Back to New York Unemployment

Mason Kaczka

If you quit work can you get unemployment in NY? My NYSDOL situation explained

So I left my job about six weeks ago and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with my UI claim. The circumstances weren't great - my employer kept changing my schedule without notice, cutting my hours by almost half, and when I brought it up with HR they basically shrugged. After three months of that I finally gave notice and walked. Filed for unemployment two weeks ago and now my claim is sitting in adjudication with zero updates. My Unemployment Services account just shows 'pending' and I genuinely don't know if I'm going to get anything at all. A friend who works in HR told me quitting almost always disqualifies you, but I've seen posts online suggesting there are exceptions. Does anyone know if NYSDOL actually considers this kind of situation when deciding eligibility? The reduced hours and schedule chaos had to count for something, right?

Your situation with the reduced hours is actually a recognized exception in NY - it's called 'constructive discharge' in legal terms, but NYSDOL calls it 'good cause' for leaving. When an employer changes the terms of employment substantially - like slashing your hours nearly in half - you may still qualify even though you technically quit. The adjudication process is exactly where they evaluate this. An examiner reviews the circumstances and decides whether your reason for quitting meets the good cause standard. The key is making sure the information on your claim accurately reflects what happened, including the percentage your hours were cut and when it started.

0 coins

My claim form did ask about the reason for leaving and I explained the hours situation. Is there anything else I should be doing while adjudication is processing? Do they ever reach out for more info?

0 coins

NYSDOL can send a questionnaire by mail or through your Unemployment Services account asking for more detail. Check your account messages daily during adjudication - missing a request for information can delay or even deny your claim. Also keep filing your weekly certifications the whole time, even while pending.

0 coins

wait they actually mail stuff? i thought everything was online now

0 coins

Adjudication when you've quit is brutal, not gonna lie. Mine dragged on for 7 weeks and I had a similarly documented case. The issue is NYSDOL has to contact your former employer too and get their version of events. Some employers fight it hard even when they're clearly wrong. Make sure you have any documentation of the schedule changes - texts, emails, anything from HR in writing would be huge here.

0 coins

Emails from HR I have almost none of, they always did everything verbally. Would my own records of schedule changes help at all?

0 coins

Your own records help but they carry less weight than employer documentation. If coworkers witnessed the same treatment or experienced the same hour cuts, written statements from them can actually make a difference. Worth asking.

0 coins

7 weeks is wild. mine was 5 weeks and i thought THAT was forever. this system is designed to wear you down i swear

0 coins

While your adjudication drags on you're probably going insane trying to get a live person at NYSDOL to answer questions about your case. I was in a similar quit situation last year and spent almost two weeks just trying to get through on the phone. A coworker told me about Claimyr - it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking directly to a live agent without sitting on hold yourself for hours. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a quit case especially it's worth talking to an agent because they can actually see your adjudication notes and tell you what the examiner is looking at.

0 coins

Two weeks trying to get through - that's exactly what I'm dealing with right now. I'll check that out. Did the agent you spoke with actually give you useful information about your case status?

0 coins

My agent was able to tell me the examiner had already made a determination and that I'd be getting a letter. Without that call I'd have been waiting and refreshing my account for who knows how long. Also confirmed I needed to keep certifying weekly, which I didn't realize mattered while in adjudication.

0 coins

30 minutes on hold is a good day for NYSDOL calls. most days it's 2 hours and then a disconnect. glad there are workarounds now

0 coins

There's some confusion in this thread worth clearing up. 'Constructive discharge' as a legal term and NYSDOL's 'good cause' standard aren't identical - good cause is broader and doesn't require proving the employer intended to force you out. For hour reductions specifically, NY unemployment law generally looks at whether the change was substantial and whether the claimant acted reasonably. A reduction of 50% would almost certainly qualify as substantial. What they also look at: did you tell your employer the change was unacceptable before quitting, and did you give them a chance to fix it? If you just gave notice without raising the issue formally, that can complicate things even if the underlying situation was legitimate.

0 coins

Formally raised it with HR verbally twice, but nothing in writing. That's going to hurt me isn't it.

0 coins

Verbal complaints still count - NYSDOL just can't verify them without witnesses or documentation. If HR personnel were present during those conversations, make sure the names and approximate dates are on any questionnaire they send you. It's not fatal to your claim, it just means your word against your employer's on that point.

0 coins

i didn't know you had to give them a chance to fix it first. that feels like a trap. most people just quit when things get bad enough

0 coins

HR told me the same thing when I researched my own claim years ago and it felt backwards. But the logic is NYSDOL wants to know you couldn't fix the situation, not just that you chose not to try.

0 coins

My quit claim got approved last spring after about five weeks of adjudication. My situation was hostile work environment rather than hours but the process felt similar. The examiner actually called my former manager and when my manager said I'd quit voluntarily with no complaints, I had a moment of real panic. But I'd kept a journal of incidents with dates and my adjudication approval came through anyway. NYSDOL adjudicators apparently see a lot of employers downplaying problems and they factor that in.

0 coins

A journal with dates - wish I'd started doing that from the beginning. Good to know they factor in employer credibility though.

0 coins

Starting the documentation habit the moment problems begin is the biggest thing I'd tell anyone. Even texts to a friend describing what happened at work that day can serve as dated records later.

0 coins

the journal idea is smart. i used screenshots of my work schedule app showing the changes over time and that helped a lot in my case

0 coins

ok so i'm gonna be the voice of caution here because I've seen this go wrong. good cause exists but NYSDOL denies a LOT of quit claims even when the person had legitimate reasons. i had a friend who quit because her commute became impossible after they moved offices - 90 minutes each way turned into 3 hours - and her claim got denied because apparently commute issues aren't automatically good cause in NY unless certain conditions are met. if your claim gets denied in adjudication you do have appeal rights, 30 days from the determination date, but appeals take time too

0 coins

30 days from determination date to appeal, got it. What does the appeal process even look like? Is it a phone hearing?

0 coins

Appeals go to the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. Usually there's a hearing, yes - either by phone or sometimes in person. You can represent yourself but having documentation really matters at that stage. The standard gets a little stricter at appeal because now you're trying to overturn a determination.

0 coins

your friend's commute situation is insane to me. a 3 hour commute each way and that's not good cause?? what are they looking for then

0 coins

There are specific criteria for transportation-based good cause in NY, something about whether the new location was a unilateral employer decision vs something that changed in the commuter's life. The rules feel arbitrary from the outside but they do have internal logic apparently

0 coins

Something I didn't see mentioned - the weekly certification still matters even during a pending quit adjudication. Each week you certify, you have to answer job search activity questions. The standard requirement in NY is three job search activities per week. During adjudication some people think they don't need to certify because nothing is being paid anyway, but those weeks get wiped from your potential benefit period if you don't certify them. Keep doing it every single week even if the payments show $0.

0 coins

Already been certifying weekly, glad I didn't stop. Three activities per week is what I've been logging. Does the type of activity matter or is it just quantity?

0 coins

NYSDOL accepts various activity types - job applications submitted, employer contacts, resume submissions through job boards, attending career fairs, etc. Having a mix is probably better than just logging applications if they ever audit your log. Keep records of what you did, where, and when.

0 coins

i didn't certify for two weeks because i thought why bother since nothing was processing and yeah i lost those weeks. wish i had seen advice like this earlier

0 coins

My hours got cut by 60% last year and my employer told me to basically deal with it or leave. I left. My initial claim got denied because I apparently didn't document that I tried to resolve it, which was infuriating. But my appeal hearing went differently - I found old texts where I complained to my shift supervisor and screenshots of my schedule app. The appeal officer was willing to look at all of it and reversed the denial. So if adjudication goes badly, don't treat it as final. The appeal process is real and it works if you have anything to support your story.

0 coins

Appeal reversed the denial - that actually gives me some real hope. How long did the full appeal process take from filing to decision?

0 coins

My appeal decision came about nine weeks after I filed it. Meanwhile I kept certifying every week. When the reversal came through, all the weeks I'd certified during the appeal paid out at once which was a significant sum.

0 coins

nine weeks is a long time to be in limbo but getting that lump sum at the end must have been a relief at least

0 coins

The lump payout was helpful but nine weeks of financial stress wasn't something I'd want anyone to go through without at least knowing what to expect. Budget for the delay if you can.

0 coins

Spent about three months trying to sort out my own quit adjudication last year. At one point I needed to give additional information to the examiner and had no idea how to actually reach anyone. A friend mentioned Claimyr and I tried it - ended up speaking with an NYSDOL agent who told me exactly which form I needed to submit and confirmed it had been received. Saved me a lot of guessing about whether my paperwork was actually in their system.

0 coins

Three months - hope mine doesn't drag that long. Good to know Claimyr was useful for actually getting answers rather than just being on hold forever.

0 coins

My agent also told me the employer had contested my claim, which I had no idea about from just looking at my Unemployment Services account. That information changed what I prepared for the examiner review.

0 coins

employers contesting claims without telling you is so common and so frustrating. you're just supposed to guess that it's happening?

0 coins

For what it's worth my situation was similar to yours in terms of the NYSDOL decision-making. Employer changed my role substantially, not just hours but duties, and I argued that amounted to good cause. Adjudication approved me without an appeal, but the examiner's letter made clear the deciding factor was that I'd raised concerns before resigning. Even one documented complaint - an email to HR saying you're concerned about the changes - can be what tips the scales. For future reference if anyone's still in that job and considering leaving: send an email first.

0 coins

the 'send an email first' advice is the kind of thing that feels obvious after the fact but nobody actually thinks to do it in the middle of a stressful work situation

0 coins

Exactly. When you're just trying to survive a bad job situation you're not thinking about building an unemployment case. But a simple email saying 'I want to note that my hours have been reduced significantly, I'm concerned about this change and hope we can resolve it' takes three minutes and could be the difference between approval and denial.

0 coins

sending that email and bcc'ing yourself to a personal account is also smart so you have a copy they can't claim was never sent

0 coins

NYSDOL adjudication timelines have been all over the place from what I've seen on this forum. Some people are waiting 3 weeks, some are waiting 10+ weeks. Is there any pattern to what causes longer delays? Like does disputing employer-submitted info make it take longer?

0 coins

Employer disputes absolutely extend timelines. When a former employer contests a claim, the examiner has to do a more thorough review and sometimes arrange a fact-finding interview with both parties before deciding. That alone can add several weeks. Claims where the employer simply confirms the info submitted by the claimant tend to move faster.

0 coins

fact-finding interview wasn't something I knew about. is that just a phone call or do you have to go somewhere?

0 coins

Usually by phone. The examiner reaches out through your Unemployment Services account to schedule it. Miss that notification and you can lose your opportunity to present your side before the determination is made.

0 coins

Used Claimyr recently when I couldn't get through to NYSDOL for three days straight about a pending adjudication issue on a quit claim. Ended up on the phone with an agent who was actually knowledgeable and walked me through what documentation the examiner had flagged as missing. Without that call I would have submitted the wrong form and probably delayed my case further.

0 coins

Flagged documentation nobody tells you about through any other channel - that's the kind of information that makes a real difference. Good to know agents can actually see the case notes.

0 coins

My agent could see the specific examiner note about what was needed. The online account just said 'pending review' which told me nothing. The direct conversation was worth the effort.

0 coins

three days of busy signals then finally getting through and getting actual useful info is exactly the kind of thing that shouldn't require that much effort but here we are

0 coins

My sister went through a similar thing - quit because her pay was cut 30% unilaterally, used Claimyr to reach NYSDOL when her adjudication had been sitting for six weeks with no update, and the agent confirmed her determination letter was already in the mail. Got approved. The reduced pay situation was treated as good cause. Moral: a pay cut or hour reduction big enough that the employer is basically changing the job on you without your agreement is taken seriously by NYSDOL, it's not automatic denial just because you quit.

0 coins

30% pay cut approved, that's really helpful framing. Mine was closer to 50% hour reduction so hopefully that's even clearer cut.

0 coins

50% hour reduction is substantial by any measure. The question is just what documentation supports your account of when it started and by how much. Employer payroll records would actually show the hours and wages paid each week if it comes to an appeal - those records can be subpoenaed in an appeal hearing.

0 coins

can the claimant request those payroll records themselves or only through the appeal process?

0 coins

You can request your own employment records directly from your former employer - there are NY labor law protections around that. For unemployment purposes, the appeal board can compel the employer to submit payroll documentation as part of the evidence.

0 coins

NYSDOL phone situation in general is legitimately bad right now. I've been trying to reach them for a completely separate issue - not even a quit situation, just a regular weekly claim question - and I've had three disconnections after 45+ minutes on hold each time. Something is really wrong with their call volume management. Even people without complicated cases can't get through.

0 coins

Update: finally got through on attempt number six across four days. Agent was helpful once I reached one but the access is just broken. If there's any service or strategy that improves the odds of actually reaching a human I'd use it without hesitation.

0 coins

45 minutes then disconnect is standard NYSDOL experience at this point. i don't understand why they can't fix this, it's been years

0 coins

the 8am right when they open trick sometimes works. sometimes. less likely now than a year ago

0 coins

My personal experience with a quit claim adjudication was that NYSDOL asked me for a written explanation of the circumstances beyond what I put on the original form. They sent me a questionnaire through my Unemployment Services account messages - it had specific questions about the nature of the job change, when I first became aware of it, what steps I took to address it, and the date I resigned. Answering those questions thoroughly with as many specifics as possible felt like it made a difference. My claim was approved after about four weeks.

0 coins

Four weeks approved with that kind of questionnaire response - that's the most hopeful thing I've heard. I'll be watching my account messages extremely carefully now.

0 coins

The questionnaire came on week two of my adjudication. I had about a week to respond. Missing the deadline would have been bad so checking messages daily really is essential.

0 coins

I missed a questionnaire deadline once on a different claim and got denied. NYSDOL doesn't send reminders - you check or you miss it. Learned that the hard way.

0 coins

There's also the question of partial unemployment worth knowing about. If your hours had been cut but you hadn't quit yet - you might have been eligible for partial UI benefits during that period to supplement reduced income. That doesn't apply now that you've quit, but for anyone else reading who is currently in a situation of reduced hours but hasn't left yet: you can file for partial unemployment while still employed if you're working below your normal hours due to employer-caused reductions.

0 coins

partial unemployment while still employed?? i did not know this was a thing. my hours got cut last year and I just suffered through it

0 coins

It's one of the least-talked-about parts of NY unemployment. You have to meet the weekly earnings threshold rules and your employer technically knows you're filing, which is what stops a lot of people. But it exists.

0 coins

your employer knowing you're filing for partial UI is the part that would make most people not do it even if they qualify. that's a whole other kind of stress

0 coins

My claim took forever partly because I didn't understand that adjudication for quit cases is handled by a specific unit with its own queue - it's not just mixed in with regular claim processing. When I finally got an agent on the phone after many many tries, they explained that adjudication reviewers work their caseload in order received and there's no way to expedite short of an emergency hardship request. Even then those are granted rarely. The only real option is waiting it out while certifying every week.

0 coins

Emergency hardship request - didn't know that existed. My situation is pretty dire financially, would it even be worth trying?

0 coins

Worth asking an agent about it directly. The criteria are specific and not publicly posted anywhere I found. The agent I spoke with described it as situations like imminent eviction or utility shutoff with documentation. If you have something at that level, it's worth a request.

0 coins

the fact that this process exists but isn't listed anywhere is so NYSDOL. everything useful requires knowing to ask the right question to the right person

0 coins

Went through a quit adjudication about 18 months ago. My situation: left a job after a manager's behavior became genuinely hostile and was documented. The adjudicator requested a phone fact-finding call, I had my dates and incident documentation ready, and I was approved. The whole process from filing to approval was about five weeks. I know that feels like forever when you need money but the outcome was worth the wait. Keep your records organized and answer every communication from NYSDOL promptly.

0 coins

Five weeks from filing to approval with a fact-finding call in the middle - really useful to have an actual timeline with that level of detail.

0 coins

My fact-finding call lasted about 20 minutes. The examiner was professional and just asked me to describe the situation chronologically. Having written notes in front of me helped a lot since I could reference specific dates without blanking on them under pressure.

0 coins

having notes in front of you during the fact-finding call is a great tip. probably obvious but stress makes you forget everything

0 coins

Worth noting for the OP: once adjudication resolves in your favor, there's often a brief additional hold while the system activates payment. Don't expect money the same day you see an approval status. The first payment usually processes within a few business days after the determination. If your bank account information in your Unemployment Services profile isn't current, update it now - a payment going to a closed account creates another delay loop that requires another agent call to fix.

0 coins

Bank account info is current, good call to double check that though. Is the payment schedule then weekly after the first one clears, or does timing vary?

0 coins

Payments follow your certification schedule after the first one. If you certify on a Sunday for the prior week, payment typically processes within a couple of business days. The holiday schedule can shift this by a day occasionally.

0 coins

the closed account delay trap is real and painful. happened to someone I know and it was two additional weeks of waiting to get that straightened out

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure