Can you take a leave of absence from work and collect unemployment in NY?
I've been going back and forth on this for weeks and finally decided to post because I genuinely can't figure out the answer. My employer offered me an unpaid leave of absence starting next month - it's not a layoff, they're not firing me, the job is technically still mine when the leave ends. But I won't be getting any income during that time and I have rent and bills to cover. Someone at work told me you can file for unemployment during a leave of absence but honestly that sounds too good to be true. Has anyone actually been through this with NYSDOL? Does it matter why the leave is being taken? I'm worried that if I file and I'm wrong about being eligible, I'll end up with an overpayment notice later that I can't pay back. My situation is kind of complicated because I didn't request the leave - my employer basically told me operations are slowing down and offered this instead of a temporary layoff. So it's not like I chose to walk away from income voluntarily. Any insight would be really helpful, I feel like I've been reading the NYSDOL site for hours and still can't get a straight answer.
78 comments

Ella Knight
Week two of my own leave situation here and I've been digging into this exact question. The way NYSDOL looks at it really depends on who initiated the leave and whether you're considered 'separated' from employment during the period. If your employer put you on the leave rather than you requesting it yourself, that's closer to a temporary layoff than a voluntary absence - which works in your favor for a UI claim. The key thing NYSDOL asks is whether you're able to work, available for work, and actively looking. That last part is where it gets complicated during a leave because technically your job is waiting for you, so are you really 'available' for other work? They may put your claim in adjudication to sort that out.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorMy employer called it a 'voluntary leave offer' but I didn't feel like I had much choice - it was either this or potentially being let go with no notice. Does framing like that hurt my claim even if the reality was closer to being pushed out?
0 coins
William Schwarz
The adjudication thing is real, almost everyone in a leave scenario gets flagged. Mine sat there for about three weeks before they made a determination. Definitely keep filing your weekly claims the whole time though or you lose those weeks even if you're eventually approved.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
My claim was in a similar gray zone last spring and I'll tell you what I learned the hard way - NYSDOL draws a sharp line between a leave you requested for personal reasons versus one the employer initiated due to business conditions. Personal leave you asked for? Almost always disqualified. Employer-driven reduction leave? Much better shot at approval. When I filed, the adjudicator asked me specific questions about whose idea the leave was and whether I had a guaranteed return date. Having that stuff documented made a real difference.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorDid they contact you in writing or by phone during adjudication? I want to make sure I don't miss anything if they reach out.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
The guaranteed return date question is huge. If your employer gave you a specific date you're coming back, NYSDOL sometimes treats that like a temporary layoff situation which is generally approvable. If the return date is vague or conditional, that can complicate things.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Yep the return date matters a lot. My neighbor went through this and she had a written letter from her employer with the exact return date and it helped her case a lot during the adjudication review.
0 coins
Daniel Price
Three weeks into waiting on NYSDOL to answer my own questions about leave status and I finally cracked and tried Claimyr - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually talking to a live agent instead of getting disconnected after 45 minutes. Got my questions answered in one conversation. If you need to actually speak with someone about whether your specific leave qualifies, it's worth checking out at claimyr.com - there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a leave situation especially, I'd really recommend talking to an agent because the written guidance on the NYSDOL site doesn't cover every scenario.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorHow long did the whole process take once you used it? I keep trying to call during what I think are off-peak hours and still can't get through.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
I've heard about this from a few people now. Getting an actual human on the line seems like the only way to get a definitive answer on edge cases like a leave of absence claim.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
The NYSDOL phone situation is genuinely awful. I tried for four days straight before I gave up and just waited for a letter. For anything complicated like leave of absence eligibility you really need to talk to someone.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
My adjudication letter came with a list of exactly what they wanted to know and I think it covers your situation too. They want to know: who initiated the leave, is there a set return date, are you available to accept other work if something came up during the leave period, and are you meeting the weekly job search activity requirement. That last one trips a lot of people up - even during a leave of absence, if you're collecting UI you still need to complete your three job search activities per week and log them. You can't just say 'my job is waiting so I don't need to look.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorWait, so even if my original employer is expecting me back, I still have to be genuinely applying to other jobs every week? That feels strange but I guess it makes sense from NYSDOL's perspective.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Yes and this is where people get tripped up and end up with overpayment issues later. You have to actually be in the labor market, not just waiting out the leave period. If NYSDOL audits your weekly claims and sees you weren't doing any job searches, they can disqualify you retroactively.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
My cousin did exactly this wrong - took a leave, filed for UI, didn't do the job searches because she figured she was going back anyway, and got hit with an overpayment demand about eight months later. It was a mess.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
Okay I'm going to push back a little on some of what's being said here because I think people are overcomplicating this. My situation was: employer-initiated leave, no specific return date, filed for UI, got approved within two weeks, no adjudication at all. I think a lot depends on how your employer codes the separation reason when NYSDOL contacts them. If the employer says 'business-driven temporary reduction' you're probably fine. If they say 'employee requested leave' you're going to have a fight on your hands.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
What industry were you in? I wonder if some sectors get less scrutiny than others. Mine dragged out forever and I was also employer-initiated.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
Retail, so pretty clear-cut business slow-down. I think if the employer's reason is obviously economic it goes smoother. Construction, hospitality, retail - those get through faster maybe because the reason is less ambiguous.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
This matches what I've seen. The employer's response to NYSDOL when they get the notice is probably the single most important factor in whether a leave claim gets approved quickly or gets stuck.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
My paperwork from NYSDOL after I filed for UI during a leave specifically said I needed to be 'totally or partially unemployed' and that the leave had to result in a complete loss of wages for the week - not just reduced wages. So if your employer is paying you anything at all during this leave, even a small amount, that changes the math significantly. Partial wages get reported and can reduce or eliminate your weekly benefit amount.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorMine is completely unpaid which I think helps - there's zero income coming in from them during the leave period.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
Then you clear that hurdle at least. The totally unemployed requirement is easier when it's a fully unpaid leave. Report exactly $0 from that employer each week when you file your weekly claims and make sure the amount is accurate.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
This is a good point that people miss. Even if the leave is 'unpaid' some employers still pay out accrued PTO during leaves. If that happens to you, those PTO payments have to be reported as wages and they will reduce your UI benefit that week.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
About six weeks into UI during my leave period and I want to share something that helped me. My claim was stuck and I needed specific information about my adjudication status that wasn't showing in my Unemployment Services account online. I used Claimyr to get through to an agent - ended up having a productive twenty minute conversation that cleared up exactly what documentation they needed from me. Got the adjudication resolved within a week after that call. For something as nuanced as leave of absence eligibility, that phone conversation was worth more than everything I read online.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorWhat kind of documentation did they ask you to provide? I want to get ahead of this if possible.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
They wanted a letter from my employer on company letterhead stating the reason for the leave, that it was employer-initiated due to business conditions, and the anticipated duration. The more specific and official-looking the better. If you can get something like that from HR before you even file, it'll help.
0 coins
William Schwarz
That documentation tip is gold. I went back to my employer and asked for exactly this kind of letter after my adjudication started and I think it's what got my claim approved.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
HR letters carry a lot of weight in these cases. I'd make sure it doesn't use language like 'at employee's request' anywhere even if the original conversation about the leave was partly your idea.
0 coins
Eli Wang
My first week filing after a leave situation I was completely lost and honestly I'd still be spinning if I hadn't gotten an actual NYSDOL agent on the phone. Used Claimyr to get there after failing to get through on my own for days. The agent I spoke with explained specifically that for employer-initiated leaves due to lack of work, NYSDOL treats the situation similarly to a temporary layoff for eligibility purposes - it's not automatic approval but it's a much cleaner path than a personal leave you requested yourself.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThat's really reassuring to hear. The 'lack of work' framing is exactly what my situation looks like on the employer's end.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
The 'lack of work' code from the employer makes a huge difference. That's one of the standard separation codes NYSDOL uses and it's the most favorable one for the claimant.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
I didn't know there were specific codes like that. So the employer actually selects a reason category when NYSDOL contacts them? And that affects the determination?
0 coins
Olivia Evans
My experience with NYSDOL adjudication during a leave taught me one thing above everything else: keep filing your weekly certifications no matter what. Even if your claim is stuck, even if you haven't gotten any payments, even if you're not sure you're eligible. You can only collect for weeks you filed for. If you stop filing while you're waiting and then get approved, those weeks you didn't file are just gone. The system doesn't go back and pay you for them.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThis is the third time I've seen this warning in this thread so I'm definitely going to follow it. Weekly claims no matter what, got it.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Seriously, so many people stop filing because they think nothing is happening and then find out they lost weeks of benefits they would have received. File every week, do your three job search activities, document everything.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
My brother in law made this exact mistake. Stopped filing after two weeks thinking the claim was going nowhere, then it got approved and he'd already lost those weeks. Files every single week now no matter what.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
My determination letter when I went through this listed several specific scenarios where leave of absence and UI eligibility intersect and I saved it. The gist: medical leave you requested is almost always disqualified. FMLA leave you initiated is disqualified. Parental leave you requested is disqualified. Leave the employer initiated for business/economic reasons - much more likely to be approved, especially if you can show total loss of wages and you're meeting the able-and-available requirement. The 'able and available' part means you have to be ready to work for another employer too, not just waiting for your old job to restart.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThis breakdown is really helpful. Mine is purely employer-initiated economic reasons, not anything health or family related on my end.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
Then you're in the best category for leave-related UI claims. I'd still document everything carefully and be prepared for adjudication since any leave situation gets extra scrutiny, but the underlying eligibility logic is in your favor.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Went through almost this exact same thing and I'd echo all of this. My claim took about five weeks from filing to first payment but it did get approved. Used Claimyr partway through when I needed to know why it was taking so long - the agent confirmed it was just normal processing for leave cases and nothing was actually wrong with my claim.
0 coins
William Schwarz
My claim experience with NYSDOL during a leave also flagged something nobody else has mentioned yet - the monetary eligibility side. You still need to meet the base period earnings requirements to get any UI benefit at all. If you haven't worked enough in the base period or your wages were low, you might qualify for a minimal weekly benefit or nothing. The adjudication everyone's talking about is about whether the leave counts as unemployment - but you also have to pass the basic earnings test first.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorI've been working full time at this job for about two and a half years so I think I should be okay on the earnings side, but good to know that's a separate piece of the puzzle.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Two and a half years full time should be more than enough to meet the monetary requirements. NYSDOL looks at a base period of about 18 months back from when you file, and you generally need a certain minimum in wages across that time. Full time employment for 2+ years clears that easily.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The monetary side is usually the easy part for people who've been steadily employed. It's the eligibility side - the reason for separation, the leave circumstances, all of that - where leave cases get complicated.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
My experience differed from some of what I'm reading here. My employer originally coded my leave incorrectly when NYSDOL sent them the form - they put 'personal leave at employee request' when it was actually an employer-driven reduction. I had to file an appeal and provide documentation to correct the record. It added six weeks to my wait. If I had to do it again I would have confirmed with HR exactly what they were going to tell NYSDOL before I even filed.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThat's a really important thing to think about - making sure HR and I are on the same page about how to characterize this before anything gets submitted.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
Have that conversation with HR in writing if you can - email is fine. Ask them specifically how they plan to respond to NYSDOL's employer inquiry and what reason code they'll use. Getting that in writing protects you if there's a dispute later.
0 coins
Ella Knight
This is probably the best practical advice in this whole thread honestly. Aligning with HR on the documentation before filing can save you months of fighting.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
An appeal because of a miscoded employer response is way more stressful than getting it right the first time. Definitely worth that HR conversation.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
My HR department didn't even know NYSDOL would contact them when I filed - they'd never dealt with a leave-and-UI situation before. Had to explain the process to them, which was not ideal. The employer gets a notice from NYSDOL asking them to respond with the reason for separation and details about the leave. How they respond within their deadline basically shapes the whole initial determination.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThat's wild that HR didn't know. How did it end up affecting your claim?
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
Caused a delay because they missed the initial response deadline, then NYSDOL had to send a second notice. It pushed my determination back by almost three weeks. When they did finally respond they got the reason right, so at least that part worked out.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
HR missing the NYSDOL response deadline is more common than you'd think. It's worth mentioning to your HR contact that there's a deadline and it matters.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
My reading of the NYSDOL rules on this boils down to something pretty simple to explain: the system was designed to help people who are out of work through no fault of their own. If your employer basically had no work for you and offered a leave rather than a straight layoff, you are out of work through no fault of your own - same underlying situation. The complications come from the technical definition of 'separation from employment' and whether a leave counts as one. For employer-initiated leaves with total loss of wages, NYSDOL increasingly treats them like temporary layoffs. That shift has been pretty consistent over the last few years.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorFraming it that way actually makes a lot of intuitive sense. The economic reality of my situation is identical to a temporary layoff even if the paperwork calls it something else.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Exactly. And if you end up needing to explain your situation to an adjudicator, that's the frame I'd use - not 'I took a leave' but 'my employer had no work for me and offered a leave as an alternative to a layoff.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
The framing you use when you talk to NYSDOL genuinely matters. Words like 'laid off temporarily' versus 'on leave' can send claims down completely different tracks even when the actual situation is the same.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
My weekly claim certifications during the leave period kept asking if I was 'able to work and available for work' and I kept saying yes because I was - I would have taken another job if one came along. But the system also asked if I 'refused any offers of work' which at first confused me because obviously my regular employer wasn't offering shifts. Those questions are designed for all kinds of situations and can read weird when you're on a leave. Just answer them accurately based on your actual circumstances each week.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThe certification questions always worry me a little because I'm scared of answering something wrong. Is there any guidance on what 'available for work' means specifically in a leave scenario?
0 coins
Caleb Stone
My understanding is you're 'available' if you would genuinely accept and start a new job during the leave period if you got one. If your plan is to absolutely return to your original employer and you wouldn't take another offer, that could technically mean you're not fully available. Most people in your situation would take another job if the original one fell through, so they truthfully answer yes.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
The honest answer to 'available for work' is the right answer. If you're not genuinely available because you're committed to returning no matter what, don't say you are. If you would actually consider other work, then yes you are available. NYSDOL isn't trying to trap you, they just need accurate information.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
My claim during a leave got one specific letter about six days after I filed - it was a request for a phone interview with an adjudicator. The letter had a specific date and time and a number to call. I missed the first appointment by accident and panicked, but they did reschedule after I contacted them. If you get one of those letters, do NOT miss the appointment without rescheduling first. Missing it without explanation can delay your claim significantly.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorDoes that phone interview happen with every leave case or only some? And what do they typically ask?
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
From what I could tell, not everyone gets one - it seems to depend on how complex or ambiguous the leave situation looks to whoever reviews the initial claim. Mine asked about the timeline of the leave decision, whether I had anything in writing from my employer, and whether I'd been offered work I turned down during the leave. Pretty straightforward if you're being honest about the situation.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The adjudicator interviews are thorough but not adversarial in my experience. They genuinely seem to be trying to understand your situation rather than catch you in something. Answer clearly and don't volunteer information they didn't ask for.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
My approval finally came through after about four weeks and I want to give some hope here because I saw multiple posts in other forums saying leave of absence claims almost never get approved. That's not been my experience or what I've seen in this thread. Employer-initiated leaves for economic reasons absolutely can be approved for UI. It's not a slam dunk and the process takes longer than a standard layoff claim, but it's very much possible. Used Claimyr at one point when I needed to get an update from NYSDOL that wasn't showing in my online account - the agent I ended up speaking with was helpful and answered my questions directly about my claim status.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorThis is really encouraging to hear. Four weeks feels long but not unbearable if the outcome is approval.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Keep yourself busy during the wait, file every week, do your job searches and document them carefully. The worst thing is letting the anxiety make you do something like stop filing or stop looking for work.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
Four weeks for a leave case is actually pretty reasonable based on what I've seen. Standard layoff claims can be two to three weeks, leave cases often run four to six. As long as you filed correctly and your employer responded accurately, the wait is just the process working.
0 coins
Ella Knight
My experience dealing with NYSDOL taught me to get everything in writing whenever possible. After I finally reached an agent - took me many attempts over many days - I asked them to summarize what I needed to do in my Unemployment Services account and to note in my file what we discussed. That paper trail saved me once when there was a discrepancy in my claim record. For leave cases especially, you want documentation at every step.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorIs there a way to get a written summary from an agent, or is it just notes they put in the system?
0 coins
Ella Knight
Mostly notes in the system that you can't see directly, but you can ask them to send you a letter confirming your claim status or the information discussed. Some agents will, some won't. At minimum write down the name of the agent, the date and time, and what was said right after the call.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
That practice of writing down agent names and call details has helped me twice now when there were discrepancies. Create your own paper trail even if NYSDOL's internal notes aren't accessible to you.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
My situation had one wrinkle I haven't seen mentioned - my leave included a provision that I could be recalled with short notice if business picked up. NYSDOL flagged that as a 'standby' situation and asked whether I wanted to file under standby status versus regular UI. Standby status has different requirements - you can be exempted from some of the job search requirements if you're expected to return to that specific employer within a certain timeframe. Worth asking NYSDOL whether standby applies to your situation if there's a reasonable chance you're going back.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
AuthorI hadn't heard of standby status at all. How is that different from regular UI in terms of what I'd have to do each week?
0 coins
Grace Johnson
Under standby, NYSDOL can waive some or all of the job search activity requirements because you're essentially waiting to return to a specific employer. You still file weekly certifications and report any earnings, but you might not have to do the three job search activities if standby is approved. The tradeoff is you have to be genuinely available to return to your employer quickly when they call.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
Standby status is actually the more accurate category for employer-initiated leaves with an expected return date. If your employer is planning to bring you back and both sides know it, that's exactly what standby is designed for. Definitely worth asking about when you contact NYSDOL.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The standby exemption from job search requirements is a real benefit if it applies. The catch is your employer has to be on board with it and NYSDOL has to approve it - it's not automatic just because you're on a leave expecting to return.
0 coins