Can I reapply for NY unemployment with only 2 days worked this year - denied due to medical lifting restrictions
I'm stuck in a really frustrating situation with NY unemployment. My benefits ran out a while back, and I haven't been able to find steady work for about 18 months now. I finally got hired at a warehouse last week but only worked for 2 days before realizing I physically can't handle the job requirements. They need people who can lift 50+ pounds regularly, but I have medical restrictions that prevent me from lifting that much weight. My doctor confirmed this years ago, but I was desperate for income so I tried anyway. Now I'm wondering if I can reapply for regular unemployment benefits even though I've barely worked in the past 18 months? Has anyone been in a similar situation? At this point I'm seriously considering just applying for SSI instead, but I've heard that's an extremely long process.
23 comments
Rita Jacobs
Unfortunately, to qualify for NY unemployment benefits in 2025, you need to have worked and earned enough wages during your base period (the first 4 of the last 5 completed calendar quarters before filing). With only 2 days of work in the past 18 months, you won't meet the minimum earnings requirement. SSI might be an option if you have a qualifying disability, but as you mentioned, it's a lengthy process - often taking 3-5 months for initial decisions, and many people get denied their first application. Have you considered vocational rehabilitation services? They can help find employment that accommodates your medical restrictions.
0 coins
Manny Lark
•Thanks for the straight answer, even though it's not what I hoped to hear. I didn't realize unemployment had such strict earning requirements. I'll look into vocational rehab - I've never tried that before. Do you know if they help with job placement or just training?
0 coins
Khalid Howes
Hey did u try filing anyway? sometimes the system lets ppl through who are like edge cases... i got denied last yr but my friend with almost same situation got approved?? the whole system is weird and inconsistent!!!
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
•This is actually not good advice. Filing when you know you don't qualify can lead to complications later. If benefits are mistakenly approved and then audited, you might have to repay everything with penalties. It's better to work with legitimate programs that match your situation.
0 coins
Khalid Howes
•ok but the system is BROKEN so sometimes u gotta try anyway... just saying
0 coins
Ben Cooper
I was in a really similar situation last year with my back injury. Couldn't qualify for regular unemployment and was totally stuck. I tried calling NY unemployment for weeks hoping to find some exception or special program - impossible to get through on the phone. Then someone told me about this service called Claimyr that gets you through to an agent fast. Checked out their demo video (https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE) and tried it. Got through to someone in less than an hour! The agent told me about a special program for workers with medical restrictions that I qualified for. Might be worth checking out their site at claimyr.com - saved me weeks of stress.
0 coins
Naila Gordon
•What was the special program they told you about? I'm curious because I know someone in a similar situation with lifting restrictions.
0 coins
Cynthia Love
•I've always been suspicious of services that claim to get you through to unemployment faster. Does it actually work? The video looks convincing but idk...
0 coins
Darren Brooks
Apply for SSI now even while looking at other options!!!!! The wait is INSANE so better start now. My cousin waited almost 2 YEARS before getting approved!!!! They deny almost everyone the first time too so be ready to appeal!!!!!
0 coins
Manny Lark
•2 YEARS?? That's terrifying. I had no idea it took that long. I guess I should start that application immediately while exploring these other suggestions too. How did your cousin manage financially during that waiting period?
0 coins
Darren Brooks
•lived with family... had no choice. system is HORRIBLE for disabled ppl who cant do physical work!!!
0 coins
Rosie Harper
have u tryed doordash or uber? that's what I did when I couldnt get unemployment and couldnt lift heavy stuff. not great money but better than nothing for now
0 coins
Manny Lark
•That's a good idea, but I don't have a car right now. I had to sell mine a few months ago when I couldn't keep up with insurance payments. Are there any delivery services that don't require your own vehicle?
0 coins
Naila Gordon
There are a few options I'd recommend looking into: 1. ACCES-VR (as someone mentioned) - they specialize in helping people with medical restrictions find suitable employment 2. Apply for SSI now, as it does take a long time, but gather thorough medical documentation about your lifting restrictions 3. Look into NY's Disability Employment Initiative - they sometimes have programs for people who fall between traditional unemployment and disability 4. Check if you qualify for temporary assistance through OTDA while pursuing these other options Regarding unemployment specifically, with only 2 days worked in your base period, you won't qualify for regular benefits. However, if you speak with a knowledgeable agent (which can be difficult to reach), they might be able to direct you to appropriate programs for your specific situation. The standard call center representatives often aren't trained on these specialized programs.
0 coins
Manny Lark
•Thank you so much for this comprehensive answer. I've never heard of the Disability Employment Initiative before. I'm going to look into all of these options. It sounds like getting through to a knowledgeable agent might be key since my situation isn't straightforward.
0 coins
Ben Cooper
Just a quick update - I used Claimyr.com last year when I was in a similar spot, and surprisingly the agent I reached was super helpful. They explained that I might qualify for partial benefits based on my previous work history combined with my medical condition. Definitely worth the call to have your specific situation evaluated. The unemployment system has so many exceptions and special programs that the website doesn't clearly explain.
0 coins
Cynthia Love
•Did they charge you for using that service? Seems weird to have to pay just to talk to unemployment when it should be free.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
I want to clarify something important here - if you get denied for unemployment, make sure you request a determination review/appeal within 30 days. Even with only 2 days worked recently, they might consider your previous work history if it falls within an alternative base period. The system doesn't always correctly identify all possible base periods during initial automated processing. An appeal gives you the chance to have a human review your specific circumstances. Document your medical restrictions thoroughly, as this could also potentially qualify you for other programs if unemployment is denied.
0 coins
Manny Lark
•This is really helpful. I didn't know about the alternative base period or that I could appeal if denied. I'll definitely request a review if they deny me. I have all my medical documentation already organized from previous jobs, so that should help.
0 coins
Khalid Howes
honestly i think its super unfair that we even have to jump through all these hoops... like ur literally unable to do heavy lifting for medical reasons but the system treats u like ur just being lazy??? the whole thing is rigged against ppl with health issues who want to work but have limitations!!
0 coins
Manny Lark
•I feel exactly this way sometimes. It's exhausting trying to navigate all these different systems when you're already stressed about income. I've spent hours researching online and still feel confused about what options I actually qualify for.
0 coins
Naila Gordon
One more important point: While pursuing SSI, consider speaking with a disability attorney. Many offer free initial consultations and only get paid if you win your case (usually taking a percentage of your backpay). They dramatically increase approval rates, especially for appeals. For immediate needs, check if your local Department of Social Services offers emergency assistance programs - these can sometimes provide temporary help while you're sorting out longer-term solutions.
0 coins
Manny Lark
•Thank you - I'll look into disability attorneys in my area. I hadn't considered emergency assistance either, but that might help bridge the gap while I figure everything else out. I appreciate everyone's suggestions here. Gives me a much clearer path forward than I had yesterday.
0 coins