Back to Virginia Unemployment

Zoe Papadakis

Virginia VEC self employed uber driver document upload 1099 w-2 requirements overpayment situation

So I've been driving for Uber on and off for about two years while also picking up occasional W-2 work through a staffing agency. Last spring the staffing gig dried up completely and I tried filing for unemployment through Virginia VEC based on my W-2 wages. What I didn't realize until recently is that VEC apparently looked at my 1099 income from Uber too when they were calculating everything, and now I'm sitting here with an overpayment notice for around $2,800 saying I didn't properly document my self-employment situation during the claim period. Here's where I'm confused - I did upload some documents when I first filed, but I honestly wasn't sure what they needed from me as someone who had both kinds of income. I uploaded my W-2 from the staffing agency but I guess I should have also been providing documentation about my ongoing Uber driving? The overpayment notice references 'failure to accurately report earnings' but I genuinely thought the weekly amounts I was reporting were correct based on what Uber was paying me week to week. Now I'm trying to figure out what documents I actually need to upload through the CSS portal to either appeal this overpayment or at least show that I was reporting in good faith. Do I need to upload my 1099-NEC from Uber, my Uber earnings statements, bank statements showing deposits, or all of the above? And does anyone know if the document upload feature on the VEC portal actually works reliably? I tried uploading a PDF last week and got some kind of error. Has anyone dealt with this specific situation where you have mixed W-2 and gig income and ended up with an overpayment issue?

The mixed W-2 and gig income situation you're describing is actually something VEC has been dealing with more and more as rideshare work became common. What they typically want when you have both types of income is documentation that separates the two streams clearly. For the Uber side you'd want your 1099-NEC showing annual totals, but more importantly for weekly reporting purposes you'd want your Uber driver earnings statements that break things down by week. Uber actually lets you download these from the driver app under the earnings section - you can pull weekly summaries going back quite a while. That weekly breakdown matters a lot because VEC calculates your benefit reduction based on weekly earnings, not annual totals, so showing what you actually earned week by week is way more useful than just handing them the annual 1099.

0 coins

Not sure the weekly breakdown from Uber's app is going to carry the same weight as official documents though - I wonder if VEC treats those app-generated summaries as sufficient or if they want something more official like bank statements alongside them?

0 coins

That's a fair question actually. From what I went through, VEC accepted the Uber earnings summaries but wanted bank statements to corroborate the deposits. So basically you'd want both - the app summaries to show the week-by-week breakdown and statements to prove the money actually landed in your account.

0 coins

This is really helpful context. I do have access to the weekly earnings breakdowns in the Uber app, I just wasn't sure if those counted as legitimate documentation. So it sounds like I should be pulling both those weekly summaries AND bank statements showing the corresponding deposits?

0 coins

Before uploading anything through the CSS portal you should know there's a specific document type you have to select in the dropdown when submitting - if you pick the wrong category the document might just sit in a queue nobody's monitoring. I made that mistake early on. For overpayment related stuff you generally want to look for options related to 'appeal' or 'overpayment response' in the document type selector rather than just generic 'other documentation.' The portal upload itself can be finicky - I've had the best luck with PDFs under 5MB and using Chrome rather than other browsers.

0 coins

The browser thing is a real issue - I tried uploading through Firefox for weeks thinking something was wrong with my documents and switching to Chrome fixed it immediately.

0 coins

Though I'd push back a little on the document category selection being the main thing - in my experience the category matters less than making sure you include your claim ID number in the document filename itself so they can match it to your file when it lands on their end.

0 coins

Both things are worth doing honestly - right document category AND the claim ID in the filename. No reason not to cover both bases.

0 coins

You're going to want to actually talk to someone at VEC before you just upload documents blindly - the reason I say that is I spent three weeks uploading things and waiting and nothing happened because there was apparently a flag on my account that needed to be cleared by a live agent first. The problem is getting anyone on the phone is a whole ordeal. What finally worked for me was using Claimyr - it's basically a service that navigates the VEC phone system and holds your place until an agent picks up, then calls you back. Saved me hours of redialing. You can check it out at claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. For a situation like yours with an overpayment and mixed income documentation, talking to an agent first to understand exactly what they need would save you a lot of guessing.

0 coins

Hadn't heard of that before. My concern is I've been trying to call VEC for two weeks and either get a busy signal or get put on hold and then disconnected. If Claimyr actually gets you through to a real person that would be huge because I genuinely don't know if uploading documents without talking to someone first is going to help or hurt my situation.

0 coins

The getting disconnected after holding forever thing is so common with VEC - at least knowing there's a workaround for the phone issue is something. The document upload question is real though, it does seem like talking to them first would clarify what they actually need.

0 coins

Yeah the disconnect after a long hold is exactly the problem Claimyr solves - you're not sitting there listening to hold music and then losing the call. It calls you back when someone is available so you can just go about your day.

0 coins

I used to think that as long as you reported something in the weekly certification you were covered and they couldn't come after you for overpayment. Turns out that's not how it works at all. What VEC actually requires is that you report your gross earnings for any week you do gig work, not what deposited into your bank account. For Uber drivers specifically this tripped me up - Uber takes their cut before they pay you, so the amount that hits your bank is less than what you technically earned. VEC wants the gross fare earnings, not the net after Uber's service fee. If you were reporting your deposits instead of your gross earnings, that could be part of why there's a discrepancy.

0 coins

Wait, so the gross amount would be before Uber takes their percentage? I think I may have been reporting the net deposit amounts this whole time. That could actually explain the discrepancy they're pointing to.

0 coins

This is a really important distinction that catches a lot of gig workers - the gross vs net thing. Though I'd also add that mileage reimbursements and tips are treated differently, tips count as earnings but the mileage portion doesn't, so make sure you're not accidentally including or excluding the wrong things.

0 coins

Exactly right on the tips - those get included in what you report as weekly earnings. The mileage component is essentially an expense reimbursement so it's separate. This stuff gets complicated fast with gig work.

0 coins

The overpayment notice itself should actually tell you what documentation they're requesting if you read through the whole thing - sometimes there's an attachment or a secondary page that lists exactly what to submit. I know it's tempting to skip to the amount owed but the full notice usually has instructions. If yours doesn't specify, then you're in the situation where you need to contact them directly which brings you back to the phone access problem.

0 coins

I did read through the notice pretty carefully and it's frustratingly vague - it basically says to submit documentation supporting your reported earnings but doesn't specify what format or exactly which documents count. That's part of why I'm spinning my wheels here.

0 coins

That vague language is pretty typical unfortunately. The appeal form - it's called the VEC-B-30 - does have a section where you can describe your situation in writing and that written explanation sometimes matters as much as the documents themselves. Don't just upload files, write a clear narrative of your income situation.

0 coins

The VEC-B-30 is definitely the right form for overpayment appeals. Worth noting that you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it, not 30 days from when you received it, so if the notice sat in your mailbox for a week you've already lost that time.

0 coins

Something that might help clarify the document situation - I had a conversation with a VEC adjudicator a while back about gig work documentation and they specifically mentioned that they prefer documentation that comes directly from the platform rather than screenshots. So for Uber that means the official earnings statements you can download as PDFs from the driver app or Uber's official reporting portal, not just screenshots of your earnings screen. The distinction mattered to them because platform-generated PDFs have metadata confirming they're authentic.

0 coins

The metadata point is interesting - I hadn't thought about that angle. Though I'd want to double-check whether VEC actually has the capability to verify PDF metadata or if that's more of a theoretical concern vs. a practical one.

0 coins

Fair point, I might be overthinking the metadata side of it. The practical takeaway is just that official downloadable PDFs from Uber's system are better than screenshots regardless of the metadata question.

0 coins

Good to know the official PDF downloads are the way to go. I've been downloading actual PDFs from the Uber driver portal so at least I'm on the right track there.

0 coins

Had a nearly identical situation - Uber driving alongside W-2 income, got hit with an overpayment notice about six months into my claim. The thing that finally moved my case forward was actually getting on the phone with VEC and having them pull up my account while I explained each week in question. I tried Claimyr after a friend recommended it and honestly I was skeptical but it worked - got a callback within a couple hours and was able to actually walk through the discrepancies with an agent who had my file open in front of them. That conversation revealed that VEC had a different weekly earnings figure than what I'd reported for several weeks, and we were able to identify where the mismatch was coming from. If you just upload documents without that conversation you're kind of guessing at what question you're answering.

0 coins

The idea of walking through it with an agent who actually has my account open sounds exactly like what I need. Right now I'm just guessing at what the specific discrepancy is because the notice doesn't tell me which weeks they're flagging.

0 coins

The agent being able to tell you which specific weeks they're questioning is huge - without that you're essentially submitting a stack of documents and hoping one of them addresses whatever their concern is.

0 coins

Exactly - once I knew which three weeks they were focused on I could pull the specific Uber earnings PDFs for those weeks and the corresponding bank statements and my appeal was much more targeted and it got resolved.

0 coins

This is making me realize I should probably be more proactive about getting on the phone with VEC regarding my own situation before it escalates to an overpayment notice. Better to clarify while things are still in the weekly claim stage.

0 coins

I want to flag something about the W-2 side of your situation too - when you have both W-2 wages and self-employment income in the same base period VEC uses a specific calculation to determine your benefit amount. If the staffing agency W-2 work is what made you eligible for benefits in the first place, then your ongoing Uber work during the benefit year might be evaluated differently depending on whether VEC classified you as an employee or independent contractor for each income source. This distinction affects how your partial benefits get calculated each week.

0 coins

The base period calculation you're describing is important - Virginia VEC uses the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters as the base period, so the mix of your W-2 and 1099 income during that specific window determines your weekly benefit amount baseline.

0 coins

Right, and the tricky part is that gig income during the base period might have affected the original benefit amount calculation in ways that aren't obvious, while gig income during the actual benefit year affects the weekly partial benefit calculation differently. Two separate issues that sometimes get tangled together.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about whether the Uber income during my base period itself affected the original benefit calculation versus the ongoing Uber work during the claim period. That might be two separate problems I'm dealing with.

0 coins

I thought for the longest time that uploading documents to the CSS portal was essentially equivalent to them receiving and reviewing those documents - like, upload it and you're covered. Found out the hard way that there's a difference between documents being uploaded and documents being actually processed and attached to your claim. I've had uploads just disappear into the system. Now I always call to confirm receipt after uploading anything important, and I note the date, time, and the agent's name or ID number if I get one.

0 coins

The upload confirmation thing is real - I'd also add that printing a screenshot of the successful upload confirmation page right after you submit is worth doing because if there's ever a question about whether you submitted something, you have a timestamp.

0 coins

That's a great habit I wish I'd had earlier. The CSS portal doesn't email you a confirmation so that screenshot might be your only proof of when you uploaded something.

0 coins

This whole thread is making me feel better about not being the only one who finds the VEC portal confusing and unreliable. It's not just me being bad with technology, the system itself is genuinely difficult.

0 coins

One thing nobody's mentioned yet - for independent contractor work like Uber driving, Virginia VEC may require you to show that you're actively trying to find traditional W-2 employment during your benefit period, not just continuing to do gig work. The job search requirements don't stop just because you're doing some part-time gig work. If your Uber driving was essentially your main activity and you weren't conducting the required weekly job searches, that could be a separate issue layered on top of the earnings reporting question.

0 coins

This is something I should double-check in my records. I was doing job searches and I have my log, but I want to make sure I can demonstrate that I was genuinely looking for W-2 employment and not just treating Uber as my full-time thing.

0 coins

The job search log being complete and showing varied search activity - different employers, different methods, not just the same company every week - is important. If your log looks too thin or repetitive that can become a secondary issue in an appeal hearing.

0 coins

The regularity and variety of job search entries really does matter - I saw someone's appeal get complicated because their job search log showed three entries every single week to the exact same three companies which raised questions about whether they were genuine.

0 coins

Okay so I went through an overpayment appeal last year for different reasons but the process itself was similar. The appeal hearing, if it gets to that stage, is less intimidating than it sounds - it's typically done by phone, you get to present your side, and the hearing officer is usually pretty willing to listen to context and explanation. The worst case scenario people imagine - like having to pay it all back immediately - rarely happens even in cases where the overpayment is upheld, because VEC has repayment plan options and waiver options in cases of financial hardship.

0 coins

Knowing there are waiver options if the overpayment is upheld is actually reassuring - I was imagining a bill I had to pay in full immediately and that's been stressing me out.

0 coins

The waiver process is separate from the appeal and you'd file for it after if the appeal doesn't fully resolve things. It requires showing financial hardship and that the overpayment wasn't your fault or that repayment would be against equity and good conscience - that second standard actually covers situations where someone made an honest reporting mistake.

0 coins

The 'against equity and good conscience' standard is genuinely something VEC can apply for good-faith errors, which sounds like what the original poster is describing. Worth mentioning that in both the appeal and any waiver request.

0 coins

There's something worth considering about the document upload errors you mentioned - when the CSS portal gives an upload error it sometimes has actually uploaded the document but just failed to show the confirmation. I've learned to wait a few minutes and then check the Documents section of my account to see if the file actually appears there even when the upload seemed to fail. About half the time for me the document was actually there despite the error message.

0 coins

I hadn't thought to check whether the document actually appeared in my account after the error. I'm going to go back and look - if it's already there that saves me from re-uploading and potentially creating duplicate confusion.

0 coins

Duplicate uploads can actually cause their own problems - if VEC sees two different versions of what looks like the same document submitted on different dates it can raise questions about which one is accurate. So definitely check first before resubmitting.

0 coins

That's a really practical tip about the portal error not always meaning failure. The VEC tech systems are old and their error messages aren't reliable indicators of what actually happened on the backend.

0 coins

Coming at this from a slightly different angle - when VEC adjudicates an overpayment for a gig worker the question they're ultimately answering is whether you were covered by their definition of 'unemployed' during weeks you received benefits. For Uber drivers this comes down to whether you were 'available for work' in the traditional sense. Full-time gig driving can sometimes lead VEC to question whether you were actually available for and actively seeking conventional employment. This is a different issue from just the earnings calculation but it often comes up in the same case.

0 coins

So there could potentially be two separate issues - one about the earnings amounts I reported and another about whether my Uber driving affected my status as available for work. I hadn't framed it that way but it makes sense.

0 coins

That's the right framing. And they may be evaluated separately in an appeal. The earnings discrepancy is more of a factual question - what did you earn, what did you report. The availability question is more interpretive and there's more room to argue context and intent.

0 coins

The availability question for gig workers is genuinely contested in how VEC interprets it - there have been situations where driving very limited Uber hours was fine and others where someone doing 40+ hours of Uber was found to be not genuinely available for traditional employment. The hours matter a lot.

0 coins

After months of trying to navigate my own overpayment situation through the portal and phone calls I eventually found Claimyr which helped me get on the phone with VEC when I couldn't get through otherwise - you can find it at claimyr.com and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. What I found was that once I was actually talking to an agent they walked me through exactly what documentation would address each week in question. For a mixed income situation like yours, the agent can literally look at your account and tell you what their records show versus what you reported, and you can start building your document response around that specific information rather than guessing.

0 coins

Having the agent pull up what their records actually show versus what I reported would completely change how I approach gathering documents. Right now I'm essentially trying to prove something without knowing exactly what I'm trying to prove.

0 coins

That's exactly the problem - when you don't know the specific discrepancy you're addressing you end up submitting documents that might not actually respond to their actual concern. The phone conversation is what makes the document submission meaningful.

0 coins

The idea that you could be submitting a bunch of documentation that doesn't even address the actual issue VEC has flagged is kind of frustrating but also makes total sense. The system makes it too hard to know what they need without talking to someone.

0 coins

I want to add something about the 1099-NEC specifically since you mentioned it - for self-employed gig work Virginia VEC treats the 1099-NEC as evidence of annual income but it doesn't by itself prove what you earned in any specific week. So while you should absolutely upload it, you need the week-by-week breakdown documents alongside it because the annual total isn't directly useful for resolving weekly certification discrepancies. Think of the 1099 as corroborating context and the weekly statements as the actual evidence for each disputed week.

0 coins

That distinction between the 1099 as annual context versus the weekly statements as the real per-week evidence makes a lot of sense. I think I was going to lead with the 1099 but it sounds like the weekly Uber earnings breakdowns are actually the more critical documents.

0 coins

Right, and when you're preparing your appeal documentation I'd suggest organizing it chronologically by week rather than by document type - so for each disputed week you have the Uber weekly statement, the corresponding bank deposit, and your original weekly certification side by side. That makes it easy for whoever reviews it to follow your case.

0 coins

Organizing by week is excellent advice - reviewers dealing with a stack of mixed documents have a harder time following your argument than if you essentially walk them through each week in order.

0 coins

Something I want to flag about the appeals deadline - I had a friend who thought the 30-day window to appeal started when she received the notice. VEC actually dates it from when the determination was issued, which is the date printed on the notice itself. The mailing can take several days, so by the time the notice arrives in your mailbox you might already be a week or more into that window. If your notice date is getting close to 30 days old you should prioritize filing the appeal form immediately even if you don't have all your documentation together yet - you can supplement with documents later but you can't extend the appeal window.

0 coins

The notice date on mine is about 12 days ago and it's the date on the letter not the date I received it, so I need to move on this. Filing the appeal form even without all documents assembled yet is better than missing the deadline while trying to get everything perfect.

0 coins

Filing the appeal and noting in the written explanation that you're gathering supporting documentation to follow is completely standard. Hearing officers understand that documentation takes time to compile - what they won't forgive is a missed appeal deadline.

0 coins

This deadline point really is critical - everything else in this thread matters but nothing matters if the appeal window closes. File first, perfect your documentation second.

0 coins

Quick note from someone who just resolved a similar situation - the whole process took about six weeks from filing my appeal to getting a hearing scheduled. During that time I kept filing my weekly certifications because stopping those while the appeal is pending can create additional complications. If you're still within a benefit year where you might be eligible for continued partial benefits on weeks you have limited Uber income, don't stop certifying while you fight the overpayment issue - those are two separate things running in parallel.

0 coins

I actually stopped certifying because I was worried about making things worse. So I need to restart that process and understand whether I'm still in a valid benefit year. That's another call to VEC I apparently need to make.

0 coins

Stopping certifications is a really common mistake people make when they're scared of making an overpayment situation worse - but unless VEC has explicitly told you to stop, ceasing your weekly certifications when you're still eligible just means leaving money on the table that you're entitled to.

0 coins

And restarting certifications after a gap can sometimes trigger its own review process, so it's better not to stop in the first place. At minimum ask VEC directly whether you should continue certifying while your appeal is pending.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure