 1) the harassment was severe enough to justify quitting and 2) you made reasonable attempts to resolve the issue before quitting. The car egging incident should be documented as well - did you file a police report? That would strengthen your case substantially.

0 coins

Max Knight

•

i just remembered something! my friend who had a similar thing happen said its super important in ur appeal to use the exact words "good cause" when explaining why u quit. they look for that specific term i guess? also mention that u had "no reasonable alternative" but to quit. those are like the magic words apparently lol

0 coins

This is actually good advice. The legal standard ESD uses for voluntary quits is indeed "good cause," and specifically for workplace issues, you need to demonstrate that you had "no reasonable alternative" but to leave the job. Using this terminology shows you understand the standard they're applying to your case.

0 coins

Lucy Lam

•

Quick update question - did your denial letter specifically state the reason for denial? If it mentions your voluntary quit as the reason, then that confirms they've made a determination on the separation issue while still investigating other aspects of your claim. This is important because it tells you exactly what to focus on in your appeal.

0 coins

Tyler Lefleur

•

Yes, the letter specifically says "Your request for unemployment benefits is denied because you quit your job without good cause." It doesn't mention anything about the other items in adjudication. So frustrating that they didn't consider all my HR documentation!

0 coins

Lucy Lam

•

Perfect - now you know exactly what to address in your appeal. Focus on proving you had good cause to quit due to harassment. Make sure to include a chronology of events, copies of all HR reports, and emphasize that the harassment escalated to property damage. Also note that you attempted to resolve the issues through proper channels (HR) multiple times before quitting. This gives you a solid foundation for your appeal.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today