TWC denied my unemployment after quitting due to work injury - appeal lost - any other options?
I had to leave my job at a warehouse after 3 years because of an unresolved back injury that happened at work (they kept making me lift heavy items even after doctor's note) plus a supervisor who kept blaming me for slowing down. I filed for unemployment in January 2025 and got denied pretty quick. The determination letter said I 'voluntarily quit without good cause connected to work.' I filed an appeal explaining about my injury and the hostile environment but just got the decision yesterday - still denied. The hearing officer basically said I should've gone to HR before quitting. I'm really struggling financially now and wondering if there's ANY way to fight this further or if I'm just out of luck? Can I file another appeal? Ask for reconsideration? Or is this just done? Has anyone successfully fought a case like this after losing the first appeal?
22 comments
Zoe Papadopoulos
Unfortunately, you're in a tough spot. After losing an appeal hearing, you can file a Further Appeal to the Commission, but you only have 14 calendar days from when you received the Appeal Tribunal decision. The success rate at this level is pretty low unless there was a clear legal error. Your situation (quitting due to injury/environment) typically needs medical documentation and evidence you tried to resolve the issues internally before quitting. Did you file a formal complaint with HR or have your doctor submit workplace restrictions?
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•No, that's the problem. I did have a doctor's note saying no heavy lifting, but my supervisor just ignored it. I didn't formally go to HR because previous complaints about him were ignored. I guess that's where I messed up. Is it worth trying the Further Appeal or just a waste of time at this point?
0 coins
Jamal Washington
been there done that!! TWC ALWAYS sides with employers on voluntary quits. they dont care if your boss was literally the devil himself. if you quit, ur pretty much screwed. they want you to have like mountains of paperwork proving you tried to fix things. my appeal got shot down too last year 😡
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•That's what I'm afraid of. Did you try anything after your appeal was denied or just give up?
0 coins
Jamal Washington
•i gave up cuz my neighbor who used to work at TWC said further appeals almost never win unless theres like a major legal mistake. not worth the stress tbh
0 coins
Mei Wong
You still have options, but they're limited. As mentioned, you can file a Further Appeal to the Commission within 14 days. Focus on any procedural errors in your hearing (if applicable) or emphasize documentation you have about your injury and workplace conditions. Beyond that, you could potentially qualify for other programs: 1. If your injury was work-related, have you pursued workers' compensation? 2. Check if you qualify for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) 3. Look into vocational rehabilitation if your injury affects your ability to return to similar work For the Further Appeal, you'll need to clearly articulate why the Appeal Tribunal's decision was incorrect based on Texas unemployment law. The key issue is proving that any reasonable person would have quit under your circumstances and that you made reasonable efforts to preserve your employment.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•Thank you for the detailed response. My workers' comp claim is actually still pending - could that help my unemployment case if it gets approved? I'm definitely going to look into those other programs too.
0 coins
Mei Wong
•A successful workers' compensation claim could potentially help with a Further Appeal by validating the work-related nature of your injury. However, they're separate systems, so one doesn't automatically impact the other. If you do file the Further Appeal, include any new documentation from your workers' comp case that wasn't available during your initial appeal hearing. Just be aware that the Commission typically only reviews the existing record unless there's new evidence that wasn't reasonably available before.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
my cousin had kinda same thing happen but she got a lawyer and won her second appeal! dont give up!!
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•Really? That gives me some hope. Do you know what kind of lawyer she used or how much it cost? I'm already struggling financially so I'm worried about attorney fees.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
•tbh not sure how much it cost but she said it was worth it. think it was some kind of employment lawyer? she had lots of medical proof tho
0 coins
PixelWarrior
Have you tried getting through to TWC directly to discuss your options? When I was dealing with my benefits issue, I spent weeks trying to reach someone on the phone with no luck - constant busy signals and disconnections. I finally used a service called Claimyr that got me connected to a TWC agent within 30 minutes. Worth checking out at claimyr.com - they have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/V-IMvH88P1U?si=kNxmh025COIlIzKh The agent I spoke with explained some options I didn't know about. In your case, they might be able to tell you exactly what documentation would strengthen a Further Appeal or if there are other programs you qualify for given your work injury situation.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•I haven't been able to get through to them at all! It's so frustrating. I'll check out that service - at this point I just need to talk to someone who can give me straight answers. Thanks for the recommendation.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
I went through something similar last year and won my further appeal, but my situation had some key differences. I had documented evidence of reporting safety issues to both my supervisor AND HR multiple times (emails and formal complaints). I also had my doctor specifically write that continuing to work there would worsen my condition. Even with all that documentation, it was still a struggle. If you do file the Further Appeal, you need to focus on two key points: 1. The work conditions were so bad that any reasonable person would have quit (the "reasonable person" standard is what TWC uses) 2. You tried everything possible to resolve the issues before quitting If you don't have documentation for #2, that's where you'll have the biggest challenge. The Further Appeal isn't about re-arguing your whole case - it's about showing the Appeal Tribunal made an error in applying the law or that new evidence has emerged that couldn't have been presented earlier.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•This is really helpful, thank you. I do have text messages to my supervisor about the pain and asking for different duties, plus my doctor's notes. But you're right that I don't have formal HR complaints. I'm going to gather everything I have and see if it's enough for a Further Appeal.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
the twc system is RIGGED!!! I quit cuz my boss was harassing me and got denied too even with PROOF!!! the whole appeal process is just for show they ALWAYS side with employers because they dont want to pay out benefits!!! the whole system is corrupt!!!
0 coins
Mei Wong
•While the process can be frustrating, TWC does approve many voluntary quit cases when properly documented. The key is providing evidence that meets the specific legal standards for "good cause connected with work." This typically requires showing you made reasonable attempts to resolve the situation before quitting and that the working conditions would cause a reasonable person to quit. Each case is decided on its individual merits.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
•whatever u sound like u work for TWC lol. i know atleast 5 people who all got denied with good documentation. the system is designed to reject people!!!
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
One more thing to consider: if your injury makes it difficult for you to perform certain types of work, make sure you're applying for jobs that accommodate your limitations. If you're medically restricted from certain activities, TWC should take that into account for your work search requirements on future claims. This won't help with your current denial, but could be important if you reapply in the future based on a different job separation.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•That's good advice. My back injury definitely limits what I can do now. I've been applying for desk jobs but haven't had any luck. If I do end up qualifying for benefits in the future, I'll make sure TWC knows about my restrictions.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
After reading all the comments, I'd say it's worth filing the Further Appeal if you have those text messages to your supervisor and doctor's notes. Make sure to emphasize: 1. The timeline of your injury 2. Exactly how your supervisor ignored medical restrictions 3. Any witnesses who saw how you were treated 4. Why you felt going to HR wouldn't help (any past examples?) Also, definitely try to speak with a TWC representative about your specific case. Sometimes they can give insights about what the Commission looks for in these cases. The 14-day deadline is strict, so don't wait too long to decide.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•I've decided to file the Further Appeal. I've got nothing to lose at this point. I'm gathering all my documentation now and will submit it before the deadline. Thank you all for the advice and support - it's really helped me figure out my next steps.
0 coins