How to end unemployment benefits with NYSDOL - what do I actually do?
My situation changed and I need to figure out how to end unemployment benefits before I accidentally get paid for a week I wasn't supposed to claim. I started a new full-time job this Monday and I'm not sure if I just stop certifying for weekly claims or if there's something formal I have to do through Unemployment Services to close things out. I don't want to end up with an overpayment notice six months from now because I didn't handle the closing process correctly. I've been on regular UI for about 10 weeks after getting laid off from my last position in logistics, and everything has been fine up to this point. Do I just not file my next weekly claim and that's it? Or does NYSDOL require me to actively cancel or notify them somehow?
62 comments

Andre Laurent
Your weekly claim is really the main switch here - if you stop certifying, your benefit payments stop. NYSDOL doesn't require a formal "close my case" request the way some people think. What you actually need to do is make sure your LAST weekly claim is filed for the final week before you started working. So if your job started Monday of this week, your last certifiable week would be the one that ended the Sunday before. When you file that final weekly claim, report any earnings you got that last week honestly - even a partial week of work at the new job might reduce your benefit for that period but you still need to report it. After that, just don't file another weekly claim and your claim goes dormant. If your new job doesn't work out within a year, your claim stays open and you can usually reopen it.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorThe partial week thing - does that mean I report the hours or the dollar amount of what I earned? My first paycheck won't come for two weeks so I won't know the exact gross amount yet.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Earnings from that week still get reported by dollar amount earned, not by when the paycheck arrives. NYSDOL goes by when you performed the work, not when the deposit hits. Estimate it based on your hourly rate times hours worked if you have to, and if it's slightly off, it generally doesn't cause major issues - but do your best to be accurate.
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
My claim went dormant after I stopped filing and when I needed to reopen it 8 months later it was pretty painless, so this tracks with what I experienced.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
Spent three weeks trying to get a straight answer from NYSDOL about almost this exact question - my last week of benefits overlapped with my start date and I couldn't figure out how to handle the partial week earnings properly. Calling their line was an exercise in frustration, hold times of 2+ hours and then the line would just drop. Eventually tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without sitting there yourself for hours. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. The agent I reached confirmed everything the previous poster said - report the earnings for whatever days you actually worked that last partial week and then simply stop filing. No formal closure needed.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorTwo hours of hold time and then the line drops? That's exactly what I was afraid of. Good to know there's an option that takes that pain away.
0 coins
Mei Wong
The hold time situation at NYSDOL is genuinely brutal. I've had the line drop on me after 90 minutes more than once. Getting an agent on the phone without doing all that waiting yourself is the smart move.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Partial week earnings tripped me up too. Reported the wrong pay period and got a small overpayment flag - wasn't catastrophic but required a whole mess of calls to sort out. Worth getting it right the first time.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
Worth pointing out what your Unemployment Services portal actually shows during this period: even after you stop filing weekly claims, your claim status page won't necessarily say 'closed.' It may just show no pending certification. That's normal. NYSDOL doesn't send you a closure letter or anything official. The portal just goes quiet. Some people panic when they see their claim status still shows as 'active' months later - that's by design, keeps the claim available to reopen if necessary.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
My portal showed 'active' for literally 11 months after I stopped claiming and I nearly had a heart attack thinking I had to do something. Nobody had told me it stays open like that.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorActive status staying on the portal even after I stop filing - does that mean I could accidentally start receiving payments again if I hit a wrong button somewhere?
0 coins
PixelWarrior
Accidentally triggering a new claim would require you to actively go through the weekly certification flow and answer all the questions - it's not something that happens on its own. You'd have to deliberately submit a new weekly claim for payments to resume. The portal sitting there showing 'active' won't generate any benefits on its own.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
NYSDOL's system is confusing in exactly this way. My sister-in-law thought her claim had auto-closed and then had no idea she could reopen it when she lost her second job. The fact that it stays 'active' is actually useful, people just don't know about it.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
The earnings reporting part is where people mess themselves up. You HAVE to report the gross wages for every week you file, even partial weeks, even if the check hasn't come yet. NYSDOL cross-checks with employer wage records and if what you reported doesn't match what your employer submitted to the state, that's how overpayments get generated. It happened to my coworker - he thought he didn't have to report his first partial week because he got paid for it two weeks later. Got hit with an overpayment notice for that week about four months down the line.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Four months later and out of nowhere! That's a nightmare scenario. I reported my partial week earnings but I guessed a little because I didn't have my pay stub yet - should I be worried?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
A small discrepancy from estimating usually doesn't trigger an automatic overpayment - NYSDOL tends to flag larger gaps. If you're off by a few dollars because you estimated, that's very different from someone who reported zero earnings for a week they clearly worked. Keep your records just in case.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Employer wage reporting to the state happens quarterly I believe, so there's often a lag before NYSDOL even has the data to compare. That delay is why overpayment notices seem to come out of nowhere months later.
0 coins
StormChaser
My experience ending my claim last spring: filed my final weekly certification for the last week I was fully unemployed, answered the questions honestly about starting work, and that was genuinely it. Never filed again, never sent a letter, never called. Roughly six months later I got a small notice about my claim's benefit year ending - completely routine, no action needed. The process of stopping is way less bureaucratic than starting was.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorHonestly that's reassuring to hear. I built this up in my head as something complicated and it sounds like stopping is actually the low-drama part.
0 coins
StormChaser
Agreed - the headache is getting approved, maintaining job search requirements every week, and dealing with any adjudication issues. Stopping is just... stopping.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
This matches my experience too. After all the stress of filing each week I expected some complicated exit process and there wasn't one.
0 coins
Ava Williams
WAIT does stopping your weekly claims affect your job search log requirements?? I've been keeping track of my 3 job contacts a week and I'm starting a new position next month. Am I supposed to keep submitting those until my last filing or what
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Your job search activities only matter for the weeks you're actively certifying for benefits. The minute you stop filing weekly claims, you're not required to track job contacts anymore. Keep records for any weeks you did file, since NYSDOL can audit those, but once you're employed and not certifying, the job search requirement is behind you.
0 coins
Ava Williams
ok phew I was worried I had to keep logging job contacts for weeks after I started working just to close things out properly. That would be annoying
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
The job search log requirement trips a lot of people up in both directions - some don't take it seriously enough while claiming, and some don't realize it ends when the filing ends.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Heads up on the benefit year thing since it came up earlier: your claim has an expiration date about a year from when you first filed, called the benefit year end date. If you stop claiming, restart claiming, whatever - that benefit year end date doesn't change. If you have weeks of benefits remaining but your benefit year expires, those unused weeks generally don't roll over. So if you're close to your benefit year end and thinking of leaving some weeks unused because you got a job, that's fine - it just means those weeks expire unused, which is a normal and totally acceptable outcome.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorMy benefit year - is that something I can look up in my Unemployment Services account or do I need to contact NYSDOL for that date?
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Your Unemployment Services account shows it - when you log in and check your claim details it should list something like a benefit year beginning and end date. Mine was listed right on my claim summary page.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Mine showed it too, though the page layout has changed a few times and I had to click around a bit to find the exact date. It's in there somewhere under claim details.
0 coins
Mei Wong
Unused weeks expiring at benefit year end is one of those things that feels unfair when you first hear it, but it makes sense - you got a job, the weeks served their purpose. Only a problem if you expected to bank them for future use.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Went through this process last fall and had a weird situation - my new employer was actually the same company that laid me off and then rehired me. I wasn't sure if NYSDOL needed to know that specifically or if it was just standard 'returning to work' on the certification. Couldn't get anyone on the phone - tried calling multiple mornings and once spent 90 minutes on hold before the line disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr and I finally got to speak with an actual NYSDOL agent. She confirmed I just needed to report the return to work normally, the specifics of it being the same employer weren't a separate reporting requirement for weekly claims.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Author90 minutes and then the line just drops - that's infuriating. Good outcome though, glad you got an answer.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
The same employer rehire situation would have confused me too. It seems straightforward but those edge cases are exactly when you want to hear it from an actual person at NYSDOL rather than guess.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
For the record on what you say when you certify that final week - most of the weekly claim questions are pretty intuitive but the 'did you work this week' question matters. If your job started Monday and your certification week runs Sunday to Saturday, and your first day was that Monday, you answer yes to working, report the earnings for those days, and that's accurate. The system then calculates a reduced benefit for that week if applicable or nothing at all if you earned too much. Either way you've reported truthfully and you're done.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorThe reduced benefit calculation for that final partial week - is it possible I'd actually get a small payment for that week even though I started working? Or does any employment automatically zero out the benefit?
0 coins
LunarEclipse
NYSDOL has a partial earnings formula - roughly speaking, you can earn up to a certain threshold before benefits drop to zero. If you only worked two or three days at a new job and your earnings were below that threshold for the week, you might still get a partial benefit for that week. It depends on your weekly benefit amount and what you earned.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
The partial benefit formula is something a lot of people don't realize exists. Many people assume any work = no benefit for that week and that's not always true.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Wait so i could have gotten a partial payment for my first week at my new job and I just didn't file?? Too late now probably but good to know for the future
0 coins
Yara Khalil
My weekly certification had a glitch the week I returned to work - the system showed an error when I tried to report my earnings and I couldn't complete the certification at all. Spent days trying to figure out if I should just not file or if the incomplete certification would cause a problem down the line. Claimyr got me to an agent who sorted it out - turns out there was a known system bug affecting a batch of claims that week and they processed my final certification manually on the backend. If I'd just abandoned the incomplete filing without speaking to someone I might have ended up with a weird overpayment or fraud flag.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorA system bug that processes incorrectly and could trigger a fraud flag - that's genuinely scary. Glad you got that cleared before it turned into a problem.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
Technical glitches in Unemployment Services are more common than NYSDOL admits. If something looks wrong during certification, don't just walk away and assume it resolved itself. Document what happened and follow up.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
The manual backend processing thing is real - agents have more tools to fix weird edge cases than the online portal lets you do yourself. Getting a human involved for unusual situations is usually the right call.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
This is a good reminder that 'just stop filing' works smoothly for most people but if the system throws an error at you during that final week, treat it seriously and get it resolved properly.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
My job returned me to full-time hours after a temporary reduction - different from a new hire situation but I still had to handle the transition out of UI carefully. Used Claimyr to reach NYSDOL when I had questions about how to close out the partial week where my hours went back up. The agent explained exactly which week I needed to report the restored hours and confirmed my claim would just go dormant after that filing. No other steps required on my end.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
Hours restoration after a reduction is a scenario that isn't covered clearly anywhere on NYSDOL's website. Getting that confirmed by an actual agent rather than guessing is exactly the right approach.
0 coins
Ava Williams
i didn't know you could file for unemployment when your hours got cut, only knew about full layoffs. learning a lot from this thread
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
The 1099 situation is worth flagging for anyone self-employed or doing gig work on the side during their unemployment period: if you had any self-employment income during your claim weeks, make sure those earnings were reported properly before you stop filing. NYSDOL matches self-employment income through tax records eventually and an unreported gig payment from month 2 of your claim can show up as an overpayment long after you've moved on and forgotten about it.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Tax record matching for self-employment income is exactly how a lot of people get surprised overpayment notices a year later. It's not because NYSDOL is watching you in real time - it's the annual wage reconciliation.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
I did some freelance graphic design work during my claim and reported the payments as earnings on those weeks. Good to know that was the right move and the records should match.
0 coins
Mei Wong
Gig and freelance reporting is genuinely confusing because those payments often come weeks after the work. The rule is report when you performed the work, same as regular wages.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Two things that catch people off guard when they're wrapping up a claim: first, if NYSDOL sends you any notices or letters after you've stopped filing, still read them. Even after a claim goes dormant you can receive things like monetary redetermination notices or audit requests. Second, hold onto your records - job search logs, pay stubs, anything related to your claim period - for at least two years. NYSDOL can audit claims and issue overpayment notices well after a benefit year closes.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorTwo years of recordkeeping - is that something NYSDOL states explicitly somewhere or more of a best practice people have figured out through experience?
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
More practical guidance from people who've been through audits than an explicit NYSDOL policy statement. The formal statute of limitations for overpayment recovery is longer, but practically speaking, most audit activity happens within that two-year window. Keeping records doesn't cost much and protects you.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Physical or digital copies of your weekly certification confirmations are especially worth keeping. If there's ever a dispute about a week you certified, having the confirmation number or screenshot is very useful.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
My certification for my final week got delayed because I forgot the system has a window - you can file for a week only during a specific period after that week ends. If you miss that window you generally can't go back and certify for it. So if your job starts and you get busy and forget to file your last legitimate week, you may lose those benefits permanently. File on time for that last week even though it's your final one.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorThe certification window closing permanently if you miss it - that's the kind of detail I would absolutely have let slip by being distracted with starting a new job.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The transition back to work is hectic and the weekly filing is easy to forget when you're suddenly busy again. Set a reminder for your final week the same as you would have normally.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Usually the certification window for a given week is available for about two weeks after that week ends, give or take. NYSDOL can sometimes process late certifications in limited circumstances but it's not guaranteed. File on time.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Putting all of this together for anyone who finds this thread later: stop certifying after your last eligible week, report earnings honestly for any partial week you worked, keep your records for a couple years, watch your Unemployment Services account for any notices even after you stop filing, and your claim stays in dormant-but-open status for the rest of your benefit year automatically. No formal closure form, no goodbye phone call required. That's genuinely it for most standard situations.
0 coins
MidnightRider
AuthorThis summary is exactly what I needed. Clear, complete, and nothing scary. Really appreciate everyone who weighed in here.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
Bookmarked this for whenever I end up needing it again. The lack of a formal closure process is weirdly the most confusing part because it feels like there should be one.
0 coins
StormChaser
Agreed on the summary. The fear that you have to do something formal to 'end' your claim is very common and very understandable but just not how NYSDOL's system works.
0 coins