Can you get unemployment while college student? NYSDOL situation explained
So I enrolled in an accelerated nursing program at a community college this fall after getting laid off from my hospital admin job in August. My position was eliminated when the hospital restructured their billing department - about 14 of us got let go at once. I filed for UI benefits right away and got approved, but then I mentioned during my weekly certification that I'd started school full time and now my claim is suddenly under review. My question is basically can you get unemployment while college classes are going on, or does being a full time student automatically disqualify you? I'm taking 15 credits which is definitely full time. The program runs Monday through Thursday 8am-2pm. I genuinely thought I could collect while in school as long as I kept doing my job search activities and was available for work. Now I'm panicking that I'm going to be disqualified and have to pay everything back. Anyone dealt with this? My claim is showing 'fact-finding in progress' and I haven't heard anything in almost two weeks.
73 comments

Juan Moreno
15 credits Monday through Thursday, that's a pretty heavy schedule. The 'available for work' requirement is what's going to be the sticking point here. NYSDOL basically wants to know that if an employer called you today and said 'can you start Monday,' you could actually say yes without your school being a barrier. Full time nursing programs are notoriously rigid with attendance.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorMy program does have mandatory clinical rotations starting in spring that are non-negotiable time-wise. I'm worried that's going to look really bad when they dig into the details.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
they usually ask if youre able to rearrange school if you got a job offer. if you say yes they might let it go but honestly nursing programs don't let you just skip clinicals so
0 coins
Alice Pierce
NYSDOL has a specific rule about this that most people don't know going in - being enrolled in school doesn't automatically disqualify you, but you have to meet the 'able and available' test. The key question they ask is whether you're restricting your availability to hours that would prevent you from accepting suitable full-time work. If your class and clinical schedule takes up most of the standard 9-to-5 workweek, they're likely to find that your availability is too restricted. Part-time students or people taking evening/weekend classes usually pass this test a lot more easily.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorEvery single class I have is during daytime hours. There's basically no flexibility in the nursing curriculum sequence either, you can't just swap to evening sections.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
This is the exact situation I was in with a graphic design certificate program. Got denied because all my classes were 9-3 on weekdays. The adjudicator said I was essentially unavailable during core business hours.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
wait so if someone takes like one or two classes at night they would still qualify? asking for a friend lol
0 coins
Elin Robinson
Two weeks of silence on a fact-finding is brutal, especially when bills are piling up. When I had an adjudication issue on my claim, I tried the NYSDOL phone line for nine days straight and kept hitting the 'high call volume' message before getting disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr - basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent instead of burning through your morning hitting redial. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Got to actually speak with an adjudicator who explained exactly what documentation I needed to send in, which sped things up a lot.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorNine days is making me sweat reading that. I'll check out that video tonight. Did the agent give you any sense of how long fact-finding usually takes once someone actually looks at your file?
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
Two weeks with no update and no way to get through on the phone is what pushed me to try Claimyr too. Ended up talking to an agent who told me my file had been sitting unassigned, which explained the delay. Never would have known otherwise.
0 coins
Beth Ford
the hold times right now are genuinely terrible. i sat on hold for 2 hours once and then the line just went dead. glad theres options out there
0 coins
Morita Montoya
There's actually an exception that might help you - NYSDOL has what's called 'approved training' status. If your nursing program was approved by NYSDOL before or shortly after you enrolled, you can sometimes collect benefits even with a full-time school schedule because they waive the availability requirement. The catch is you usually need to have been directed into training, or applied for approval before starting. Did you check with NYSDOL about training approval before you enrolled?
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorNobody mentioned approved training to me when I filed. I just filled out the initial claim, got approved, and started school. Is it too late to apply for that status now?
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Approved training applications can sometimes be retroactive if the program qualifies and you apply quickly. The Trade Adjustment Assistance program covers some workers displaced from certain industries. Hospital billing work probably doesn't qualify for TAA but there are other NYSDOL workforce training programs worth checking.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
I applied for approved training after I already started my program and they did consider it. Took a while to process but I didn't lose my benefits during the review period. Worth trying if you haven't.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
My claim went through something similar when I was taking evening classes - two nights a week - and the adjudicator was actually fine with it because I could demonstrate I was available for full-time day work. The documentation that helped me was a letter from my school showing class times and a written statement from me saying I would drop or reschedule classes if full-time work became available. For a nursing program though I'd be more cautious because those programs don't typically allow that kind of flexibility.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorA written statement saying I'd drop out of a nursing program for a job offer... I honestly don't know if I could say that in good faith given how competitive the application process was to get in.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
That's actually a real issue the adjudicator will probe. If you can't credibly say you'd leave school for a suitable job, they can find that your attachment to the training program limits your availability. It's not just about what you write, they may ask follow-up questions.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
i mean how would they even verify if you would really quit school? seems like you could just say you would
0 coins
Kiara Greene
My situation was a part-time certificate program and I still got flagged for a fact-finding. After weeks of phone tag getting nowhere, Claimyr got me in front of an actual NYSDOL agent who walked me through exactly what the adjudicator needed from me. Turns out I just needed to submit a school schedule and a simple statement about my availability. Whole thing resolved in days after that conversation.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorWeeks of phone tag is what I'm most scared of. I really can't afford gaps in payments right now with tuition on top of everything else.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Same experience here, the documentation piece is key. Once I actually got an agent on the line and understood what to submit, the fact-finding closed faster than I expected.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
full time nursing program is really tough to argue around tbh. i had a friend who tried to claim while in a full time cosmetology program and got denied outright. they said she wasnt available for work during normal hours. she had to pay back a couple months of benefits which was rough
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorPaying back benefits on top of tuition would be catastrophic for me right now. How far back did they go on the repayment?
0 coins
Amy Fleming
they went back to when she started school i think, like 3 or 4 months. she did appeal it but lost. idk if nursing programs are different though
0 coins
Morita Montoya
The overpayment issue is real and worth taking seriously. If the adjudicator determines your availability was restricted from day one of school, the determination could be retroactive to your enrollment date, not just the fact-finding date.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
Part-time enrollment is a game changer for this. After I got denied for my full-time certificate program, I dropped to part-time status - 6 credits instead of 12 - and the determination on my new claim came back approved. The key was showing my remaining class hours were evenings only and I had the majority of business hours available.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorDropping to part time in a nursing program isn't really possible without losing your spot in the cohort. These programs run as a lock-step sequence.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
Yeah that's the brutal part about healthcare programs specifically. You can't just take half the nursing credits and pause the rest. It's a cohesive program or nothing.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
This is why the approved training route is worth pursuing aggressively. If NYSDOL formally approves the training, the standard availability rules get modified and you don't have to drop to part-time to keep collecting.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
does this whole thing depend on what kind of job youre looking for too? like if someone is in nursing school and they apply for nursing jobs that have night shifts wouldn't that show availability during different hours
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Night shift nursing jobs do count as suitable work if you have the credentials, but as a nursing student you're not yet licensed so you can't legally work as a nurse. The job search has to be for work you're actually qualified for right now, which for a former hospital billing person would be administrative or billing roles, mostly daytime.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
oh that makes sense, didnt think about the licensing piece
0 coins
Juan Moreno
There's also the question of whether a nursing student doing clinical rotations could actually take a full-time day job even if they wanted to. The clinicals typically require daytime availability, so the conflict doesn't go away even with night-shift job searching.
0 coins
Beth Ford
Fact-finding dragging into week three now on my claim for a totally different reason and I feel this post in my soul. The uncertainty is the worst part - not knowing if money is coming or if you owe it back.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorWeek three and counting over here too. What's your situation if you don't mind sharing? Trying to figure out if the timeline is similar for different types of reviews.
0 coins
Beth Ford
Mine's about a freelance project I did during my claim period. Reported it, then suddenly fact-finding. Adjudications seem to take anywhere from 2-6 weeks based on what I've read on here.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
6 weeks is brutal when rent is due. The inconsistency in timeline is what gets people - there's no real way to predict it from outside the system.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
my roomate went through this exact thing last year with a full time welding program and they actually approved him after he explained he was doing the program to become more employable and he was still looking for work. maybe it depends on who reviews your case
0 coins
Morita Montoya
Adjudicator discretion is real. The 'more employable' argument maps onto the approved training logic even informally. If you can frame the nursing program as increasing your workforce value and show genuine job search activity, some adjudicators will view it more favorably.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
yeah he said he made sure to actually apply to jobs every week and kept a really detailed log which he gave them. they asked to see it
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorMy job search log is thorough - I've been applying to medical billing coordinator and healthcare admin positions every week. At least that part should be solid.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Weekly certification question about school - how are you answering the 'were you available for full-time work' question each week? Because whatever you've been certifying will be part of what they look at during the fact-finding.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorI've been answering yes to available for full-time work because I genuinely believe I am - I could work evenings and weekends and I haven't turned down any job offers. But I see now how the daytime class schedule complicates that answer.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
That 'yes' answer is actually important for your case. Consistency between your certifications and what you tell the adjudicator matters a lot. If you've been saying available and can explain why you believe that, it's better than having flipped answers across your claim weeks.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
The 'turned down job offers' piece works in your favor too. If no employer has actually offered you a position that you declined because of school, the restriction hasn't been tested in practice.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Tried Claimyr last month during a similar fact-finding situation and I was genuinely surprised - ended up talking directly with an NYSDOL agent within the same morning I signed up. The agent flagged that my file needed a specific form I didn't know about and told me exactly where to upload it in the Unemployment Services portal. The fact-finding closed about five days later.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorFive days after getting the right information from an agent - that's the kind of turnaround I need. I'm going to try it this week.
0 coins
Beth Ford
Five days is so much better than the 'just wait and check your account' advice you get from the main phone line recording.
0 coins
Morita Montoya
Getting direct information about what documentation is needed versus guessing and submitting things randomly is genuinely the difference between a 2-week resolution and a 6-week one.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Approved training under NYSDOL's workforce development programs covers quite a few healthcare fields, nursing included. The process involves submitting a Training Waiver Request form. Even if you're already enrolled, you can sometimes get retroactive approval if the training is on the approved program list and you can show you're in good academic standing.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorTraining Waiver Request - writing that down right now. Do I submit that through my Unemployment Services account or is it a physical form?
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Both options exist depending on the type of training approval. Some are submitted through the online portal under 'correspondence' and some require going to a career center in person. An NYSDOL agent can tell you which applies to your specific program.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Career centers also sometimes have workforce advisors who help people through the training approval process specifically. That's worth a call to your local center too.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
Submitted my school schedule and an availability letter to NYSDOL during a similar fact-finding and the adjudicator actually found in my favor. The letter I wrote was pretty specific - I listed the exact hours my classes ran, explained that I was actively searching for work in my field, and stated clearly that work would take priority over school attendance if a qualifying offer came through. Whether that statement is realistic for a nursing program is a separate question but the format worked.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorFormat of the letter is helpful to know. Did you send it through the correspondence section in Unemployment Services or mail it?
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
Correspondence section in the portal, with 'adjudication' in the subject line. Keep a screenshot of the confirmation that it was submitted.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
screenshotting everything is so important. i learned that the hard way when they said they never got something i definitely sent
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
Hospital billing departments eliminating positions is happening everywhere right now with the coding automation push. Fourteen people laid off at once from your team actually strengthens your claim - mass layoffs from a single employer are well-documented and adjudicators generally don't question the separation. Your issue is purely the school availability question, which is a narrower problem to solve than people who have messy separation circumstances.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorThat's a good reframe actually. At least the reason I'm unemployed isn't the problem - it's just the school piece.
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
Exactly. Focus your energy on the availability documentation rather than re-explaining the layoff. The layoff itself is clean.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
wait im confused about something - if you get denied from unemployment for being in school full time can you appeal that? or is the determination just final
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Appeals are absolutely an option. After a determination is issued you have 30 days to file a formal appeal with the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. The hearing is conducted by an administrative law judge and you can present evidence and testimony about your availability. Many people win on appeal when the initial determination was based on incomplete information.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
ok so it's not over even if you get denied initially. that's good to know
0 coins
Morita Montoya
The appeal process is worth taking seriously if it comes to that. Bring your job search log, school schedule, any documentation of job offers you received or applied to, and the availability letter if you wrote one. First-time appeal success rates are higher than people expect when the claimant shows up prepared.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
genuinely didn't know you could be on unemployment and in school at the same time. thought it was totally banned. learning things today
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Part-time students with daytime availability can and do collect UI regularly. The rule isn't about being in school at all - it's about whether the school schedule prevents you from accepting suitable work. A lot of people assume it's automatic disqualification and don't even try to claim.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
i wish i had known that when i took a couple classes online after my last layoff. probably would have still tried to file
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
My fact-finding resolved two weeks ago and I wanted to come back here with what actually happened. The adjudicator sent a questionnaire to my Unemployment Services account - I almost missed it because it was in the 'notices' section, not 'messages.' Check both sections in your account religiously. Missing their questionnaire deadline is what actually tanks people's claims.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
AuthorChecking right now - I only ever look at the main page and messages. If there's something in notices I haven't seen that would explain everything.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Log in and go directly to the Notices tab. Questionnaires during fact-finding often appear there with a 10-day response window that starts when they post it, not when you see it.
0 coins
Beth Ford
This is genuinely critical information. I had a questionnaire sit there for 8 days before I found it. Responded with 2 days left and it was fine but I had no idea that section existed.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
NYSDOL considers the questionnaire delivered when it posts in your account, so the clock is running whether you've seen it or not. That notices section needs to be part of everyone's weekly claim routine.
0 coins