Do I have to use up PTO before getting unemployment during furlough?
So my employer just told us we're being furloughed for at least 6 weeks starting next Monday. HR sent out this whole packet and buried in page 4 it says employees 'may be required to exhaust accrued paid leave before accessing outside benefits.' I have about 112 hours of PTO saved up and I've been hoarding it for a vacation I'll obviously never take now. I work in commercial printing and our biggest client pulled their contract, so this isn't some pandemic thing, it's just a straight business slowdown. My question is whether Washington ESD actually requires me to burn through all my PTO first before I can file for unemployment, or if that language is just the company covering itself legally. I don't want to file too early and get denied, but I also don't want to sit here for weeks waiting when I could be getting benefits. Anyone gone through a furlough with PTO still on the books?
55 comments

Peyton Clarke
Week 2 of my own furlough when I'm writing this, so this is fresh for me. The short answer is it depends on how your employer classifies the PTO payout. Washington ESD looks at whether you're receiving wages during the furlough period. If your company is forcing you to use PTO during the furlough, those days count as wages and ESD will reduce or eliminate your weekly benefit for whatever weeks you're getting paid out. So if you have 112 hours and you work 40 hour weeks, that's roughly 2.8 weeks where you'd be receiving wages and wouldn't qualify. But here's the thing - if your employer is NOT requiring you to use PTO and you're just choosing to hold onto it, you can file for UI right now. The HR language you're describing sounds like a company policy thing, not an ESD requirement. You need to find out specifically whether your employer is going to pay out PTO automatically or if it's your choice to use it.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorJust got off email with HR actually - they said using PTO during the furlough is 'strongly encouraged' but not mandatory. So technically I don't have to burn it. Does that change things for the ESD claim?
0 coins
Vince Eh
My first week of my furlough last year I had the same situation. If it's truly optional and they're not scheduling you for PTO days, you're good to file. ESD doesn't penalize you for HAVING PTO, only for receiving PTO payments during weeks you're claiming. Keep those 112 hours for whenever you go back.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
Got my determination letter about three weeks into my furlough and it specifically asked about any wages received. PTO you're not using doesn't count as wages received. You're fine to file now.
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
Just finished my fourth weekly claim this morning so timing on this is good. I want to flag something that tripped me up during my own furlough claim last spring - I could NOT get through to ESD for two weeks trying to ask this exact same kind of question. Kept getting the busy signal recording or waiting 90 minutes to get disconnected. Someone here actually told me about a service called Claimyr that gets you through to a live ESD agent without you sitting on hold forever. I used it, got through in about 20 minutes, and the agent clarified everything about my PTO situation directly. Their site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you want to see how it works before trying it. For a question like yours where the answer really depends on your specific employer setup, talking to an actual ESD agent is worth it.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorHonestly the idea of calling ESD and waiting forever has been part of why I haven't filed yet. I'll check out that video tonight. Did the agent give you a definitive answer about PTO or was it still kind of vague?
0 coins
Ezra Beard
Three weeks into adjudication on my current claim and I wish I'd known about this earlier. The phone situation with ESD is genuinely terrible. You call, wait, get disconnected, repeat. Anything that cuts through that is useful.
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
My whole furlough experience last year was basically just fighting with the phone system. This would have saved me so much stress.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
Submitted my first weekly claim two days ago and saw your post right after. I'll give you the rule the way my uncle who worked in HR explained it to me after I got burned on my own layoff situation. He said think of it this way: ESD is measuring whether money is hitting your bank account from your employer in a given week. If yes, that counts against your UI for that week. If no, you're in the clear regardless of what's sitting in your PTO balance. Where people mess up is they voluntarily use a PTO day here and there during the furlough thinking it's free money on top of their UI, then they get an overpayment notice six months later because those PTO payments were wages. Don't do that. File now, don't touch your PTO, claim every week of the furlough. When you go back to work you'll still have your PTO intact.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorThis is the clearest explanation I've seen. So the vacation hours just sit there untouched, I collect UI for the furlough weeks, and then when I return to work everything is normal with my PTO balance?
0 coins
Aria Khan
Received a confusing determination letter last month that turned out to be about exactly this. Your uncle's explanation is correct. I had a coworker who used two PTO days during her furlough thinking she was supplementing her income and ended up with an $800 overpayment notice. ESD matched the payroll records.
0 coins
Everett Tutum
Starting week three of my furlough and I had this same conversation with an ESD agent I reached through Claimyr actually. The agent walked me through how the wage reporting works for PTO specifically. Really worth calling them if you have any doubt about how to report things correctly - even one week reported wrong can spiral into an overpayment situation. claimyr.com is the site if you haven't looked it up yet.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
Got my approval letter last Friday after a pretty stressful two weeks so I feel like I can contribute here. One thing nobody mentioned yet - you need to look at whether your company will pay out unused PTO if you end up getting laid off after the furlough. Some companies have a use-it-or-lose-it policy and others pay it out. If yours pays it out at separation, holding onto your PTO is definitely the right move because you get cash at the end. If it's use-it-or-lose-it, that's a harder calculation, but even then using PTO during the furlough would offset your UI dollar for dollar so you're not really gaining anything financially.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorLooked up our employee handbook just now - we do get PTO paid out at separation. So holding onto it is definitely the right call. Good catch.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
My company had the same policy and I held onto my PTO during my furlough last year for exactly this reason. When they made the furlough permanent I got a nice chunk back. Worth knowing your company's policy before making any decisions.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
HR at my job tried to tell me I HAD to use PTO during the furlough. That turned out to be false - Washington ESD does not require it and my employer couldn't legally force me to under the specific circumstances of my layoff. Ended up not mattering because they recalled us after 5 weeks, but worth knowing employers sometimes get this wrong too.
0 coins
Melissa Lin
WAIT. I just want to make sure people aren't giving wrong info here. I was told by someone that you have to report PTO on your weekly claim even if you're not being paid out, just because you have it. That doesn't sound right but I don't want OP to get in trouble if that's actually true??
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
Filing my sixth weekly claim as I read this. That is not how it works. You only report income you actually received during the claim week. Accrued PTO sitting in your balance is not income and you don't report it. Only if your employer actually pays it out to you in a given week does it need to be reported.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
Confirmed wrong. ESD asks about wages and payments received, not about benefits you have available. Your PTO balance is irrelevant until someone actually pays it to you.
0 coins
Melissa Lin
ok good, the person who told me that was just confused then. thanks for clearing that up
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Dealing with my adjudication status going on day 18 and stumbled on this thread. Slightly different question but related - what about sick leave? I have 3 weeks of sick leave on top of PTO. Same rules apply right? Sick leave you're not using doesn't affect your UI?
0 coins
Vince Eh
My paperwork from ESD when I went through this covered both PTO and sick leave. Same principle - only payments you actually receive matter. Sitting sick leave balance doesn't affect anything.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
Got the same question answered in my own ESD review. Sick leave, vacation leave, personal days - all the same treatment. The dollar amount in your bank account that week from your employer is what matters, not what you've accrued.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Thank you, that's what I figured but wanted confirmation from people who went through it
0 coins
Romeo Quest
my furlough started last week. i think u also have to do the job search thing even on furlough? like 3 activities a week? or does standby apply here
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
About to submit my claim for the week and yes, job search requirements are real for furloughed workers UNLESS your employer puts you on official standby status with ESD. If they filed standby paperwork, you're exempt from the job search requirement for up to 8 weeks. If they didn't, you have to do the 3 job search activities per week just like anyone else.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
my hr hasnt said anything about standby status so i guess i have to do the job search thing. annoying but ok
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorHad no idea about standby status, I'm going to ask HR about this explicitly. If the company filed that paperwork it would make the whole furlough much simpler from a UI standpoint.
0 coins
Aria Khan
My employer filed standby for about half of us and not the others due to some HR mix-up. The ones not on standby had to do job searches even though we were all getting recalled. It was frustrating. Definitely confirm with HR either way.
0 coins
Val Rossi
Something clicked for me reading this whole thread that I wish someone had explained to me before my first furlough two years ago. I reported a PTO payout correctly on one weekly claim and ESD processed it fine - my benefit that week was just reduced by the PTO amount rather than eliminated entirely. So even if you DO end up receiving some PTO payment, it's not necessarily a disaster, it just reduces that week's benefit. The overpayment problems happen when people DON'T report the PTO payment and later ESD matches it against payroll records.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorThat's actually reassuring. So transparency is the key - if for some reason PTO comes through, report it and your benefit adjusts. Got it.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
Exactly right. Partial weeks, partial PTO payouts, all of it just gets factored into the weekly benefit calculation as long as you report honestly. It's the unreported stuff that becomes an overpayment nightmare months later.
0 coins
Ezra Beard
Waiting on my adjudication to clear and this thread is helping me understand the whole picture way better than the ESD website does honestly
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Just got recalled from my furlough yesterday after 7 weeks so I can speak to this from the other side. One thing that helped me enormously was actually calling ESD at the very start of my furlough and asking them to flag my file for the recall - basically just letting them know the furlough had a likely end date. The agent walked me through exactly how to handle the PTO question and the job search question for my specific situation. If anyone is struggling to get through to ESD on the phone, I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to skip the hold time, which made actually having that initial conversation possible. The whole furlough would have been way more stressful without that call.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorFlagging the file for recall is something I hadn't thought about at all. My employer gave us an estimated return date of 6 weeks - is that something I'd tell the agent when I call?
0 coins
Eve Freeman
My recall date was also an estimate and the agent just noted it in the system. It didn't lock anything in, it just gave context. If the recall date changes you can call back and update it.
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
Had my recall conversation with ESD on the phone and they were actually really helpful once I got through. The getting through part was the problem. Wish I'd found a better way earlier in my claim.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
Question from someone a little confused by all this - does it matter whether the furlough is voluntary vs mandatory? My company said employees 'can opt into' the furlough to avoid layoffs. I opted in but now I'm wondering if that creates problems for my UI claim since I technically chose it.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
Tried to figure this out for my own situation weeks ago actually. The key Washington ESD looks at is whether you had a genuine choice or whether opting out meant losing your job. If 'opting out' of the furlough meant getting laid off anyway, ESD generally treats it the same as a mandatory furlough. If you actually had the option to continue working normal hours and voluntarily chose the furlough, that's more complicated and could affect your claim. What were the real alternatives your employer offered?
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
The alternative was 'we'll eliminate your position in the restructuring.' So basically it was furlough or get fired. That sounds like it falls into the first category?
0 coins
Vince Eh
My situation was identical - 'accept the furlough or we're restructuring your role.' ESD approved my claim no problem. The documented threat of job elimination makes it involuntary in their assessment.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Had a coworker fight this exact thing in an appeal and win. The appeal hearing officer basically said any reasonable person facing job elimination would choose the furlough, so the choice wasn't truly voluntary. They got full back benefits.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
Two months past my own furlough now and something I should mention - keep all your documentation. The email from HR about the furlough, any communication about PTO policy, the return-to-work date they give you. I had to provide documentation during my claim and the people who had everything saved had much smoother processes. ESD can ask for proof of the furlough circumstances especially if the claim gets flagged for review.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorAlready saved the HR email to a folder. Good reminder to keep adding to it as the furlough continues.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
Learned this the hard way in my first furlough claim. Didn't save anything and when ESD asked for documentation I had to scramble to get HR to resend emails. Keep everything from day one.
0 coins
Aria Khan
My adjudication was specifically triggered by ESD wanting to verify the furlough circumstances with my employer. Having the original documentation ready sped that up significantly.
0 coins
Caden Turner
Eight days into filing weekly claims and something that surprised me - ESD can actually contact your employer to verify furlough details without you knowing, and sometimes that employer response takes a while and triggers an adjudication hold. I got stuck in adjudication for almost three weeks on a furlough claim that seemed completely straightforward. When I finally talked to an ESD agent via Claimyr they explained my employer's HR department had been slow to respond to the ESD verification request. The agent was able to escalate it after I called. If your claim goes into adjudication, don't just wait - call and find out what's actually holding it up. claimyr.com got me to an agent when I couldn't get through any other way.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorThis is good to know in advance. If I see adjudication status appear I'll know to call and find out what specifically triggered it rather than just waiting.
0 coins
Ezra Beard
Currently in adjudication day 21 and this is exactly what I needed to hear. I've been just waiting assuming it would resolve. Going to try to get through to an agent to find out if there's a verification delay I could help move along.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
My furlough adjudication was also employer-verification-related. Called ESD after two weeks of waiting and the agent said my employer had responded but the rep reviewing it hadn't updated the file yet. Literally got resolved same day once I called.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
This kind of thing happens constantly and ESD's online system gives you zero visibility into why you're in adjudication. The only way to find out is to actually talk to someone.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
Just want to add one more thing for OP since you work in commercial printing - if your furlough ends and your employer recalls you but you feel unsafe returning or the conditions changed significantly, that's a separate conversation entirely. But for the actual unemployment-during-furlough question your original post asks, you've got your answer: file now, don't touch the PTO, report honestly each week. Good luck with the recall in 6 weeks.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
AuthorThanks for the wrap-up. Filing today. Really appreciate everyone who weighed in on this - it went from a confusing HR packet to a pretty clear picture of what I need to do.
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
Same situation as OP and this whole thread answered like four questions I had. Forum threads like this are genuinely more useful than the ESD FAQ pages.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Good luck on the furlough. Six weeks is manageable especially now that you know how to handle it. The documentation + not touching the PTO combo is really the whole answer.
0 coins