How long after NY unemployment hearing will judge send decision?
I had my hearing with a judge last Friday for my NY unemployment appeal. I was let go back in August and my employer claimed misconduct, which I totally disagree with. I had pretty solid evidence showing I was following company guidelines and had positive performance reviews right up until they restructured my department. The hearing lasted about 45 minutes and I thought it went well, but now I'm just anxiously waiting. Has anyone gone through this process recently? How long should I expect to wait before getting the judge's decision? I'm down to my last few hundred dollars and really need this resolved soon.
32 comments
Sofia Rodriguez
I had my hearing in december and got my decision in the mail 3 weeks later. The judge ruled in my favor thankfully. Make sure ur checking ur mail everyday cuz they only send paper notices for this stuff. I think they say it can take up to 6 weeks but mine came faster. Good luck!
0 coins
NightOwl42
Thanks for the info! Did they also send you any kind of email notification or was it just the mail?
0 coins
1M
Sofia Rodriguez
Just mail. Kinda annoying they dont use email for something so important but thats ny unemployment for ya 🙄
0 coins
28d
Dmitry Ivanov
Mine took exactly 4 weeks to arrive. No email, just snail mail like we're living in 1995 or something.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Ava Thompson
After getting nowhere with the unemployment office for weeks, I tried this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) and they got me connected with a live rep who helped me track down my appeal status. Turns out my decision had actually been made but never mailed to me correctly. Talking to an agent got my $ unlocked so fast. They also have this helpful video if you want more info: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
wait hold up - does this actually work or is it just the usual BS? I've called like 50 times and can't get through to anyone.
0 coins
1M
Ava Thompson
It definitely works! I was super skeptical too but I was desperate. They basically call repeatedly for you and then connect you when they get a human. Saved me literally days of being on hold.
0 coins
27d
Zainab Ali
hmm I've been burned by so many of these 'services' before... what makes this different? 🤔
0 coins
26d
Ava Thompson
The difference is it actually connected me to a real person at unemployment. I was able to get my appeal status and fix the issue with my address that was causing the delay. Was totally worth it for me.
0 coins
25d
Connor Murphy
another day, another company promising to fix the unfixable unemployment system lol
0 coins
25d
Ava Thompson
Listen I get the skepticism. I felt the same way. But after 3 weeks of trying to call myself with no luck, this actually worked. Just sharing what helped me 🤷♀️
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Yara Nassar
From my experience and what ive heard from others, 3-6 weeks is typical. My friend just went thru this in october and it took about a month. But the system is so backed up right now who knows
0 coins
Write a comment...
StarGazer101
my desision took 8 weeks to come (this was in feb/march) and i had to call multiple times to follow up. The judges are WAY behind schedule because of all the appeals. if u need $$ fast u should look into emergency assistance programs while u wait.
0 coins
NightOwl42
Thanks for being honest. 8 weeks sounds brutal. Did you end up winning your appeal at least?
0 coins
28d
StarGazer101
yep i won. the wait was worth it but it was stressful af. ended up having to borrow money from family which sucked.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Keisha Jackson
It really depends on how complex your case is and how busy your particular judge is. Some areas of NY have fewer judges handling more cases. I've seen people get decisions in 2 weeks and others wait 2+ months. The law says they're supposed to issue a decision within 30 days, but that's more of a guideline than a rule they actually follow 😒
0 coins
Paolo Romano
Yup, the "30 day rule" is a complete joke. I waited 74 days for mine last year. The system is completely broken.
0 coins
25d
Amina Diop
My friend got hers in 10 days! But I think thats super rare. Probably depends on the judge.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Oliver Schmidt
Here's what I learned from my own unemployment appeal process (which took forever): First, the timeframe varies wildly. In theory, ALJs are supposed to issue decisions within 30 days of the hearing, but with the current backlog, 4-8 weeks is more realistic. My decision took 5 weeks. Second, calling regularly helps. The regular phone lines are useless, but I had success using claimyr.com to get through to a live agent who could check on my status. Without that I'd probably still be waiting. Third, check your mail EVERY day. They only send paper notices for appeal decisions. Fourth, if it's been more than 6 weeks, contact your state representative's office. They can sometimes light a fire under the department. Fifth, prepare for either outcome. If you win, it could still take 1-2 weeks for payments to start. If you lose, you'll have 20 days to appeal to the next level. The whole system is frustrating, but hang in there! And definitely try to get to a live agent to check on your status - it made all the difference for me.
0 coins
NightOwl42
This is incredibly helpful, thank you for taking the time to write all this out. I'll definitely check out that service if I don't hear anything in the next couple weeks.
0 coins
25d
Natasha Volkov
I second contacting your state rep if it drags on! My rep's office got my decision unstuck after 7 weeks of nothing.
0 coins
25d
Javier Torres
Did the claimyr thing actually work? Seems sketchy.
0 coins
25d
Oliver Schmidt
Yeah, it worked for me. I was skeptical too but I was desperate after weeks of trying to call myself. It basically just keeps calling for you until it gets through, then connects you to the agent. Saved me hours of hold time.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Emma Wilson
Don't hold your breath. I'm still waiting on mine from NOVEMBER 😡 The whole ny unemployment system is a complete joke
0 coins
NightOwl42
November?? That's insane! Have you tried contacting them about it?
0 coins
25d
Emma Wilson
I've called at least 20 times. Either can't get through or get someone who has no idea and just tells me to "keep waiting" 🤬
0 coins
25d
QuantumLeap
You need to contact your state assembly person. That's way too long to wait.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Malik Johnson
One thing nobody has mentioned - check your online account too. Sometimes the decision appears there before you get the mail.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Isabella Santos
The wait is different for everyone tbh. Mine took 37 days exactly (yes i counted every single day lol). The judge ruled that my company was wrong to deny me benefits. Waiting was the worst part but it was worth it in the end when i got that backpay. hope u get good news soon!
0 coins
NightOwl42
37 days sounds rough but at least you won! Did you get paid pretty quickly after the decision?
0 coins
25d
Isabella Santos
Got my first payment 5 days after the decision letter and backpay hit about a week after that. Once they decide in your favor things move pretty fast.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Ravi Sharma
I won my appeal in september, it took exactly 4 weeks and 3 days to get the decision in the mail. Be prepared to wait but also dont lose hope! From what i've seen, judges tend to side with the workers more often than employers in these cases. The system is defiantly designed to be frustrating but hang in there
0 coins
Write a comment...