Back to Virginia Unemployment

Norman Fraser

Can I collect unemployment if fired for tardiness? Virginia VEC situation

So I got let go from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and the termination paperwork says the reason is 'attendance policy violation' which basically means I was late too many times. I'm not going to pretend I had a perfect record - I was dealing with some transportation issues after my car broke down and the bus routes in my area are unreliable. I tried talking to my supervisor about it but they went ahead and terminated me anyway after my fourth late arrival in about six weeks. I went ahead and filed a claim with Virginia VEC but now I'm sitting here not knowing if tardiness counts as misconduct in their eyes or if I might still qualify for benefits. The online portal just shows my claim is under review and I haven't gotten any letters yet explaining what they're determined. I know some people get denied when fired for cause but I've also heard that not everything counts as disqualifying misconduct under Virginia unemployment rules. Has anyone been through something similar? I'm a pretty hard worker, the tardiness was genuinely circumstantial and not me just not caring about the job. Would really appreciate hearing from people who've actually dealt with Virginia VEC after being fired for attendance issues.

Week three of my own adjudication right now so I'm watching this thread closely. When I got fired from my last job for similar reasons they sent me a fact-finding questionnaire before making any decision. Did you get one of those yet? Virginia VEC usually sends that out to both you and your former employer to get both sides of the story before they rule on whether the termination was for disqualifying misconduct.

0 coins

Nothing in the mail yet and my CSS portal doesn't show any questionnaire either. How long did yours take to arrive after you filed?

0 coins

My fact-finding notice came by mail about 10 days after I filed, didn't show up online at all. Keep checking your actual mailbox not just the portal.

0 coins

Same here, got mine by mail only. The CSS portal doesn't always reflect every document they send you so definitely watch your mailbox every day.

0 coins

Just wrapped up my own fired-for-attendance situation last month and honestly the hardest part was actually getting someone at Virginia VEC on the phone to ask questions. I found this service called Claimyr that gets you connected to a live VEC agent way faster than sitting on hold for hours - claimyr.com has the info and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. Being able to actually talk to an agent and explain the transportation circumstances behind my tardiness before they made a decision felt like it really mattered.

0 coins

Appreciate this, I've been going crazy trying to get through on the phone. I'll check out that link.

0 coins

I spent literally four days trying to call VEC before giving up. Might have to look into this.

0 coins

The phone situation at VEC is honestly the worst part of this whole process. Anything that helps cut through that is worth knowing about.

0 coins

My termination letter said 'repeated policy violations' and I was sweating bullets thinking I'd get disqualified. Here's what I learned going through it - Virginia VEC doesn't treat every firing as automatic misconduct. The way it was explained to me by the VEC agent I eventually spoke with, they look at whether you were actually trying to mess the employer over or if the attendance problem came from circumstances outside your control. Stuff like a car breaking down or transportation problems can actually work in your favor during adjudication because it goes to your intent.

0 coins

This is genuinely reassuring. I kept documentation on the bus schedule failures and even have a repair estimate for my car from that period. Should I be submitting that somewhere?

0 coins

My fourth week waiting and I wish I'd known to gather that kind of documentation earlier. When I finally reached a VEC agent through Claimyr they specifically asked me about documentation of why I was late. Having it ready would have sped things up.

0 coins

Yeah the intent angle is huge. I got approved after being fired for attendance and the fact that I'd communicated with my manager about the situation before the terminations is what I think tipped it.

0 coins

Got my determination letter two weeks ago after being fired from a retail job for showing up late seven times over three months. The way Virginia VEC broke it down in my letter, they were looking at whether my employer had a written policy, whether I knew about it, and whether I violated it deliberately. What saved me was that I had texts showing I always notified my supervisor before my shift when I knew I'd be late - they apparently counted that as showing I wasn't acting in willful disregard of my job.

0 coins

I did text my supervisor every single time I was going to be late. I still have all those texts. So that kind of communication record actually helps during the VEC review?

0 coins

Doctor's notes, texts, emails - save everything. Any paper trail showing you weren't just blowing off the job matters a lot when Virginia VEC is deciding whether something rises to the level of misconduct.

0 coins

This matches what I went through. Proactive communication with your boss before each late arrival versus just showing up late without a word are treated really differently by VEC in my experience.

0 coins

wait so just texting your boss before you're late can actually change whether you get unemployment?? that seems like a really small thing to decide something that big

0 coins

THREE MONTHS into dealing with VEC nonsense here and let me tell you something. They will find any reason to deny a claim if your former employer pushes back hard enough. I was late because my kid's school kept calling me in for emergencies and VEC still put me through the wringer. The whole 'misconduct' question is totally subjective and depends way too much on whoever is reviewing your file that day. I'm not saying don't try but just be prepared for a fight.

0 coins

Has your situation resolved yet or are you still fighting it?

0 coins

This is real talk but I'd push back a little - there are actual Virginia rules about what qualifies as misconduct versus a fireable offense that isn't misconduct. It's not totally random, though I get why it feels that way when you're in the middle of it.

0 coins

Sorry you're going through that. The school emergency situation sounds like it really should have protected you. Hope it comes out right eventually.

0 coins

About six weeks into my claim right now and I want to add something practical about the phone issue since it came up earlier. After spending almost a full week trying to get through to Virginia VEC the regular way I tried Claimyr and it was a genuinely different experience. Got connected to an actual VEC agent who could look up my specific claim and answer questions about how my termination was being classified. For anyone worried about their fired-for-attendance situation, being able to have that direct conversation is worth a lot - claimyr.com if you need it.

0 coins

In week two of waiting for my adjudication decision and I've been scared to even call because I don't want to mess anything up. Is it okay to call VEC just to ask questions while your claim is pending?

0 coins

Totally fine to call and ask general questions. Just be factual and don't volunteer information beyond what they ask. Knowing where your claim stands is your right as a claimant.

0 coins

Two months ago I thought calling might jinx my claim somehow lol. Definitely not how it works, calling to check status is completely normal.

0 coins

My situation involved getting fired from a logistics company after five late arrivals in two months. What ended up mattering for my Virginia VEC claim was something I hadn't even thought about - my employer couldn't produce a signed copy of their attendance policy with my signature on it. Without that documentation they had a harder time proving I fully understood the progressive discipline process. Worth thinking about whether you ever signed anything acknowledging their specific attendance policy.

0 coins

I went through new hire orientation digitally and I honestly can't remember if I electronically signed the attendance policy or not. How would I even find out what my employer submitted to VEC?

0 coins

You can request your claim file documents through the CSS portal or by calling VEC. It's your right to see what your employer submitted as their side of the story, especially if you think you might need to appeal.

0 coins

Signed acknowledgment thing is real - my HR rep accidentally admitted during the fact-finding call that they couldn't locate my signed copy. I think that contributed to me getting approved.

0 coins

huh never thought about the signed policy angle. good tip

0 coins

Got my denial letter last week after being fired for attendance at a restaurant and now I'm figuring out the appeals process, so I'm following this thread looking for similar stories. For what it's worth on the original question - yes Virginia VEC absolutely can and does approve claims for people fired for tardiness, it's not an automatic disqualification. The question is always whether they classify it as 'misconduct' under their definition or just a regular fireable offense.

0 coins

What's your plan for the appeal? I want to understand the whole picture of what could happen even if I get approved at first.

0 coins

Gathering all my documentation, writing out a timeline, requesting a copy of everything my employer submitted. The appeal hearing is basically a mini trial so I want to be ready. Good luck with your initial determination though, hopefully you don't need to go that route.

0 coins

Appeals have a 30-day window from the determination letter date so if anyone reading this gets a denial don't wait on it. That deadline is strict.

0 coins

Finishing up week five of my claim. Wanted to circle back on the calling VEC issue because I tried everything - called at 7am, called at lunch, tried different days of the week. Nothing worked for weeks. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I was skeptical but it actually got me through to a live VEC agent in a way I couldn't manage on my own. The agent I spoke to explained exactly how my employer had described my termination and what information I could provide to respond to their characterization. That conversation completely changed how I approached my claim. claimyr.com if you're stuck in that phone loop.

0 coins

My former employer and I definitely have very different stories about what led to my terminations. Getting to hear how they characterized it to VEC sounds really valuable.

0 coins

Week one of my claim and already dreading the phone situation. Good to know there are options.

0 coins

The employer characterization thing is so important. They frame the story first and you need a chance to respond to their version before a decision is made.

0 coins

Had my determination come through after being let go from a healthcare admin job for being late, and I want to give some specific Virginia VEC context here. The way the law essentially works in Virginia - my uncle is an employment attorney so he walked me through it - is that getting fired for something doesn't automatically mean you get cut off from benefits. Virginia requires the conduct to reach a certain threshold, like you were doing it on purpose or just completely didn't care about keeping your job. Pure circumstantial stuff like car trouble usually falls below that threshold if you can back it up.

0 coins

The car documentation I have is pretty solid - repair bills from the week before my first late arrival, screenshots of bus delay notifications from the transit app. Building my case now just in case.

0 coins

Transit app delay notifications are great evidence honestly. Anything timestamped and third-party verified.

0 coins

Your uncle is right about the threshold thing. I've read through the actual Virginia code section on misconduct and it really does require willful disregard, not just mistakes or circumstances beyond your control.

0 coins

Eight weeks ago I was sitting here panicking about the same exact thing after getting fired from a distribution warehouse. The whole adjudication process for misconduct determinations took about three weeks from filing to decision in my case. My advice - keep filing your weekly claims every single week while you wait, don't stop just because your claim is in adjudication. I almost made that mistake and would have lost weeks of payments even after I was approved.

0 coins

I've been filing weekly even without knowing if I'll be approved, wasn't sure if I should continue. Glad to hear that's the right move.

0 coins

This is such important information. I stopped filing during adjudication my first time going through this thinking I had to wait and lost three weeks of payments.

0 coins

Can confirm, keep filing weekly no matter what. The CSS portal lets you do it even when your status shows pending or adjudication.

0 coins

VEC website actually says to keep filing weekly claims during adjudication but it's buried deep in the FAQ so most people miss it.

0 coins

Just got past my fact-finding interview stage and waiting for the written determination now. What nobody tells you about the fact-finding process for fired-for-attendance cases is that the interviewer asks very specific questions about whether your employer offered any accommodations, whether you requested any schedule changes, and what conversations you had with management before the terminations. Think through all of those before your interview if you haven't had it yet.

0 coins

I did ask my supervisor once about shifting my start time by thirty minutes but it was denied. Does that work for or against me in VEC's eyes?

0 coins

Asking for an accommodation and being denied actually can work in your favor - shows you were trying to fix the problem rather than ignoring it. Document that you made the request.

0 coins

My case involved a denied schedule change request too. The fact-finder seemed very interested in that detail and asked me follow-up questions about how I made the request and what the manager said.

0 coins

Real talk from someone whose claim got approved after being fired for tardiness from a construction supply company. The thing my VEC reviewer focused on was the gap between what a firing offense is versus what actually cuts off your unemployment. Lots of things can get you fired that don't meet the bar for disqualifying misconduct. My being late didn't make me a bad employee trying to hurt the company, and they agreed with that framing eventually.

0 coins

How did you frame that in your fact-finding questionnaire? I want to make sure I'm communicating the right way.

0 coins

Just told the truth straightforwardly - what caused the tardiness, what I did to try to fix it, that I communicated with management, that I wanted to keep my job. Didn't overthink it or use fancy language.

0 coins

that framing distinction between fireable offense and actual misconduct is the key thing most people don't know going in

0 coins

Filing my claim this week after being let go for attendance at a call center. The number of people in this thread who got approved after being fired for tardiness is honestly a relief to read. I had no idea it wasn't automatic disqualification.

0 coins

Virginia VEC has to prove you willfully disregarded your job duties, not just that you got fired. The burden isn't entirely on you to prove innocence.

0 coins

Don't get too comfy though - employers fight these claims and their word carries a lot of weight with VEC reviewers. Have your documentation ready.

0 coins

Point taken. Already pulling together everything I have - texts, emails, transit records. Not going in empty handed.

0 coins

week 2 and no letters yet. this whole process moves so slow its making me anxious. does everyone have to go through adjudication when they get fired or only some people

0 coins

Pretty much everyone who's fired rather than laid off goes through some level of review. When the reason for separation is a firing the system flags it automatically for adjudication because they have to verify whether it was for misconduct.

0 coins

ugh so this is just standard not like a warning sign or anything. ok that makes me feel slightly better

0 coins

Standard process, don't read anything extra into it. Adjudication just means they're reviewing it, not that you're being denied.

0 coins

Two determination letters into my VEC history now - one denial, one approval, both for fired-for-attendance situations at different jobs. The difference between the two cases came down to documentation and employer pushback. Second time around I had everything organized before the fact-finding call and I'd kept a personal log of every late arrival with the reason written down at the time. That contemporaneous log was something the fact-finder specifically mentioned.

0 coins

What do you mean by contemporaneous - did you write down reasons at the time the tardiness happened or reconstruct it later?

0 coins

At the time, which is what made it valuable. Notes you wrote the day of each incident are way more credible than a list you reconstruct later when you're trying to build a case.

0 coins

This is a genuinely important point. If you're still employed and having attendance issues start keeping that log now before anything happens. And if you're already fired write down everything you remember as soon as possible while it's fresh.

0 coins

Wrapping up my fourth week post-determination and I want to add one thing for anyone reading who gets denied - the appeals process is real and it works. I won my appeal after an initial denial on a fired-for-attendance claim. The appeal hearing gives you an actual chance to present your side with documentation in front of a hearing officer who wasn't involved in the original decision. It's not just rubber-stamping the first decision.

0 coins

Good to know there's a real path if the initial decision goes against me. How formal is the actual hearing?

0 coins

Pretty formal in structure but the hearing officer is usually pretty human about it. You can bring documents, make your case, and respond to whatever your employer says. Treat it seriously but don't panic about the format.

0 coins

Agreed on this. I'm going into my appeal hearing next week and the prep process has actually made me feel more confident about my case than I did during the original adjudication.

0 coins

The appeal success rate is higher than people think. Lots of initial denials get overturned especially when the claimant shows up prepared with documentation.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure