What happens if employer doesn t respond to unemployment claim - NYSDOL explained
So I filed my unemployment claim about two weeks ago and I've been in this weird limbo since. My former employer hasn't responded to NYSDOL at all - at least that's what it looks like from my end since my claim is just sitting there with no movement. I was let go from my warehouse supervisor position after almost four years, they said it was a 'workforce reduction' but honestly the whole thing felt off and I've been suspicious they might contest it. Now I'm wondering if the employer not saying anything actually helps my case or hurts it, and whether NYSDOL just moves forward without them. My bills are stacking up and I need to know how long I can expect to wait before getting any kind of determination. Anyone been through this?
70 comments

Omar Hassan
Went through almost this exact situation last year. My old employer dragged their feet for weeks and I was convinced they were going to swoop in and blow up my claim right at the last second. Here's what ended up happening for me: NYSDOL sent them a notice asking for their side of the story, and when they didn't respond within the window they were given, the adjudicator just moved ahead using the information I'd already submitted. Got my approval about a week later. The way it works is that your employer gets a specific deadline to respond - if they miss it, they basically lose their window to contest without a really good reason. NYSDOL isn't going to hold your claim hostage forever waiting on a silent employer.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorHow long was the window they gave your employer? Mine has been quiet for about 12 days and I'm not sure if the clock has even started.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Mine was around 10 days from when NYSDOL sent them the notice, but honestly that timeline felt like it varied. The adjudicator on my case moved pretty fast once the deadline passed. Your 12 days might mean the window already closed for them.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Ugh the waiting is the worst part. I had a claim stuck for three weeks once and no way to find out what was actually happening. Tried phoning NYSDOL like 20 times in a week and kept hitting the same wall of hold music until it dropped. Eventually my neighbor told me about Claimyr - it's at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - basically it sits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent. That agent told me exactly where my claim was in the process and what the employer had or hadn't submitted. Way better than staring at my account portal trying to decode it myself.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorHad no idea something like that existed. Did the agent actually give you useful specifics or just the runaround?
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Phones at NYSDOL are absolutely brutal. Three hours in a queue then a disconnection is basically tradition at this point.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
Might be worth trying, honestly. Getting any real information out of NYSDOL through their website alone is basically impossible when your claim is in adjudication.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
People get this backward a lot - the employer not responding is almost always better for the claimant, not worse. Your employer was notified and given a deadline to dispute your claim. If they let that deadline pass without saying anything, NYSDOL treats their silence as essentially no contest. The adjudicator decides based on what you said, and if your separation was a layoff or workforce reduction like you said, that's already a favorable circumstance. I've seen plenty of these go through smoothly once the response period expires. The main thing is to keep filing your weekly certifications no matter what while you wait - stopping those is a mistake that delays payment even after approval.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorI've been certifying every week, so at least I've got that covered. Good to know the silence works in my favor.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Does that mean the employer can't come back later and contest it after the deadline? Or can they still do it at some point?
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
They can try to appeal after the fact but they'd need to show NYSDOL a legit reason why they missed the original response window. Missing it without a good excuse makes their position way weaker in any subsequent appeal hearing.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
The portal thing drives me insane. My claim sat at 'pending' for so long I genuinely thought the system had just forgotten I existed. When I finally got someone at NYSDOL on the phone they told me my employer had responded but their response was flagged for review which is why there was no movement visible on my end. Moral of the story - what you see on your account isn't always the full picture of what's actually happening behind the scenes.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorThat's honestly unsettling. So things could be moving without any visible indication?
0 coins
Zara Rashid
Yep. The portal is essentially useless for real-time status. The only way to get actual info is to reach someone by phone.
0 coins
Luca Romano
My claim showed pending for almost a month and then one day just flipped to approved with back pay deposited all at once. The system is definitely not transparent about what's going on.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Former HR person here, now on the other side of this. At my old job we got these employer response notices from NYSDOL and you'd be surprised how many small businesses just... don't respond. Sometimes it's because they don't contest the separation. Sometimes it's just disorganization. Either way, from your perspective as a claimant, an employer who doesn't respond is not fighting you. The deadline to contest is real and NYSDOL does enforce it. That said, even after approval your former employer can initiate a protest period if they believe there was an error, so the story isn't completely over but their leverage drops significantly once that initial window closes.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Does that protest period have its own deadline too? Or is it open-ended?
0 coins
Nia Jackson
There's a window for employer appeals too, it's not unlimited. If they miss both the response window AND the appeal window, their options become very limited. At that point they'd basically need to demonstrate fraud or administrative error to reopen things.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Ended up having to look into all of this myself when my claim got weird. Claimyr got me to an actual NYSDOL agent who walked me through the timeline on my specific case - way less confusing than trying to parse the general rules online when you don't know which situation applies to you.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
My situation was a little different but related. Got laid off, filed, employer responded late and then tried to claim the separation was for cause. The adjudicator rejected their late submission because they had no documented reason for missing the deadline. My benefits were approved and when they appealed to the ALJ level, the late response issue actually hurt their credibility. The employer not responding or responding late is genuinely not a good position for them to be arguing from.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorALJ level - does that mean it went to a full hearing? How long did that drag out?
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
It did go to a hearing but I had already been receiving benefits the whole time since the initial determination was in my favor. The hearing was months later and the original decision held. You can keep getting paid while an employer appeal is pending as long as your claim was approved first.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Wait I'm confused about something. If the employer doesn't respond does that mean the claim is automatically approved or does someone still have to review it?
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Someone still reviews it - an adjudicator at NYSDOL goes through what you submitted and makes a determination. The employer not responding means the adjudicator only has your version to work with, which is obviously advantageous for you, but it's not a rubber stamp. They're checking whether your reason for separation and your eligibility meets the requirements regardless.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Ohh ok that makes more sense. So it's not like automatic but it's still better than if they respond trying to fight it?
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Exactly. No contest from the employer plus a qualifying separation like a layoff is about as clean a path to approval as you can have.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Nobody at NYSDOL ever told me any of this when I filed. I genuinely thought if my employer didn't respond that my claim was just going to sit there indefinitely. I spent two weeks refreshing my portal like a crazy person before I figured out what was actually happening. The whole process would be so much less stressful if they sent claimants a simple timeline of what to expect.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorHonestly the anxiety of not knowing is almost the worst part. What ended up happening with yours?
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Employer never responded, got approved after about 18 days total. Back pay came through for all the weeks I'd certified. It worked out but those 18 days were rough without any visibility into what was happening.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
NYSDOL communication is basically nonexistent. They operate on a 'we'll tell you when we tell you' basis and apparently that's just how it is.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
I keep seeing people say to keep certifying weekly and I want to second that really hard. My cousin didn't file his weekly claims for three weeks because he thought his claim was frozen and nothing would happen anyway - turned out the claim processed fine but he had no certified weeks on record so he got paid for zero of those weeks. NYSDOL doesn't go back and let you certify retroactively in most cases. Those weeks are just gone.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorYeah I've been certifying every week religiously. Definitely not making that mistake.
0 coins
Luca Romano
This is a really underrated point. The weekly certification is completely separate from whatever status the underlying claim is in. You have to keep doing it.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Even if you have no job search activity to report some weeks, you still certify and explain your situation. Stopping the certifications is one of the most common and painful mistakes people make.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
My employer responded to my UI claim and it still took forever because they disputed the reason for separation. At least if yours isn't responding you're not dealing with that extra layer of back and forth. I had to submit a written rebuttal to their response, then wait for an adjudicator to weigh both sides, then wait more. The whole thing took 47 days. Having a non-responsive employer sounds genuinely better by comparison.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Author47 days is terrifying. Did you get back pay for all of that?
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
Yes, once it was approved I got back pay for every week I had certified during the wait. That's the one thing that made it survivable - I knew the money wasn't just disappearing, it was accumulating.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
The back pay aspect is so important for people to know about. The wait is awful but those weeks don't disappear as long as you're certifying.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Can your employer respond but NOT contest it? Like respond and just confirm it was a layoff?
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Yes, absolutely. Employers respond and confirm the reason for separation all the time. If they confirm it was a layoff or reduction in force, that actually speeds up the determination because the adjudicator has corroboration from both sides pointing the same direction.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Hm ok so an employer response isn't automatically bad news. Good to know I've been panicking every time the status changes.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
FOUR HOURS on hold yesterday trying to check my claim status. Four hours. Disconnected at the three hour and fifty minute mark. This is not acceptable for a government agency that handles people's income during unemployment. I have bills. I have a kid. I cannot spend half my day chained to a phone that never answers.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
My experience was exactly like this for two straight weeks. Claimyr is the only thing that actually worked for me - sat on hold with NYSDOL so I didn't have to, and I wound up speaking directly to a live agent who had my file open in front of her. First real information I'd gotten in weeks.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
How long did it actually take once you used that? Because four hours is apparently not long enough for NYSDOL.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
I'd been trying on my own for two weeks with nothing. Got to an agent through Claimyr the same day I tried it. Night and day difference from burning hours on hold myself.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
There's actually a reason employers sometimes strategically don't respond right away. I worked in business admin and I saw this - some employers wait because they're evaluating whether the claim is worth contesting given their history with that specific employee. If the separation is clean they may just not bother. If they think there's grounds to dispute they engage. So radio silence from your employer might literally just mean they looked at your case and decided not to fight it.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorThat's actually a weirdly reassuring way to look at it. Almost like a soft signal they're not going to push back.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
It's not a guarantee but it's a reasonable interpretation. An employer who intends to aggressively dispute usually moves fast to get their narrative in first. Silence often means no contest.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
My adjudicator actually reached out to me by phone during my pending period asking for clarification about my last day of work. I hadn't expected any contact so I nearly didn't answer. Heads up to everyone - if an unknown number calls while your claim is pending it might be NYSDOL trying to reach you, pick it up.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorOh wow I hadn't thought about that. Good to know to watch for incoming calls too.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Yeah it threw me off completely. They left a voicemail luckily but I almost ignored it. The voicemail explained it was an adjudicator with a question about my claim. If I'd missed it who knows how much longer things would have dragged on.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
They don't always call but it does happen especially when something in the claim needs clarification before they can issue a determination. Best to answer unknown numbers during this period.
0 coins
Luca Romano
Honestly reading this thread helped me understand what's going on with my own claim better than the NYSDOL website did. I'm in almost the exact same boat - laid off, employer hasn't said anything, claim just sitting there. I'm going to stop panicking and just keep certifying.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorWe're in the same boat then. Hoping both our claims come through without drama.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Keep certifying every single week without exception. That's the main thing in your control right now.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
Two things that made a huge difference for my sanity during my adjudication wait: I checked my account first thing in the morning rather than constantly throughout the day, and I set a reminder to certify on the same day every week so I never forgot. The claim moves on its own timeline and refreshing the portal hourly doesn't change that, but missing a certification absolutely can hurt you.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorSetting a fixed certification day is actually a great idea. Putting it in my calendar right now.
0 coins
Luca Romano
The obsessive portal checking is so real. I had to force myself to stop looking more than once a day for my mental health.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
Went through adjudication twice now with two different employers. First time the employer responded quickly and disputed, second time they didn't respond at all. Second one resolved in 11 days, first one took almost two months with a whole hearing process. If you've got a silent employer consider yourself lucky relative to what the alternative looks like. Also Claimyr is worth knowing about if you need to actually reach NYSDOL - both times I eventually needed to talk to an agent and that was the only approach that actually worked for me.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorTwo months with a hearing sounds absolutely brutal. That puts my 12 days of waiting in perspective.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
The second one felt almost anticlimactic by comparison. Got the approval notice in my portal and kind of didn't believe it after the first experience.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
The difference between a contested and uncontested separation really is enormous in terms of timeline. Uncontested with a qualifying reason is as smooth as this process gets.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
My job search log - does anyone know if that gets reviewed more carefully when a claim is in adjudication? I've been keeping detailed records but I want to make sure I'm not doing something wrong while I wait for the determination.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Your job search activities are generally reviewed during your weekly certifications and can be audited at any point. NYSDOL requires three job search activities per week for most claimants. The adjudication of your separation reason is a separate review from your ongoing eligibility, but both matter. Keep your records detailed and accurate regardless.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
Three activities per week - is that confirmed for 2025 or has it changed recently?
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Three qualifying activities per week has been the standard requirement in New York. Keep documenting employer name, contact method, date, and position applied for. That's what auditors look for if your records get pulled.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
I keep seeing people stress about the employer response thing and I get it but I want to say - even when employers DO respond and contest a claim, claimants win a pretty significant portion of those disputes and appeals. The whole system isn't designed to automatically side with employers. A lot of people assume fighting an employer means automatically losing and that's just not true.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
AuthorThat's genuinely good to hear. The power imbalance feels so real when you're the one waiting.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
Won my appeal against my employer's response after a full hearing. It's stressful but the process does give claimants a real chance to present their side. Gather your documentation and don't just assume you'll lose.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Documentation is everything. Emails, texts, performance reviews, anything that supports your account of the separation. If it ever goes to a hearing, evidence matters.
0 coins