What makes you ineligible for unemployment in NY? NYSDOL rules explained
My job as a project coordinator at a mid-sized logistics company ended about six weeks ago and I've been trying to wrap my head around whether I even qualify for unemployment benefits. The separation wasn't entirely clean — I had been placed on a performance improvement plan for about two months, and my manager ultimately said they were 'parting ways' with me, but HR framed it in a way that felt like they were suggesting I had a choice in the matter. I've filed my initial claim and it's been sitting in adjudication since I submitted it. What I keep wondering about is what actually disqualifies someone from collecting UI in New York. I've heard everything from 'if you quit you're done' to 'misconduct is an automatic denial' but I can't find a clear breakdown of the actual rules. My weekly claims are going through fine but I haven't seen a single payment yet. Does anyone have a solid understanding of what makes you ineligible for unemployment when it comes to how the separation happened? I want to know if my situation even has a shot before I get too invested in the appeal process.
69 comments

Luca Marino
My claim went through the same adjudication limbo last spring and I burned two weeks trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL by phone. Every time I dialed the claims line I got a busy signal or sat on hold for 90 minutes before the system dropped me. A friend told me about Claimyr — claimyr.com — and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. That agent was actually the one who explained to me in plain language exactly what flag had triggered my adjudication. Knowing what the issue was made the whole appeal process way less terrifying. If you're stuck and can't get through, it's genuinely worth trying.
0 coins
Nia Davis
Your situation sounds almost identical to mine from last year. The agent who picked up was the first person who could actually read the notes on my file and tell me whether the separation was coded as a discharge or a voluntary quit — that distinction alone determined everything about my eligibility.
0 coins
Mateo Perez
Two months I spent redialing before someone told me about services like that. Two months of my life I will never get back lol
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
wait does it work for the NYSDOL number specifically or just general government lines? asking bc i keep hitting the automated system and it never gets me to a human
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
My termination years ago taught me that the whole ineligibility question basically comes down to three buckets in New York. First, how you left — if you quit without what NYSDOL considers 'good cause' tied directly to your job, you're disqualified right there. Second, whether your employer claims misconduct — not just bad performance but actual intentional rule-breaking or gross negligence. Third, whether you're currently able to work, available for work, and actively looking. Miss any of those ongoing requirements and your payments stop even if you were initially approved.
0 coins
Zara Malik
The misconduct piece is what's tripping me up. My employer put everything in writing as 'performance issues' but I don't know if NYSDOL reads that the same way they do. Performance and misconduct feel like they should be treated differently but I honestly don't know how the state sees it.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
NYSDOL absolutely draws a line between poor performance and misconduct. Performance means you tried but didn't meet standards — that's generally NOT disqualifying. Misconduct means you deliberately violated a known workplace rule. If your PIP paperwork just says you didn't hit targets or had quality issues, that's usually on the performance side, which works in your favor.
0 coins
Zara Malik
That distinction actually makes me feel a lot better about my specific situation. My whole PIP was about project delivery timelines, nothing about policy violations or anything intentional.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
voluntarily quitting is the big one people get caught on. my neighbor filed after leaving her job because her commute went from 20 minutes to 2 hours after they moved offices. she thought quitting for any reason meant automatic denial but actually NYSDOL ruled her commute change was a substantial change in employment conditions so she qualified. the rules are more nuanced than people think
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
Your neighbor's case is actually a classic 'good cause' voluntary quit scenario. NYSDOL recognizes things like a dramatic commute change, significant pay cuts, unsafe working conditions, or medical reasons tied to the job as good cause. The key is you have to have made a reasonable effort to fix the issue before quitting — like asking for a transfer or accommodation — and documented it.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
My boss cut my hours by almost 40% and I didn't think I could quit and still file. I just suffered through it for four months before they let me go anyway. Wish I had known this sooner honestly
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
yeah the system does NOT make this information easy to find. i only knew because a family member had gone through it before me
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
Weekly certification requirements catch a lot of people off guard too. My first time filing years ago I missed certifying for three weeks because I didn't realize I had to do it every single week even while waiting for adjudication to resolve. NYSDOL treats each week independently — if you don't certify, you don't get paid for that week, period, and they generally won't go back and pay you for weeks you skipped even if everything else gets resolved.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Mine have been going through each week so at least that part I seem to have right. The issue is the payment hold during adjudication — does it release everything all at once once they decide in my favor?
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
My experience when adjudication resolved in my favor was that all the held weeks released in one big payment. It took about 3-4 days to hit my direct deposit after the determination letter showed up in my Unemployment Services account online.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
that is such a relief to hear. i have 5 weeks banked up right now waiting on a decision and i was scared they would just disappear
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Refusing suitable work is another thing that'll get you disqualified and I don't see people talk about it enough. NYSDOL can determine you ineligible if you turn down a job offer for a position that pays reasonably close to your prior wage and is in your field. The definition of 'suitable' considers your skills, experience, pay history, and how long you've been unemployed — the longer you're out, the broader 'suitable' gets. So early in a claim you have more wiggle room to decline a job below your pay grade. Six months in, that wiggle room shrinks.
0 coins
Nia Davis
My claim actually got flagged because a former employer listed me as having 'refused rehire.' That's a whole separate adjudication trigger — they treat that similarly to refusing a suitable offer. Took me forever to reach someone who could explain what was actually on file.
0 coins
Mei Liu
My situation with the refused rehire thing was identical and I could not get anyone at NYSDOL on the line for weeks. Eventually used Claimyr and ended up talking to an agent who pulled up my file and explained the employer had submitted a form I didn't even know existed. That cleared up weeks of confusion in one phone call.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
The employer-side documentation is so invisible to claimants. You have almost no way to see what your former employer filed unless you specifically ask an agent to read it to you.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
My former coworker got denied because she hadn't worked enough hours in the base period — she'd switched jobs twice in 18 months and her total base period wages didn't hit the threshold. NYSDOL uses your earnings from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters to determine your benefit rate and whether you even qualify. If your wages during that window are below a certain floor you just don't qualify regardless of how the separation went.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Base period wages weren't something I was worried about since I'd been with this company for over three years, but I hadn't thought about how the quarters get counted. Good to know that piece is probably solid for me.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
i made the mistake of thinking my most recent quarter would count and it doesnt. lost like 6 months of higher earnings from my calculation because of when i filed. the alternate base period saved me tho, worth asking about if ur wages look low
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
The alternate base period uses the most recent four completed quarters instead, and you can request it if the standard calculation leaves you below the threshold. It's not automatic — you have to specifically ask NYSDOL to run your claim under the alternate method.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
collecting while working is a gray area people mess up constantly. if you pick up any part time hours during the week you're certifying you HAVE to report those earnings. NYSDOL doesn't just disqualify you for earning money — they reduce your benefit by a formula — but if you don't report and they catch it later that becomes an overpayment plus potential fraud. the reporting requirement is absolute
0 coins
Mateo Perez
Fraud designation is no joke either. My cousin didn't report a few weeks of gig work thinking it was under the radar and ended up with an overpayment notice for over $4,000 plus a fraud surcharge on top of the original amount. The recovery process was brutal.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
gig work is actually a really murky area because NYSDOL has specific rules about self-employment income that differ from W2 part time work. either way report it and let them do the math rather than guessing what to disclose
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
wait so like if i do one doordash shift do i have to report that too
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Yes, any earnings in a certification week need to be reported, that includes gig platforms. Report the gross amount you earned that week, not what deposits to your account.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
My situation was a bit different — I was laid off but then my employer contested my claim saying I had been terminated for cause. The hearing process that followed was something I had not prepared for at all. NYSDOL schedules an administrative hearing where both sides can present their case and the ALJ makes a binding determination. I got help from Claimyr just to understand what documentation I needed before the hearing — the agent I reached explained the process step by step in a way the NYSDOL website absolutely does not.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Contested claims through a hearing is exactly what I'm worried about if my employer pushes back on the adjudication. How long did the hearing process take from the initial adjudication trigger to the actual hearing date?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
My timeline from adjudication flag to scheduled hearing was about seven weeks. The determination letter came roughly ten days after the hearing itself. Throughout that whole period I kept filing weekly claims as normal and the held payments released after the favorable ruling.
0 coins
Luca Marino
Hearings are genuinely intimidating but the ALJ process is way more claimant-friendly than people expect. They're not trying to catch you — they just want to hear both accounts and determine which one matches the documented evidence.
0 coins
NeonNova
okay dumb question but can you get disqualified for not doing enough job search activities? i thought that was separate from eligibility but someone told me NYSDOL can retroactively disqualify you for weeks where you didn't do your required contacts
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Your understanding is partly right but slightly off. The job search requirement is 3 employer contacts per week in New York, and you self-certify compliance when you file your weekly claim. NYSDOL can audit your log and if you can't prove your contacts, they can disqualify specific weeks and issue an overpayment for those weeks. It's not exactly retroactive ineligibility — it's more like week-by-week disqualification for weeks you can't document.
0 coins
NeonNova
oh wow ok so if i claimed I did my contacts but didn't actually document them anywhere that could come back to bite me??
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Your log doesn't have to be submitted upfront but you need to be able to produce it if audited. Keep records of company name, position applied to, method of contact, and date. A spreadsheet works fine — doesn't need to be fancy.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
NYSDOL audited my job search records last year completely out of nowhere like 8 months after I had stopped claiming. Had to dig through old emails to prove my applications. Keep those records way longer than you think you'll need them
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
My layoff came with a severance package and I didn't file for a couple months because I assumed I was ineligible while getting severance. Turns out NYSDOL treats severance differently depending on how it's structured — lump sum severance paid out all at once typically doesn't delay your eligibility start date the way weekly continuation pay would. I lost about six weeks of benefits I could have been collecting because I waited.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Nobody told me this either and I did have a small severance paid as a lump sum. I filed within two weeks of my last day so hopefully my start date wasn't affected but I'm definitely going to verify this when I finally get to talk to someone.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
Your lump sum should be fine — the ones that cause delays are structured payments that mirror a regular salary, like getting 'continuation pay' for 8 weeks post-termination. That gets treated almost like you're still employed during that period.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
My case had exactly that continuation pay situation and my effective claim date was pushed out by the full continuation period. When I finally reached someone at NYSDOL through Claimyr they explained that the system had automatically calculated my claim start date based on how the payout was coded in what my employer reported — nothing I entered myself had caused it, it came from the employer's quarterly wage filing.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Availability requirements are something a lot of people unknowingly violate. 'Available for work' isn't just about being physically present in NY — it means you can't be unavailable for a substantial portion of the week due to school, childcare constraints, medical restrictions, or anything else. My sister-in-law enrolled in a full-time nursing program while claiming and her case went to adjudication because NYSDOL questioned whether a full-time student was genuinely available for full-time employment.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
The school thing is a real trap. Part time evening courses generally don't affect availability but anything that restricts your daytime hours significantly can get flagged. Some training programs are actually approved by NYSDOL which exempts you from that restriction but you have to get approval before you enroll.
0 coins
NeonNova
wait so if i took a certification class online at my own schedule would that count against me
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Your own-schedule online coursework is generally fine since it doesn't restrict when you're available to interview or work. The issue is fixed-schedule programs that would prevent you from accepting a job offer or attending an interview during normal business hours.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
NYSDOL approved training is actually worth looking into if you're in a field that needs retraining. They have a program where you can take approved courses without it affecting your benefits and they'll even help fund some of the tuition
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
Failing to report to your Career Center when required is another trip wire. NYSDOL sometimes requires claimants to attend orientation sessions or reemployment services appointments, and if you ignore those notices you can be disqualified for the weeks you didn't comply. The notice comes either by mail or in your Unemployment Services online account and people miss them because they're not checking both places.
0 coins
Zara Malik
My Unemployment Services account has been pretty active with notices and I've been checking it every couple of days. Is there a way to set up email or text alerts so I don't have to log in manually to catch something important?
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
My account has notification settings under the profile section — you can opt into email alerts when new correspondence is added. It's not perfectly reliable so I'd still recommend checking in manually every few days especially during active adjudication.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
the career center appointment thing blindsided me because i got the notice by mail and it arrived two days after the appointment date that was listed on it. had to call and explain and luckily they rescheduled without penalty but it was stressful
0 coins
Jamal Carter
my employer is now saying i abandoned my job by not showing up after i got hurt and went to the doctor. i had a medical note and everything but they coded my separation as a voluntary quit due to job abandonment. is that actually going to make me ineligible??
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Your medical note is key evidence here. Job abandonment is a valid basis for disqualification IF the claimant actually abandoned the position — but if you notified your employer, provided documentation, and had a legitimate reason for the absence, the abandonment designation can be challenged in adjudication. Submit any documentation you have showing you communicated your situation before or during your absence.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Medical separations are their own whole category. If your injury or illness was work-related or made you unable to perform your specific job duties, there are provisions under NYSDOL rules for that. If your absence was temporary and you intended to return, the abandonment coding really needs to be challenged — that determination was your employer's framing, not necessarily the final word.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
i have texts showing i messaged my supervisor the day i went to the doctor and told them i had an appointment. i didn't even know i needed to file unemployment until three weeks later when they never put me back on the schedule
0 coins
Nia Davis
Pension income can affect your weekly benefit amount too, though it doesn't necessarily make you ineligible. My dad retired from a company and then got laid off from a part-time position he'd taken up after retirement. His pension reduced his weekly UI benefit by an offset formula. He was still eligible, just collecting less than a pure calculation would have shown.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
Social security works differently from a pension for offset purposes — my uncle's SS income only got deducted at half the rate from his benefit, while his small company pension was deducted at the full amount. The rules depend on whether you or your employer contributed to the plan.
0 coins
Nia Davis
The employer contribution piece is exactly right. If your former employer funded the pension entirely, the offset is 100% of the weekly pension equivalent. If you contributed too, only the employer-funded portion counts toward the offset. Worth clarifying with NYSDOL directly on your specific pension structure.
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
has anyone had their claim denied because of a non-compete or separation agreement they signed when they left? my company made me sign something when they let me go and there was language about 'voluntary resignation' in it even though it was clearly a layoff. wondering if that document could hurt my NYSDOL claim
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
Separation agreement language does not bind NYSDOL — they make their own factual determination based on the actual circumstances of your separation, not what a private contract says. If the reality was a layoff and you can demonstrate that through documentation like a termination letter, final pay records, or communications with HR, the 'voluntary resignation' language in a private agreement won't override what actually happened.
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
oh that is such a relief because i was scared signing that thing basically ended any shot i had at benefits
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
My termination was packaged as a 'mutual separation' in my agreement and NYSDOL still found in my favor during adjudication because the underlying facts showed the company had already eliminated my position. What actually happened matters more than how the paperwork was labeled.
0 coins
Mateo Perez
something i never see mentioned: immigration status can affect eligibility. you generally need to have been authorized to work in the US during your base period earnings to qualify. not trying to make assumptions about anyone but it's a real eligibility condition that NYSDOL checks
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Work authorization during the base period is a federal requirement tied into the UI system nationally, not just NY. If your authorization status changed or lapsed during any part of your base period, it can affect what wages are countable. Very specific situation and worth getting actual legal advice on if it applies.
0 coins
Mateo Perez
right i just mention it because it comes up and people don't always know it's one of the boxes NYSDOL checks during the initial eligibility review
0 coins
Zara Malik
Thank everyone for the breakdown here — this thread has actually given me more clarity than three weeks of googling. My plan now is to get on the phone with NYSDOL to understand exactly what triggered my adjudication, gather my PIP documentation to show the separation was performance-based and not misconduct, and keep filing my weeklies every week without missing. If the adjudication comes back against me I'll file an appeal within the 30-day window. Really appreciate all the specific information especially the distinction between performance and misconduct — that piece mattered a lot to me.
0 coins
Luca Marino
Your approach is exactly right. Getting the specific adjudication issue clarified by an agent is step one — everything else flows from knowing what flag actually triggered the hold. Good luck and keep filing those weeklies no matter what.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
My experience going through a contested case was that having organized documentation made a huge difference at the hearing stage. Even if adjudication resolves in your favor, having a clean file with timelines and written evidence makes you prepared if the employer appeals the determination.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
update us when you hear something — threads like this are way more useful when the original poster comes back to say what actually happened
0 coins