Can I get unemployment if fired for cause and starting new job - Virginia VEC question
So I'm in a weird spot and can't find a straight answer anywhere online. Got terminated from my warehouse supervisor position about six weeks ago - my employer documented it as misconduct because I apparently violated a safety protocol. I disputed it at the time but honestly didn't push back hard enough when it happened. Filed for unemployment almost immediately and my claim has been sitting in adjudication ever since with zero movement. Here's the twist that makes my situation different from most posts I've found: I already accepted a new job offer that starts in about three weeks. It's not full time hours yet - they're bringing me on part time at first (around 22 hours a week) with the expectation it goes full time in 90 days. So now I'm wondering if the new job situation even changes what I can claim, and whether the fired for cause issue is ever going to get resolved before I start working again anyway. My questions are basically: (1) can I get unemployment if fired for cause and starting new job is actually in my near future - does the new job cancel out any potential benefits? (2) Is there any point continuing to file weekly claims while adjudication drags on? (3) Should I even be worried about the misconduct determination or will the part-time hours mean I'd be eligible for partial benefits regardless? I've been keeping up my job search log even though I'm not sure I need to since I already have something lined up. Been doing everything by the book because I don't want any issues later.
57 comments

Salim Nasir
Week 4 of my own adjudication just ended when I finally got through to Virginia VEC and that call changed everything for me. Before I get into what they told me, let me answer your question the best I can from what I've been through. The fired for cause piece and the new job piece are actually two totally separate things Virginia VEC looks at. The misconduct determination decides whether you're eligible at all going backward from your separation. The new job situation affects what you can collect going forward. So yes, you could theoretically still get paid for weeks between your termination and when you start the new gig - IF the adjudication goes your way on the misconduct question. On actually getting through to anyone at Virginia VEC to find out what's happening with your adjudication - I spent two and a half weeks hitting redial before someone recommended Claimyr to me. It's at claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. Basically it handles the hold time and calls you when an agent picks up. I was skeptical but I got through within a couple hours and an agent actually walked me through my adjudication issue. For something like yours where you need a real explanation of the misconduct finding, talking to an actual person is probably your fastest path.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
Two and a half weeks of redialing sounds like my entire month of September. The phone situation with Virginia VEC is genuinely demoralizing.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorThe separation between the backward-looking misconduct question and the forward-looking new job question is actually really clarifying for me. I think I was conflating them into one problem when they're really two distinct determinations. Did the agent you spoke with tell you anything about how they weigh misconduct claims when the employer is the one who characterized it that way?
0 coins
Laila Fury
Virginia VEC adjudication being two separate tracks is accurate - seen this confirmed in a few different places. Good breakdown.
0 coins
Geoff Richards
My determination letter came on day 29 and the misconduct language they used was so vague I didn't even understand what they were saying at first. What I learned going through it: Virginia VEC doesn't automatically take the employer's word when they say misconduct. There's a difference between getting fired for something that was genuinely a deliberate violation versus getting let go for a mistake or not meeting performance standards. The way Virginia VEC actually sees it is that true disqualifying misconduct has to be like... you knowing something was against the rules and doing it anyway, not just making an error. A safety protocol violation could go either way depending on how it's documented. If your employer is saying you deliberately ignored a posted safety rule that you'd been trained on, that's harder to fight. If it was more of a judgment call in the moment or an honest mistake, that's not necessarily disqualifying misconduct under how Virginia handles these things. Keep filing your weekly claims no matter what. If adjudication resolves in your favor, they go back and pay those weeks. If you stop filing you lose those weeks permanently even if you win.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorDay 29 for a determination letter - that's both reassuring and anxiety-inducing depending on where I am in the count. The distinction you're drawing between intentional rule-breaking and an honest mistake in the moment is basically the core of my argument. The safety incident was a judgment call under time pressure, not me ignoring a rule I knew about.
0 coins
Simon White
This is right about keeping weekly claims going. I made the mistake of stopping during my adjudication because I assumed I'd be denied anyway and missed out on three weeks of back pay when I won the appeal. Don't do what I did.
0 coins
Hugo Kass
The intentional vs mistake standard is real but Virginia VEC doesn't always apply it consistently from what I've seen people post here. Sometimes feels like luck of the draw which adjudicator you get.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Seconding the keep filing advice hard. That's non-negotiable regardless of what you think will happen.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Three Mondays ago I got my first partial payment after what felt like forever fighting the system. Partial UI when you have part-time work is actually a thing in Virginia - you don't just lose everything the moment you start any job. The way it works is Virginia VEC looks at your weekly earnings and reduces your benefit amount based on what you made that week, but you can still collect something if your part-time wages fall below your weekly benefit amount. So if your weekly benefit amount is say $400 and you work 22 hours making $280 that week, you'd still be eligible for a reduced payment. Virginia VEC does the math on this and you have to report your earnings accurately every week when you file your weekly claim. The job search requirement also adjusts once you have part time work but you should confirm that with VEC directly. Your situation has a complication though - you haven't started yet so for right now you still have to meet all regular requirements including job search activities every week.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorThree Mondays ago means you're still pretty fresh in the partial benefits process - so the reporting system is working smoothly for you so far? I want to make sure I understand the earnings reporting piece before I actually start because I don't want to mess that up.
0 coins
Myles Regis
The partial benefits calculation in Virginia is real but the threshold matters. Worth looking up your specific weekly benefit amount in your account so you know the actual numbers before you start.
0 coins
Brian Downey
wait so u can collect unemployment AND get paid by the new job at the same time?? i didn't know that was a thing
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Yes that's the whole partial UI system, it's specifically designed for people who have some work but not enough. You just have to be honest about every dollar you earn each week.
0 coins
Jacinda Yu
Last Tuesday I got off a 47-minute hold with Virginia VEC and the agent told me something I hadn't seen clearly stated anywhere about misconduct and subsequent employment. If your fired-for-cause case goes into a formal hearing (which can happen if the initial adjudication is unfavorable and you appeal), the fact that you've already found new employment can actually work slightly in your favor in terms of showing you're genuinely part of the workforce and weren't just looking to collect. It doesn't change the legal question of whether the original termination was disqualifying misconduct but it can influence how the hearing officer perceives the case. Also on the new job starting: once you begin working and earning wages, those weeks get handled differently. Virginia VEC needs to know your start date and your earnings each week from that point forward. If your hours ramp up and your wages exceed your weekly benefit amount you just stop collecting, no big formal process needed - you stop filing or you file and get a zero dollar payment that week.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
Author47 minutes is brutal but the info you got sounds worth it. The point about subsequent employment potentially helping the optics in a hearing is interesting - I hadn't thought about it from that angle at all.
0 coins
Landon Flounder
Since we're talking about actually reaching Virginia VEC - I had the same 40+ minute hold problem every time I tried calling. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I was pretty doubtful at first. Ended up trying it because I needed to get answers about a misconduct notation on my claim and I genuinely could not get through any other way. The site is claimyr.com and the walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k makes it pretty clear what happens. Got a callback within about 90 minutes, spoke to an agent for almost 20 minutes, got actual answers. For the OP who needs to understand what specifically is flagged in the misconduct adjudication, that call is going to be necessary at some point.
0 coins
Callum Savage
90 minutes for a callback is way better than what I've been dealing with trying to get through the regular way.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
My appeal decision came back last week after nine weeks of back and forth and I want to share what I learned about the misconduct standard specifically because I see a lot of vague answers on this. Virginia treats misconduct as something that has to show you deliberately disregarded your employer's known and reasonable expectations. Getting fired for cause doesn't automatically mean misconduct in the unemployment sense - employers call things misconduct all the time in their internal documentation that doesn't meet Virginia's actual legal standard. What actually matters is what you knew, when you knew it, whether the rule was clearly communicated to you, and whether a reasonable person in your position would have known they were crossing a line. Safety violations are tricky because employers document them heavily and they tend to look bad on paper. But if the rule wasn't clearly posted or trained, if the violation was ambiguous in the moment, or if other employees regularly did the same thing without discipline, those are all arguments that cut against the misconduct finding. Virginia VEC adjudicators and hearing officers are supposed to look at the full picture, not just the employer's characterization. Make sure when you respond to any adjudication questionnaire that you give the full context of what happened - what exactly the protocol was, how you learned about it, what the circumstances were in the moment, whether this was your first offense. Details matter enormously.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorNine weeks is a long road but congrats on getting your decision. The point about other employees doing the same thing is actually relevant to my case - this was a protocol that was inconsistently enforced at my workplace and I wasn't the only one who made similar calls. That feels like it should matter.
0 coins
Aliyah Debovski
Month two of my own adjudication and I finally got through to Virginia VEC using Claimyr last week - found it at claimyr.com with a demo at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. The agent confirmed basically what you said about the standard. They told me specifically that inconsistent enforcement is something I should document and bring up if it goes to a hearing. OP - inconsistent enforcement is apparently a real argument that adjudicators consider, definitely mention it in any written response you submit.
0 coins
Miranda Singer
The inconsistent enforcement angle is underused by claimants. Document everything you can remember about how that protocol was applied to others.
0 coins
Cass Green
right at the start of my claim i made a mistake that cost me weeks of benefits so sharing this in case it helps anyone: i stopped doing job search activities after i had a verbal offer from a new employer because i figured the search was over turned out Virginia VEC still required the weekly job search contacts right up until i actually started the job. the verbal offer doesn't count. the written offer doesn't count. the offer letter doesn't count. you are required to do your job searches every week until you're actually employed and working, period OP you said you're keeping up the job search log which is great don't stop until your first actual day of work
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorRight at the start - that's when these kinds of mistakes hit hardest. I've been keeping the log which is good to have confirmed. Does Virginia VEC ever actually audit the job search contacts or is it more of an honor system?
0 coins
Finley Garrett
They do audit sometimes - I got a letter asking me to submit my job search records for a random three week period about two months into my claim. Had them all documented and it was fine but if I hadn't kept records it would have been a problem.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
The job search audit is real. Keep physical or digital records with dates, company names, positions, and how you applied. Email confirmations are great if you can get them.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
Six days after my first weekly claim payment finally hit I want to talk about something nobody mentioned yet which is the timeline issue in your specific situation. If your new job starts in three weeks and adjudication is still pending, you might be in a race against the clock. If adjudication takes another four to six weeks (which is common), you'll have already started the new job by the time it resolves. That changes things because Virginia VEC will be calculating any back pay owed against what you were earning during that period. For anyone reading this who is stuck in the calling loop trying to get status updates on their adjudication - I found out about Claimyr from someone in a similar thread and it's the only thing that actually got me through. Claimyr is at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. Got through on my second try with it after weeks of failed regular calls. I asked specifically about my adjudication timeline and they were actually able to give me a projected window and explain what documentation they still needed from me. That documentation piece was the holdup and I never would have known without getting through to a live person.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorSix days since your first payment - so you're freshly out the other side of this. The race against the clock framing is actually what's been stressing me out without me being able to articulate it. If I start the new job before adjudication resolves, does the partial work situation actually help or complicate things?
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
the documentation thing is SO real. my claim was stuck for extra weeks because they needed something from me and never sent a clear notice about it. only found out when i finally got through on the phone
0 coins
Laila Fury
Partial work while adjudication is pending adds a layer but VEC can and does handle it. You just keep filing accurately every week and the system eventually catches up. Not ideal but not a disaster either.
0 coins
Hugo Kass
The timeline crunch you're describing is genuinely common and VEC does deal with it. Keep everything documented and keep filing.
0 coins
Malia Ponder
My situation from earlier this year rhymes with yours and I want to share the actual outcome. Fired for cause, employer claimed misconduct, I had a new job lined up two weeks out. Filed immediately, adjudication dragged on for eight weeks. New job started, I switched to filing partial weeks since I was part time at first. Adjudication eventually resolved in my favor - they found that what my employer called misconduct didn't meet Virginia's standard. Got back pay for all the weeks I'd been filing, minus what I'd earned on the new job during the overlap weeks. Total received in back benefits was around $2,800 over the period before my new job wages exceeded my weekly benefit amount. That's not life-changing money but it was real and it covered most of a month of bills during a rough stretch. The process was slow and annoying but it worked out. The critical thing: I never stopped filing weekly claims. Even during weeks when I thought I'd probably lose the adjudication. Those weeks were all paid once it resolved.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorEarlier this year means this is recent enough to be genuinely relevant to current VEC procedures. The $2,800 back pay figure is meaningful - that's a real outcome, not theoretical. Did you have to do anything specific to trigger the back pay calculation once adjudication resolved, or did the system handle it automatically?
0 coins
Myles Regis
Back pay for filed weeks being automatic after a favorable adjudication - yes this is how it works. System calculates it based on your filed weeks and what you earned. Usually shows up within a couple weeks of the determination.
0 coins
Simon White
This kind of real outcome story is what people need to see when they're in the middle of it and don't know if any of this is worth continuing. Keep filing people.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
Day 19 of my adjudication and reading this thread like it's a crystal ball into my future. Had a question nobody directly answered yet: if the new job starts and you're earning partial wages, do the job search requirements change at all? Like are you still required to look for additional work while you're employed part time and collecting partial UI? Also what happens if the part time job goes full time before adjudication resolves - do you lose the pending back pay claim or does it still resolve?
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Day 19 is actually still relatively early - brace yourself for potentially more waiting but don't despair yet. On your questions: job search requirements while working part time and collecting partial benefits - my understanding from VEC is that you're supposed to continue job search activities if you're still collecting, but the specifics can depend on your situation. This is exactly the kind of thing worth confirming with an actual VEC agent because I've seen conflicting information.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
The pending adjudication back pay doesn't disappear just because you go full time. If adjudication resolves in your favor they calculate what you were owed for the eligible weeks before you exceeded your benefit amount. Going full time just determines the end point of the calculation, not whether the prior weeks get paid.
0 coins
Geoff Richards
Both of these questions are ones I had too. The job search while part time employed question is genuinely confusing and I think the answer might vary based on individual claim specifics. Second the advice to get a VEC agent on the phone for clarity.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Something I want to flag because I see it missing from the conversation: the questionnaire. When Virginia VEC adjudicates a misconduct claim they almost always send a questionnaire to both you and your former employer. If you haven't received one yet or already submitted it, that's one of the first things to check. The questionnaire is your opportunity to frame the safety incident in your own words - not just answer yes/no to their questions but actually explain the context, the circumstances, how the rule was communicated to you, what you understood in the moment. Before I knew how important this was I submitted mine too quickly without thinking through my answers. I basically confirmed the employer's framing without meaning to. Had to go through a full appeal and hearing to get it corrected. If you haven't submitted the questionnaire yet, take your time with it and think through every question carefully before you answer.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorSomething I should have asked earlier - I never received a questionnaire that I noticed. Could it have gone to spam or been a letter I didn't recognize? This is suddenly a concern.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Check your CSS portal account first under any pending issues or items needing action. Also check physical mail, VEC still sends letters. If you're not sure whether one was sent call and ask - an agent can tell you what communications have gone out on your claim.
0 coins
Finley Garrett
The questionnaire being submitted too fast and accidentally confirming the employer's framing is unfortunately common. Take your time answering these things.
0 coins
Callum Savage
Didn't know the questionnaire was that important. Filed mine same day I got it without really thinking through what I was saying. Now I'm worried.
0 coins
Ryder Ross
Just finished week 11 of collecting and wanted to add something from the employer side since I used to work in HR before my own layoff. Employers who document terminations as misconduct don't always do it accurately or even strategically - sometimes supervisors just put what sounds official in the paperwork without really understanding what their state's unemployment agency will examine. I've seen safety protocol violations documented as misconduct internally that absolutely would not have held up under VEC scrutiny because the employer never bothered to actually establish that the protocol was trained, posted, and enforced. If your employer documented it as misconduct in their own internal records that's different from them successfully arguing misconduct in a VEC proceeding. You have the right to request information about what your employer submitted to VEC and to respond to it. Don't assume the employer's characterization ends the analysis.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorWeek 11 and still going - that's a whole journey. The HR perspective is actually really valuable here. The idea that the employer's internal documentation might not hold up under VEC's actual standard is something I need to sit with.
0 coins
Miranda Singer
The distinction between what goes in HR paperwork and what actually qualifies as misconduct under Virginia's unemployment law is real and claimants underestimate it constantly. Employers know this and sometimes use misconduct documentation strategically to avoid unemployment claims even when it won't hold up.
0 coins
Brian Downey
wait they can try to block your unemployment?? i thought employers didn't really have that much control over it
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
My appeal letter arrived on week eight and I'm now on the other side of this. Something nobody has fully addressed in this thread: the new job starting doesn't eliminate the possibility of collecting for the gap period EVEN IF you lose the initial adjudication. If you get an unfavorable adjudication determination you have the right to appeal to a VEC hearing officer. That appeal process can take additional weeks but those weeks between termination and your new job starting could still become payable if you win the appeal. The appeal is worth filing if you believe the misconduct characterization is wrong - which it sounds like you do. Appeal deadlines are strict though - typically 30 days from the determination. So if and when you get an unfavorable finding, do not wait on filing the appeal.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorWeek eight for your appeal letter - at least there's a defined end point even if it's a long way out. The appeal deadline being strict is exactly the kind of thing I would have let slip if I hadn't read it here. I'll keep that 30-day window front of mind the moment any determination comes through.
0 coins
Jacinda Yu
30 days from the determination letter date, not from when you receive it. Mail processing times matter. File as early as possible.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
The appeal being worth pursuing even when you've already found a new job is a point worth hammering home. I've seen people say 'why bother I'm employed now' and leave real money on the table.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
The 30-day window being from the letter date not the receipt date is a detail I would absolutely have gotten wrong. Good to know.
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
About two weeks into starting my new part time job and filing partial weeks - want to be really specific about the weekly earnings reporting process since that's coming up for the OP. Every Sunday when I file my weekly claim I report exactly what I earned that week - gross wages, not take-home. Virginia VEC uses gross earnings in the calculation. If you underreport even accidentally it creates an overpayment that you have to pay back later with potential penalties. If you overreport you just get less than you're entitled to which is a smaller problem but still wrong. My employer doesn't pay weekly so I had to figure out how to calculate what I earned for that specific week even though my paycheck covers a different period. Virginia VEC wants the wages for the week you worked them not when you got paid. First week I did it wrong and had to call and correct it - annoying but fixable before it became a bigger issue.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
AuthorTwo weeks into the part time situation means you're living exactly what I'm about to face. The gross vs net earnings distinction is critical - I would have reported net without thinking about it. And the wages-when-earned vs wages-when-paid calculation is something I'd have definitely gotten wrong for a biweekly paycheck.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Gross wages, wages when earned. These two things trip up almost everyone doing partial UI for the first time. Good practical post.
0 coins
Myles Regis
The overpayment risk from underreporting wages is serious - Virginia VEC can and does pursue recovery with penalties. Always better to report more if you're unsure and call to correct it than to underreport.
0 coins