NY unemployment direct deposit KeyBank account access issues - can't log in for months
Has anyone else struggled to access their KeyBank account for NY unemployment direct deposits? I've been locked out of my online account AND mobile banking for over 2 months now. Every time I call KeyBank customer service, they tell me to try a different browser, clear my cache, uninstall/reinstall the app, or reset my password - NOTHING WORKS! I keep getting an error message saying my account needs verification but then the verification process fails. I'm starting to worry I won't be able to access my unemployment funds when I need them. The KeyBank rep today suggested I might need to visit a branch in person, but the closest one is 40 miles away! Has anyone solved this issue without driving to a branch?
21 comments
Join the conversation
Chloe Boulanger
I had the exact same issue back in January! The KeyBank portal for unemployment deposits has been notoriously glitchy since they updated their system in late 2024. What worked for me was using a completely different device - not just a different browser. I borrowed my sister's laptop and suddenly it worked. Something about device recognition in their security system is messed up. Also make sure you're not using any VPN when you try to log in.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•Thanks for the suggestion! I've only tried on my phone and personal laptop. I'll see if I can borrow someone else's device. Did you have to go through the whole verification process again or just regular login once you used a different device?
0 coins
James Martinez
omg keybank is THE WORST!!! i've been dealing with them for my ny unemployment since november and nothing but problems!!! their customer service is useless and they keep transferring me around. finally got so fed up i switched to direct deposit to my regular bank account. you can do that through your ny.gov account under payment method. took like 3 days to process then no more keybank headaches
0 coins
Noah Ali
•I didn't even realize switching was an option! I thought KeyBank was the only way to get NY unemployment payments. I'll definitely look into changing to my regular bank. Thank you!!!
0 coins
James Martinez
•np! just go to ur dashboard on ny.gov and look for payment preferences or something like that. sooooo much easier than dealing with keybank trust me
0 coins
Olivia Harris
This is a common issue with the KeyBank unemployment card system right now. I work with unemployment claimants, and I've heard this complaint from at least 15 people in the past month. Here's what you need to know: 1. KeyBank did a major security upgrade in December 2024 that's causing authentication problems 2. Their phone support is limited in what they can fix - most representatives can only follow basic troubleshooting scripts 3. You DON'T necessarily need to visit a branch The most reliable solution is to call the dedicated NY unemployment KeyBank line at 1-866-295-2955 (not the regular KeyBank customer service). Ask specifically to speak with a security authentication specialist. They have a separate team that can manually verify your identity and reset the security parameters on your account. If that doesn't work, you can absolutely switch to direct deposit to your personal bank account through your NY.gov unemployment portal under payment preferences.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•This is incredibly helpful! I've been calling the general KeyBank number (1-800-539-2968) which explains why I kept getting the runaround. I'll try the dedicated unemployment line tomorrow and specifically ask for the security authentication team. Thank you so much!
0 coins
Alexander Zeus
keYbAnK iS a JoKe!! they lost access to my account for 6 WEEKS and i almost got evicted cuz i couldnt get my money!!! the whole system is designed to make it hard to get YOUR OWN MONEY!! switch to direct deposit immediately!
0 coins
Alicia Stern
•While I understand your frustration, I don't think there's a deliberate conspiracy to withhold funds. Financial institutions have to comply with strict security protocols, especially for government benefit disbursements. That said, their technical execution and customer service clearly need improvement. I'm sorry you almost faced eviction - that's truly unacceptable when you're relying on timely unemployment benefits.
0 coins
Gabriel Graham
I had this issue too and wasted hours on the phone with no solution. What finally worked for me was using the Claimyr service to get through to an actual NYSDOL representative who could help with KeyBank issues. They got me connected within 30 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. The rep was able to submit an internal ticket to KeyBank's unemployment services team which fixed my access within 48 hours. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE and their website is claimyr.com. Honestly, after all the frustration, it was worth it to finally get someone who could actually help.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•I've never heard of Claimyr before. Does it really work? I've been trying to get through to someone at NYSDOL for weeks with no luck.
0 coins
Gabriel Graham
•Yes, it definitely worked for me. The regular NYSDOL phone line kept disconnecting me after waiting for 2+ hours. Claimyr got me through to an actual person who could help with the KeyBank issue. The representative was able to escalate it properly since they deal with this problem frequently.
0 coins
Drake
This might sound weird but check what internet connection you're using. My KeyBank account would never work on my home wifi but worked fine on my phone data or at the library. Something about their security flags certain networks. Also they completely lock accounts if you try too many times from different places, could be what happened.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•That's interesting! I have been trying from both my home wifi and my phone data, switching back and forth when one didn't work. Maybe that's part of the problem if their system flags multiple connection types as suspicious? I'll try sticking to just one connection type when I try again.
0 coins
Chloe Boulanger
One other important thing - if you do decide to switch to direct deposit to your personal bank account (which I recommend), make sure you still try to resolve the KeyBank issue. Any funds already sent to your KeyBank account will remain there, so you need access to transfer those out even after you switch payment methods for future deposits.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•That's a really good point I hadn't considered! I think I have about $870 still sitting in the KeyBank account that I need to access. I'll definitely follow the advice about calling the dedicated unemployment line and asking for the security authentication team first.
0 coins
Sarah Jones
Hey so my brother works at KeyBank (not customer service but IT) and they've been having MAJOR database issues with the unemployment card system. Something about the conversion to a new security protocol that went really wrong. They're working on fixes but it's taking forever because it's a whole government contract thing with approvals needed. His advice to family has been just switch to regular direct deposit because the card system won't be fully fixed until May probably.
0 coins
Olivia Harris
•This is actually consistent with what we've been hearing through official channels as well. There was supposed to be a security certificate update that would fix many of these issues by the end of March, but it's been delayed. Your brother's May timeline sounds realistic based on the current situation. Thanks for sharing this insight.
0 coins
Noah Ali
UPDATE: I just got off the phone with the NY unemployment KeyBank line that someone suggested (1-866-295-2955), and it was like night and day compared to the regular KeyBank customer service! The rep immediately understood the issue and transferred me to their security team. They confirmed my identity through a different process and manually reset something on my account. I was able to log in right after the call! For anyone else having this issue, definitely call this specific number and ask for the security authentication team right away. Now I need to decide if I should stick with KeyBank or switch to direct deposit to my regular bank...
0 coins
James Martinez
•Switch to regular bank!!!! Trust me you'll thank urself later!!! KeyBank will probably just have more problems again
0 coins
Alicia Stern
•Glad you got it resolved! Based on the recurring issues many users are experiencing, switching to direct deposit to your personal bank account would be the most reliable option. The transition process through NY.gov is relatively straightforward and typically takes 3-5 business days to become effective. Keep in mind that any payment initiated during that transition period might still go to KeyBank.
0 coins