< Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

Can I get PA UC if I refused work that previously caused injury after light duty ended?

I'm in a real dilemma with my job situation and hoping someone can help me figure out if I can file for PA unemployment. I've been on light duty for 3 months after hurting my back loading heavy equipment. Today, my supervisor suddenly told me I'm being moved back to the same exact position where I got injured before! I literally just found out 2 hours ago and I'm panicking. My doctor recommended I avoid that specific type of lifting, but my employer is insisting I return to that role or quit. If I refuse to do work that already injured me once, can I qualify for unemployment benefits? Has anyone dealt with something similar? I don't want to just quit and be left with nothing, but I'm scared of reinjuring myself worse.

Ava Martinez

•

Yes, you may qualify for PA UC benefits in this situation as it could be considered a necessitous and compelling reason to leave employment. This falls under health-related reasons for quitting. A few things you need to do ASAP: 1) Get documentation from your doctor stating that this specific work will aggravate your injury or is medically inadvisable 2) Formally request accommodation in writing to your employer 3) If they refuse accommodation, document that refusal 4) When you file, make sure to clearly explain that you had medical restrictions that your employer wouldn't accommodate. Keep all documentation because UC will likely investigate this thoroughly.

0 coins

StarSurfer

•

Thank you for the detailed response! I do have the doctor's note from my original injury, but it's 3 months old. Should I get an updated one specifically saying I can't return to that position? And how exactly should I document if they refuse accommodation - just in writing through email?

0 coins

Miguel Castro

•

you shoud probly file for wrkmans comp not unemployemnt if u got hurt on the job. thats what i did when i hurt my knee at work last yr

0 coins

Not the same thing. Workers comp is for when you're injured and can't work at all or need medical treatment. OP is asking about quitting because they're being asked to do something unsafe after returning from light duty. Unemployment is the right thing here if they have to quit for safety reasons.

0 coins

Connor Byrne

•

This is actually a complex situation that falls under both PA UC regulations and potentially ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) protections. If your doctor provided medical restrictions and your employer is not accommodating them, you may have what PA calls a "necessitous and compelling reason" to quit, which wouldn't disqualify you from benefits. However, you need to take some critical steps FIRST before quitting: 1. Get your medical restrictions updated and in writing 2. Formally request accommodation from your employer (in writing via email so you have records) 3. If they refuse to accommodate, document their refusal 4. Consider filing an ADA complaint Only after taking these steps should you consider quitting. When you file for unemployment, you'll need to explain exactly why you had no choice but to leave, and provide all this documentation. UC will contact your employer for their side of the story, so having everything documented is essential.

0 coins

StarSurfer

•

This is really helpful information. I hadn't even thought about ADA protections. I'm going to call my doctor tomorrow to get updated restrictions in writing. My employer has been pretty dismissive so far, claiming they need me back in that position due to staffing shortages. Is there specific language I should use when requesting accommodation to make sure it's properly documented?

0 coins

Yara Elias

•

I'm sorry your going thru this! My husband had something similar happen he was a warehouse worker hurt his back and they tried to put him right back on the loading dock after light duty. He ended up quitting AND GOT DENIED BENEFITS AT FIRST. Had to appeal and it was a nightmare trying to reach anyone at UC.

0 coins

QuantumQuasar

•

The appeal process is brutal but worth fighting through. I had to appeal a denial last year and ended up winning but took FOREVER to get through to someone! Have you tried using Claimyr? That's how I finally got through to a PA UC agent after weeks of busy signals. Website is claimyr.com and they have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2 - saved me so much frustration when dealing with my appeal. You get placed in the callback queue without spending hours redialing.

0 coins

Keisha Jackson

•

DONT JUST QUIT!!!!! If u quit they will 100% deny benefits and say it was voluntary. I learned this the hard way. Ask for accommodation IN WRITING and keep copies of everything!!!! PA UC system is designed to deny you benefits they can!!

0 coins

StarSurfer

•

I definitely won't just walk out! Based on everyone's advice, I'm going to document everything. What's stressing me out is my supervisor is pushing for an answer by tomorrow about whether I'll do the job or not.

0 coins

Ava Martinez

•

To follow up on my earlier comment, you asked about getting an updated doctor's note - yes, absolutely get one that specifically addresses current restrictions. For documentation, emails are good but also summarize any verbal conversations in an email afterward ("As we discussed today, I am unable to perform X task due to my medical restrictions..."). If they terminate you for being unable to perform work that violates your medical restrictions, that's generally not considered willful misconduct and you should qualify for benefits. But if you quit without proper documentation of trying to resolve the situation first, it's much harder to prove your case.

0 coins

Connor Byrne

•

Perfect advice. One additional point - PA unemployment puts the burden on you to prove you had no reasonable alternative to quitting. So documenting that you tried to find alternatives (like requesting different duties, different shifts, etc.) strengthens your case substantially. It's not enough to just say the work would hurt you - you need to show you tried everything possible to preserve the employment relationship before quitting.

0 coins

I've been through exactly this with PA UC! Here's my experience: I was a CNA who hurt my back, came off light duty, and they wanted me back to full lifting. My doctor said no lifting over 25lbs permanently, employer said that's not possible. I quit and applied for benefits. Initially denied! Had to appeal. The key was having my doctor fill out a specific form about my restrictions and proving I couldn't do the essential functions of the job without risking injury. Eventually won on appeal but took almost 3 months to get any money.

0 coins

StarSurfer

•

Thank you for sharing your experience. Did you have a hearing for your appeal? I'm worried about potentially going months without income while fighting for benefits.

0 coins

Yes, I had a hearing over the phone with a referee. My advice is start looking for work you CAN do safely immediately after leaving this job. You need to be able to show you're available for and seeking suitable work that doesn't violate your restrictions. That was actually a big part of why I won my case - I could prove I was looking for work within my restrictions. If you just say you can't work at all, they'll deny you.

0 coins

Yara Elias

•

Just wondering have u tried talking to HR instead of just ur supervisor? Sometimes they understand the legal stuff better and might find u another position?

0 coins

StarSurfer

•

That's a good point. We have a small company, but there is an HR coordinator. I'll reach out to her tomorrow too, maybe she can help find another solution that my supervisor isn't seeing.

0 coins

Keisha Jackson

•

also make sure ur continously looking for work after u quit cuz u still need to fulfill work search requirements even with a medical situation!!! u need to look for jobs that dont aggravate ur condition

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,875 users helped today