Can you get unemployment if fired for absences? My NYSDOL claim just got flagged
My employer terminated me two weeks ago and the reason they put on my separation paperwork was 'excessive absences.' Here's the thing though - every single absence I had was either covered by a doctor's note or I called in advance and got verbal approval from my supervisor. I never just ghosted shifts or anything like that. Filed my UI claim with NYSDOL right after I lost my job and now it's sitting in adjudication with no movement. I'm genuinely unsure whether absences count as misconduct under New York unemployment rules or if the fact that they were documented and approved changes anything. My Unemployment Services portal just says a determination is pending and there's no timeline. Has anyone been through this specific situation where you were fired for attendance but had legit reasons backing up each absence? Did NYSDOL approve you or deny you?
79 comments

Zainab Ahmed
My situation was almost identical - fired for attendance after a string of medical absences, all with documentation. The way NYSDOL looks at it, 'misconduct' has a specific meaning that's different from just being fired for a performance or attendance issue. What ended up mattering in my case was whether I had a pattern of willful disregard for my employer's rules or whether I had genuine reasons each time. NYSDOL approved my claim because I could show every absence had a cause I didn't create on purpose. Keep all your doctor's notes and any texts or emails where your supervisor acknowledged or approved time off - those are going to be your strongest evidence if this goes to a determination interview.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorMy supervisor's approvals were all verbal, nothing in writing. Is that going to be a problem if NYSDOL asks me about it?
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
Verbal approvals are harder to prove but not useless. Write down the dates and what was said while your memory is fresh. If there were any witnesses to those conversations that helps too. NYSDOL will also contact your former employer for their version so having your timeline tight matters.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
My HR manager told me after I was let go that verbal approvals 'don't count' in their records - which is exactly what they said to NYSDOL too. Make sure you're really thorough documenting what you remember.
0 coins
Yara Abboud
Absences by themselves don't automatically disqualify you from UI - the question NYSDOL asks is whether what you did rose to the level of 'misconduct.' Missing work repeatedly even if you get fired for it isn't necessarily misconduct in the legal sense unless you were deliberately ignoring warnings and had no good reason. Attendance issues caused by illness or family emergencies tend to fall on the side of not being misconduct. The adjudication process exists specifically to sort this out, so them flagging your claim isn't the same as denying it - it just means they want more info.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHow long does adjudication typically run for a separation dispute like this? I've seen everything from two weeks to two months mentioned on here.
0 coins
Yara Abboud
Realistically in New York right now, four to six weeks is pretty common for a separation-related adjudication. Some people have waited longer. The frustrating part is NYSDOL won't usually give you a heads up before they reach out - you just have to keep checking your portal and certifying your weekly claims in the meantime.
0 coins
PixelPioneer
Six weeks seems optimistic honestly. My adjudication for a firing case ran almost nine weeks before I got a determination letter. Keep certifying no matter what though.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Spent two and a half weeks trying to get through to NYSDOL on the phone while my claim sat in adjudication with no explanation. Tried mornings, tried afternoons, got disconnected more times than I can count. A coworker told me about Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows what it does. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually speaking with a live agent there. Got through the same day I tried it. The agent told me exactly what document they needed to move my claim forward - saved me weeks probably.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorLooked up that video just now. Honestly at this point I'm willing to try anything because getting through on my own has been a complete disaster.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Tried it myself after seeing it mentioned somewhere else. Ended up with an agent on the line within a few hours and she actually pulled up my claim while we talked and explained the whole adjudication status.
0 coins
Amina Sy
My whole thing with services like this is I'm not sure why NYSDOL can't just answer the phone. But if it works it works I guess.
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
Worth knowing that NYSDOL will send both you AND your employer a questionnaire during adjudication for a fired-for-cause situation. Your former employer has to respond within a certain window and if they don't respond, that actually often works in your favor. Keep an eye on your mail AND your Unemployment Services inbox because the questionnaire can come either way and there's usually a deadline to respond. Missing that deadline can really hurt your case.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorChecked my Unemployment Services portal inbox and there's nothing there yet. How do I know if the questionnaire already went out?
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
Your portal won't always tell you when a questionnaire is sent, only when a determination is issued. If it's been more than three weeks since you filed, try to reach an agent to confirm the questionnaire stage - that's the main reason it helps to actually get someone on the phone.
0 coins
Natasha Ivanova
My questionnaire came by postal mail and I almost missed it because it got buried in junk mail. Check everything carefully.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
NYSDOL DENIED ME the first time for absences and I appealed and WON. The key was I had a whole folder of documentation - my attendance log I kept myself, the doctor's notes, and printed emails where HR had acknowledged my FMLA request even though I wasn't technically on approved FMLA at the time. The appeals process is real and it works if you have your documentation organized. Don't give up if you get a denial.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHow long did your appeal take from filing to the hearing date?
0 coins
NebulaNomad
My hearing was scheduled about six weeks after I filed the appeal, then the written decision came about two weeks after the hearing. So roughly eight weeks total from appeal filing to final answer. It felt like forever but I kept certifying my weekly claims the whole time and when I won, the back pay came through for all those weeks.
0 coins
Javier Garcia
My appeal hearing was totally by phone which I didn't expect. Having notes and documents in front of me really helped since the judge moved through things quickly.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
Eight weeks is actually pretty fast for an appeal hearing. Mine took almost four months to get scheduled. Location probably matters a lot.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
ok so I'm confused about something reading this thread - does 'adjudication' mean they think you did something wrong already or is that just normal for any firing situation? asking bc my claim also says pending adjudication and I was fired for being late too many times
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
Adjudication just means they're reviewing it - doesn't mean you did anything wrong or that denial is coming. Any time there's a question about why you left a job, whether fired or quit, it goes to adjudication. It's routine for separation disputes.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
oh ok that's a relief I was panicking thinking it meant I was definitely getting denied
0 coins
Yara Abboud
Lateness cases can go either way similar to absences - if the lateness was caused by something outside your control like a medical condition or transportation issues NYSDOL tends to be more sympathetic than if there were warnings you ignored repeatedly.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
My termination paperwork said 'attendance policy violation' and my NYSDOL claim was approved without even going to a full hearing - they just did the questionnaire process and determined it wasn't misconduct. The thing that helped me was that my doctor had faxed documentation to HR on three separate occasions and I had copies. The more paper you have the better your position honestly.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorMine went to adjudication though even with documentation. Does that mean my situation is more complicated than yours was?
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Not necessarily - adjudication doesn't tell you much about which way it'll go. Some claims with tons of documentation still get flagged just because the employer contests it. The questionnaire and adjudication are just how they gather info to make the call.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Employer contesting it almost always triggers adjudication regardless of how strong your documentation is. That's normal.
0 coins
CosmosCaptain
Three different people at NYSDOL told me three different things when I asked about misconduct and absences. First agent said I'd probably be denied, second said I'd probably be approved, third actually walked me through the standard they use. The third one explained that they look at whether the behavior was willful - meaning did you just not care about showing up versus did you have reasons outside your control. Illness with documentation is about as far from willful as you can get.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHow did you manage to get through to agents three times? I've been trying for days and can't get anyone.
0 coins
CosmosCaptain
Honestly the first two times were luck - called right when they opened and somehow got through. The third time I used Claimyr and that one was the most useful conversation I had. The agent actually had my file open and could see specific notes on my claim.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
Calling right when they open at 8am used to be the trick but lately even that isn't reliable for getting through quickly.
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
My claim for the same type of situation - fired for missing too many days even with doctor's notes - took almost seven weeks in adjudication. The worst part was not knowing anything for weeks at a time. When I finally needed to actually understand what was happening with my claim I ended up using Claimyr and it was the first time anyone at NYSDOL explained the process to me directly. The agent noted in my file that I had documentation ready which I think helped move things along.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorSeven weeks is a long time to go without income. Were you able to get any advance or partial payment during that period?
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
No advance - the payments were all held until the determination came through. When I was approved the full back amount for all the certified weeks hit my debit card within a few days. That part at least went fast.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
My situation dragged out similarly and the financial stress of waiting through adjudication was brutal. The not knowing is the worst part for sure.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
My HR department actually told me when I was fired that I 'wouldn't qualify for unemployment' - which turned out to be completely wrong. They say that sometimes to try to discourage people from filing. Absences that are documented and approved are very different from walking off the job or getting caught stealing. File your claim, respond to every NYSDOL communication promptly, and don't let your former employer's HR rep make you think you're automatically disqualified.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorMine said something similar - basically implied I'd be wasting my time filing. Glad I did anyway.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
They almost always say that. HR's job is to protect the company not to advise you on your rights. NYSDOL makes the actual determination based on the facts, not on what HR tells you.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
my HR said the exact same thing lol. filed anyway and got approved. dont listen to them
0 coins
PixelPioneer
Calling NYSDOL during the adjudication waiting period became almost a part time job for me. Hold times over two hours, getting disconnected, starting over. The whole experience was demoralizing. Eventually a friend suggested Claimyr and I ended up talking to an agent that afternoon after weeks of trying on my own. She confirmed my questionnaire had been received and told me the adjudication was nearing its final stages.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorTwo hour hold times and then getting disconnected sounds absolutely miserable. At least you eventually got through to someone useful.
0 coins
PixelPioneer
The disconnections were the worst part - sitting through two hours of hold music and then getting cut off right when you hear a live voice. Using Claimyr meant I didn't have to do any of that sitting and waiting myself.
0 coins
Natasha Ivanova
Got disconnected twice after long waits and both times I was so demoralized I didn't try again that day. That's how weeks go by without getting any answers.
0 coins
Javier Garcia
My adjudication determination came in the mail rather than through the portal and I almost missed it. The letter said I was approved and explained that my absences didn't meet the threshold for misconduct because they were medically documented. NYSDOL's standard basically says if you had real reasons and weren't just blowing off work, it's not misconduct even if your employer had every right to fire you for it. For what it's worth I had to reach an agent once during my process and used Claimyr to do it - ended up with someone on the line who could actually look at my claim status directly.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorThe portal vs mail thing is confusing to me - should I be watching both equally?
0 coins
Javier Garcia
Watch both for sure. My determination came in the mail but other notices had come through my Unemployment Services inbox. No consistent rule about which way different documents arrive.
0 coins
Yara Abboud
Physical mail can get lost or delayed. If your portal shows a status change that you don't understand, calling to ask about it is worth the effort even if getting through is hard.
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
Signed up for email notifications in my Unemployment Services account which helped - at least I got an alert when anything changed even if the actual document was mailed.
0 coins
Amina Sy
Absences are tricky bc companies write up the reason as 'policy violation' on the separation paperwork which sounds bad but that phrase on its own doesnt mean anything to NYSDOL. The actual question is what was happening behind that policy violation. Most people I know who had documented medical absences got approved eventually even if there was a delay in adjudication.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorMine literally says 'violation of attendance policy' on my termination letter. Is that going to be the first thing NYSDOL sees?
0 coins
Amina Sy
Yeah that's what your employer will report on their side too. But NYSDOL digs deeper than the label - the questionnaire they send is where you explain the actual circumstances.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
The separation code the employer puts on the initial notice isn't the final word on anything. It's just the starting point for adjudication.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
My termination was for absences related to a mental health situation and I was honestly afraid to disclose the reason to NYSDOL. But the adjudicator wasn't judgmental at all - they just wanted to know if the absences were documented and if I had communicated with my employer about what was going on. I was approved and the process was actually more straightforward than I feared.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorThat's actually really reassuring. I was nervous about how much detail NYSDOL would want on the nature of the absences.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
My experience was they care about the pattern and documentation more than the specific medical details. You don't have to disclose your diagnosis - just that there was a medical reason and you communicated it to your employer.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
The adjudicator in my situation was similarly matter of fact about it. They've heard everything and they're not there to judge, just to apply the standard.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Fourteen weeks after my termination for excessive absences my claim was finally approved. I know that sounds like a nightmare timeline but mine had complications including my employer appealing the initial determination. What I learned is that you absolutely need to keep certifying your weekly claims every single week through the entire process - if you stop certifying you can lose out on benefits even when you eventually win.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorFourteen weeks is a lot. I keep hearing 'keep certifying' but what does certifying do if the claim is still in adjudication?
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Certifying establishes that you were unemployed and looking for work during each week. If your claim gets approved, they go back and pay you for every week you properly certified. Miss a week and that week's payment is usually gone even if everything else is approved.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
This is the most important thing in this whole thread honestly. Certify every single week no matter what is happening with your adjudication. That weekly claim is your record of eligibility for each week.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
My cousin almost stopped certifying because she thought the claim was going to be denied anyway. She kept going on my advice and when she was approved she got months of back pay at once.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
Former HR here (different industry now). The way terminations get coded in HR systems often doesn't match what NYSDOL actually evaluates. 'Excessive absences' is a catch-all code that HR managers use for clean documentation but it tells NYSDOL nothing about the why. What NYSDOL evaluates is the conduct behind the label - whether you deliberately violated a policy knowing the consequences with no good reason. Medical absences, family emergencies, transportation breakdowns - these generally don't clear that bar even if the employer was completely justified in letting you go.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorSo from an HR perspective, what would actually constitute misconduct in an absences case?
0 coins
Freya Johansen
My experience - someone who was warned multiple times, agreed to improvement plans, then missed more days anyway with no documented reason, and didn't notify their supervisor. That pattern suggests willfulness. Yours sounds like the opposite.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
The employer's internal policies don't define misconduct for UI purposes. Even if you violated their attendance policy fair and square, that doesn't automatically translate to UI misconduct. Two different standards.
0 coins
Natasha Ivanova
My claim for a firing came back denied on first determination even though I thought I had a solid case. Filed the appeal within the 30-day window and won at the hearing. The hearing officer asked pointed questions and really dug into whether my employer had given me adequate warning and what the nature of the absences was. Having a written timeline I had prepared ahead of the hearing made a huge difference.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHow formal is the appeals hearing? Do I need a lawyer?
0 coins
Natasha Ivanova
Mine was a phone hearing, pretty conversational but the officer was thorough. Most people don't have lawyers for the first appeal level - it's designed so you can represent yourself. A lawyer becomes more relevant if it goes to the board of appeals after that.
0 coins
Yara Abboud
Preparing your own written summary of what happened, with dates and documentation references, is often just as effective as having legal representation at the first appeal level.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
My job search log requirement surprised me during adjudication - I didn't realize I was supposed to be doing and recording three job search activities per week even while my claim was being adjudicated. The adjudicator mentioned it almost in passing and it wasn't something I'd paid attention to. Make sure you're keeping that log from day one of filing.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorThree job search activities per week - what counts as an activity? Just applying to jobs or other things too?
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Applying counts, but so does things like attending a job fair, contacting an employer directly even without a formal listing, or working with a recruiter. The NY Career Center website has the full list. Keep records of dates, employer names, and contact methods.
0 coins
Amina Sy
Networking events and resume workshops through the Career Center count too. I always used those when I was running low on actual applications in a slow job week.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
My sister works for a staffing agency and says they see this constantly - people fired for attendance who assume they won't get UI and don't even file. The reality is a significant portion of those cases result in approved claims once NYSDOL evaluates the actual circumstances rather than just the termination code. Always worth filing and letting the process play out.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHow long do I have to file from my last day of work? I want to make sure I'm within the window.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
You should file as soon as possible - there's no backdating to before your filing date except under specific circumstances. Every week you wait is potentially a week of benefits you won't collect even if you're approved.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
File the same week you lose your job ideally. The effective date of your claim is typically the Sunday of the week you file, so delays in filing mean delays in when your benefit period starts.
0 coins