Getting unemployment after being fired - what NYSDOL actually looks at
So I got let go from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and I'm honestly not sure where I stand with my claim. My employer told HR it was due to 'performance issues' but the situation is way more complicated than that — I had a documented medical thing going on that was affecting my output, and my supervisor never gave me any formal written warning before they pulled the plug. I filed my UI claim through the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal the day after it happened and it's been showing 'pending' ever since. The separation reason on my employer's side might be getting flagged because I didn't resign — they terminated me. I know getting unemployment after being fired isn't automatic in New York, but I also read that you can still qualify if the firing wasn't for 'misconduct' under NYSDOL's definition. My question is basically: how do NYSDOL determine whether what happened to me counts as misconduct, and is there anything I should be doing right now while I wait for the adjudication to wrap up? I've been certifying my weekly claims every week and logging my job search activities, but I don't know if I should be reaching out to anyone or gathering documentation. Any guidance from people who've been through this would be really helpful.
72 comments

Mia Roberts
Two weeks into my own adjudication right now after getting terminated from a retail job, so I feel this post in my bones. The thing that tripped me up at first was not understanding that 'misconduct' under NYSDOL's rules isn't just 'your boss didn't like you.' They draw a line between poor performance — which can get you approved — and deliberate rule-breaking or gross negligence, which can get you denied. Performance issues tied to something medical almost always land on the 'not misconduct' side of that line, especially if you have any documentation from a doctor or HR showing the situation. Keep certifying every week regardless of where your adjudication stands, because those weeks are being tracked and you'll get paid retroactively once a decision comes through.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThe retroactive payment thing is actually really reassuring to hear, I had no idea that's how it worked. Do you know if NYSDOL will reach out to me directly when the adjudication decision is made, or do I just have to keep checking my account?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
They post the decision in your Unemployment Services account and also mail a letter. I'd check the account first because the letter can lag by a few days. If a fact-finding interview gets scheduled, you'll see that in the account too — that's usually the step before a final decision when there's any dispute about why you were let go.
0 coins
The Boss
My claim sat in adjudication for almost five weeks before I got desperate enough to actually talk to someone at NYSDOL. Phone lines were a nightmare — I tried eight or nine mornings in a row and kept hitting the busy signal or getting dropped after a 45-minute hold. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. I finally got to explain the full story of my termination to an actual human, and the agent flagged something in my file that had been holding things up. Got a decision letter within a week of that call.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorFive weeks is a long time — I'm only at two right now but good to know there are options when it drags on that long. I'll bookmark that for later if things stall out.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
I had a similar experience with the phone situation. Those hold times are genuinely brutal, especially when you're anxious about your claim status and every day feels like it costs you money.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
Does it work for all kinds of adjudication holds or just termination cases? Asking because mine is a voluntary quit situation that got complicated.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Former HR coordinator here, now on the other side of things unfortunately. The key thing NYSDOL looks at in a termination case is whether the employer can show you intentionally violated a known company policy. Medical-related performance declines almost never meet that bar, especially if you weren't formally warned in writing first. I'd put together a folder right now with anything that shows the timeline: doctor's notes or any medical documentation, any emails from your supervisor, your performance reviews if you have access, and anything from HR. If NYSDOL schedules a fact-finding interview, you'll want to walk in with specifics — exact dates, what was said, what was written vs. what was verbal. The more concrete your version, the better your chances.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThat's exactly the kind of info I needed. My former employer never gave me anything in writing — it was always verbal feedback and then suddenly I was out the door. I do have some emails from my doctor that mention the medical issue, so I'll pull those together.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
HR person confirming this tracks with what my adjudicator told me too. Written vs verbal is a huge deal in these cases — employers who only did verbal warnings have a harder time making the misconduct argument stick.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
My HR gave me written warnings but they skipped two of the required progressive discipline steps before firing me. Ended up qualifying for UI because they didn't follow their own documented process. So documentation of what they DIDN'T do matters just as much as what they did.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
My adjudication closed after three weeks and they ruled in my favor on a termination case last spring. What helped me most was writing out a detailed personal statement before my fact-finding interview — not reading from it, just having organized my thoughts. The adjudicator asked me to walk through the events leading up to my termination chronologically, so having that mental map ready made a huge difference. The medical angle in your situation is genuinely one of the stronger positions a claimant can have. NYSDOL looks unfavorably at employers who fire someone for performance without any accommodation conversation, especially when there's a documented health issue in the picture.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThe 'mental map' idea is actually really practical advice. Did your fact-finding interview happen by phone or was it in person?
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Mine was by phone, which I think is the standard format now. They give you advance notice through your account, and you just need to be available at the scheduled time. Have your facts ready and be straightforward — the adjudicator isn't trying to trick you, they're just trying to get the same story from both sides.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
Phone interviews are definitely the norm these days. I had mine earlier this year and it lasted maybe 20 minutes. They're pretty structured questions, not a free-form conversation.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
My cousin went through almost this exact situation last year — terminated for 'performance' at a job where she'd been dealing with a health issue they knew about. She got approved. The employer rep at the fact-finding interview couldn't point to a single written warning or any documentation that she'd been told her job was at risk. NYSDOL basically said the employer didn't meet the standard of proof for misconduct. She kept certifying through the whole adjudication period and got all those weeks paid out at once when the approval came through — it was a substantial amount.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThat's genuinely encouraging to hear. The employer not having written documentation is basically my situation too.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
The lump sum retroactive payment hits different when you've been stressed about bills for weeks. My approval came after 31 days and I was relieved to see all those certified weeks covered at once.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
PLEASE keep certifying your weekly claims no matter what. I stopped for two weeks because I figured nothing would happen during adjudication and I lost those weeks entirely. NYSDOL won't pay weeks you didn't certify even if you get approved retroactively. That's a mistake I still regret.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorI've been certifying every Sunday since I filed — did not know skipping them meant losing them permanently, so glad I didn't make that mistake.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
This is so important and not obvious at all. The portal doesn't warn you about it clearly. You'd think they'd have a banner saying 'keep certifying during adjudication' but nope.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Lost two weeks this way myself. Adjudicator confirmed they couldn't be recovered even after my claim got approved. It's brutal but it's the rule.
0 coins
Anthony Young
My termination adjudication took almost six weeks because my former employer disputed everything and requested an extended review period. The whole process felt opaque — I had no idea what was happening or what stage things were at. I ended up writing a letter directly to the NYSDOL adjudication unit explaining my medical situation with supporting documentation, and I think that actually moved things along. Worth trying if your claim goes past the four-week mark.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorCan you send documentation directly to the adjudication unit without being specifically asked for it? I didn't know that was an option.
0 coins
Anthony Young
You can — there's a fax number and a mailing address on the NYSDOL site for the adjudication unit handling your claim region. It's not the most obvious thing to find but it's there. I'd call to confirm they received it though because things can get lost.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Sending unsolicited documentation is generally fine and can help your case, but make sure you clearly label everything with your Social Security number and claim ID so it gets matched to your file properly.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Went through a messy termination case last year — my employer claimed misconduct but couldn't back it up with anything concrete. Ended up getting approved but it took forever partly because I couldn't get a human on the phone to find out what was going on. Eventually used Claimyr and finally got an agent who pulled up my file and explained exactly where things stood and what the hold was. Having that information was a huge relief even before the actual decision came through.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
The 'knowing where things stand' part is underrated. Half the stress of adjudication is just not knowing if your claim is moving at all or sitting in some forgotten queue.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorHonestly that's exactly where I am right now — not panicking about the outcome, just frustrated by the total silence from NYSDOL on what's happening.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Agreed. The lack of status updates during adjudication is one of the worst parts of the whole process. The online portal status barely changes even when things are actually moving behind the scenes.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
My firing was framed as 'insubordination' but what actually happened was I pushed back on being asked to work through a legally required break without pay. Got approved for UI after the fact-finding interview because the adjudicator agreed that refusing an unlawful instruction doesn't qualify as willful misconduct. The lesson from my case: the specific language your employer uses to describe the termination matters a lot less than what actually happened. NYSDOL is trying to find the real facts, not just rubber-stamp whatever the employer wrote on the separation notice.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThe break thing is wild — your employer actually tried to use that? Glad NYSDOL saw through it.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
They had a whole narrative built up about me being 'difficult.' The adjudicator heard me out and asked the employer rep some pointed questions about the break policy. The employer's story kind of fell apart under questioning.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
This is a good reminder that adjudicators are trained to probe both sides. It's not just whoever files first or whoever has better paperwork — the actual story matters.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My situation was different — I quit but under circumstances I think could qualify as constructive discharge, which from what I've read might still let me claim UI. Anyone dealt with that? I've been reading conflicting stuff online about whether NYSDOL recognizes constructive discharge as a valid reason for leaving.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
NYSDOL does recognize constructive discharge situations, but the bar is high. You basically have to show your employer made working conditions so intolerable that any reasonable person would have felt forced out — and that the employer knew and didn't fix it. It's genuinely harder to prove than a straight termination case but it's not impossible.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My employer changed my schedule to something that made childcare literally impossible after I returned from FMLA leave. That's not an accident — it's a pattern. I've got the schedule emails.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
The FMLA angle combined with a sudden hostile schedule change is a strong set of facts for constructive discharge. I'd document every schedule change and when it happened relative to your return date. That timeline tells a story.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Week six of my own adjudication when I found this thread. My case involves a termination where the employer claimed I violated a 'code of conduct' policy but never gave me a copy of that policy. The adjudicator told me in my fact-finding interview that if the employer can't prove I had access to the written policy, they can't prove I knowingly violated it. That was a turning point.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorWeek six sounds exhausting. Did they give you any timeline for when the decision would actually come after the fact-finding interview?
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
The adjudicator said decisions typically go out within 10 business days of the interview closing. Mine came on day 8. Try not to watch the clock — easier said than done, I know.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
The 'access to the policy' argument is underused. A lot of employers fire people for violating policies that were buried in an onboarding packet from three years ago and never re-distributed. That matters.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
My NYSDOL fact-finding interview happened last Thursday and I have no idea how it went. The adjudicator seemed neutral to the point of being unreadable — didn't react to anything I said. Is that normal? I keep second-guessing whether I explained things clearly enough.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Completely normal. They're trained to stay neutral so neither side feels like they're winning or losing during the interview itself. The unreadable vibe is not a bad sign — it's just the format.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
My adjudicator was the same way. Genuinely gave no signals whatsoever. I got approved. Try to let it go if you can.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
That's helpful to hear from people who've been through it. The waiting after is somehow worse than the interview itself was.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
My employer actually lied during the fact-finding interview — claimed they gave me three verbal warnings when I know for certain one of those conversations never happened. I didn't know I could dispute specific factual claims during the process. Is there a way to submit a rebuttal after the interview if the employer made false statements?
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
You can contact the adjudication unit after the interview and ask to submit additional information or a written response to the employer's claims. Do it in writing if possible, with your claim ID on everything. If your claim gets denied based on false information, the appeals process is specifically designed to let you present your version of events with evidence.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
The appeals process feels intimidating but I guess that's the backstop if the adjudicator gets it wrong based on bad information from my employer.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Appeals are actually more claimant-friendly than the initial adjudication in some ways — you get a formal hearing with a referee, you can bring documentation and testimony, and the standard for 'misconduct' gets examined really carefully. Don't be scared of the appeals route.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
My claim approval came through yesterday after exactly 23 days in adjudication — termination case, employer called it a 'policy violation,' I had no written warnings. Got approved. For anyone reading this thread who's in the middle of their own wait: the process does work, it just moves at its own pace.
0 coins
Grace Lee
Author23 days and approved — genuinely good to hear. Gives me some hope that mine might resolve before I completely lose my mind.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Congrats on the approval. That first payment hitting after weeks of waiting is a real feeling.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
23 days with no written warnings in the employer's file — that tracks with what most people report. Employers who can't produce documentation tend to lose these cases.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
My situation wrapped up last month and I want to say something about the job search requirement because I almost messed it up. During adjudication you are still required to do your three job search activities per week and log them. I assumed adjudication was like a pause button where the requirements also paused. It is not. My adjudicator mentioned during the interview that my job search log was complete and accurate, and I genuinely think that helped my credibility. Keep those logs clean and detailed — employer name, position, date, how you applied.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorI've been doing all three every week but I had no idea the adjudicator might actually look at the logs during the interview. That's a detail I'll make sure to stay on top of.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
The job search logs are checked more often than people realize. I've heard of claims being complicated by missing or vague entries even when the underlying case was strong.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My entries have been pretty bare-bones — just the company name and 'applied online.' Should I be adding more detail than that?
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Add the specific job title, the date you applied, the method (company website, Indeed, LinkedIn, in person), and a contact name or posting URL if you have one. The more specific the better. Vague entries don't get you in trouble automatically but detailed ones look better if anyone reviews them.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
My brother got fired two months ago from a restaurant — employer said misconduct but it was really just a personality clash with a new manager who wanted to bring in his own people. NYSDOL approved my brother's UI claim after the fact-finding interview because the employer's 'misconduct' claim amounted to 'we didn't like his attitude' with zero documentation. Personality conflicts and vague attitude complaints almost never rise to the NYSDOL definition of misconduct.
0 coins
Grace Lee
Author'Didn t like his' attitude with no documentation — yeah'that s not going to hold up. Glad your brother gotapproved.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
The 'attitude' termination with no paper trail is one of the clearest paths to UI approval. NYSDOL has seen that employer move a thousand times.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
My brother said the fact-finding call lasted maybe 15 minutes. The employer rep basically had nothing specific to point to and the adjudicator moved on pretty quickly.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
My own termination adjudication is pending and I found this thread doing research. What I keep seeing is that the documentation angle is real — employers who didn't do written warnings or progressive discipline almost always lose these cases at NYSDOL. I went back through my emails and found a note from my manager saying 'keep up the good work' three weeks before they fired me. Saving that one.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
A 'keep up the good work' email three weeks before a termination-for-performance is genuinely useful evidence. It directly contradicts the idea that you were on notice about serious problems. Bring that to your fact-finding interview.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
I had no idea a random positive email would matter that much. I almost didn't bother going through my old work emails.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Old emails are gold in these cases. Anything that shows the employer's story doesn't line up with what they were actually saying to you at the time — that's exactly the kind of thing adjudicators weigh.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
My termination was framed as a layoff when I was actually let go for a specific reason my employer didn't want to put on paper. Got a little complicated because the official paperwork said one thing and what actually happened was different. NYSDOL sent me a questionnaire asking me to explain the separation from my perspective. Filled it out honestly and in detail. The questionnaire response is apparently your first real chance to shape how the adjudicator understands your case before they talk to the employer.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorI didn't even know there was a questionnaire step — did it come through your Unemployment Services account or by mail?
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
Mine came by mail but I've heard others get it through the account. Check both. It had a deadline on it — I think 10 days — so don't sit on it if you get one.
0 coins
Anthony Young
The questionnaire response is underestimated. A lot of people write two sentences when they could write two paragraphs. The more context you give upfront, the less the adjudicator has to assume.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Treat the questionnaire like you're writing a clear, calm statement to someone who knows nothing about your situation — because that's essentially what it is. Facts, timeline, specifics. Leave out anything emotional and stick to what happened and when.
0 coins