How to appeal unemployment deputy determination ineligible no work since original claim - Virginia VEC
So I got blindsided last week. Filed my weekly claims consistently for about two months after losing my warehouse supervisor job, reported everything accurately, did my three job contacts per week - the whole deal. Then out of nowhere I get a letter from Virginia VEC saying a deputy reviewed my case and determined I'm ineligible. The reason listed is basically that I haven't had any new employment since my original claim was filed. I'm sitting here completely confused because... I never had a new job to report? That was the whole point. I lost my job and filed a claim. Now they're saying that's the problem? I've been trying to reach someone at VEC to explain this to me in plain English but the phone lines are a nightmare. I either get a busy signal or sit on hold forever and then get disconnected. Meanwhile my bills aren't pausing for any of this. Has anyone actually dealt with a deputy determination coming back ineligible for this kind of reason? I need to understand what I'm even appealing before I can write anything coherent. Do I just explain my work history again? Do I need new documentation? The letter mentions I have a right to appeal but doesn't really walk me through what that means in practice. Any guidance would be genuinely appreciated right now.
79 comments

Mei Liu
Claimyr got me through to a live VEC agent in under an hour when I was dealing with almost this exact situation - deputy said I was ineligible and I couldn't get anyone on the phone to explain it. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k - seriously saved me so much time because the agent I reached actually pulled up my file and told me specifically what the deputy flagged. That context made writing my appeal letter ten times easier. The appeal itself still took weeks but at least I knew what I was fighting.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
The video on that page - is it showing the actual call process or just an ad? Genuinely asking because I've been burned by services that promise phone access and deliver nothing.
0 coins
Mei Liu
My phone bill that week showed one outgoing call and it connected. That's really all I can tell you from my own experience. The video walks through what to expect before you commit to anything.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Jumped in here to second this - I used it about three months ago for a different VEC issue and got through same day. The key thing is you actually talk to a real agent who can see your specific claim details, not just a recording.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
Thirty days. That's the number that freaked me out when I first read my deputy determination letter - you only get 30 calendar days from the date on the letter to file your appeal, not 30 business days, not 30 days from when you received it. The clock starts on the letter date. So whatever else you do, count that out right now and make sure you're not running close. The appeal itself goes to the VEC Commission and you can file it online through the CSS portal or mail it, but I'd do both just to have proof.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorAlready counted - I have about 19 days left. That's enough time but not a ton of it. The CSS portal is the Customer Self Service site at uidirect.vec.virginia.gov right? I want to make sure I'm logging into the right place.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
My determination letter had two different dates on it - the issue date and a 'mailed' date that was three days later. Used the issue date to count and then panicked before someone clarified it's actually the mailed date that starts the clock. Confirm that detail before you assume you have more time than you do.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
My calendar was sitting open when I read that letter. Yeah, CSS portal is the right place. When you log in there should be an option under your claim to file a protest or appeal - the wording has changed a few times but it's in there. Upload any documentation you have when you submit.
0 coins
NeonNova
Deputy determinations for 'no work since original claim' are actually a specific thing that comes up more than people realize. Here's what's usually happening behind the scenes: when VEC audits claims they sometimes flag cases where there's no new base period wage information or no employer separation to reference - basically the system looks for a triggering employment event and if your claim predates any recent payroll records they can find, it throws a flag. The deputy then has to make a call about whether you meet the ongoing eligibility requirements. What you need in your appeal is documentation of your original layoff, your job search logs for every week you claimed, and a clear written statement explaining your employment history timeline.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorOkay this actually helps me understand what might have happened. My layoff was at the end of last year and I've been claiming since January. Would the base period thing explain why they suddenly flagged it two months in rather than from the start?
0 coins
NeonNova
Exactly that, yes - sometimes VEC runs these reviews on a cycle and your claim just hit a review window. The two-month gap before the flag isn't unusual. The important thing is your documentation shows continuous eligibility throughout, not just at filing.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
My cousin works in HR and she said this kind of flag can also happen when an employer submits amended payroll records late - the system might see a discrepancy and kick it to a deputy automatically. Worth asking in your appeal letter whether there were any employer wage records that triggered the review.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
Something nobody's mentioned yet - when you write the appeal statement, don't just say 'I disagree with the determination.' Adjudicators see that all day. Walk them through your situation like you're explaining it to someone who has never heard of you: date of last day worked, reason for separation, every week you filed and what your work search looked like, and why the deputy's reason doesn't apply to your specific facts. The more specific and factual you are, the better. Generic appeals get generic results.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorMine went something like this in my head - started work at the warehouse in 2021, got laid off when they closed our distribution center in December, filed VEC claim in early January, submitted weekly claims with job search contacts every single week. Is that the kind of detail level you mean?
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
My notes from when I did this say almost exactly that format - yes. Add the specific dates if you have them and attach anything that corroborates the layoff (separation letter, final pay stub, whatever you got). The more it reads like a timeline with evidence rather than an argument, the stronger it is.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
Also worth noting - if your employer is contesting your claim on their end, you need to address that directly in the appeal. Sometimes the ineligibility determination is downstream of an employer response you never knew about.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
This is good advice. I added way too much emotional context to my first appeal and it got denied. Second appeal I stripped it down to just facts and dates and it was approved. The commissioners aren't there to feel bad for you, they want to see whether the rules were met.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
wait so they can just say ineligible with no explanation of which rule you supposedly broke?? mine said the same kind of vague thing and i had no idea what i was even supposed to be arguing against. feels like they're making it hard on purpose
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
The determination letter is supposed to cite a specific section of the Virginia unemployment code. If yours didn't, that's actually something you can note in your appeal - procedural deficiency. The code they usually cite for no-work situations is around the 'able and available' requirements or base period wage calculations.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
My letter just said 'deputy determination: ineligible' and had a code number I couldn't find any explanation for anywhere. How do I even look up what that code means?
0 coins
NeonNova
Title 60.2 of the Virginia Code is where all the unemployment statutes live. The code number on your letter should correspond to a specific section. You can search the Virginia Legislative Information System website and type in the code to pull up the actual text. It's dense but at least you'll know what they're citing.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
Had a similar ineligible determination six months ago and I was completely lost on what to do next. A friend told me about Claimyr and I finally got a real agent on the line who explained that my deputy had flagged a potential issue with my employer's separation report conflicting with what I'd filed. Without that call I would have written an appeal addressing the wrong thing entirely. claimyr.com is the site - worth it just for the information you get from actually reaching someone.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorReading this and realizing I might be making the same mistake - trying to appeal without fully knowing what specifically got flagged. Did the agent you reached actually have access to the deputy's notes or just the determination outcome?
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
My screen was showing the determination letter on one side and I was on the phone with the agent - she could see internal notes that weren't in my letter and told me there was a discrepancy between my separation date and what my former employer reported. That's the kind of thing you can't know without reaching someone who has full file access.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
This is a real issue. The letter they send claimants has the conclusion but not the reasoning. You're supposed to appeal blind unless you can get someone to tell you what's actually in the file. Wild system honestly.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
One thing I learned going through this process - the appeal hearing is actually more like a phone interview than a courtroom. A hearing officer calls you at the scheduled time, asks you questions, and may also call your former employer. You can present documents but you have to submit them in advance of the hearing, not during it. So don't wait until the hearing to gather your evidence - everything needs to be attached when you file or submitted to the hearing officer before the scheduled date.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorThat's genuinely useful because I was picturing something way more formal. So I should attach my job search logs and separation documentation to the initial appeal filing, not hold them for the hearing?
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Attach everything you have when you file. You can submit additional docs later but earlier is better. The hearing officer gets your file before the call and having everything there upfront means they're already familiar with your evidence.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Does your employer always get notified when you appeal? I'm worried about burning a reference if I push back on this.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Former employers do get notified and may participate in the hearing - that's standard practice. But it's also standard for unemployment claims in general. If they were going to contest it they likely already did before the deputy determination.
0 coins
StarSailor
okay genuine question - does appealing the deputy determination affect whether you can keep filing weekly claims while the appeal is going? i stopped filing when i got the ineligible notice and now im reading that might have been a mistake
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
Keep filing every single week even while your appeal is pending. This is really important - if you win the appeal you only get paid for weeks where you filed a claim. If you stopped filing you may have gaps you can't go back and fill depending on how long ago they were.
0 coins
StarSailor
My portal still shows the claims option as available - going back in right now. I missed two weeks thinking I wasn't supposed to. Can I backfile those?
