Back to New York Unemployment

MidnightRider

Can you collect unemployment a different way if your industry is seasonal in NY?

So I've been working in landscaping for about 8 years now, always seasonal, always laid off in November and rehired in spring. Last year I finally filed for UI benefits during the winter gap and it went fine. This year though my situation is a little different - I picked up a part time retail gig in October, like 12 hours a week, and I'm still working those hours even though the landscaping company let me go November 1st. My question is basically whether I can still collect unemployment given that I have this part time thing going on. Someone at the job site told me you can collect if your earnings are below a certain amount but I honestly don't know how that works with NYSDOL. My gross from the retail job is around $160 a week. Does NYSDOL reduce your benefit or do they just deny you outright if you have any income at all? I've been going back and forth on whether to even file because I don't want to mess something up and end up with an overpayment notice six months from now.

I went through almost this exact situation two winters ago, working part time at a hardware store while waiting for my construction gig to pick back up. What NYSDOL does is calculate a partial benefit based on what you earn in the week. The way it shook out in my case was that they don't just cut you off for having some income - they reduce what they pay you instead. There's a formula where your part time wages factor in and your weekly benefit amount gets adjusted down. You are absolutely eligible to file, the part time work doesn't disqualify you as long as your total earnings don't go over your weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

I had no idea it worked that way. So I'd file like normal and just report the $160 each week when I certify?

0 coins

Exactly - when you do your weekly claim certification you report your gross earnings for that week, every dollar you made. NYSDOL does the math from there. Underreporting is what gets people in trouble with overpayments, not the act of working part time itself.

0 coins

This matches what happened to me too. My benefit got reduced but I still got something every week which was way better than nothing during the slow months.

0 coins

My landscaping buddy was in a nearly identical spot last winter and was going absolutely crazy trying to get through to NYSDOL on the phone to ask questions like yours before filing. He spent three days redialing and kept hitting the busy signal or getting dropped. He ended up using Claimyr - the way it works is it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually on the phone with a live agent there. He said he finally got someone who walked him through the partial benefit calculation specific to his earnings. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it goes.

0 coins

Tried to reach NYSDOL this morning and yeah the line was just ringing forever. I'll check that out, thank you.

0 coins

I had the same experience with the phones, spent an entire morning getting nowhere. Ended up figuring things out from forums like this one but I wish I'd known about an easier way to actually talk to someone.

0 coins

The partial UI questions really do need an agent to answer properly because everyone's benefit rate is different. Having that conversation directly with NYSDOL makes a lot of sense before you file your first week.

0 coins

My first unemployment claim was during a seasonal gap in hotel work and I was so confused about the part time earnings thing I almost didn't file at all. Here's how I eventually understood the formula: NYSDOL lets you earn up to a certain amount before it starts eating into your weekly benefit. I believe the threshold is something like $504 or around there, and earnings above that threshold start reducing your benefit dollar for dollar. With $160 a week in earnings you are likely well under that and would still receive a meaningful partial payment. File the claim, report honestly every week, and you should be fine.

0 coins

Wait I thought the threshold was different, like it was tied to your specific benefit amount not a flat number? Either way the OP should definitely file and not just assume they're disqualified.

0 coins

You're right that there are some nuances I may have oversimplified. The takeaway though is that part time wages don't equal automatic disqualification, that's the main thing.

0 coins

Both of these answers are helpful - seems like the consensus is I should just file and report accurately. I was so worried I was going to trigger some kind of fraud flag just by having any income at all.

0 coins

Fraud flags are for people who hide their income, not for people who report it properly. NYSDOL's partial benefit system literally exists because seasonal and part time situations are extremely common in this state.

0 coins

The anxiety around filing with part time income is real and I had it too when I left my full time restaurant management job and kept a weekend catering gig on the side. What helped me was looking up the NYSDOL fact sheet on partial unemployment benefits before I did anything. It spelled out that partial benefits are a normal part of the UI system, not some exception or loophole. You file your initial claim just like anyone else, and then each week in your certification you answer yes to whether you worked and enter your gross wages. The system handles the rest.

0 coins

Pulling up that fact sheet now - this is exactly what I needed to find. Thank you.

0 coins

The NYSDOL website is better than people give it credit for on this stuff. The partial UI section is pretty clear once you find it.

0 coins

My experience was that the information is there, it's just scattered. The fact sheet consolidates it nicely.

0 coins

okay so I'm seasonal too (tree service) and also confused. does the retail income affect your base period earnings at all when they calculate your benefit rate? like will NYSDOL count those retail wages when deciding how much your weekly benefit is gonna be??

0 coins

Your weekly benefit amount gets set at the time you file and it's based on your highest earning quarter in the base period - typically the year before you file. If you were working retail during that period, yes those wages would be included in the calculation, which could actually help your benefit rate if retail boosted your earnings in one of those quarters.

0 coins

oh that's actually good to know, I picked up some extra shifts last winter so my Q4 earnings were higher than usual. maybe that bumps my rate up a bit

0 coins

My rate went up because of a second job I'd had for a few months - I was surprised but the base period calculation includes all covered employment in New York.

0 coins

My neighbor who does seasonal pool installation tried Claimyr when he was getting nowhere with NYSDOL and said it was the most useful thing he found during his whole unemployment process. He needed to talk to an agent about exactly this partial benefit question because his situation had a complication - he was also doing some side cash work and needed to understand how to report it. Having a real agent on the line who could actually look at his account made a huge difference.

0 coins

The side work complication angle is interesting - for me it's all on the books thankfully so I'm hoping it's more straightforward.

0 coins

Even straightforward situations can get confusing when it's your first time navigating the partial certification questions. Having an agent confirm you're doing it right is worth a lot.

0 coins

Agreed. I've never regretted the times I managed to actually speak with NYSDOL directly. The online FAQ only goes so far.

0 coins

BEEN DOING THIS FOR SIX YEARS AND IT NEVER GETS LESS STRESSFUL. Every winter same thing - file the claim, panic about whether the part time hours mess everything up, spend hours on the phone getting nowhere. What I will say is the system does work if you report correctly. Had one year where my retail income was higher in December because of holiday hours and my partial benefit dropped almost to zero for those weeks. I reported it anyway and had no issues. The year I was tempted to fudge the numbers I didn't, and I'm glad because NYSDOL does cross check with employer wage records.

0 coins

The cross check part is what scares me honestly. Like what if my employer reports different hours than I remember working?

0 coins

Your employer reports dollar amounts not hours - at least for the UI wage records. The gross earnings are what NYSDOL cares about week to week. Keep your pay stubs or check your bank deposits so you have the exact numbers when you certify.

0 coins

This is the best advice in the thread. Keep records of your actual gross wages each week, not estimates. I write mine down in a notebook which sounds old school but it means I never have to guess.

0 coins

Came from the same kind of seasonal bind myself - commercial painting crew that shuts down December through March. The partial UI question burned me once because I didn't understand that you report gross wages, not net. I was putting in my take home pay and my benefit calculations were off for three weeks before an agent caught it. When you certify, the number to enter is what you earned before taxes, not what hit your bank account.

0 coins

Oh wow I definitely would have gotten that wrong. Gross not net, writing that down right now.

0 coins

This trips up a lot of people. Gross wages for the week you worked them, not the week you got paid. If you work Monday through Friday but your check comes the following Tuesday, you report those earnings on the certification for the week you worked.

0 coins

The 'week you worked not week you got paid' piece is another one that confuses people. I reported a paycheck's arrival date instead of the work week once and had to call NYSDOL to get it corrected.

0 coins

My thing is I had a totally different situation where I was misclassified as an independent contractor by a landscaping company and when I filed for UI they flagged my claim for adjudication because the employer said I wasn't their employee. Took forever to resolve. OP your situation sounds much cleaner than mine was but just mentioning it because the classification issue is real in seasonal work industries.

0 coins

I'm a straight W-2 employee at both jobs so hopefully that side of things is clean. That sounds like a nightmare you went through.

0 coins

It was months of back and forth. If anyone reading this is paid as a 1099 for seasonal work, check your classification before you file because it'll save you a lot of headache.

0 coins

The misclassification problem is huge in landscaping, construction, delivery - basically anywhere that uses seasonal crews. NYSDOL does have a process for challenging it but it's slow.

0 coins

Something that helped me feel less anxious about the whole thing was realizing NYSDOL sends you confirmation of what you certified each week. If something looks off you can catch it early. My first partial UI experience I checked my Unemployment Services portal obsessively after every certification and it did give me peace of mind to see the pending payment amount.

0 coins

Does the portal update like the same day you certify or is there a delay?

0 coins

Mine usually showed a pending status within a day or two and then moved to paid status after that. Direct deposit hit a few days after that in my experience.

0 coins

I set up direct deposit when I had my previous UI claim so at least that part is already sorted. Good to know the portal shows you what's happening so you're not flying blind.

0 coins

My experience with the NYSDOL phone line during partial UI questions was genuinely terrible - two hours of hold music followed by a disconnect, then same thing the next morning. A coworker told me about Claimyr and I was skeptical but I tried it and ended up speaking directly with an agent who answered every question I had about reporting part time earnings. Worth looking into if you're spinning your wheels trying to get through on your own.

0 coins

The disconnect-after-long-hold thing is infuriating. Glad you found something that worked.

0 coins

That's the thing I'm most dreading - getting to the front of the queue and then getting cut off. I might just try what you're describing before I even file so I can ask my questions first.

0 coins

Asking before you file is smart. The agent I spoke with actually caught that I was going to report earnings in the wrong week, which would have caused me problems down the line.

0 coins

My first winter filing was 2021 and even back then the partial benefit system worked pretty much the same way - report your gross, let them calculate, receive the difference. The COVID era messed with a lot of UI rules temporarily but the core partial UI structure has stayed consistent. What OP is describing is a textbook partial benefit scenario and should go smoothly as long as the reporting is accurate.

0 coins

Reassuring to hear the system is at least consistent on this. I keep reading old forum posts and panicking that the rules changed.

0 coins

Some of the dollar thresholds have shifted over the years but the basic partial UI concept - work some, still get some - has been the same the whole time I've been doing this.

0 coins

In the landscaping and grounds maintenance world basically everyone I know deals with winter UI at some point. The ones who don't file because they think the part time job disqualifies them are leaving money on the table. The partial benefit exists specifically for situations where you lose your main income source but still have minor work going on. NYSDOL designed it that way.

0 coins

Yeah I've had coworkers tell me they just didn't bother filing because they had side jobs and I always thought that seemed wrong.

0 coins

It is wrong. I've seen guys leave thousands of dollars in benefits unclaimed over a winter because of that misunderstanding.

0 coins

Preach. File the claim. Report the wages. Take the partial payment. It adds up and it's what the system is there for.

0 coins

My HR person at a previous job actually walked me through the partial UI rules when I was first getting laid off seasonally. She said NYSDOL has a disregard amount on part time earnings - basically a portion of your wages that doesn't count against your benefit at all, and then beyond that it reduces your payment gradually. I don't remember the exact current figures but the point is there's cushion built in, it's not a dollar-for-dollar reduction from the first dollar you earn.

0 coins

This matches what I understand too. The structure is intentionally forgiving for people with small amounts of part time work, which is exactly the OP's situation.

0 coins

It made sense to me once someone explained it. The system is trying to avoid penalizing people for picking up a few hours while still unemployed from their main job.

0 coins

This is making me feel genuinely better about filing. I went from thinking I'd be denied outright to understanding I'll probably just get a reduced benefit, which is still helpful.

0 coins

My partner waited three weeks after being laid off from her main seasonal job before filing because she thought the retail hours made her ineligible. When she finally filed she lost those three weeks of benefits retroactively - NYSDOL won't backpay for weeks before your claim date. File as soon as you lose your primary job, don't wait to figure it all out first.

0 coins

This is the push I needed. Filing today.

0 coins

Good. The effective date of your claim matters. Even if the first week is a waiting week with no payment, you want your claim date to be as early as possible.

0 coins

The waiting week thing is worth knowing - your first certified week is typically unpaid as a waiting period. It doesn't mean your claim is denied, it's just how NYSDOL handles new claims.

0 coins

Reporting errors are where people get into real trouble with overpayments, not the existence of part time work itself. My situation involved me forgetting to report a weekend shift because it felt too small to matter - turns out every dollar counts and NYSDOL's reconciliation with employer records flagged it months later. I had to repay a small amount. Annoying but totally preventable.

0 coins

How much trouble was the repayment process? Like did they make it a big deal?

0 coins

My situation was relatively minor and I didn't get penalized beyond repaying the amount. They gave me options for how to pay it. The bigger the discrepancy the worse it gets though, especially if they determine it was intentional.

0 coins

Intentional misreporting is where the word 'fraud' enters the picture and that is a whole different level of problem. Honest mistakes generally get treated as overpayments and can be repaid, not as fraud cases.

0 coins

The other thing worth flagging if you're in seasonal landscaping - check whether your employer puts you on standby status. If your employer has indicated you'll be rehired in spring, NYSDOL sometimes handles these differently and the job search requirements may be waived while you're on standby. Worth asking about when you file.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about standby status. My boss has always taken me back in spring but we've never formally done anything about it. I'll ask about this when I get through to NYSDOL.

0 coins

Your employer would need to request the standby designation and there are rules around how long it lasts. It doesn't happen automatically but if your employer is willing to do it, it removes the weekly job search requirement which is a big deal for some people.

0 coins

Standby status also reassures NYSDOL that you're not really permanently separated from your employer, just temporarily laid off. It can smooth the adjudication process for seasonal workers.

0 coins

okay I know this is a little off topic but does anyone know how many job search contacts you need per week in NY if you're NOT on standby? I've been assuming it was three but someone told me it went up recently

0 coins

My understanding is three contacts per week is the current requirement and it's stayed at three for a while now. Each contact needs to be with a different employer and you log them in your Unemployment Services account.

0 coins

okay three I can do. I was scared someone said five

0 coins

Three is what I've been told by NYSDOL agents and what I've been doing without any issues. Keep records of each contact in case you get audited on your job search activities.

0 coins

I've been collecting partial UI through seasonal layoffs for years and the one tip I'd give anyone starting out is to treat your certifications like a weekly task you don't skip, not something you remember when you feel like it. Miss a week of certification and you lose that week's benefit - there's no going back and certifying late for a week you forgot. Set a reminder, do it on the same day every week.

0 coins

Mine from the previous claim was Sunday certifications so I already have that habit at least.

0 coins

Perfect. The certification window opens Sunday and closes Saturday for most people. Miss the whole window and that week is gone.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way my first year. Missed a week in December because of holiday chaos and just had to accept that week was gone. Never missed one since.

0 coins

The Saturday cutoff catches people over long weekends and holiday weeks especially. Worth setting a calendar alert if you know you'll be traveling or distracted.

0 coins

My seasonal coworker just went through this exact scenario last month - main job ended, kept the part time gig, wasn't sure about filing. He filed, reported his earnings accurately every week, and has been receiving a partial benefit check each week without any issues. The anxiety beforehand was way worse than the actual process.

0 coins

That's genuinely encouraging to hear. I think I've been catastrophizing because I had a smooth run last year with no income at all and this new wrinkle made me nervous.

0 coins

The clean single-job UI claim is simpler but partial UI is not dramatically more complicated. The extra step is just remembering to enter your wages each week when you certify.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure