Back to New York Unemployment

Sofia Hernandez

Can you get unemployment if you quit NYC job? My NYSDOL situation

So I walked off my job at a logistics company in Queens about three weeks ago and I'm now wondering if I completely torpedoed my chances at getting any UI benefits. It wasn't some impulsive thing — my supervisor had been scheduling me for shifts that conflicted with a medical appointment series my doctor had me on, and HR basically told me to deal with it or leave. After six weeks of that back and forth I finally just left. Now I'm sitting here staring at my NYSDOL claim that says 'adjudication in progress' and I have no idea if quitting means I'm automatically disqualified or if there's actually a path to getting approved. I reported that I left voluntarily when I filed but I also uploaded a note from my doctor and some emails I saved from HR. Did I just waste my time filing? Has anyone actually gotten through adjudication after quitting a job in NYC?

Week two of adjudication myself right now so I've been reading everything I can find on this. From what I understand, NYSDOL doesn't automatically disqualify you just because you quit — they look at WHY you quit. The magic phrase they use is 'good cause.' If your reason for leaving was something a reasonable person in your shoes would also have left over, that can count. Medical reasons connected to your job conditions are specifically listed as examples in NYSDOL guidance. You filed exactly right by uploading the doctor's note and those HR emails. Those are going to matter a lot.

0 coins

My termination paperwork says 'voluntary separation' which I keep worrying about. Does that specific wording hurt me in adjudication?

0 coins

Voluntary separation just means you weren't fired — NYSDOL already knows that because you told them you quit when you filed. That label doesn't close the door, it just triggers the adjudication review to figure out if your reasons qualify as good cause.

0 coins

I had 'voluntary separation' on mine too, two months back. Got through adjudication approved after about five weeks. The form language isn't the deciding factor.

0 coins

Three weeks into my own adjudication when I finally got through to an actual NYSDOL agent and it changed everything for me. I'd been trying the phone lines for days with nothing but busy signals and disconnects. A friend told me about Claimyr — claimyr.com — the idea is that it sits on hold with NYSDOL so you don't have to, and you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. The agent I eventually talked to walked me through exactly what documentation the adjudicator was looking at and what I still needed to send in. For a quit situation especially, being able to actually talk to someone about the specifics of your case is worth a lot.

0 coins

I've been trying to get through on the phone all week. Every time I dial I either get a busy signal or sit on hold for two hours and then get cut off. I'll look into Claimyr.

0 coins

The phones at NYSDOL are genuinely brutal. I spent four days trying before I gave up and sent a message through the Unemployment Services portal instead. Got a form response two weeks later that didn't answer my actual question. Some people have better luck calling right at 8am.

0 coins

Early mornings helped a little but I still wasn't getting through consistently. That's why I went with Claimyr. Actually talking to an agent was the only thing that gave me real answers about my specific claim.

0 coins

I had no idea this existed. I've just been refreshing my account page every morning hoping something changes.

0 coins

My quit was about two years ago and I want to lay out what NYSDOL actually looks at, because there's a lot of confusion about this. The question you want to put to any agent you reach is: does my reason for quitting fall under a compelling circumstance that left me no real choice? That's the frame NYSDOL uses. They look at whether you tried to fix the situation before leaving — did you report the scheduling conflict to HR? Did you ask for accommodation? Did you give the employer a chance to resolve it? Then they look at whether your documented reason (medical, in your case) was real and verifiable. The doctor's note and those HR emails you uploaded are directly responsive to both of those questions. The adjudicator is essentially going to ask: would a reasonable employed person have stayed under those conditions? If the answer is no, that's good cause.

0 coins

My paper trail with HR goes back almost two months — emails, one written warning I got for missing a shift because of an appointment, and my doctor's note recommending the specific schedule I was asking for. Is that enough to show I tried before leaving?

0 coins

Two months of documented back and forth plus a written record of discipline they handed you over a medical appointment — that's actually a strong paper trail for a quit case. The fact that HR gave you a warning for attending a medical appointment rather than accommodating it strengthens the argument that you had no real alternative but to leave.

0 coins

I didn't know any of this when I filed after quitting last year. I didn't upload anything, just said I quit for personal reasons. Got denied immediately. Had to appeal and it took months. Upload everything you have while you're in adjudication, don't wait.

0 coins

My situation was different — I quit a retail job over hours but it wasn't medical — and I got denied. But I want to say something about the NYC part of your question because I see people mix this up. Your NYC location doesn't change the NYSDOL rules that apply to you. The state standards for good cause are the same whether you worked in Manhattan, Queens, Buffalo or anywhere else in New York. Where NYC comes into it is just the specific Career Center you'd be assigned to if you need in-person services.

0 coins

Good to know, I wasn't sure if NYC had separate rules or anything. I know the Career Center near me in Queens has specific job search requirements but I assumed the actual claim eligibility was state level.

0 coins

Exactly right. Career Center requirements, job search logs, those can have local variations in terms of which office handles things, but whether your quit qualifies is purely a state determination made by NYSDOL adjudicators.

0 coins

I actually asked an agent about this directly because I worked in the Bronx but live in New Jersey — the eligibility determination is 100% based on where you worked, and the state rules that apply are New York's because that's where the wages were earned.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost exactly this — medical thing, job wouldn't work with her, she finally quit — and she got approved. It took about six weeks total in adjudication but she got it. Her advice was to not stop filing your weekly claims during adjudication. Even if nothing is showing as approved, you need to keep certifying every week or you lose those weeks even if you eventually get approved retroactively.

0 coins

I've been certifying weekly, yes. I figured I should keep doing that regardless. Good to know that's the right call.

0 coins

100% keep certifying. I forgot one week during my adjudication and when I finally got approved I had a gap week I never recovered.

0 coins

This is so important and nobody tells new claimants. Keep filing those weekly claims no matter what your status says.

0 coins

Agreed. My claim was stuck for eight weeks and I kept certifying the whole time. When it resolved I got all eight weeks paid out at once.

0 coins

My experience quitting and filing was not great at first but I want to push back on the idea that you're automatically in trouble. I quit a healthcare admin job over what I would call hostile scheduling after I told them about a chronic health issue. My initial determination came back denied, I appealed, and the appeal board sided with me. The appeals process exists exactly for situations where the initial adjudicator gets it wrong. I'm not saying you'll need to go that route — your documentation sounds better than mine was initially — but if you do get denied, that is not the end of the road.

0 coins

How long did your appeal take from start to finish?

0 coins

My appeal was filed in early spring and I had a hearing scheduled within about seven weeks. The actual decision came maybe three weeks after the hearing. So call it roughly ten to eleven weeks total from appeal filing to resolution. During that whole time I kept certifying weekly.

0 coins

I went through an appeal process myself after a quit denial and during the whole thing I was trying to track down my employer's documentation through NYSDOL. I ended up using Claimyr to get an agent who could actually look at my case file and tell me what documentation the employer had submitted so I could respond to it. Without talking to that agent I'd have been responding blind.

0 coins

My whole adjudication was resolved by getting the right agent on the phone, honestly. The portal gives you nothing — just the same 'adjudication in progress' screen. I called probably a dozen times over three weeks before I got through to someone who could actually look at my file. When I did, she told me my claim was stuck because the system had flagged a wage discrepancy from a part-time job I'd had two employers back. Had nothing to do with why I quit. If I hadn't gotten through to ask, I'd still be waiting with no idea why.

0 coins

This is exactly what worries me — that there's some flag on my claim I don't even know about. The portal really does show nothing useful.

0 coins

Ask an agent specifically: is there anything flagged on my claim that's causing a delay separate from the standard adjudication review? That question got me the actual answer immediately when I finally got someone on the line.

0 coins

The portal hiding what's actually happening with your claim is one of the most frustrating things about this whole process. At least when you can get an agent they can see the actual notes.

0 coins

My job search requirements while in adjudication — I want to flag this for you since you're in NYC. Even while your claim is pending adjudication, NYSDOL expects you to be doing your three job search activities per week and logging them. If your claim gets approved and they pull your records and see gaps in job search activity during the adjudication period, that can create new issues. Keep your log current.

0 coins

I've been doing the job search activities but I've been sloppy about logging them in the system. How far back can I enter activities retroactively in the portal?

0 coins

My understanding is you can enter them same week or the following week but after that it gets complicated. I'd enter what you have now and be more consistent going forward. If you have emails, LinkedIn activity or any other record of the actual searches you did, hold onto those in case questions come up.

0 coins

My adjudicator asked about my job search activity when I spoke with her, so definitely don't let that slip. It's one of the things they can use to deny benefits even after your quit issue is resolved.

0 coins

My denial letter when I first filed after a quit laid out exactly what NYSDOL wanted me to prove on appeal. The letter actually cited the specific statutory language around voluntary separation and good cause. If you get a denial — which isn't guaranteed, your situation sounds defensible — read that letter word for word because it's essentially a roadmap. Mine told me I needed to show I reported the problem to management before quitting. I had done that, I just hadn't submitted the evidence. Appeal + evidence = approval for me.

0 coins

I really hope I don't need to go the appeal route but it's good to know the denial letter itself explains what they need. I've been so worried this would just be a black box.

0 coins

It's not a black box once you get the denial, ironically. The initial adjudication is the black box. After that the process becomes more transparent.

0 coins

This matches my understanding too. The appeals system is actually more navigable than the initial adjudication because you get a real hearing with a real person instead of just a faceless review.

0 coins

My situation involved quitting after my commute changed dramatically when my employer relocated. I want to mention that NYC-specific circumstances can actually support a good cause argument in certain ways — if your employer required something that's genuinely unreasonable in a New York City context (commute, schedule, conditions), NYSDOL adjudicators are aware of what's reasonable in this environment. A three-hour subway commute change in NYC is different from the same commute change somewhere else.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about it from that angle. Mine was about medical appointments but I could see how a reasonable person standard in NYC specifically might look different from other places.

0 coins

Exactly. 'Reasonable person' isn't totally abstract — it's a reasonable person in that situation, and the adjudicator knows what working in this city is actually like.

0 coins

I'd be careful about leaning too hard on the NYC angle in a formal argument — the statutes don't carve out geography explicitly. The reasonable person standard is the standard, it just gets applied to your actual facts, which happen to be NYC facts.

0 coins

My weeks of trying to reach NYSDOL finally ended when I used Claimyr. I'd spent three weeks hitting redial and sitting on hold with no result. With Claimyr doing the hold-waiting for me, I eventually got to speak with an actual agent at NYSDOL who had my file open and could answer specific questions about my quit case. The thing that helped me most was being able to ask what the adjudicator's notes said and what, if anything, was still missing from my file.

0 coins

My phone attempts have been exactly that — just hold music and then a disconnect. I might actually try this.

0 coins

My honest take: for a quit case especially, being able to have a real conversation with an agent who can see your specific file is worth figuring out. The portal just doesn't give you enough information to know what's actually happening.

0 coins

I wish I'd known about Claimyr when I was going through my denial last year. I spent weeks not knowing what was in my file and by the time I found out it was almost too late to get the right evidence together for the appeal.

0 coins

My adjudication after a quit went about seven weeks total and here is what I'd tell anyone going through this right now: the NYSDOL adjudicator is not trying to find a reason to deny you. They're trying to determine whether your situation meets the legal definition. I know it feels adversarial but the person reviewing your file is doing a job, not building a case against you. Medical documentation plus documented attempts to resolve the situation before leaving is exactly the evidence they're looking for.

0 coins

That reframe actually helps. I've been thinking of this as me versus the system but it's really just a review process.

0 coins

It is a review process and your documentation actually sounds like it was put together well. The doctor's note plus the HR email chain is a solid foundation. Just keep certifying and try not to spiral while you wait.

0 coins

Easier said than done when bills are coming in. But the advice is right. I spent so much mental energy catastrophizing during adjudication that I wasn't spending it on the job search, which I actually needed to maintain.

0 coins

My adjudication resolved after I finally got an agent to actually read me the notes in my file. For anyone stuck in the 'adjudication in progress' loop — when you do eventually get through to a live person, specifically ask them to tell you what's in the case notes and whether the adjudicator has requested anything from your employer. That second part matters a lot. Sometimes your employer is the one holding up the process because NYSDOL sent them a request and they haven't responded.

0 coins

I hadn't even considered that the holdup might be on my employer's end. Is there anything I can do if the employer is dragging their feet responding?

0 coins

My agent told me there's a timeframe employers are supposed to respond within and after that the adjudicator can proceed without their response. So if your employer is slow, it doesn't necessarily mean you're stuck forever — there's a deadline they have to work within.

0 coins

I found this out the hard way. My former employer never responded to NYSDOL's inquiry and my claim was processed after a certain number of days anyway. The agent I spoke to said that happens fairly often.

0 coins

My first filing after a quit was rejected within days, before I'd even uploaded any documentation. That was my mistake — I filed first and then tried to add evidence later, but the initial decision had already been made. If you haven't uploaded everything yet, do it now before adjudication closes. Don't wait for them to ask. Send the doctor's note, the HR emails, anything that shows the conditions you were working under and the steps you took to fix them before leaving.

0 coins

I uploaded the main documents when I filed but I have some additional emails I found since then. I'll go in and add those to my file today.

0 coins

Yes, do it now. The portal lets you upload additional documents to an open claim. Every piece of evidence that's in your file before the adjudicator makes their decision is better than evidence you're submitting after a denial in an appeal.

0 coins

My appeal was entirely because I didn't upload documents upfront. I had the evidence, I just didn't know I was supposed to submit it proactively. The portal makes it feel like they'll ask you if they need something, but they often just decide based on what's there.

0 coins

My whole adjudication process made me realize how much these cases turn on the specific wording you use when you describe why you left. 'I quit because of scheduling conflicts' sounds very different from 'I left after my employer refused to provide reasonable accommodation for documented medical treatment despite repeated written requests.' The underlying facts might be identical but the framing tells NYSDOL something very different about whether you had a good-faith attempt to stay employed.

0 coins

I described it as scheduling conflicts in my initial filing. Should I be trying to update or expand that description somehow?

0 coins

My suggestion would be to upload a written statement — just a clear, organized paragraph — that explains the full picture in that more complete way. You can add it as a document upload. It's not changing your answer, it's just providing context your original one-line response couldn't capture.

0 coins

This is good advice. The adjudicator reads whatever is in the file. A one-line description gives them one line to evaluate. A thorough written statement with the timeline and your attempts to resolve it gives them a real picture of what happened.

0 coins

My claim has been in adjudication for five weeks now after a quit and I found this thread looking for anyone with a similar situation. The uncertainty is the hardest part. I called NYSDOL probably thirty times across two weeks and I don't think I actually spoke to a human being once. I either got a busy signal, hit the automated system, or got disconnected somewhere in the hold queue. At this point I'm just refreshing my portal page and hoping.

0 coins

Five weeks of that phone situation sounds exhausting. When I was in the same spot I ended up trying Claimyr and it was the first time I actually reached a live agent. Knowing what was actually happening in my file — even when the news wasn't perfect — was way better than the total silence from the portal.

0 coins

I'll try it. At this point I'd try anything to get actual information. Five weeks of zero communication from NYSDOL while bills pile up is not sustainable.

0 coins

Hang in there. Five weeks feels like forever but it's not unusually long for a quit adjudication in my experience. The question is whether anything is flagged that you don't know about — that's why getting a live agent matters.

0 coins

My denial after quitting felt like a gut punch at the time, but looking back I didn't give the adjudicator enough to work with. I said I quit for health reasons but I didn't upload anything, didn't document my communications with my employer, and my description in the initial filing was about three sentences. If I could redo it, I'd have submitted a full timeline document, every email I had, and my doctor's written recommendation. I ended up getting approved on appeal but those months between the denial and the appeal decision were brutal.

0 coins

I really appreciate you sharing this. I've been feeling like the portal is so minimal that there's nothing more I can add, but it sounds like you can actually put a lot more in there.

0 coins

You absolutely can add documentation. Think of your file like a legal brief — the adjudicator can only evaluate what's in it. More evidence of the right kind doesn't hurt you, it helps.

0 coins

The appeal process is real and it works, but it's slow and stressful. Front-loading your evidence in the initial adjudication is so much better if you have it available.

0 coins

My question to anyone reading this thread who's also in adjudication after a quit: are you still doing your required job search activities every week? Because I see a lot of people so focused on the adjudication that they let the job search logging slide, and that can open up a whole separate problem. Your eligibility for each week's benefits depends on you being able and available and actively looking for work. Keep those three activities logged per week in the portal no matter what else is happening.

0 coins

Yes, I've been keeping up with the job search activities. I log them when I do them, which has been every week.

0 coins

You're doing it right. I know people who got their adjudication approved after a quit only to have weeks denied because their job search log had gaps. Don't give them a separate reason to deny individual weeks.

0 coins

I had a conversation with an agent who specifically told me that adjudication approval and weekly eligibility are two separate determinations. You can win on the quit issue and still have weeks denied if your job search requirements weren't met.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure