Do you have to pay back unemployment? What NYSDOL told me
So I've been going back and forth on this for weeks now and finally want some clarity. I was laid off from my warehouse job back in January and started collecting UI benefits through NYSDOL. Everything seemed fine — I reported my earnings each week when I had a few hours of part-time work, certified on time, did my job search activities. Then out of nowhere I got a letter in the mail saying there may have been an overpayment on my account. I nearly had a panic attack reading it. My whole question is: do you have to pay back unemployment if NYSDOL decides there was an overpayment? Like is that automatic, or do you have an appeal window? The letter wasn't totally clear on the amount or even why they flagged it. I haven't been able to get anyone on the phone to explain it. Really hoping someone here has dealt with this.
70 comments

Muhammad Hobbs
My situation last year was almost identical to yours — got an overpayment notice out of nowhere and spent three weeks trying to reach NYSDOL by phone with zero luck. Every time I dialed in the hold times were insane and the line would just drop. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) — what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live NYSDOL agent. There's a video demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see it before trying. I finally got an agent on the line, explained the overpayment notice, and she walked me through exactly why it happened and what my options were. Turned out I had a week where my part-time earnings were coded wrong and it triggered the flag. Completely fixable once I actually spoke to someone.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorThe part about the earnings being coded wrong — that's what I'm worried about too. I had a couple of weeks where I reported hours but my employer might have submitted something different. Did the agent tell you whether you still had to repay if the error was on their end?
0 coins
Noland Curtis
wait so you just handed your info to some random service?? idk man that sounds sketchy to me
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Yeah the agent confirmed it was a data mismatch, not anything I did wrong. They submitted a correction internally and the overpayment notice was eventually withdrawn. You absolutely want to talk to a live agent before assuming you owe anything.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
To answer your core question directly: yes, NYSDOL can require you to repay benefits if they determine an overpayment occurred. BUT — and this is a big but — the type of overpayment matters enormously. When I went through this two years ago, the rep explained it to me like this: if the overpayment happened because of NYSDOL's own mistake or some administrative error, they're sometimes willing to waive recovery, especially if repaying would cause you financial hardship. If the overpayment was because you gave incorrect information, that's a different story and they pursue it more aggressively. Either way, you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file a formal appeal if you think the determination is wrong.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Author30 days from the notice date — okay that's the number I needed. My letter is dated about 10 days ago so I still have time. Do I appeal through the Unemployment Services online portal or is there a separate form?
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
i thought the appeal window was only 2 weeks?? my friend told me that and now im not sure who to believe
0 coins
Diez Ellis
The 30-day window is accurate for most overpayment determinations under NYSDOL's standard process. Your friend might be thinking of a different kind of notice — sometimes there are requests for information that have shorter response windows but those aren't the same as a formal determination. Check the actual letter; the appeal deadline should be printed right on it.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
The appeal goes through the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. There's a form on the NYSDOL website but you can also just send a written letter to the address on your notice within that window. Keep a copy of everything you send.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
My overpayment notice came when I was on standby status and my employer ended up not recalling me on the schedule they originally told NYSDOL. The whole thing was a mess because I'd already certified weeks of benefits during the standby period. When I finally got someone on the phone they explained that standby overpayments get handled differently from regular UI overpayments because the employer is usually the one that submitted the wrong return-to-work date. Took months to sort out but eventually NYSDOL agreed the employer gave them bad info and they adjusted it without me having to repay.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorStandby situations sound even more complicated. Mine is a straight layoff — no recall expected — so hopefully that makes it a bit cleaner to dispute.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
my situation was similar but i was on regular UI not standby and they still blamed me even though my employer was the one who reported the wrong dates to them, like how is that even fair
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Employer reporting errors are incredibly common and NYSDOL does have a process for employer corrections but it takes forever. Your best move is to get the employer to submit a corrected wage record if they're willing to do it.
0 coins
Laila Prince
There are basically two ways this shakes out from what I've seen people go through. Either NYSDOL sends you a bill and expects repayment, or they just deduct from future benefits if your claim is still active. I had benefits reduced on a future week because of a small discrepancy — it wasn't even a formal overpayment notice, they just took it out automatically. No one told me it was happening until I checked my payment history and saw the deduction. That's why I always tell people to actually look at the payment details in the Unemployment Services account every single week.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorI hadn't thought about them just deducting silently like that. I'm going to log in and look at every week's payment breakdown right now. How do I see that in the portal?
0 coins
Isabel Vega
in your unemployment services account there should be a payment history section and you can click each week to see the detail — it shows gross amount, any deductions, and what was actually deposited
0 coins
Laila Prince
Yeah exactly what the other commenter said. If the numbers don't match up week to week that's a sign something was adjusted. It's tedious but worth doing before you even respond to the overpayment notice so you understand what you're actually disputing.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
i checked mine once and found they had taken out like 60 bucks i never knew about from way back when. had no idea that was even allowed without telling you first
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
The hardest part for me was figuring out whether my overpayment was fraud-related or just an administrative mistake, because NYSDOL treats those two things very differently. I got flagged because my part-time hours during one week crossed a threshold I didn't know existed. I reported them honestly, didn't hide anything, but apparently because the gross earnings in that week exceeded a certain percentage of my weekly benefit rate they should have reduced my payment more than they did — and their system didn't catch it at the time. When I eventually got to speak with someone, they confirmed it was a system lag, not misreporting on my part. The difference between fraud and non-fraud overpayments matters a lot when you're asking whether you have to pay back unemployment — fraud ones come with penalties on top of the repayment.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorThe fraud vs. non-fraud distinction is what scares me honestly. I'm certain I reported everything accurately but reading the letter again it doesn't say which category I'm in.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
the letter should use specific language if it's alleging fraud — words like willful misrepresentation or false statements. if it doesn't say that explicitly then it's probably a standard overpayment not a fraud one
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Exactly right. If the notice doesn't mention willful misrepresentation it's most likely a plain administrative overpayment. Still stressful but the path forward is cleaner.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
wait i thought any overpayment automatically became fraud if you didn't respond within like 2 weeks? someone told me that at the career center
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
That's not accurate. Ignoring an overpayment notice can lead to the amount being referred to collections and potentially affect future claims, but silence doesn't reclassify it as fraud. Fraud is a separate determination based on your original certifications.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
NYSDOL has been IMPOSSIBLE to reach by phone lately and everyone going through an overpayment situation right now is basically stuck trying to figure this out without any actual help from a human being. I had three separate appointments scheduled through the career center that got postponed and every time i called the main UI line i sat on hold for over an hour before getting disconnected. My overpayment notice was for $2,800 and I had no idea if I was supposed to set up a repayment plan or fight it or what. The website gives you almost no guidance on WHAT SPECIFICALLY triggered the overpayment. It's infuriating.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
The phone situation with NYSDOL is legitimately brutal right now. When I had my overpayment issue I tried for two weeks straight and kept getting dropped. A coworker mentioned Claimyr and I figured I had nothing to lose — it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up speaking to an actual live agent. I finally got someone on the line after trying on my own for so long. She pulled up my account, saw the specific weeks flagged, and explained that two of my job search contacts hadn't been recorded correctly in their system. Without that call I would have had no idea what I was even disputing.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
hmm okay might look into that. i genuinely can't keep spending my mornings dialing and redialing. did the agent help you understand your actual options once you got them on the phone?
0 coins
Angel Campbell
She went through all of it — repayment plan options, how to submit a hardship waiver request if I qualified, and the appeal process. Way more useful than anything on the website. I ended up setting up a payment arrangement right on the call instead of worrying about it for another month.
0 coins
Payton Black
I work adjacent to HR at a mid-size company and have seen this from the employer side a couple times. When an employee's wages get reported incorrectly to NYSDOL — and it does happen, sometimes because payroll enters the wrong quarter or misreports a termination date — the resulting overpayment technically lands on the claimant even though they did nothing wrong. NYSDOL's default is to pursue the claimant first. The employer can file a correction but many don't bother because it's not their money at risk. If you suspect the issue started on your employer's end, you can specifically request that NYSDOL investigate the employer's wage records rather than just defaulting to asking you to repay.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorRequesting that NYSDOL look at the employer's wage records specifically — is that something I do in a written appeal or is there a separate request process for it?
0 coins
Payton Black
You'd include it as part of your appeal or any written response to the notice. State clearly that you believe the discrepancy originated from an employer reporting error and ask them to pull the quarterly wage records submitted by the employer. Be specific about which weeks you're questioning.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
i asked for this exact thing and NYSDOL sent me a form to fill out requesting employer records review — it took about 6 weeks to get a response but they did actually do it
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Appeals genuinely do work and people shouldn't be scared off from filing them. My overpayment was initially for around $4,100 and after the appeal hearing it was reduced to zero because I had my job search logs, pay stubs, and a letter from my employer all organized and ready. The hearing itself was over the phone and lasted maybe 25 minutes. The administrative law judge asked me to walk through each week in question and I explained my earnings and how I'd certified them. The key thing is you have to show up — if you file an appeal and then don't participate in the hearing, the determination typically goes against you automatically.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorYou said the hearing was by phone — does NYSDOL still do in-person hearings at all or is it all remote now?
0 coins
Abby Marshall
As of this year most UI appeal hearings through the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board are conducted by phone. You can sometimes request an in-person hearing but it usually just slows down the scheduling. Phone hearings are honestly easier to manage anyway since you can have all your documents in front of you.
0 coins
Harold Oh
i was so scared about my hearing but honestly it was way less intimidating than i expected. the judge was actually pretty calm about it and let me explain my side fully
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
does it help to have a lawyer at the appeal hearing or is that overkill for a small overpayment amount
0 coins
Abby Marshall
For smaller amounts most people represent themselves successfully. If the overpayment is large or involves a fraud allegation, having a legal aid attorney can make a real difference. Many legal aid societies in NY offer free representation for UI appeals.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
The hardest thing to understand is the hardship waiver. When I first got my overpayment notice I didn't even know that was an option. NYSDOL can waive recovery of a non-fraud overpayment if repayment would cause you serious financial hardship — but you have to actually apply for it. They don't offer it to you automatically. I found out from someone in a forum like this one, not from NYSDOL directly. The waiver form asks for your monthly income, expenses, assets — basically a snapshot of your financial situation. Mine was approved and I didn't have to repay a single dollar.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorA waiver that completely zeroes out the overpayment — I didn't know that was even possible. Where do I find the actual waiver form?
0 coins
Dominique Adams
You request it through NYSDOL directly — either by calling them or by sending a written request to the address on your overpayment notice. There isn't a simple online form for it last I checked; it's a process you kind of have to push for.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
i heard waivers only apply if you weren't at fault AND it would be against equity and good conscience to make you repay. both things have to be true not just one of them
0 coins
Dominique Adams
That's accurate. You need to meet both standards. NYSDOL won't waive it just because repaying is hard — they also look at whether you had any reason to know there was an overpayment happening.
0 coins
Summer Green
My neighbor was going through the same overpayment situation and had spent weeks hitting dead ends trying to reach NYSDOL by phone. I told her about Claimyr because it had been mentioned to me earlier in my own claim process. She used it last month, got a live NYSDOL agent on the line, and walked away from that call knowing exactly what she owed, which weeks were disputed, and what her deadline was to respond. She filed her appeal the same day with actual information instead of guessing. Sometimes having that one real conversation changes everything.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
okay this is the third time i've seen Claimyr mentioned in this thread — was everyone just not able to get through to NYSDOL on their own or is regular hold time just that bad right now
0 coins
Summer Green
The hold times are genuinely that bad. I've sat on hold for 90 minutes and had the line drop. It's not exaggeration, it's just the current state of the UI phone lines.
0 coins
Harold Oh
i tried calling at 8am exactly when the lines open and still waited over an hour before anyone picked up. the system is overwhelmed
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
There's a part of this that trips people up: not every overpayment notice means you definitely owe money. Sometimes NYSDOL sends a preliminary notice that's essentially saying they're looking at your account, not that a final determination has been made. I got one of those and panicked, but when I read more carefully it said 'potential overpayment under review' — not 'you owe X amount.' If your letter says something under review, you may have time to submit documentation proactively before they even finalize anything.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorMine uses the phrase 'potential overpayment determination' — so that sounds like it might still be in the review phase rather than a final bill. Is that right?
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
That wording strongly suggests it's still preliminary. Use that window. Submit anything you have — pay stubs, your job search log, employer contact records — to the address on the letter and explicitly state you're responding to the preliminary notice with supporting documentation.
0 coins
Gael Robinson
My letter said potential determination too and I sent in my earnings records before they finalized anything. NYSDOL closed the review without issuing a repayment demand. Probably saved myself a lot of hassle by not waiting to see what they'd do.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
I want to lay out the basic repayment mechanics because I had no idea how this worked when I went through it. If NYSDOL finalizes an overpayment and you don't successfully appeal or get a waiver, they can recover it a few different ways: they deduct from future benefit payments if you file a new claim, they can intercept state tax refunds, and in some cases they refer the amount to the state attorney general's office for collections. They don't necessarily come after you all at once — often they'll set up a repayment plan if you contact them and ask. But you have to initiate that; they won't automatically offer installments.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorTax refund interception — I had no idea they could do that. That changes how urgently I need to get this resolved.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
It's one of those things nobody mentions upfront. If you're expecting a state refund and there's an outstanding overpayment balance, NYSDOL can capture that refund to offset what you owe. Getting ahead of it by either appealing or setting up a payment plan protects you from that.
0 coins
Laila Prince
the deduction from future benefits is the one that catches people off guard — you think you're getting your normal weekly amount and it's short because they took some for the old overpayment
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Went through adjudication AND an overpayment notice within the same claim period and it was overwhelming. What helped me keep it straight was treating them as two completely separate processes with their own deadlines and their own paperwork. Adjudication is about eligibility — NYSDOL deciding whether you qualify to receive benefits in the first place. Overpayment is about whether you received more than you were entitled to, which can happen even if you were fully eligible. Mixing up the two processes or filing responses to the wrong office caused me delays I didn't need.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorI hadn't thought about those as being separate tracks. My adjudication was resolved months ago — I was found eligible — but now this overpayment notice seems to be questioning specific weeks after the fact.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Exactly and that's very common. Being found eligible overall doesn't prevent them from later reviewing individual weeks and deciding a specific payment was more than it should have been. Those week-level reviews happen independently.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
oh wow i thought if adjudication was cleared that meant everything was fine forever. this thread is giving me anxiety about my own claim now
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Your eligibility determination and your individual week payment accuracy are genuinely separate things. Being cleared in adjudication just means you qualified — it doesn't lock in every payment as correct permanently.
0 coins
Harold Oh
My whole overpayment ended up being traced back to a week where I reported partial earnings but the amount I listed was before taxes, not my gross wages. The NYSDOL system wants gross earnings — before any deductions. I didn't know that at the time and I was apparently underreporting my earnings for three separate weeks, which meant they had paid me more than they should have based on the correct gross figures. I had to repay the difference. It wasn't fun but once I understood exactly what happened I couldn't really argue it.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorGross earnings before any deductions — I want to make sure I did that right. I reported my hourly rate times hours worked without subtracting taxes. Is that the right interpretation?
0 coins
Harold Oh
Yes, hourly rate times hours worked before any withholding is taken out — that's gross and that's what they want. If you did it that way you should be in good shape on that point at least.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
i reported net by mistake too during my first claim and had the same exact issue. the instructions on the weekly certification page could be so much clearer about this
0 coins
Gael Robinson
My overpayment notice came when I had already exhausted my claim and had no future benefits for them to deduct from. I was worried they'd come after my bank account directly and that fear kept me up at night. When I finally reached an actual NYSDOL agent — I used Claimyr to get through after my own attempts kept failing — she explained that for non-fraud overpayments they typically don't pursue bank levies as a first step. They usually try deductions from future claims first, then tax intercept, then potentially collections referral. Knowing the actual sequence made it way less scary.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
AuthorThe sequence of how they pursue it matters a lot to me right now. So tax intercept comes before collections referral — good to know. And they wouldn't go straight to a bank levy on a non-fraud case?
0 coins
Gael Robinson
For standard non-fraud overpayments that's how it was explained to me. Fraud determinations are treated more aggressively. Keep everything non-fraud and you have more options and more time.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
i was terrified about the same thing — bank levies felt like the nightmare scenario. glad to know there are steps before it gets there
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
does the tax intercept apply to federal refunds too or just the state tax refund?
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
NYSDOL's overpayment recovery through tax intercept applies to your state tax refund. Federal refunds are a separate matter and would involve a different federal process — NYSDOL doesn't directly intercept federal refunds for UI overpayments.
0 coins