Back to New York Unemployment

Brooklyn Foley

Do churches pay unemployment taxes in NY? Trying to understand NYSDOL rules

My situation is a little complicated and I've been going down a rabbit hole trying to figure this out. I worked as an office coordinator for a mid-sized church here in upstate New York for about four years. When my position was eliminated last spring, I went to file a UI claim through NYSDOL and hit a wall almost immediately. The adjudication process flagged my claim and I haven't been able to get a straight answer about whether my former employer was even contributing to unemployment insurance in the first place. From what I can gather, religious organizations have some kind of special status when it comes to payroll taxes, but I honestly don't know if that applies to unemployment specifically or just FICA stuff. My paystubs never showed any unemployment tax withholding but I know employees don't pay into UI anyway so that's not really telling me anything. What I need to know is whether the church itself was required to pay FUTA or the NY state equivalent, and what happens to my claim if they weren't. Anyone dealt with this before? My claim has been sitting in adjudication for going on six weeks now with zero communication from NYSDOL.

My claim got stuck in almost the exact same kind of limbo last year after leaving a nonprofit. Six weeks with no movement is genuinely rough, and the NYSDOL phone lines make everything ten times harder. At that point I tried Claimyr — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up on the phone with a live NYSDOL agent instead of spending hours redialing. Huge difference for me when I needed real answers fast. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a situation like yours where the employer's tax status is literally the core issue, talking directly to an adjudicator is probably the only way you're going to get movement.

0 coins

Thanks, appreciated. Did you have to explain the nonprofit angle to the agent or did they already have notes on the account?

0 coins

My experience with Claimyr was the same — ended up actually speaking to someone at NYSDOL after days of trying on my own. For church employer stuff especially you want a human, not an automated system.

0 coins

Six weeks and nobody from NYSDOL has reached out is not unusual unfortunately, their adjudication backlog is real. Getting an agent on the line is the move.

0 coins

$1,000 is roughly the threshold that matters here — New York applies what's called the "reimbursing employer" option to churches and certain religious nonprofits rather than the standard tax route. Under that setup, instead of paying quarterly UI taxes into the state fund, the organization pays NYSDOL dollar-for-dollar for any benefits actually paid out to former employees. So your claim can absolutely be valid even if the church never paid traditional unemployment taxes. The hitch is that NYSDOL has to verify which category your employer fell into before they release benefits, and that verification is literally what adjudication is for in your case.

0 coins

Okay so the reimbursing employer piece is what's causing the flag on my claim? That actually makes sense now. Does NYSDOL notify the church that they owe the reimbursement, or does that happen automatically?

0 coins

Exactly right on the reimbursing employer setup. My former employer was a hospital system that did the same thing. The adjudication delay in those cases is NYSDOL waiting to confirm the employer's election status with their own records before approving anything.

0 coins

wait so the church still has to pay, it's just paid differently?? i always thought religious orgs were totally exempt from unemployment stuff

0 coins

Federal law under FUTA actually carves out churches and certain religious organizations — they are exempt from the federal unemployment tax. New York State follows a similar path where religious organizations are not required to pay into the state UI fund the standard way. BUT — and this is the part that trips people up — New York gives religious nonprofits the option to participate voluntarily as either a contributing employer (pays the standard tax rate) or a reimbursing employer (pays back benefits as they're claimed). If your church opted into one of those tracks, your claim should be valid. If they never opted in at all, that's where it gets messy and your claim could get denied or significantly delayed.

0 coins

Mine seems like maybe the third option then — they may have never opted in. What happens to claimants in that situation? Am I just out of luck?

0 coins

HR at my old church job had no idea they even had these options. I found out the hard way when I filed and got the adjudication flag too. Took almost two months to sort out.

0 coins

four years of employment and potentially no unemployment coverage — that is a genuinely terrible situation and NYSDOL needs to communicate this better to employees of religious orgs before it becomes a crisis

0 coins

Churches that never elected coverage — either contributing or reimbursing — essentially means their employees worked outside the UI system the whole time. NYSDOL can still investigate and in some cases compel the employer to pay, but the claimant is usually stuck waiting while that gets sorted. The adjudication flag on your claim is almost certainly NYSDOL trying to figure out which bucket your church falls into before they process anything further.

0 coins

My HR contact at the church has been vague about this when I've reached out. Would NYSDOL tell me directly what they found, or do they only communicate through mail?

0 coins

NYSDOL will typically send a determination letter by mail once adjudication concludes. Your Unemployment Services online account should also update, though sometimes the letter arrives before the system reflects the change.

0 coins

ugh the communication lag from NYSDOL is so frustrating. i've had determination letters show up literally 10 days after the date printed on them

0 coins

Twenty-two dollars per thousand in wages is roughly what the standard NY employer UI tax runs at base rate, so the financial incentive for a small church to never elect coverage is real even if it's legally questionable. What matters for your claim though is the investigation outcome. If NYSDOL determines the church was required to elect but didn't, they have enforcement mechanisms — the employer can be billed retroactively. Your benefits are not necessarily dead in the water even in that scenario, it just takes longer.

0 coins

Retroactive billing to the employer actually helps me feel a bit better about this. I was afraid the adjudication was going to end with just a denial and no path forward.

0 coins

My aunt went through retroactive employer billing after a small nonprofit dispute. NYSDOL collected from the employer and her back benefits were eventually paid, but it was a four-month ordeal total.

0 coins

four months. FOUR MONTHS. how are people supposed to survive while waiting that long

0 coins

Your weekly claims during adjudication — are you still filing them? A lot of people stop filing when their claim is flagged, thinking there's no point. Keep filing every week even while adjudication is pending. If your claim gets approved, you'll get back pay for all the weeks you certified, but only for weeks you actually filed.

0 coins

Yes, still filing every week. I read that somewhere early on and have been keeping up with it.

0 coins

This is so important and not obvious at all. My cousin stopped filing during adjudication and lost weeks of back pay when she was finally approved. She was devastated.

0 coins

NYSDOL does not remind you to keep filing during adjudication, which is a real gap in how they communicate the process to claimants.

0 coins

FUTA exemption for churches gets confused with state UI exemption all the time, and they're related but not identical. The federal exemption just means churches don't file the federal 940 form or pay into the federal fund. New York has its own UI system and its own employer election rules for religious orgs. So when people say churches are exempt from unemployment taxes, they're usually talking about FUTA, not necessarily the state system. Worth knowing when you're trying to explain your situation to an adjudicator.

0 coins

Good to know the distinction before I talk to anyone at NYSDOL. I've been lumping them together in my head.

0 coins

Exactly — and adjudicators at NYSDOL deal with state law, not federal. Coming in with that distinction clear in your mind will make the conversation go faster.

0 coins

honestly I didn't know there was a difference until reading this thread. I always just assumed exempt meant exempt across the board

0 coins

My experience trying to reach NYSDOL about an employer verification issue was brutal — multiple days of busy signals and disconnections before I tried Claimyr. It basically sits on hold for you and you end up speaking directly to an NYSDOL agent. For an employer tax status question like this one, you really do need a human on the other end, not a voicemail box.

0 coins

Worth a shot at this point — six weeks of silence from NYSDOL and I haven't been able to get a person on the phone on my own.

0 coins

Employer verification adjudications are specifically the type that rarely resolve on their own without someone at NYSDOL manually pushing the case forward. Getting an agent involved is not optional in those situations.

0 coins

i've had good luck calling very early, like right at 8am when the lines first open, but even then it's maybe a 40% success rate getting through lately

0 coins

Scroll through your Unemployment Services account under the "Claim Summary" section — there's sometimes a flag description or pending issue listed there that tells you exactly what NYSDOL is waiting on. It's not always populated but when it is, it gives you the specific adjudication reason. Mine said something about employer registration verification, which is basically what yours sounds like.

0 coins

Mine says 'employer coverage eligibility review' which lines up exactly with what everyone's been describing in this thread.

0 coins

Employer coverage eligibility' review is the specific flag for the religious/nonprofit UI election question.'That s your answer — NYSDOL is verifying whether the church electedcoverage.

0 coins

at least you have the flag language. Mine just said 'under review' for weeks with zero additional detail, which was maddening

0 coins

Appeals are your next step if adjudication results in a denial rather than approval. The appeal window in New York is 30 days from the determination date on your letter — not 30 days from when you receive it, from the date printed on the letter itself, so open it and act fast. Appeals go to the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board and you don't need a lawyer, though having organized documentation of your employment, your pay history, and any communication about why you were separated helps a lot.

0 coins

30 days from the letter date, not receipt date — genuinely would not have known that. Saving this.

0 coins

The Appeal Board hearings are conducted by phone usually, and the administrative law judge is generally reasonable if you come prepared. Most claimants represent themselves without issue.

0 coins

I went through an appeal on a different basis and the key was having a written timeline of events with dates. The judge appreciated having something concrete to work from.

0 coins

My job search log while in adjudication status — do I still have to maintain it? I went through a UI adjudication period myself and got confused about whether the job search requirement applies during the investigation. For standard eligibility adjudications it does still apply. For employer-coverage adjudications it may be handled differently but I'd confirm with NYSDOL directly. At the time Claimyr is what finally got me talking to someone who could answer that exact question after I'd been trying to reach anyone there for days.

0 coins

Good question actually — I've been keeping my job search log going just to be safe.

0 coins

Keeping the job search log during adjudication is always the safer move. If the coverage question resolves in your favor, NYSDOL may review prior weeks and you don't want any other basis for a denial to surface.

0 coins

i didn't keep mine for two weeks thinking i didn't need to and then got a whole separate issue added to my claim. do not make that mistake

0 coins

Four years of employment and potentially falling into a gap because of your employer's tax elections — that's a genuinely unfair position to be in as a worker. The religious organization exemption policy was designed around the organizations, not around protecting employees. Workers in that sector should really be asking HR detailed questions about UI coverage before it becomes an issue at separation.

0 coins

HR at smaller religious orgs often has no idea about these distinctions either. My old church's HR was two people sharing a part-time role.

0 coins

The lack of worker notice about employer election status is a real policy gap. You can work for an organization for years and never know you might not be covered until the moment you need unemployment.

0 coins

This is exactly why I think more transparency is needed in onboarding documentation about whether employers are contributing vs. reimbursing vs. exempt

0 coins

8am sharp is when NYSDOL lines open and that is genuinely the best window. After about 9:30am the hold times climb fast. My personal record waiting was about two and a half hours before getting disconnected without ever reaching a person. The employer coverage questions specifically seem to get routed to a subset of agents, not just any available rep, which makes the wait even longer for that type of issue.

0 coins

Two and a half hours and then disconnected — that's genuinely awful. I've had similar experiences.

0 coins

Routing to specialized agents for employer coverage issues is accurate from what I've seen. That's also why it takes longer — there are fewer people handling those specific cases.

0 coins

Wednesday midmorning is statistically the worst time to call any state agency, that's when everyone who failed Monday and Tuesday tries again. Avoid it.

0 coins

Determination letters from NYSDOL adjudication will give you the specific statutory basis for whatever they decide. For employer coverage cases, the determination will cite either Labor Law Section 512 (for religious orgs and their election status) or a related section. The citation tells you exactly what ground you'd be appealing on if needed, and looking up that section helps you understand what documentation to gather.

0 coins

Labor Law 512 is exactly the section that governs reimbursing employer elections for nonprofits including religious organizations. Good citation to know.

0 coins

Having the statutory basis in hand before an appeal hearing is genuinely useful — the administrative law judge goes by those exact sections and your argument will be sharper if you're speaking the same language.

0 coins

Bookmarking the Labor Law 512 reference for when my determination letter comes. At least I'll know what I'm looking at.

0 coins

My sister-in-law works in HR at a large diocese and says most individual churches within a diocese are covered under the umbrella organization's UI election, which means employees of individual congregations affiliated with a larger denomination may actually have coverage they don't know about. If your church was affiliated with a denomination rather than fully independent, it may be worth asking NYSDOL whether the parent organization's election covers you. Claimyr is how she recommended I reach an actual NYSDOL agent when I had my own employer coverage question — took way less time than my previous attempts on my own.

0 coins

My church was part of a larger denomination actually. This is something I had not considered at all — going to ask about umbrella coverage specifically.

0 coins

Diocesan or denominational umbrella coverage is real and it does extend to affiliated congregations in many cases. The NYSDOL employer records would show the election under the parent organization's EIN rather than the individual church's.

0 coins

If the determination letter doesn't mention umbrella coverage and you have reason to believe it applies, that's exactly the kind of thing to raise in an appeal. Adjudicators may not have checked the parent organization's election status.

0 coins

Reimbursing employer elections require the organization to have filed a formal notice with NYSDOL, usually within 30 days of the organization first becoming an employer. If the church never filed that notice and also never paid UI taxes, NYSDOL's position is essentially that the church has no standing as a UI employer at all — which creates the coverage gap you're experiencing. It's a paperwork failure at the employer level that ends up harming employees.

0 coins

Employee harm from employer administrative failures — that describes my situation exactly from a few years back. NYSDOL enforcement eventually caught up with the organization but it took months.

0 coins

The burden falling entirely on the worker to navigate the consequences of their employer's paperwork failures is the core unfairness of the current system design.

0 coins

so basically if your employer never filed the right forms youre just stuck??? thats insane

0 coins

Documentation worth pulling together now regardless of outcome: your complete pay history from the church, your W-2s for the years worked, any offer letter or employment agreement, and any written notice of your position elimination. If the case goes to appeal, that packet covers most of what you'll need. The W-2s are especially useful because they confirm the employer's EIN, which NYSDOL will use to look up the church's election status in their records.

0 coins

W-2s and EIN to cross-reference employer election status — practical and actionable. Already have those pulled.

0 coins

The employer EIN is actually the fastest way for an NYSDOL agent to look up election history. Having it ready when you do get through to someone saves time on the call.

0 coins

Pay history also helps establish that you meet the base period earnings threshold for UI eligibility separately from the coverage question — so it serves double duty in your documentation.

0 coins

My adjudication for a nonprofit employer coverage question lasted nine weeks total before I got a determination letter. The wait is brutal but the letter did eventually come and it explained exactly what NYSDOL found. In my case the organization had filed as a reimbursing employer and the delay was just NYSDOL verifying that filing. Benefits came through retroactively for all weeks I had certified during adjudication.

0 coins

Nine weeks and still resolved correctly — that actually helps. I'm at six weeks and starting to feel like it might go on forever.

0 coins

Retroactive benefit payment for all certified weeks is the best outcome and it does happen. Keeping those weekly filings current is what makes it work.

0 coins

Nine weeks is a long time to be in financial limbo. I hope the OP's situation resolves faster but good to know the system does eventually produce an outcome.

0 coins

Your Unemployment Services account message inbox — check it in addition to waiting for mail. NYSDOL sometimes sends adjudication updates as secure messages in the portal rather than or in addition to paper letters. Not everyone knows the inbox exists or how to find it. Log in, go to 'My Online Services,' and look for a message or notification tab. Mine had an update sitting there for a week before I found it.

0 coins

Checked immediately after reading this — there's actually a message there from two weeks ago I somehow missed. It says they've sent a request for information to my former employer. So they are actively working on it.

0 coins

A request for information sent to the employer is a good sign — it means adjudication is actively progressing, not stalled. Employers usually have 10 business days to respond.

0 coins

Employer response to NYSDOL's information request is what typically triggers the next step in adjudication. If the church responds promptly with their election records, your determination could come relatively soon after that.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure