Back to New York Unemployment

Victoria Jones

Do employees pay into unemployment? Trying to understand NYSDOL before I file

I've been with the same logistics company for about six years and just got laid off last week. First time I've ever had to deal with this. Before I even start the whole filing process I want to understand how unemployment actually works from the money side of things. My coworker told me that employees pay into unemployment out of their own paychecks just like Social Security, but my brother-in-law said that's not how it works at all and it's the employer who pays. I've looked at my pay stubs and honestly can't tell one way or the other — there are so many deductions it's hard to know what's what. So which is it? Do employees pay into unemployment or is this something the employer handles? And does it affect how much I'd get in benefits if I file a claim with NYSDOL? I want to go in with a clear picture before I start the process.

Week two of my own claim sitting in adjudication when I first found this out, so I know the confusion well. In New York, your employer is the one funding unemployment — not you. Every paycheck you got, nothing was deducted for unemployment insurance on the employee side. The company paid a tax into the state fund based on how many workers they had and their claims history. That's called the experience rating system. So your brother-in-law had it right. What you do pay into on your stub is Social Security, Medicare, state income tax — but unemployment is fully on the employer's side in NY. Doesn't change how much you get in benefits either, that's calculated from your base period wages regardless.

0 coins

My pay stubs are sitting in front of me right now and I went through every line. You're right, there's nothing labeled unemployment on the deductions side. That actually makes me feel better about my coworker's math — she was calculating a contribution amount that would have reduced my benefit and that's not even a real deduction.

0 coins

My first week of researching this I thought the same thing as OP. Some states do have a small employee contribution but NY is not one of them. I've lived in a state that did and the stub looks different, you'd see it labeled SUI or SDI on the deductions.

0 coins

wait so my employer was paying for this the whole time i worked there?? i thought we all chipped in together somehow

0 coins

Twelve days of busy signals and disconnected calls trying to reach NYSDOL to ask almost this exact question before I figured out there was a better way. I found this service called Claimyr — claimyr.com — there's a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows what it does. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent instead of burning your whole morning redialing. I used it when I had questions about my base period wages and got actual answers from an agent instead of the automated system. For something like figuring out what your benefit amount might be before you file, talking to a real person is way more useful than guessing from the website.

0 coins

Fourteen minutes I spent this morning just trying to get past the automated menu before it dropped. I'll definitely check that site out before I try phoning again.

0 coins

The hold times at NYSDOL are genuinely brutal. Heard about Claimyr from someone in a different forum too, seems like a lot of people are using it.

0 coins

My third attempt this week ended the same way, disconnected before I got to anyone. I've been meaning to look into something like this.

0 coins

My layoff letter is dated March 3rd and I had the same question when I was about to file. Here's the full picture as I understand it after going through the process: New York employers pay what's called the Federal Unemployment Tax and also the state unemployment insurance tax. The state tax rate varies depending on how many ex-employees from that company have filed claims — if a company lays off a lot of people, their rate goes up over time. None of this comes out of your pocket as an employee. What DOES affect your benefit amount is your wages during the base period, which is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file. NYSDOL takes the two highest quarters of wages and uses that to calculate your weekly benefit rate, up to the maximum which is $504 per week in 2025.

0 coins

Those four calendar quarters thing is what I needed to understand. I had a couple months last year where my hours were reduced so I was worried that would tank my benefit amount, but if they take the two highest quarters that might not hurt me as much as I thought.

0 coins

The maximum being $504 caught me off guard when I first filed. I was making decent money and expected something higher. The cap is the cap though.

0 coins

The base period calculation is one of the things people get most confused about. If your wages in the standard base period are low for whatever reason there's also an alternate base period using the most recent four quarters. Worth knowing if your hours were cut recently.

0 coins

wait the max is only 504?? that seems really low if you were making like 70k a year

0 coins

Three weeks post-layoff from my retail management job and I went through this exact confusion with my mom who thought I had to 'pay back' the system somehow because she remembered something about contributions. That's not New York. The fund is built entirely by employers and what you receive when you file is not a loan or a repayment of your own contributions — it's a benefit you qualified for by working and being laid off through no fault of your own. The only money-related thing employees handle on their end is that unemployment benefits are taxable income. NYSDOL can withhold federal and state taxes from your weekly payments if you opt in, which I'd recommend so you don't get a surprise bill in April.

0 coins

Benefits being taxable income is something I completely forgot about. I'll set up withholding from the start so I don't end up owing in April. Good call.

0 coins

My first year filing I didn't do withholding and owed a chunk at tax time. Learned that lesson the hard way. Always opt in upfront.

0 coins

My HR person also mentioned that the employer not paying into the system enough can sometimes cause processing delays but I don't actually know if that's true? Anyone know if that affects individual claims?

0 coins

HONESTLY I'm so tired of people spreading wrong information about this. YES employees pay into unemployment!! I see it on MY check every week. It says 'UI' right there in the deductions!!

0 coins

Your pay stub is probably showing SDI — the state disability insurance deduction — which IS an employee contribution in New York, but that's a separate program from unemployment insurance. Easy to mix those two up since they both come out of your wages, but unemployment benefits and disability benefits are funded differently.

0 coins

oh. hm. i genuinely always thought that was unemployment. they should label these things better

0 coins

My stub had the same confusing labels when I first started working. SDI and UI look similar and both relate to losing income, so the mix-up is understandable. But yeah, in NY unemployment insurance itself is 100% employer-funded on the payroll tax side.

0 coins

My HR rep explained this to me when I was laid off and she said the employer's experience rate — meaning how often their former employees file successful claims — actually increases what the company pays into the fund over time. So in a way, every layoff the company does costs them more money eventually. Didn't stop them from letting us go but interesting to know.

0 coins

My old company laid off like 40 people in one shot and I always wondered if they even thought about the UI tax impact. Probably not when they're cutting costs I guess.

0 coins

Knowing this doesn't make the layoff sting less but it's slightly satisfying that filing a claim actually has a consequence for the employer down the road.

0 coins

this is kinda wild that the system basically penalizes companies for laying people off. makes sense though

0 coins

My claim is currently in its second week of pending status so I've been deep in research mode. The employer-funded side is straightforward, but I want to add something about the actual filing process since OP mentioned wanting to go in with a clear picture. When you file your initial claim with NYSDOL you'll need your work history for the last 18 months — employer names, addresses, dates worked, reason for separation. The online system at labor.ny.gov is reasonably easy to navigate. After you file, there's usually a one-week waiting period before benefits start. You'll need to certify weekly after that by filing your weekly claim, and you have to meet the job search requirement — currently three work search activities per week.

0 coins

Three activities per week sounds manageable. I was worried it was going to be something like five applications a day. What counts as a work search activity? Just submitting applications or other things too?

0 coins

Applications, interviews, attending job fairs, networking contacts, uploading your resume to a job site, completing a resume or cover letter — NYSDOL has a list. It's broader than just submitting applications which is good because sometimes the application well runs dry.

0 coins

My case worker at the career center told me that attending workshops there counts too. Worth knowing if you get connected with one.

0 coins

The waiting week tripped me up — I thought the first week I was just waiting for approval, didn't realize it was actually the unpaid waiting week. File as soon as you can after your layoff date so that week gets out of the way.

0 coins

My situation last spring was almost identical — logistics company, six years, first time filing. The employee vs employer contribution question was the first thing I Googled. For what it's worth the NYSDOL website does actually explain this in their FAQ section but it's buried a few pages in. The short answer is you contribute nothing directly to the unemployment fund. Your employer did that the entire time you worked there. You just have to meet the eligibility requirements to access it — work enough weeks in the base period, earn enough wages, be unemployed through no fault of your own, be able and available to work, and do your weekly job search.

0 coins

The 'through no fault of your own' part is what I keep thinking about. It was a straightforward layoff, restructuring situation. No performance issues, no voluntary quit. I'm hoping that means adjudication goes smoothly.

0 coins

Layoffs almost always qualify without an adjudication issue. The cases that get flagged are usually voluntary quits, terminations for cause, or when the employer contests the reason for separation. A clean restructuring layoff should be pretty smooth.

0 coins

My layoff was similar and it went through without any adjudication hold. The process felt daunting at first but once I filed it was actually less complicated than I expected.

0 coins

My first claim got stuck because I didn't understand the difference between filing and certifying. After it got sorted out I had to ring NYSDOL a couple times with follow-up questions. Second time around I used Claimyr and that was a much better experience — ended up talking to an actual agent in a reasonable amount of time instead of spending two hours on hold. If OP has questions about their specific wage history or what their benefit rate might look like before filing, talking to an agent directly is worth it.

0 coins

Filing versus certifying — this is exactly the kind of thing I didn't know I didn't know. What's the difference in practice?

0 coins

Filing is the initial application where you set up your claim — work history, reason for layoff, all of that. Certifying is what you do every week after that to claim your weekly benefits. You answer questions about whether you worked, earned any money, did your job search activities. Both have to happen but they're separate steps.

0 coins

My first week I certified and then panicked thinking I'd somehow filed a whole new claim. The system labels are not super clear. But you get used to it after the first couple of weeks.

0 coins

i messed this up my first time too lol

0 coins

My former employer is in a different county and I was worried that complicated things — it doesn't. NYSDOL handles claims statewide, doesn't matter where your employer was located as long as you worked in New York. The payroll taxes your employer paid went into the state fund, not a local fund.

0 coins

My employer was actually headquartered in New Jersey but I worked at a facility in NY. That one did get a little more complicated, had to figure out which state's system applied. Answer was whichever state I physically worked in.

0 coins

The physical work location rule is the right one. I had the same question when my company was incorporated in Delaware.

0 coins

Mine is a New York employer and I worked at a New York facility so at least that part is simple.

0 coins

My cousin worked in HR and explained that the employer's unemployment tax rate in New York starts at a 'new employer' rate and then adjusts every year based on that company's history of claims. Companies with more stable workforces pay less into the fund. Companies that do frequent layoffs end up paying more. The whole system is designed so that the cost of layoffs falls on the businesses doing the laying off rather than on the workers losing their jobs.

0 coins

The experience rating system is actually one of the more logical parts of how UI is designed. It creates at least some financial incentive not to do unnecessary layoffs.

0 coins

doesn't seem to stop anyone though lol

0 coins

My old employer laid off half the warehouse and I guarantee their rate went up. Cold comfort but still.

0 coins

My paperwork from NYSDOL arrived yesterday and I've been going through it. The benefit calculation is based on your highest two quarters in the base period — they add those two quarters together, divide by 26, and that's roughly your weekly benefit amount before hitting the cap. So if you made $18,000 in your two best quarters combined, you'd be looking at around $692 a week but it'd be capped at $504. If your two best quarters combined were under about $26,000 you'd get less than the cap and the formula applies directly.

0 coins

Running the math on my own wages now. My two best quarters were probably around $22,000 combined which puts me somewhere around $846 before cap so I'd be getting the $504 max. That's actually more than I expected at this stage.

0 coins

The cap is frustrating for higher earners but $504 is better than zero. And don't forget you can file for up to 26 weeks in New York on a standard claim.

0 coins

My benefit calculation came out exactly as that formula predicts. Worth noting NYSDOL will send you a Monetary Determination letter after you file that shows all of this officially so you don't have to guess.

0 coins

The Monetary Determination letter is key — it also shows your base period quarters so you can verify NYSDOL has the right wage amounts on file. Errors happen.

0 coins

My layoff notice came the same week as annual review season which felt particularly rough. What helped me was understanding that the unemployment insurance system in New York is actually one of the more comprehensive in the country — the max benefit is higher than many states, the job search requirements are reasonable, and the online filing system actually works most of the time. It doesn't fix the situation but knowing the system is designed to work in your favor helps mentally.

0 coins

Mentally is half the battle right now honestly. Good to hear the system is at least functional.

0 coins

The NY system isn't perfect but compared to what I've heard from friends in other states it's genuinely better in several ways. File promptly and certify on time every week and it mostly runs itself.

0 coins

depends on the week lol adjudication made mine anything but smooth

0 coins

My adjudication hold lasted three weeks and the most useful thing I did was get through to an agent to understand exactly what triggered it. Turned out my employer had filed a separation notice that didn't match what I'd written on my initial claim — just a wording difference in describing the reason for layoff, but it was enough to trigger review. Once an agent explained what NYSDOL needed to clear it, I submitted the right documentation and it resolved within days.

0 coins

This is good to know in advance — the separation reason wording matters and needs to match what the employer says. I'm going to be precise when I describe the layoff on my initial claim.

0 coins

Precision helps. Use clear, plain language about what happened — restructuring, position eliminated, that kind of thing. Avoid anything that sounds like you chose to leave.

0 coins

My adjudication also came from a discrepancy between what I wrote and what HR reported. Getting ahead of it by being clear and consistent in your initial filing saves a lot of back-and-forth.

0 coins

My first week of filing I also wondered whether my employment history would affect how much my employer had to pay into unemployment before I could use it — like a vesting period. There's no vesting. If you meet the base period wage and week requirements, you're eligible. NYSDOL doesn't care how long you were with that specific employer as long as your wages in the base period are sufficient. The minimum is $3,400 in the base period with at least $1,900 earned outside your highest quarter.

0 coins

Six years of steady work there so I'm definitely over those thresholds. Good to have that confirmed.

0 coins

You're in a very straightforward position to qualify. The cases that get complicated are people who worked very part-time or moved between multiple short-term jobs during the base period.

0 coins

Gig workers and people cobbling together multiple part-time jobs have the roughest time meeting the base period requirements. Full-time, long-tenure situations like OPs are the cleanest.

0 coins

My phone attempts to reach NYSDOL this past month were an exercise in patience I didn't have. A friend mentioned Claimyr and after I tried it, I ended up speaking with a live agent at NYSDOL who answered my base period questions in about ten minutes. Sometimes you just need a human to look at your specific wage history and tell you what your likely benefit rate will be, and no FAQ page substitutes for that.

0 coins

Ten minutes with a live agent sounds like a dream compared to what I've been experiencing. I'll look into it before my next attempt to reach them.

0 coins

My agent at NYSDOL was actually really helpful once I got through to one. The challenge is always getting through. Anything that makes that easier is worth it.

0 coins

I've tried the early morning strategy, the right after lunch strategy — the lines are just busy. Having something that handles the hold process for you sounds like a sanity saver.

0 coins

My sister works in payroll and she confirmed something worth adding here: in New York there's also the SDI deduction — state disability insurance — that employees DO pay into. That's the one that covers you if you're out of work due to a non-work injury or illness, not layoff. Some people see that deduction and assume it's unemployment. It's separate. If you're laid off, you're filing for UI, not SDI, and UI is funded entirely by the employer side.

0 coins

THIS is what i was seeing on my check and i really did think it was unemployment this whole time. SDI vs UI is so confusing

0 coins

You're definitely not alone in that confusion. SDI deduction shows up on stubs and it sounds related to unemployment but the two programs are completely separate from each other.

0 coins

The SDI deduction is actually quite small — usually around half a percent of wages up to a certain cap. But visible enough on a stub to cause confusion if you don't know what it is.

0 coins

My initial claim got filed on a Tuesday and by that Thursday I had a Monetary Determination letter in my online account showing my benefit rate. The turnaround was faster than I expected. The online Unemployment Services portal at labor.ny.gov is actually pretty good for tracking where things stand. Set up email notifications so you see when new correspondence arrives — otherwise things can sit in your account unread and you miss response deadlines.

0 coins

Setting up email notifications from the start, noted. I don't want to miss a deadline because something sat in an inbox I forgot to check.

0 coins

Deadlines are unforgiving in the UI system. Appeal deadlines especially — you typically have 30 days from the mailing date of a determination to appeal, and if you miss it the determination stands.

0 coins

My appeal deadline snuck up on me because I didn't realize the clock starts from the mailing date on the letter, not the date I actually opened the envelope. NYSDOL is strict about that.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal clock is one of the more important things to know going in. Mark the date on the determination letter the moment you receive it.

0 coins

ok so reading all this i have a question. what if you quit your job, can you still get unemployment?

0 coins

Voluntarily leaving disqualifies you in most situations, but NY does recognize certain 'good cause' reasons for quitting — like working conditions that became genuinely unsafe, significant reduction in pay, or a compelling personal reason in limited circumstances. It's harder to qualify and usually triggers adjudication review, but it's not automatically disqualifying.

0 coins

what counts as compelling personal reason though

0 coins

The 'compelling personal reason' category is narrow — relocating for a spouse's job is one that sometimes qualifies, serious family caregiving situations in some cases. It's evaluated case by case and you'd need to demonstrate you had no reasonable alternative. Standard job dissatisfaction or a better opportunity don't qualify.

0 coins

My monetary determination arrived with a base period summary that showed slightly lower wages than I expected because one quarter got cut off. That's when I learned about the alternate base period option — if the standard base period (first four of the last five completed quarters) doesn't work in your favor, you can request the alternate which uses the four most recently completed quarters. Worth asking NYSDOL about if your determination comes back lower than expected.

0 coins

The alternate base period is something I'll keep in my back pocket. My reduced-hours months were in an earlier quarter so hopefully the standard base period works out fine, but good to know there's an alternative.

0 coins

Requesting the alternate base period isn't automatic — you have to ask. A lot of people don't know it exists and just accept a lower benefit amount than they might qualify for.

0 coins

My determination was fine on the standard period but I had a friend whose wages were much higher in recent quarters and the alternate made a significant difference in her weekly amount. Always worth running both calculations.

0 coins

My layoff was two months ago and I've been getting weekly benefits without issue since week three. The process is very much a 'set it up once and certify weekly' routine once the initial claim gets approved. The hardest part honestly was getting all my work history together for the initial application and understanding what all the letters NYSDOL sent actually meant. After that the weekly rhythm is pretty simple.

0 coins

Getting past the unfamiliar terminology on those initial letters is exactly what I'm prepping for. Good to hear the ongoing process is simpler once the claim is established.

0 coins

The first determination letter looks intimidating but it's mostly just confirming your base period wages and weekly rate. If the numbers look right, you're in good shape.

0 coins

My weekly certification takes me maybe five minutes now. First week took thirty because I was second-guessing every question. It gets faster.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure