Back to New York Unemployment

Avery Saint

Can you collect unemployment if you quit your job? My NYSDOL situation explained

I've been going back and forth on this for weeks and finally decided to just ask because I can't find a straight answer anywhere. My situation: I left my job at a logistics company about a month ago. It wasn't a rage quit or anything impulsive - my manager had been making my working conditions genuinely unbearable for months. We're talking constant schedule changes with no notice, being assigned to roles I wasn't trained or hired for, and at one point being told I'd be docked pay for taking a sick day I had accrued. I documented everything but honestly wasn't sure if any of it would hold up. I filed a UI claim with NYSDOL and now I'm sitting here staring at an adjudication status and no explanation. I've seen people say that if you quit, you're automatically disqualified from collecting unemployment in New York. I've also seen people say there are exceptions. I genuinely don't know what to believe. Did I just throw away my shot at benefits by leaving instead of waiting to get fired? For context, I'd been there almost 4 years and this treatment only started when new management came in about 8 months ago. Any help appreciated.

My claim is in week six right now and I went through almost this exact situation last year, so let me tell you what I learned the hard way. Quitting doesn't automatically disqualify you in New York - there's a specific pathway called 'good cause' and if your working conditions changed significantly from what you were originally hired into, that actually counts. The key phrase NYSDOL uses is 'good cause attributable to the employer.' What you described - the schedule chaos, role changes, the pay docking thing - those are exactly the kinds of things that can qualify. The adjudication you're in right now is NYSDOL investigating whether your reason for leaving meets that standard. It doesn't mean you're denied, it means they're looking at it.

0 coins

I had no idea 'good cause' was even a category. My whole assumption was that quitters don't collect, period. So the adjudication is basically them deciding if my reason was legitimate enough?

0 coins

Yeah the good cause thing is real but NYSDOL is super strict about what counts. Like 'my boss was mean' doesn't cut it but actual documented changes to your pay or duties often does. The documentation OP mentioned matters a LOT here.

0 coins

Exactly. And the burden is on you to show the conditions changed, not just that you were unhappy. If OP has emails, written schedules, anything showing the before and after, that strengthens the case significantly.

0 coins

Three weeks into my own adjudication when I finally got through to someone at NYSDOL who could actually explain what was happening on my claim. I'd been trying the phone lines for days and kept getting either a busy signal or getting dropped after 45 minutes of hold music. A friend told me about Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video showing what it does here: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent. When I finally got an agent on the line she walked me through exactly what documents I needed to submit for my adjudication and what the timeline looked like. For anyone stuck in this quit-or-fired grey zone, actually talking to an agent makes a massive difference because the website gives you nothing.

0 coins

45 minutes of hold music and then dropped - that's been my experience exactly. I didn't know there was anything that could help with that. Going to look into Claimyr tonight.

0 coins

I tried calling NYSDOL like four times and gave up. Did the agent actually tell you useful stuff or just generic 'your claim is under review' type answers?

0 coins

The agent I spoke with was genuinely helpful - she told me which specific section of my claim was flagged and what I could upload to address it. Way more than the portal ever showed me.

0 coins

My experience with NYSDOL agents varies wildly. Some are super knowledgeable, some just read you back what's on the screen. But even getting through to anyone is better than staring at a status that hasn't changed in weeks.

0 coins

Week two after getting my adjudication notice here and I've been researching this nonstop. The 'good cause' standard in New York has a few specific categories that NYSDOL recognizes. What I'd look at first in your situation is whether the changes to your job constituted a substantial change in the terms of your employment. Working conditions that deviate significantly from your original offer - different duties, altered pay structure, irregular scheduling - fall under what adjudicators examine. The pay docking situation you described is especially relevant because that potentially touches on wage theft, which is about as solid a 'good cause' reason as you can have. Document everything in a timeline if you haven't already.

0 coins

The pay docking happened twice that I know of. I did raise it with HR both times and they basically said it was 'policy' even though nothing in my offer letter said anything like that. I have emails from both times I complained.

0 coins

Those HR emails are gold. They show you raised the issue internally before quitting, which is something NYSDOL adjudicators look for - that you tried to resolve the problem rather than just walking out. Keep copies of everything.

0 coins

HR saying something is 'policy' when it contradicts your offer letter is a huge red flag legally, not just for unemployment. Might be worth looking into that angle separately too.

0 coins

Adjudication week four and I'm about to lose my mind tbh. Reading this thread though because I also quit and was told I had no shot at benefits. Is 'good cause' something you apply for separately or does it get reviewed automatically when you file?

0 coins

My first step when I filed after quitting was making sure I explained my reason thoroughly in the initial claim form - there's a section where you describe why you left. NYSDOL reviews what you wrote there first, then usually sends a questionnaire asking for more detail. It's not a separate application, it's part of the same adjudication process.

0 coins

I pulled up my claim form just now and I think I wrote like two sentences for that section. I didn't know it mattered so much. Is it too late to add more information?

0 coins

You can typically submit additional documentation through your Unemployment Services portal, or you can send it in writing to your local NYSDOL office. Don't just sit on information you have - get it in front of them proactively.

0 coins

Two sentences is probably not enough for a quit situation, yeah. The more specific detail you give about why you left and what changed, the better. Generic answers get generic results with NYSDOL.

0 coins

My letter from NYSDOL arrived last week asking me to complete a questionnaire about my separation, which is apparently standard when you quit. I was in adjudication for almost five weeks before that letter showed up. Something that actually helped me was getting an agent on the phone before the questionnaire deadline - I used Claimyr and after spending literally days trying to reach NYSDOL myself, I ended up speaking to an agent who clarified exactly what the questionnaire was asking and what level of detail they needed. I had been worried I'd under-explain and blow my claim.

0 coins

Five weeks before you even got the questionnaire? That's longer than I've been waiting. Did anything trigger it or did it just show up?

0 coins

Mine just showed up - no warning, nothing changed on the portal. One day it was just in my mail. The portal status didn't update for another week after that even.

0 coins

The lag between what actually happens on your claim and what shows on the portal is SO frustrating. I've heard agents can see more detail than what claimants see online, which is why talking to one actually helps.

0 coins

I got that same questionnaire. They asked about the specific incidents that caused me to leave, whether I spoke to management, and whether I had documentation. It felt almost like a mini-interview in written form.

0 coins

My understanding from when I went through something similar is that NYSDOL also looks at whether a 'reasonable person' would have quit under the same circumstances. That's the standard they apply. So it's not just about whether YOU felt the conditions were bad enough - it's about whether any reasonable worker would have done the same thing. Changes to pay and job duties hitting the bar of 'reasonable person would leave' is very achievable when they're significant and documented.

0 coins

That framing actually makes me feel better about my case. The changes were significant enough that two of my coworkers also left around the same time for similar reasons.

0 coins

Your coworkers leaving is actually relevant context you could mention in your documentation. It supports the argument that the conditions were objectively bad, not just a personal grievance.

0 coins

Worth noting that NYSDOL may also contact your former employer to get their version of events. They'll have a chance to say you quit without good cause. That's part of the adjudication - both sides get heard before a determination is made.

0 coins

I checked my account this morning and it now shows my employer submitted a response. I didn't even know they'd been contacted. Does that mean a decision is coming soon?

0 coins

Honestly the system is designed to make you give up. I quit a job three years ago under similar circumstances - manager from hell, complete restructuring of my role, pay issues - and NYSDOL denied me on the first determination. I appealed and WON, but that took another two months. The initial denials for quit cases are really common even when you have a solid good cause argument. Don't assume a denial is the end of the road.

0 coins

How hard was the appeal process? I'm already stressed enough and the idea of more waiting is rough.

0 coins

Appeals are more formal - there's a hearing with an administrative law judge, you can submit evidence, and you have a right to represent yourself or bring someone. It was nerve-wracking but honestly the hearing felt more fair than the initial determination. The judge actually read my documentation.

0 coins

Appeals have a good success rate when the original denial was for a quit with potentially valid good cause. The initial adjudication process is kind of blunt - appeals are where nuance actually gets considered.

0 coins

30 days from the determination notice to file an appeal. That deadline is strict. If you get denied, file the appeal before you do anything else.

0 coins

My sister went through this whole thing last year and what messed her up was not filing the weekly certifications while waiting for adjudication. She thought since her claim wasn't approved yet there was no point. Turns out you're supposed to keep certifying every week even during adjudication, because if you get approved, they pay you back for all the weeks you certified. If you stopped certifying, those weeks don't get paid even if you're approved.

0 coins

I've been certifying every week even though I'm in adjudication - is that correct? I wasn't sure if I should stop since nothing is approved yet.

0 coins

Yes keep going. Every week you certify is a week you can potentially get paid for once the determination comes through. Stopping means losing those weeks forever.

0 coins

This is one of the most important things anyone can say in this thread. Weekly certifications during adjudication are non-negotiable. The job search requirements also apply - you still need to be completing your required contacts each week and logging them even before your claim is approved.

0 coins

I did not know this when I first filed and I missed two weeks of certifications. Lost those two weeks of potential benefits entirely. Don't make my mistake.

0 coins

My determination letter just came yesterday after six weeks of adjudication - I was approved! I quit due to a hostile work environment and was terrified I'd be denied. The determination letter actually cited the specific incidents I described in my questionnaire. The whole thing felt impossible while I was in it but it did resolve. Hang in there to anyone else waiting.

0 coins

This is genuinely encouraging to read. Congrats on the approval. Did you submit a lot of documentation or mostly rely on your written explanations?

0 coins

I submitted emails, a written timeline I created myself, and I included the name of a coworker who could corroborate what I described. The timeline I think was what made everything coherent - it connected the dots between events.

0 coins

Pulling up my claim right now after reading this. Mine still says pending but at least I know there's light at the end of this.

0 coins

Congratulations! And good tip on the timeline. I'm going to put one together this weekend for my own situation.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged into week seven before I finally got desperate enough to try Claimyr because I could not get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone no matter what time I tried. It waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent - which sounds simple but when you've been trying for two weeks it feels like a miracle. The agent told me my employer had contested my claim and that I had an upcoming deadline to submit additional documentation I hadn't even been notified about properly. Would have missed it completely if I hadn't gotten through.

0 coins

An upcoming deadline you hadn't been told about - that's genuinely alarming. How would you have found out otherwise?

0 coins

Honestly I'm not sure I would have. The portal just said 'adjudication in progress.' There was nothing about a deadline, nothing about my employer contesting. The agent saw it all when she pulled up my file.

0 coins

This is exactly why talking to an actual human at NYSDOL matters so much. The portal doesn't show you everything and missed deadlines can sink your claim.

0 coins

Former employer contesting is very common in quit cases. They have an incentive to say you quit without cause because approved claims can affect their unemployment insurance tax rate. Don't take their response personally - it's almost automatic.

0 coins

My question might be slightly different but related - what happens to your job search requirements while in adjudication for a quit case? I've been doing three contacts a week but someone told me the requirements don't apply until you're actually approved. Now I'm confused.

0 coins

My first instinct would be to keep doing the job search contacts no matter what. The official NYSDOL position is that job search requirements apply from when you file, not when you're approved. If you stop and then get approved, you could face issues with weeks where you weren't conducting required searches.

0 coins

My weekly certification actually asks me to confirm I completed job search activities, so I've been answering honestly that I did them. Seems like they're expected during adjudication then.

0 coins

Three contacts per week is the standard requirement for most claimants in New York. Keep logging them in your job search record too - NYSDOL can audit those records and you want documentation if they ever ask.

0 coins

My whole view on this changed when I actually read the NY unemployment law rather than just random forum posts. The law says you're disqualified if you quit without 'good cause provided by the employer' - but that last part is key. It has to be something the employer did or caused, not just general dissatisfaction. What OP described - employer-initiated pay changes, role changes, schedule changes - is precisely what 'provided by the employer' means. The employer created the conditions. That's the argument.

0 coins

The way you've framed it - the employer created the conditions that caused me to leave - is exactly how I've been thinking about it but couldn't articulate. That's how I'll describe it in any additional documentation.

0 coins

That framing matters because NYSDOL adjudicators are looking for a causal chain: employer action led to changed conditions, changed conditions made work untenable, leaving was a reasonable response. If you can walk through that chain with documentation at each step, you're making their job easier.

0 coins

This is a really clear way to put it. The adjudicator isn't asking 'was this person unhappy' - they're asking 'did the employer do something that a reasonable employee couldn't be expected to tolerate.' Completely different question.

0 coins

My claim got denied initially even though I had what I thought was solid documentation. I'm now in the appeals process. For anyone else who ends up there: the appeal form is called the LO 400 and you file it with the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. You have 30 days from the mailing date on your determination notice, not the date you received it. That distinction matters if your mail is slow.

0 coins

I really hope I don't get to that point, but I'm saving this information anyway. 'Mailing date not received date' is an important distinction.

0 coins

My denial came on a Friday and I didn't open the mail until Monday. Lost three days right there before I even knew about the deadline. That's why I mention it.

0 coins

You can also fax or mail the appeal rather than submitting in person, which matters for people who don't live near an NYSDOL office. The mailing address is on the determination letter itself.

0 coins

Does submitting additional documentation during the appeal period help? Or does it only matter at the actual hearing?

0 coins

My background is in HR so I've seen this from both sides. Employers in New York are almost always going to respond to NYSDOL adjudication inquiries by saying the employee quit voluntarily without notifying management of any issues. They do this because it's their standard response to protect themselves. This is why YOUR documentation has to tell a complete story - because their version will be a sanitized 'we knew nothing, they just quit.' Your version needs to be specific, dated, and corroborated where possible.

0 coins

My former employer is a pretty large company with an HR department. I fully expect their response to be exactly what you described. I'm going to focus on making sure my documentation is as specific as possible.

0 coins

Large companies especially have standardized responses. The more specific your documentation, the harder it is to dismiss. 'My manager changed my schedule' is easy to wave away. 'On March 3rd my manager assigned me to warehouse duties I was not trained for and was not in my job description, and I have an email from that date confirming this' is not.

0 coins

This is really valuable perspective. The adjudicator is essentially weighing two accounts - an institutional one that's vague and a personal one that could be highly specific. Specificity wins.

0 coins

My claim certification is due tomorrow and I realized reading this thread I've been doing my job search log wrong - I've been keeping it in a personal spreadsheet but I think NYSDOL wants it logged in their system somehow? Can someone clarify where the job search record is supposed to be maintained?

0 coins

My first step with the job search record was finding it in the NY.gov Unemployment Services portal under the weekly certification section. When you certify each week it asks about your job contacts - but separately, NYSDOL has an online job search activity record where you can log each contact with the employer name, date, position, and how you applied. The portal has a section specifically for this.

0 coins

I just logged into my portal and found it - there's a 'job search activities' section I had completely missed. Going to enter all my contacts now. Thank you.

0 coins

Keep your personal spreadsheet as a backup. If NYSDOL audits your job search records, having your own detailed notes alongside the portal entries shows you were genuinely tracking this. Belt and suspenders approach.

0 coins

My determination came in after I sent additional documentation through the portal AND mailed physical copies to my local NYSDOL office. I don't know which one actually mattered but I was approved for a quit case and the agent I spoke with had told me to do both. The agent mentioned that physical documents sometimes reach the actual adjudicator faster than portal uploads, which surprised me but I wasn't going to argue.

0 coins

I haven't tried mailing physical copies - I've only been uploading to the portal. Good to know that might be worth doing as well.

0 coins

Claimyr was how I got that agent on the phone after trying NYSDOL myself for most of a week. Speaking to someone directly gave me actual actionable advice instead of just refreshing the portal endlessly.

0 coins

The dual submission approach makes sense from a 'cover all bases' standpoint. NYSDOL handles massive claim volume and anything you can do to make sure your documentation actually reaches the right person is worth the effort.

0 coins

My agent also told me to follow up with a written summary after submitting documents - basically a cover sheet explaining what each attachment was and why it was relevant. Small thing but it probably helps whoever is reviewing it.

0 coins

My situation was different from OP's - I was laid off, not a quit - but I've been following this thread because a friend of mine is in almost exactly OP's position. The thing I keep coming back to is how much of this process is invisible to the claimant. You're just sitting there watching a status screen that says nothing while all this evaluation is happening behind the scenes. The only way to get real information is to get a human on the phone.

0 coins

That's exactly how it feels. The portal tells me nothing except 'adjudication in progress' and I have no idea what stage it's at or what's happening.

0 coins

My friend ended up getting through to NYSDOL after about a week of trying different times of day. Early morning apparently has shorter wait times - like right when lines open at 8am. Though even then it's not guaranteed.

0 coins

Early morning is real - 8am sharp when they open is by far the best shot at getting through without an endless hold. Even then some days the volume is just too high and you get cut off.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure