Back to Washington Unemployment

Henry Delgado

How to cancel unemployment claim to file a new one after going back to work?

Okay so this is kind of embarrassing to admit but I've been sitting on an open unemployment claim for almost two months now and never actually filed any weekly claims on it. I got laid off from my warehouse job in February, started the claim, then my old employer called me back for a temporary project that ran about six weeks. I figured I'd just pause and pick back up when the project ended but then I got a different permanent job offer mid-March and took it. That job just ended last week — they did a round of layoffs and I was in the last-hired group so I got cut. Now I want to file for unemployment again but I don't know if I should be using my old open claim or if I need a completely new one. The old claim has zero weeks filed on it. I did a little research and some people say you just file weekly claims on the existing claim, others say you need to cancel it and start fresh especially if your base year has changed. My base year situation is definitely different now because I have earnings from both the warehouse and this new job. Can someone help me clarify — do I actually need to know how to cancel unemployment claim to file a new one, or can I work with what's already open?

Your employer situation rings a bell — the fact that you have new earnings from a completely different job is the thing that matters here. When your base year has changed significantly and you have new wages from a new employer, filing on the old claim might actually shortchange you. Washington ESD uses your wages from roughly the first four of the last five completed quarters to calculate your weekly benefit amount. If you filed on that old claim right now, it might not count the new job's wages at all. Starting fresh often gets you a higher weekly benefit amount if you earned more recently. That said, you don't just 'cancel' a claim through some button — you'd call ESD and ask them to withdraw or close the existing claim, then file a new one. Some people skip this step and just file the new claim directly, which sometimes triggers adjudication because ESD sees two active claim records.

0 coins

Writing this down so I don't forget — so calling ESD to close the old claim first is the safer route before filing anything new, got it. What number do you call for this, is it the main claims line?

0 coins

Yeah the main claims line is what you want, 800-318-6022. Tell them right away you have an existing open claim with no weeks filed and you need to withdraw it before opening a new benefit year. They can usually handle it in one call.

0 coins

Does this mean his weekly benefit amount could go up pretty noticeably with the new wages included?

0 coins

Depending on what he earned at the new job it could go up quite a bit. Warehouse work plus a full-time permanent job even for a few months can bump the weekly benefit calculation meaningfully.

0 coins

Wait — did you actually certify for ANY weeks on the old claim, even accidentally? Like zero means you logged in and filed zero claims, right, not that you filed weeks and got $0?

0 coins

Pulling up my account right now to double check — yeah, it shows zero weeks certified, I literally only got to the initial claim filing step and then stopped.

0 coins

Okay that makes things cleaner. No certified weeks means no payment history, so withdrawing it is simpler and there's less chance of an overpayment issue popping up later.

0 coins

This is actually the key detail here, good catch.

0 coins

Getting through to ESD on that claims line is honestly the hardest part of this whole process — I tried for three days straight and either got disconnected or was on hold for 2+ hours. What ended up working for me was using Claimyr. It basically holds your place in the ESD call queue and calls you back when an agent is ready. Saved me from sitting there redial-ing all day. You can check it out at claimyr.com and they have a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ. For something like withdrawing a claim, you really do need to talk to an actual agent and not just the automated system.

0 coins

Bookmarking that link — the hold time thing is what I was dreading most about this whole process honestly.

0 coins

Can confirm the hold times are brutal lately. Anything requiring an actual account change is worse than just checking status.

0 coins

Is that callback thing available for Washington ESD specifically? Some of these services only do certain states.

0 coins

Yep, works for Washington ESD specifically. That's exactly what I used it for.

0 coins

Something I want to flag because I see people get tripped up on this — the 'new claim vs old claim' question isn't just about base year wages. It also depends on whether your benefit year has actually expired. A benefit year lasts 52 weeks from when you opened the original claim. If you're still inside that 52-week window, Washington ESD may require you to exhaust or withdraw the first claim before they'll open a new benefit year. Since you opened yours in February and it's only been a couple months, you're definitely still in the original benefit year. That means you can't just file a 'new' claim on the ESD website without that old one being addressed first.

0 coins

So theoretically he could file on the old claim for the weeks his permanent job ended, using the old base year wages?

0 coins

Technically yes but that could mean a lower weekly amount if the old base year doesn't capture his more recent earnings. The smart move is withdrawing and opening fresh — but only if the new base year wages are actually higher.

0 coins

Checking my old pay stubs to compare — do you know if ESD can tell me what my benefit amount would be under each option before I commit to one?

0 coins

They can run a rough estimate when you call. Ask the agent specifically to compare both scenarios before they process anything.

0 coins

Piggyback question here — my situation is similar but I did certify for about three weeks on my old claim before getting rehired. Now I'm laid off again. Am I completely out of options on a new claim? I tried calling ESD forever and couldn't get through. Someone mentioned Claimyr upthread and I finally tried it last week — honestly it worked exactly like they described, got connected to an agent in like 45 minutes instead of the usual multi-hour ordeal. The agent told me that because I had certified weeks, I'd need to go through a formal claim withdrawal request and there might be a waiting period before they'd open a new benefit year. So for anyone with zero weeks filed like OP, the process is actually simpler than mine.

0 coins

Three certified weeks and then a new job — did the agent say if you'd owe anything back or if the payments were legitimate since you were actually unemployed those weeks?

0 coins

Asking that exact question was my first priority on the call. She said since I was genuinely unemployed and reported everything correctly, those weeks were valid and I wouldn't owe anything back. The withdrawal just means closing out the claim going forward.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. I was worried certified weeks made the whole thing complicated.

0 coins

Makes sense that certified-but-legitimate weeks are fine. It's only a problem if you certified while working and didn't report earnings.

0 coins

Honestly just want to vent for a second because I went through almost this exact scenario last spring. I had a gap claim from a previous layoff and tried to 'reactivate' it like the website suggested. ESD processed it as a continuation of the old claim and my weekly benefit amount was based on wages from almost two years prior. Took me six weeks of phone calls to get it sorted and by then I'd filed three weeks on the wrong claim with the wrong benefit amount. It was a mess. If I could do it over I would have called ESD first, before touching ANYTHING online, and gotten explicit instructions on whether to withdraw or continue.

0 coins

That story is exactly what I'm afraid of — glad I asked before clicking anything. Did they eventually fix your weekly benefit amount?

0 coins

They did fix it but it took a formal adjustment request and about three extra weeks of waiting before I saw the corrected payment. Not fun when you're counting on that money.

0 coins

This is why the phone call first approach is so important for anything non-standard. The website is built for straightforward cases.

0 coins

ESD's website really does not make this obvious at all, I had no idea claims had expiration timelines until reading this thread.

0 coins

Quick clarification on terminology because I see some confusion in these threads — 'withdrawing' a claim and 'canceling' a claim are basically the same thing as far as ESD is concerned, but the word they use internally is 'withdrawal.' When you call, use that word specifically. Telling the agent you want to 'cancel' your claim sometimes confuses the interaction because agents might interpret that as canceling a weekly certification rather than closing the whole claim. Also, when the agent asks why you're withdrawing, say 'returned to work and have new base year wages' — that flags it for the right processing path.

0 coins

Saving this exact wording — 'withdrawal' and 'returned to work with new base year wages.' Exactly what I needed.

0 coins

Is there any paperwork or written confirmation after they process the withdrawal?

0 coins

You should get a notice in your eServices account inbox within a few business days confirming the claim status changed. Screenshot it or download it as proof.

0 coins

Good tip on the terminology, that kind of miscommunication seems like it would be really easy to have with ESD.

0 coins

Had a weird thing happen when I tried to close out a dormant claim last year — the agent told me the claim had already auto-expired because I went more than 52 weeks without filing. So I didn't even need a formal withdrawal, I just filed a new claim directly and it went through without any adjudication. Not sure if that applies here since OP is still pretty fresh into the benefit year, but just flagging that if you wait long enough the problem solves itself in a way. I also want to add that Claimyr came up earlier and yeah I've used it too — if the ESD phone line is being impossible, that's genuinely the most practical workaround I've found for getting complex questions answered by an actual human.

0 coins

Mine definitely hasn't expired yet, it's only been a couple months. But useful to know for future reference.

0 coins

Auto-expiration is real but definitely don't count on it strategically — the timing of when it actually processes in ESD's system can vary and you don't want limbo during that window.

0 coins

Waiting it out also means you can't file weekly claims during that whole time, right? So you'd just be going without benefits longer.

0 coins

What industry was your permanent job in? I ask because certain industries have different documentation requirements when you refile — like if you were in a union or had a collective bargaining agreement, there are sometimes extra steps in the new claim process around confirming your separation reason.

0 coins

No union involved — it was a small tech startup, standard at-will employment, laid off due to reduction in force. Pretty clean separation.

0 coins

Clean layoffs are the easiest case. No misconduct issue to adjudicate, no union paperwork, just straightforward separation. Your new claim should process quickly once the withdrawal clears.

0 coins

RIF layoffs are genuinely the most straightforward separations for unemployment eligibility. Good that you don't have any misconduct complication.

0 coins

Real talk — the job search requirement starts immediately on your new claim, not after your first payment. I see people mess this up constantly. Washington ESD requires you to complete three job search activities per week for every week you certify starting from the very first week. If you're certifying during a week where you weren't actively job searching, you have to report that and it can affect your eligibility for that week. Just make sure you have your three activities documented before you file your first weekly claim on the new benefit year.

0 coins

Writing this in my notes app right now — three job search activities per week starting week one, documented. Does using a job board count or does it have to be actual applications?

0 coins

Applying counts, but so do things like creating or updating your resume on a job site, attending a WorkSource workshop, doing a formal job interview, or making direct employer contact. Just make sure you can describe each activity with the employer name, contact method, and date if ESD audits your log.

0 coins

Is there any grace period on the job search requirement for the first week after you file?

0 coins

The first week after filing is typically your waiting week, so you don't get paid for it, but the job search requirement still applies technically. Some people skip documenting that week and it comes back to bite them if ESD ever audits.

0 coins

For the base year calculation question — your situation after being laid off from the startup mid-year is a good example of why re-filing often makes more financial sense. Say your warehouse job paid you around $18/hr and your startup gig was paying you something higher, maybe $24-26/hr. Even if you only worked the startup job for two to three months, that concentrated chunk of wages in one quarter can really shift your average quarterly wage calculation upward. Washington ESD divides your two highest earning quarters and that becomes the basis for your weekly amount. More recent higher-paying work almost always pushes that number up. The withdrawal and refile path is almost certainly the right call in your case.

0 coins

That math actually makes me more motivated to get this sorted quickly. I was at $22/hr at the startup, up from $17 at the warehouse.

0 coins

That difference matters. Two high-earning quarters at $22/hr versus older quarters at $17/hr could mean meaningfully more per week. Worth every minute of the phone call to get it set up right.

0 coins

This is exactly the scenario I wish someone had explained to me before I reactivated instead of refiling.

0 coins

Does any of this change if he had any earnings he didn't report during those few weeks between the warehouse job and the new one? Like is there any look-back for that?

0 coins

The look-back for unreported earnings would only matter if he had filed weekly claims during that time. Since he filed zero weeks on the open claim, there's no certification period where he was obligated to report earnings. No certified weeks means no reporting obligation triggered.

0 coins

Oh that makes sense. The obligation to report is tied to actually certifying, not just having an open claim.

0 coins

Exactly. Opening a claim puts you in the system but the weekly certification is what creates the obligation to report wages for that specific week.

0 coins

Just want to say this whole thread helped me understand something I've been confused about for weeks. I had a similar dormant claim situation and was scared to touch it because I didn't understand the benefit year stuff.

0 coins

Same honestly — glad I posted instead of just guessing and clicking around on the ESD website.

0 coins

These are the cases where the ESD website genuinely fails people. It's designed for simple in-out claims, not for people with complicated work histories or dormant claims.

0 coins

Agreed, I spent like an hour on the ESD FAQ and still couldn't figure out my situation.

0 coins

Follow up question — once OP gets the withdrawal processed, how long before he can actually file the new claim? Is there a waiting period between withdrawal approval and new claim eligibility?

0 coins

Usually pretty quick, like 1-3 business days for the withdrawal to fully process in ESD's system. Once the old claim shows closed in eServices, you can file the new claim directly on the website. I'd call and confirm the closure before filing just to be safe.

0 coins

So realistically he could have this wrapped up within a week of making the call?

0 coins

Probably yes, assuming no complications. The 1-week waiting period for the new claim would start once it's approved, so the sooner he calls the sooner that clock starts.

0 coins

The waiting week thing is annoying but unavoidable. At least the job search activities during waiting week count toward your documented history.

0 coins

Has anyone tried doing any of this through the ESD eServices online secure messaging instead of calling? I've been trying to avoid the phone hold situation.

0 coins

Secure messaging works for some things but claim withdrawal is usually flagged as requiring a phone call. ESD treats it as a significant account action that needs verbal confirmation. I tried the message route once and they messaged back telling me to call anyway.

0 coins

Ugh that's frustrating, feels like they deliberately push you to the phone line.

0 coins

For account-level changes like this, verbal confirmation is actually a fraud-prevention measure. Same reason they want you on the phone for address changes or bank info updates. Annoying but it has a logic to it.

0 coins

I didn't know that about secure messaging having limits — assumed it could handle most requests.

0 coins

Genuine question about the new base year — if OP worked at the warehouse from like January through mid-February, then the temp project ran mid-Feb through late March, then the startup from late March through last week... how does ESD slice up the quarters to figure out which wages count?

0 coins

The base year is the first four of the last five complete calendar quarters before you file. 'Complete' meaning fully ended, so Q1 of this year might not be in the base year yet depending on when exactly he files the new claim. All wages from all employers within that base year window count toward the calculation — ESD pulls from wage records reported by each employer separately.

0 coins

So all three employers' wages could potentially count in a fresh calculation if they all fall within those four quarters?

0 coins

Potentially yes. Warehouse wages, temp project wages, and startup wages could all be in scope depending on exact dates. That's why a fresh claim calculation might be quite a bit higher than the old one.

0 coins

Came here searching for info on exactly this situation and this thread is gold. One thing I'll add from my own experience: when you call ESD to do the withdrawal, have your claim ID number ready. It's the number that starts with 'SS' in your eServices account. Giving that to the agent immediately speeds things up because they can pull your account without having to verify through the full ID process first.

0 coins

Pulling that up right now — found it in the account summary section. Got it ready.

0 coins

Also write down the name of the agent and the time/date of the call. If anything gets processed incorrectly, having that reference makes follow-up calls so much faster.

0 coins

The documentation habit is huge. I wish I'd done this during my own ESD nightmare last year.

0 coins

Alright update for everyone who helped — called ESD this morning using the method someone shared above to get through faster. Talked to an agent named M (she said she couldn't give full names), explained I had a dormant claim with zero certified weeks and new base year wages from a different employer. She pulled up my claim, confirmed zero weeks filed, and processed the withdrawal while I was on the phone. Took about 12 minutes total once I was connected. She said the new claim should be available to file within 48 hours and confirmed my new base year would include wages from both my second and third jobs. Weekly benefit estimate she quoted was about $180 more per week than my original claim would have paid. SO worth making the call.

0 coins

$180 more per week is massive — that's the difference the base year update can make. Really glad you pushed to do this the right way.

0 coins

Great outcome! That weekly benefit difference adds up fast over a full claim.

0 coins

This thread is going to help a lot of people. The 'just refile' instinct is usually right when you have new wages from a new employer.

0 coins

This is the best kind of update. Congrats on getting it sorted and good luck with the new claim.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure