Fired for being sick, can I collect unemployment in NY?
My job let me go last Tuesday and I'm still kind of in shock about how it happened. I'd been with the company almost four years, and over the past two months I had three absences because I was dealing with a bronchial infection that kept coming back. Each time I brought in a doctor's note. HR called me in last week and said the absences violated their attendance policy regardless of the reason, and that was that. No warning, no PIP, just terminated effective immediately. I went to file my UI claim on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal the same day and it's been sitting in adjudication since then. I didn't get any notice explaining why it was flagged, just that an issue needed to be reviewed. My former employer is a mid-size logistics company and I assume they're contesting it, probably arguing it was misconduct. Here's what's really stressing me out: from everything I've read, being fired doesn't automatically mean you can't collect unemployment, but I genuinely don't know if illness-related absences count as misconduct in NYSDOL's eyes. I had documentation for every single absence. Does anyone have experience with a situation like this? Did adjudication go in your favor when the firing was for attendance but you had medical backup?
74 comments

Owen Jenkins
Claimyr (claimyr.com) is worth looking at if you haven't tried it yet — it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking to a live agent without spending your whole day on hold. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that explains what it does. My adjudication was dragging into week five with zero updates on my Unemployment Services account and I finally got some real answers from an agent after using it. For your situation specifically, being able to tell an agent you have medical documentation for every absence could actually move things along faster than just waiting.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorMy phone attempts so far have been a total wall — either the line disconnects or I get the 'high call volume' recording. I'll check that video out tonight, honestly at this point I need to talk to an actual person.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Tried Claimyr when my own claim got stuck and ended up speaking with someone at NYSDOL within the same afternoon. Way better than the two weeks I spent redialing before that.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
does it work for adjudication holds specifically or only like general questions
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Four years at a company and they fired you over documented medical absences with no prior written warning — that pattern is exactly the kind of thing that tends to go in a claimant's favor during adjudication. NYSDOL draws a pretty clear line between genuine misconduct and situations where someone couldn't control what happened to them. Getting sick and bringing in doctor's notes is about as far from willful misconduct as you can get.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThat's genuinely reassuring to hear. My big worry was that the word 'terminated' on the separation notice would just automatically trigger a denial without anyone looking at context.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Termination alone means nothing — it's why the adjudication even exists, to look at the actual facts. The employer still has to prove misconduct, not just say the policy was violated.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Used Claimyr myself when adjudication was taking forever and finally got an agent on the line. The agent I spoke with actually looked up notes on my claim and told me exactly what documentation they were waiting on — that kind of specific info is impossible to get from the portal alone.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
My layoff was for attendance too, different circumstances, but I want to flag something from my own case: NYSDOL asked me during adjudication whether I had notified my employer each time before or on the day of each absence. Even with doctor's notes in hand after the fact, the notification piece mattered to them. If you can show you followed your employer's call-out procedure every single time, that really strengthens the 'not misconduct' argument.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorEvery absence I called in before my shift started, so I should be okay on that front. I hadn't even thought about that being a separate question from the medical documentation itself.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
same thing came up in my case, they wanted to know about the call-in procedure specifically, good point
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
The notification piece is underrated in these cases. NYSDOL looks at whether the person tried to minimize the harm to the employer, and proper call-outs show exactly that.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
WAIT so they can fire you for being sick even with a doctors note and you still have to fight for unemployment?? that seems completely backwards. the company gets to fire you AND try to block your benefits?
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Employers can challenge claims but they don't get to decide the outcome — NYSDOL makes the final call after reviewing both sides. And the threshold for proving misconduct is actually on the employer, not the claimant.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
ok that makes more sense i guess, i just assumed if you got fired with proof you were sick they just automatically approved it
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
My claim was in adjudication for 31 days before I got a determination letter. During that entire stretch the portal just said 'pending review' with no other info. The letter eventually came by mail, not through the portal, and it was an approval. Keep filing your weekly certifications every single week without fail during adjudication — missing even one can complicate things significantly once a decision is issued.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorWeekly certifications — yes, I've been doing those each Sunday. Didn't want to assume I could skip them while adjudication was open.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
31 days is a long time to just sit and wait with no information. did you try calling at all during that period or just watched the portal?
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Tried calling probably a dozen times over those 31 days, never got through to a person. If Claimyr had existed in my life at that point I would have used it, honestly.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Documentation is going to be the backbone of your case here. Pull together everything you have: the doctor's notes from each visit, any texts or emails where you notified your manager or HR about the absences, any HR emails acknowledging receipt of your documentation, and anything from your four-year employment history that shows you were otherwise a reliable employee. If you get scheduled for a phone interview with an adjudicator, having all of that ready to reference by date will make a real difference.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorI have the doctor's notes and I still have the texts to my supervisor for each call-out. I should probably screenshot and organize everything chronologically before any interview happens.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
The chronological organization tip is huge. My adjudication interview caught me off guard and I was fumbling to find things. Being prepared with dates and documents right in front of you makes you sound credible and in control.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
do they always do a phone interview for adjudication or only sometimes
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Phone interviews during adjudication aren't guaranteed — sometimes NYSDOL just reviews the written information from both sides and issues a determination without speaking to either party. Whether they schedule one depends on how complex the dispute looks to the adjudicator assigned to your case. If they do reach out, it'll come through your Unemployment Services account or by mail, so check both regularly.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
oh ok i didn't realize it could just get decided without talking to you, thanks
0 coins
Arjun Patel
My adjudication was decided with no phone interview at all — approval came via letter about three weeks in. Yours was medical, same type of situation, and they apparently had enough info from the documents to decide.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Went through almost this exact situation about eight months ago — terminated for attendance, had medical documentation. My adjudication took about six weeks and during that time I tried calling NYSDOL probably thirty times without reaching anyone. Eventually used Claimyr and ended up speaking with an actual NYSDOL agent who could see my file. She confirmed they had all my documents and that the determination was being finalized. Knowing that stopped me from spiraling every day wondering if something was lost in the system.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorSix weeks is tough but at least it ended well. How did your determination come out?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Approved. The adjudicator found the absences weren't willful misconduct because I had medical reasons and had followed call-out procedures. Benefits backdated to my original filing date too.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
backdated to the original filing date is so important for people to know, you don't lose those weeks just because adjudication takes forever
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Under New York unemployment law, misconduct means something done deliberately or with reckless disregard for the employer's interests — getting sick and missing work doesn't meet that standard, even if it technically violated an attendance policy. Courts and NYSDOL have consistently held that absences driven by illness, especially documented illness, fall outside what qualifies as disqualifying misconduct. Your employer can argue the policy, but the policy violation alone doesn't make the case for them.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThis is exactly the distinction I was struggling to understand. The fact that my company has an 'attendance policy' doesn't automatically mean I committed misconduct in the legal sense — that's what I was hoping someone could clarify.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
The word 'willful' is what trips people up. Policy violation is not the same as willful misconduct, and NYSDOL adjudicators know the difference.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
i wish they explained this somewhere obvious on the NYSDOL website instead of making everyone google it and find forum posts
0 coins
Haley Bennett
My determination took forever and I got desperate enough to try everything. Claimyr was the thing that actually worked — I stopped burning hours redialing and instead ended up on the phone with a live NYSDOL agent who walked me through exactly what was holding my case. For something like your situation where the facts are on your side, getting that direct conversation with an agent can help you understand where things stand instead of just watching the portal say nothing.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorAt week two now with the same 'pending review' message and I'm definitely feeling the desperation creeping in. Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
The portal silence is genuinely the worst part. You file, you certify weekly, and then you just sit there with no feedback. Getting a human on the line who can look at your actual file is completely different.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
My sister's partner — wait, actually I shouldn't speak for someone else. What I can say is that I know someone personally who was fired for attendance due to a chronic health condition and won their UI appeal after the initial denial. The adjudication had denied them, but the appeal went differently once they submitted a written statement explaining the medical timeline in detail. Moral of the story: if adjudication doesn't go your way, the appeal process exists and it works.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorAppeal process — hadn't even thought past adjudication yet but it's good to know there's another layer if the first determination goes badly.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Appeals are heard by an Administrative Law Judge and you get a full hearing where you can present testimony and documentation. The standard for misconduct is the same, but you get a more thorough review. Many denials get reversed at that stage.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
how long does an appeal usually take tho because that could be months more without benefits
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Appeals can take anywhere from six to twelve weeks typically, but here's the thing most people miss — if your appeal is successful, your benefits are paid out retroactively for the full period you were waiting. So you don't permanently lose those weeks, you just receive them in a lump once the appeal is decided in your favor. That's why it's essential to keep certifying weekly every single week throughout the entire process.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
ok the retroactive part is good to know, makes it less terrifying to wait through
0 coins
Rami Samuels
keeping up weekly certifications no matter what is the most underrated advice in this whole thread, i almost stopped mine assuming it was pointless
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Four years of employment history with no prior discipline and then terminated during a documented medical situation — your fact pattern is strong. The adjudicator is looking at the totality of the circumstances. A four-year tenure with clean history before this tells a story that a single policy violation does not.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorI hadn't framed it that way in my head but you're right — four years of presumably solid employment history is part of the picture too, not just the last two months.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
Prior discipline history absolutely matters. I've seen people get denied when they had written warnings before the termination. No prior discipline is genuinely significant.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
ok genuine question — my situation is different, i quit a job for health reasons rather than got fired. is that treated the same way? asking because this thread is the most useful thing ive found about medical situations and UI
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Quitting versus being fired is handled differently under NYSDOL rules. A voluntary quit requires you to show 'good cause' for leaving, and while medical necessity can qualify, the bar is different than what applies when you're fired. Worth searching for posts specifically about that scenario.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
ok thanks for clarifying, i'll look into that separately, didn't want to hijack the thread
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Your situation does have a pathway through NYSDOL — medical necessity as good cause for a voluntary quit is a recognized category. The documentation requirements are similar though, you'd need medical evidence supporting the decision to leave.
0 coins
Nina Chan
ive been reading this whole thread because im in kind of a similar boat. fired last month, attendance related, no doctor notes though because i didn't go to the doctor every single time. im worried that hurts me compared to OP's situation
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Doctor's notes for every absence are the strongest position but they aren't the only evidence that can help. Other things like your call-out records, any HR communications, and your overall employment history can still support your case. Document what you do have.
0 coins
Nina Chan
i have texts to my supervisor for most of them at least, i guess that's something
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Those texts are valuable — they show you were communicating with your employer in real time, which goes to the notification question adjudicators care about. Gather every one of them.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
NYSDOL adjudication has been sitting at 7 weeks for me now on a totally different kind of claim and reading this thread is both helpful and deeply stressful. the system is completely broken, they expect you to survive on nothing while they take their time deciding
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Seven weeks is brutal. At that length I would really push to get a person on the phone somehow — sometimes a claim just needs someone to look at it and move it along.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
i have literally been trying to call every single day for two weeks and cant get through
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Claimyr is what finally got me talking to a live NYSDOL agent when I was in a similar loop of never reaching anyone. At week seven I would not keep redialing manually, there are better uses of your time.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
The employer in these situations often just submits a form saying the termination was for policy violations and doesn't elaborate much. Adjudicators have seen this exact setup — fired for attendance, medical documentation on the claimant's side — many times. The burden of proof that there was actual misconduct sits with the employer and 'they violated our policy' is usually not enough on its own to meet it.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThat reframing genuinely helps. I've been anxious imagining the employer making some elaborate argument but maybe their submission is as simple as 'attendance policy violation' and no more.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Employer responses to adjudication questionnaires are typically brief. They state the reason for termination and check some boxes. The depth of investigation is NYSDOL's job, not the employer's.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
my claim got denied in adjudication two months ago for misconduct even though i thought i had a good case and i never appealed because i thought i couldn't win. reading this thread i'm realizing i probably should have. is it too late
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Appeal deadlines are strict — you have 30 days from the mailing date of the determination letter to file. If two months have passed since that letter, the standard appeal window is likely closed. There is a process to request a late appeal but you'd need to show good cause for missing the deadline.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
the letter came like 10 weeks ago so i probably missed it. that's really frustrating to find out now
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Contacting NYSDOL directly about your specific situation is worth doing even now — there are limited circumstances where late appeals are accepted. Getting an agent to look at your file and explain your options exactly is the only way to know for sure what's available to you.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
Weekly certifications every Sunday since filing, check. Documentation organized by date, check. Keeping records of every call attempt to NYSDOL in case it ever matters, also check. Reading everything in this thread and feeling like I finally understand what I'm waiting for — that's new. OP you're going to be okay based on everything people have laid out here.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThank you for this, genuinely. This thread has been more informative than anything I found on the actual NYSDOL website.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
That's how it always goes. The official pages tell you almost nothing about what adjudication actually looks like from the inside.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
Updating everyone since a few people asked me to: got through to an NYSDOL agent this week (finally) and she confirmed my employer submitted their response and it's with an adjudicator now. She couldn't give me a timeline but said there were no additional documents needed from my side. Still waiting on the determination but at least I know it's moving. Will post again when I have a final answer.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
That's exactly the kind of update that makes all the difference mentally — knowing your file is complete and in someone's hands versus complete silence from the portal.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Fingers crossed for you. Everything people have described about your situation points toward approval. Keep certifying.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
The confirmation that no additional documents are needed is actually meaningful. It suggests the adjudicator has what they need to make a decision. Good sign.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Thanks for the update — a lot of people read these threads anxiously hoping to see that someone in their situation came out okay. Post back with the determination when it arrives.
0 coins