0 coins
NeonNova
You can sometimes request to backfile missed weeks but VEC has to approve it and they don't always do so. File the ones going forward immediately and separately contact VEC about the missed weeks - they can sometimes make an exception if you have a documented reason for the gap.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
This exact thing happened to me and I lost payments for three weeks because I stopped filing during my appeal. Don't make that mistake. File every week no matter what your claim status says.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
The job search log situation stressed me out more than anything else during my appeal. I had been doing my three contacts a week but keeping them in my head and in some random notes app, not in any organized format. For the appeal I had to reconstruct everything from my email sent folder, LinkedIn activity, and indeed application history. If you're in a similar boat, start pulling that documentation together now - you'll need employer names, contact methods, dates, and outcomes for each contact.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorGoing through my sent emails right now and I actually do have records of everything - application confirmations, follow-up emails, a couple of phone call notes I emailed to myself. This is more organized than I thought actually.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
My inbox search turned up way more than I expected too. Application confirmation emails from job boards usually have the date, employer name, and position in the subject line which is exactly what the log format wants. Screenshot everything and compile it into a document before the appeal.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
Virginia VEC's official job search log format asks for specific fields - date, employer, type of contact, and result. Even if your records don't perfectly match that format you can organize them that way retrospectively. The substance matters more than the format for appeal purposes.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
Something that tripped me up - 'no work since original claim' as a determination reason can mean two different things and you need to figure out which applies to you. First possibility: they think you need to have worked and earned wages since your previous benefit year to establish a new claim, which is an eligibility requirement some people don't know about. Second possibility: they're saying your ongoing able-and-available status is in question. Those require completely different appeal strategies.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorOkay this is actually really important. How do I tell from the determination letter which one applies? Mine just says the reason is 'claimant has not had employment since original claim was filed' verbatim.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
That wording sounds more like the second type to me - they're questioning whether something changed in your circumstances. But you really need to look at the specific Virginia Code section cited. If it's under 60.2-612 that's able and available. If it's under 60.2-613 or the base period sections, it's about wage eligibility.
0 coins
NeonNova
This distinction is legitimately important and I've seen people write appeals arguing the wrong point entirely because they didn't nail this down. The code section is the fastest way to know.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
I want to circle back to the phone situation because I know how hard it is to get anyone at VEC on the line when you have a time-sensitive appeal. I ended up using Claimyr about a month ago when I was trying to get information about a pending determination on my claim - got connected to an actual VEC agent who could look at my file in real time. The demo at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k shows the process. For an appeal situation where you need to know exactly what the deputy documented, that phone access is worth a lot.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
How long did the whole thing take start to finish? Asking because I've tried calling VEC myself at like 7am and still can't get through.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
My call log shows I went from starting the process to being on the phone with an actual agent in about 45 minutes that day. Way faster than anything I'd tried on my own. The agent was able to tell me things about my claim status that weren't showing anywhere on the portal.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
The 7am trick stopped working a while ago - too many people figured it out. Any genuine shortcut to actual phone access is worth knowing about at this point.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
Has anyone here had their appeal go all the way to the full Commission level after losing at the hearing officer level? I'm trying to understand how far this can go and whether it's worth fighting at each stage.
0 coins
NeonNova
Yes, there are three levels: deputy determination, then Special Examiner/hearing officer level, then the full VEC Commission. After that you can appeal to circuit court but that gets into actual legal proceedings. Most people resolve at the hearing officer level one way or another.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
My paperwork shows I'm at the hearing officer stage right now. If I lose there, what are the realistic chances at the Commission level? Or is it basically a rubber stamp of the hearing officer?
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Commission level reviews are more limited - they generally look at whether the hearing officer applied the law correctly rather than reweighing all the facts. Fresh evidence is harder to introduce. Win your case at the hearing officer level if you can.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
The Commission does reverse hearing officer decisions but it's not super common based on what I've seen in these forums. The hearing officer level is where most of the action happens, so put your best case together for that.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Does anyone know if you can get legal help for a VEC appeal without paying a lawyer? The whole situation feels really overwhelming and I'm not sure I can present my case well on my own.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
Legal Aid works in Virginia - they handle unemployment appeals for free if you qualify income-wise. Virginia Legal Aid Society and Central Virginia Legal Aid Society are both worth contacting. They have people who specifically know the unemployment appeal process.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
My income right now is literally just the unemployment payments that got stopped. Would that qualify me?
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
Almost certainly yes. Contact your local legal aid office as soon as possible - they sometimes have limited capacity and you don't want to wait until close to your hearing date to reach out.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorHad no idea legal aid handled this. That's actually really helpful to know. I'm going to try to handle mine on my own first but it's good to know there's professional help available if the first attempt doesn't go well.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
The thing that surprised me most about my appeal was that the hearing officer actually called me back ten minutes earlier than scheduled and I almost missed it. For anyone who has a hearing scheduled - block that entire hour on your calendar, have all your documents in front of you, be in a quiet place, and do not be doing anything else. Missing or fumbling a hearing over logistics is a real thing that happens.
0 coins
StarSailor
Can you reschedule a hearing if something comes up? Or is missing it basically automatic loss?
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
You can request a continuance but I've heard it's hard to get approved unless you have a genuinely serious reason. Medical emergency, documented conflict, something real. 'I forgot' or 'I had work' probably won't fly. Treat the scheduled time as fixed.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
If you miss a hearing without getting a continuance approved, the determination generally stands against you by default. You'd have to file a new appeal explaining why you missed and ask for it to be reopened, which adds weeks to the process.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
Random thing that might help - I went to my actual local VEC office in person when I couldn't get through on the phone, and I was able to talk to someone face to face about my determination. It wasn't the same as calling the main line. The local office staff couldn't override anything but they did help me understand what was in my file and what the determination was actually based on. If you're stuck trying to reach anyone, that's an option people overlook.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorThere's a VEC office in my area I've never actually been to. Do you need an appointment or can you just walk in?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
My visit was a walk-in - no appointment. The wait was about 25 minutes on a Tuesday morning but I got actual face time with someone. Hours vary by location so check the VEC website first.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Didn't even know in-person offices still existed honestly. Everyone says to call or use the portal and never mentions you can just go there.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Local office staff can't resolve the appeal itself but they can submit service requests on your behalf and help you understand what's in your file. Sometimes having them note in the system that you came in person helps move things along.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
Just want to add from recent experience - when you write your appeal statement keep it under two pages if you can. I wrote seven pages for my first appeal and later someone who works in employment law told me that length actually works against you because examiners have huge caseloads. Clear, factual, organized, brief. That's the format that works.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
Two pages is a good ceiling. Bullet points with dates are your friend. The examiner is reading dozens of these a week - make it easy to find the key facts quickly.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorMine is currently at four pages of notes but I think I can get it to two pages of actual substance if I cut the background and focus on just the facts that directly address the determination reason.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
The structure I used was: one paragraph explaining my employment situation, one paragraph specifically responding to the determination reason with facts, and then attached documentation. That was it. Got a favorable outcome at the hearing officer level.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Can I just ask - if someone wins their appeal, do they automatically get back pay for all the weeks they were denied during the appeal process? Or do you have to request that separately?
0 coins
NeonNova
If you win and you kept filing weekly claims throughout the appeal period, back pay for those weeks should process automatically. The weeks where you were denied that you appealed are released for payment. That's one of the reasons it's so important to keep filing even during the appeal.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
My claim has been in this weird limbo for six weeks - I filed every week but it all shows as denied. If I win the appeal that's potentially six weeks of payments all coming at once?
0 coins
NeonNova
Yes, that's how it typically works - you get a lump payment for all the approved back weeks. It doesn't come instantly, there's usually some processing time after the appeal decision, but you should receive payment for every week you were eligible and filed for.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
Keep screenshots of your weekly filing confirmations if you have them. When back pay processes if there are any discrepancies you want documentation that you filed every week as required.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
following this thread closely bc i have almost the exact same situation - ineligible determination, no new work, been claiming since i got laid off from my delivery job in march. reading through this whole thread is honestly making me feel less alone about it. didn't realize how common this is
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
AuthorWent through every reply here twice already myself. It's weirdly reassuring to know other people have navigated this and come out the other side. Good luck with yours.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
My letter is sitting on my kitchen table and I keep picking it up and putting it back down. After reading this I think I finally understand what I'm actually dealing with well enough to write the appeal.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
That's exactly the moment to write it - when you understand it. Put together your timeline, pull your job search records, state your case clearly. You've got this.
0 coins