Back to New York Unemployment

Avery Davis

How to fake unemployment job search activities on NYSDOL weekly claims?

Okay so I'm going to be honest here because I've seen people dance around this topic and I just want real answers. I got laid off from my warehouse job about six weeks ago and I've been collecting UI benefits while I look for work. The problem is my industry is really slow right now and there genuinely aren't that many positions open in my area. I've been applying to stuff but some weeks it's hard to find the required number of job search activities. So I've been wondering what people actually do when they can't meet the weekly job search requirements - like do you just list employers that you can't really verify? Can NYSDOL actually check whether you contacted someone? I'm scared of an overpayment notice or worse but I'm also scared of losing my benefits if I don't report enough activities. My weekly claims are due every Sunday and I'm just stressed about this every single week. Anyone dealt with this situation before?

My first week filing I had the exact same panic about not having enough contacts to report. What actually got me through it was realizing NYSDOL counts way more activities than most people think. Sending a LinkedIn message to a recruiter counts. Attending a virtual job fair counts. Registering with a staffing agency counts as one activity. Updating your resume on Indeed or through the NY Career Center portal counts too. You genuinely have more documented activities each week than you realize - you just have to log them properly in your Unemployment Services account.

0 coins

Your point about the NY Career Center is something I totally missed my first month. Does using their resume builder tool actually count as a separate activity from registering with them?

0 coins

Their resume workshop sessions definitely count as separate activities from just registering. Any time you attend something they offer, log it as a 'career center activity' in your weekly claim form.

0 coins

My case worker at the career center told me the same thing. They really want you using those resources and it's all legitimate stuff.

0 coins

Okay real talk though - NYSDOL does cross-reference employer information sometimes, especially if you get flagged for an audit. It's not like they check every single claim but if your claim goes into adjudication for any reason, they can pull your job search log and actually verify contacts. I work in HR and we occasionally get inquiry letters from NYSDOL asking us to confirm whether someone applied. Putting fake employer names or fake contact info is fraud and the consequences are brutal - repayment of all benefits plus fines plus potential criminal charges. I know it feels like a system that doesn't care about you but this particular shortcut is genuinely not worth it.

0 coins

Wait, your HR department actually gets letters from NYSDOL asking about applicants? How often does that happen and what triggers it?

0 coins

Honestly it's not super frequent but it does happen. Usually when someone files an appeal or when their former employer contests the claim, that can open everything up to scrutiny including job search records. Random audits happen too - probably a small percentage of claims but it's real.

0 coins

This scared me straight honestly. I had been kind of vague about some of my contacts and after reading this I went back and made sure everything was accurate.

0 coins

The fraud penalties really are no joke. My neighbor had an overpayment case that started from a discrepancy in their job search log and they ended up owing back like $4,200 plus a disqualification period.

0 coins

Before I found legitimate ways to meet my job search numbers, I was spending hours trying to reach NYSDOL to ask what actually counts as a valid activity. Their phone lines were impossible - I'd dial in, sit there for two hours, and get dropped before reaching anyone. A coworker told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up talking to a live agent instead of being stuck in the queue forever. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. The agent I spoke with walked me through every type of activity that qualifies and it completely changed how I approach my weekly claims - all legitimate stuff I was already doing but not logging correctly.

0 coins

Your coworker suggesting that actually helped you get through? I've tried calling probably eight times over the past month and either get the busy signal or just sit on hold until the line drops.

0 coins

My first real conversation with an NYSDOL agent happened because of it. The agent was actually helpful - told me about activities I didn't know counted, like contacting a union hall about membership openings.

0 coins

Two hours on hold and then dropped is basically my weekly routine at this point. Might have to look into this.

0 coins

My experience trying to reach NYSDOL by phone was so demoralizing I basically stopped trying. Good to know there's an option that actually works.

0 coins

The standby status option is something a lot of people in seasonal or slow industries don't know about. If you're attached to a specific employer who's planning to bring you back, you might qualify for standby and your job search requirements get waived entirely during that period. You'd need your former employer to certify that you have a definite return date within 8 weeks. It doesn't sound like your situation from what you wrote but worth mentioning for anyone reading this.

0 coins

Your mention of standby - does that apply even if the employer hasn't officially said there's a return date, just that it's 'likely'?

0 coins

No, it needs to be a definite recall date, not just a maybe. If it's uncertain, you'd still have to do the regular job search activities. The employer actually has to file paperwork confirming the recall.

0 coins

Mine was a full layoff with no recall so standby wouldn't apply, but this is good info for other people in this thread.

0 coins

The union hall contact thing genuinely surprised me when I found out it counts. My whole career has been in trades and I always thought the job search requirement meant submitting resumes to companies directly. Turns out contacting your union about work referrals, checking the dispatch board, even attending a union meeting where job leads are discussed - all of that can count. The key is documenting the date, the name of who you contacted or what you attended, and the outcome or response. NYSDOL wants to see that you're making genuine efforts, and for trades workers that looks different than it does for office workers.

0 coins

Your trades example is exactly what I needed to see. I'm in construction and I've been forcing myself to apply to random office jobs just to hit my numbers when my actual job search is happening through the union.

0 coins

Yeah don't do that - the activities should actually reflect your genuine job search in your field. Random applications to jobs you're unqualified for or not pursuing seriously could actually raise flags if reviewed.

0 coins

My dad is a union electrician and he had no idea his dispatch hall contacts counted. He was applying for random retail jobs he had no intention of taking just to meet the requirement.

0 coins

What field are you in if you don't mind sharing? Because the advice changes a lot depending on the industry. Someone in tech has a million ways to document legitimate activities. Someone in manufacturing or skilled trades or the arts - those job searches genuinely look different and NYSDOL's requirements are supposed to accommodate that. The online application model of job searching isn't the only valid one.

0 coins

Warehouse and logistics is my background. There are job boards but it's a lot of the same 20 openings cycling through, and I've already applied to most of them in my area.

0 coins

Warehousing actually has a decent amount of qualifying activities beyond the boards - staffing agencies that specialize in logistics, contacting distribution centers directly even without an open posting, attending local job fairs. The Indeed.com warehouse filter plus local temp agencies alone should give you plenty.

0 coins

My brother is in logistics and his case manager at the career center helped him build an entire tracking spreadsheet for activities he was already doing but not counting.

0 coins

The NY Career Centers really are underutilized for exactly this kind of situation. They offer free services including resume review, job coaching, workshops, and direct connections to employers. Each of those is a documentable job search activity. I went through a period where I was struggling to find enough contacts to report and my career center case manager basically showed me I was doing plenty - I just wasn't tracking it correctly or thinking broadly enough about what counted.

0 coins

Your career center experience - did you have to make an appointment or can you walk in?

0 coins

Appointments are strongly recommended and you can book through the NYSDOL website. Some centers do have drop-in hours but they vary by location. The online portal also has virtual workshop options now which is great if getting there in person is tough.

0 coins

My career center was actually booked out like two weeks when I first tried. Worth calling ahead and also getting on the cancellation list.

0 coins

There's one not too far from me I've been meaning to check out. This thread is pushing me to actually go do it.

0 coins

NYSDOL audits are real and I've personally been through one. They audited my claim about four months in and asked me to submit documentation of my job search activities for three specific weeks. I had kept decent records and was fine but it was stressful. The audit came completely out of nowhere - no warning, just a letter saying to submit my job search log within 10 days. If I had been padding my activities I would have been in serious trouble.

0 coins

How did they contact you about the audit - through your Unemployment Services online account or by physical mail?

0 coins

Physical mail to my address on file. The letter had a deadline and a fax number to submit documentation. I also uploaded to my online account just to be safe and noted that I did both.

0 coins

My understanding is they want actual proof - emails from employers, rejection letters, notes with dates and contact names. Screenshots of Indeed applications with confirmation numbers are also good.

0 coins

This is making me start keeping way better records going forward. I've been kind of casual about it.

0 coins

My sister went through something kind of related - she was struggling to meet job search requirements during a slow period and her NYSDOL claim actually went into adjudication because of an inconsistency in what she reported. The adjudication process took about five weeks and her payments were held the whole time. Even after everything got cleared up she had to repay nothing but the stress and the financial hit from delayed payments was really hard. The legitimate path is always the better option even when it's annoying.

0 coins

Your sister's adjudication - did it get triggered by something specific she did wrong or was it random?

0 coins

She listed a contact that she said she reached out to but couldn't document, and when NYSDOL apparently verified they said no application was received. It flagged something and her whole claim went under review.

0 coins

Five weeks with payments held would be devastating. That's the kind of thing that makes it very clear why doing this by the book matters.

0 coins

There's a broader thing worth saying about how the job search requirement actually works in practice. NYSDOL isn't expecting you to find a job every week, obviously. They're expecting documented proof that you're actively trying. Three activities per week sounds like a lot but once you count staffing agency contacts, LinkedIn outreach to recruiters, attending virtual career events, following up on previous applications with a phone inquiry, and reaching out to professional contacts - most people doing any kind of real job search are hitting three without much effort. The documentation is what trips people up, not actually finding the activities.

0 coins

My problem was always the documentation part. What counts as enough documentation if you apply online through Indeed?

0 coins

A screenshot showing the application confirmation or the job listing you applied to with the date visible is solid. Some people keep a simple spreadsheet with date, employer, position, method, and outcome. That's all you need.

0 coins

My case manager actually gave me a template spreadsheet on my first visit to the career center. It had all the right columns already set up.

0 coins

Honestly this whole thread has changed my perspective. I was thinking about how to fake things when really I was just failing to document the real things I was actually doing.

0 coins

My situation earlier this year was stuck - my claim had a complication and I needed to actually speak to someone at NYSDOL to sort it out. Regular calling got me nowhere for three weeks straight, just busy signals and dropped lines. A friend suggested Claimyr and I ended up speaking to an actual NYSDOL agent who helped me through the problem in one conversation. For anything that needs a real human answer, having that option makes a huge difference.

0 coins

Your claim complication that needed a live agent - was it something they could fix on the spot over the phone or did they have to refer it somewhere?

0 coins

The agent was able to note the issue and escalate it internally right on that call. Within a few days my account showed the correction and payments resumed normally.

0 coins

Three weeks of busy signals and drops sounds exactly like what I've been dealing with. The phone system is completely broken.

0 coins

My experience with their phone line has been the same - it's not just you, it's genuinely this bad for everyone right now.

0 coins

Part of what makes people think about this stuff is that NYSDOL's explanations of what counts are buried in their website and not super clear when you first file. The welcome email they send when you open a claim has a link to a job search requirements FAQ but honestly it doesn't cover a lot of the edge cases like union halls, networking contacts, or attendance at career events. The career center staff know all of this by heart though - that's the resource people should actually be using.

0 coins

My welcome packet from NYSDOL was confusing enough that I genuinely wasn't sure what counted for the first three weeks. I was doing way more than I needed to and stressed anyway.

0 coins

Their documentation could be so much clearer. The online portal has a dropdown of activity types when you're entering your weekly claim but most people just pick 'applied for job' for everything when they could be selecting options that better match what they did.

0 coins

The dropdown options are actually useful once you know to look at all of them. 'Employment agency contact,' 'union hall contact,' 'career fair attendance' - they're all there, most people just don't scroll down.

0 coins

Attending virtual job fairs is probably the most underused legitimate activity I've found. Indeed, LinkedIn, local chambers of commerce - they all run them regularly and many are free. Registering for and attending one is a legitimate documented activity, and you usually get confirmation emails that serve as your proof. During a week when real applications are hard to come by, one job fair can count as one of your three activities.

0 coins

Are virtual job fairs something you need to register for in advance or can you just show up day-of?

0 coins

Most require registration in advance and that registration email is actually useful to have as documentation. The confirmation email shows date, event name, and your attendance registration - exactly what you need for your log.

0 coins

LinkedIn regularly posts virtual career events and many are industry-specific. For logistics and warehouse work there are supply chain career fairs that run pretty regularly.

0 coins

NYSDOL's phone situation right now is genuinely terrible and it's making everything harder than it needs to be. My claim has had the same question mark on it for two weeks - something about my employer separation that I need to explain - and I cannot get anyone on the line to even ask about it. The online message system shows my inquiry as received but no response. Meanwhile my payments are kind of in limbo.

0 coins

Your employer separation thing - is it showing as 'adjudication in progress' on your account or just a note with no status change?

0 coins

My account shows a pending adjudication status but no explanation of what specifically triggered it. I've uploaded my separation paperwork already but nothing has changed.

0 coins

Adjudication with no explanation is so stressful. Mine lasted about three weeks before anything updated and I could never reach anyone during that time.

0 coins

My adjudication situation earlier this year was resolved faster once I actually got to speak with an agent. Claimyr is what finally got me there - I'd been trying on my own for weeks. When I finally had an agent on the line she was able to see exactly what documentation was needed and told me what to upload to clear the hold. Same day upload and within a few days the adjudication resolved. For complicated stuff like separation disputes or job search audits, talking to an actual person makes everything clearer.

0 coins

Your upload fixing it same day - did the agent actually stay on the line with you while you uploaded or just tell you what to send and end the call?

0 coins

She stayed on the call while I went into my Unemployment Services account and started the upload process, confirmed she could see the documents coming in on her end, and then told me what the next steps would look like. It was a much more productive conversation than I expected.

0 coins

Having an agent confirm they can see your uploads in real time sounds incredibly reassuring compared to just submitting into the void and hoping.

0 coins

My uploads have always felt like sending things into a black hole. Never any confirmation that anyone saw them.

0 coins

The honest answer to the original question is that you probably don't need to fake anything - most people actually undercount their activities. Calling a company to ask if they're hiring even when no position is posted counts. Reaching out to a former colleague to ask about openings at their company counts. Sending a message to a LinkedIn recruiter counts. Following up with an employer you already applied to counts as a new activity. People think 'job search activity' means submitting a formal application and nothing else, but it's way broader than that.

0 coins

Following up on a previous application counting as a new activity is something I genuinely didn't know. That changes things for weeks when openings are slow.

0 coins

Yes - each follow-up on a prior application is a separate dated activity as long as you log it with the date, the employer, the position, and what you did (emailed, called, LinkedIn message, etc.

0 coins

My NYSDOL agent confirmed this exact point when I had a similar question. Each distinct contact or action is its own activity even if it's with the same employer.

0 coins

Honestly the whole job search requirement system makes more sense once you understand the NYSDOL is trying to verify effort, not results. They're not expecting you to get job offers - they're expecting to see that you're actively trying. The documentation standard is pretty reasonable once you know what it is. And the career centers exist specifically to help people in slow industries or fields where traditional applications don't cover the whole job search process.

0 coins

My mindset shift happened exactly the way you're describing. Once I stopped thinking about it as a quota to hit and started thinking about it as documenting what I was already doing, it got way less stressful.

0 coins

The quota mindset trips a lot of people up. Three activities sounds arbitrary until you realize most job searches involve way more than three touchpoints per week without even trying.

0 coins

Effort documentation vs. results requirement is a really useful frame. I'm going to remember that explanation.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure