Back to New York Unemployment

Ethan Clark

Can unemployment overpayments be placed chapter 7 bankruptcy? My NYSDOL situation

I'm in a rough spot and trying to figure out my options. Back in 2023 I lost my hospitality job and filed for UI benefits through NYSDOL. Everything seemed fine at the time - I was certifying weekly, logging my job searches, the whole routine. Fast forward to a few months ago and I get a letter saying I owe back $6,800 in overpayments because NYSDOL determined I was supposedly not fully eligible during certain weeks. I disputed it but the appeal didn't go the way I hoped. Now I'm looking at this debt sitting there while I'm working a part-time gig that barely covers rent. My attorney mentioned chapter 7 bankruptcy might wipe out some of my debts and I immediately thought about this overpayment. So my actual question is: can unemployment overpayments be placed chapter 7 bankruptcy proceedings and potentially discharged? Has anyone actually done this or know someone who has? I really need to understand whether this NYSDOL debt is even eligible before I go further down this road with my lawyer.

Week 6 into my own overpayment nightmare so I've been digging into exactly this question. The short answer is it depends heavily on WHY the overpayment happened. If NYSDOL determined the overpayment was due to fraud on your part, that debt is almost certainly NOT dischargeable in chapter 7 - federal bankruptcy law treats fraudulently obtained government benefits the same way it treats other fraud-based debts. But if the overpayment was a plain administrative error or a disagreement about eligibility that didn't involve any intentional misrepresentation, there's a real argument that it CAN be discharged. Courts have gone both ways on this honestly. Your bankruptcy attorney is the right person to push on this.

0 coins

The overpayment in my case was classified as an 'eligibility issue' not fraud - NYSDOL's letter didn't use the word fraud anywhere. Does that distinction matter for the chapter 7 question?

0 coins

That distinction matters a lot actually. 'Eligibility issue' versus 'fraud' are treated differently. If there's no fraud finding in writing, your attorney has much more to work with.

0 coins

My brother went through something similar - overpayment from a state agency - and his attorney told him the same thing about fraud being the key dividing line.

0 coins

Three months into dealing with my own NYSDOL overpayment letter and I'll say the first thing I did was try to actually speak to someone at NYSDOL to understand exactly how they categorized the debt. That took forever because the phone lines are absolutely brutal. I spent probably 12+ hours across multiple days trying to get through before I ever spoke to a live agent.

0 coins

The phone situation with NYSDOL is genuinely terrible. I tried for two weeks straight before getting through once.

0 coins

Have you found any way to actually reach them without spending all day on hold? I need to get more details about how exactly my overpayment was categorized before my next attorney meeting.

0 coins

Mornings right when they open used to work better for me but even that stopped being reliable after a while.

0 coins

My overpayment was about $4,200 and I went through this exact research phase you're in. While I was trying to figure out the bankruptcy angle I also desperately needed to get NYSDOL on the phone to get documentation of how they classified the debt. After days of failed attempts I found Claimyr - it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent yourself without sitting there for hours. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. That was how I finally got the actual written breakdown of my overpayment classification, which my bankruptcy attorney said was essential for figuring out the discharge question.

0 coins

That documentation angle is something I hadn't thought about - I need the exact language NYSDOL used to classify this. I'm going to look into Claimyr because I genuinely cannot spend more days sitting on hold.

0 coins

The classification language is exactly what your attorney needs. Vague terms on the original notice versus what's in NYSDOL's system can sometimes differ.

0 coins

Had a friend use Claimyr for a different NYSDOL issue and she said she got through to an actual agent after a long time just not being the one sitting there waiting.

0 coins

My attorney explained the federal bankruptcy framework to me when I was in a similar spot last year with a government debt. The question you want to ask NYSDOL - and then bring the written answer to your attorney - is whether your overpayment determination includes any language about willful misrepresentation or false statements. Here's why that matters: under 11 U.S.C. Section 523, debts obtained through false pretenses or fraud are specifically carved out from chapter 7 discharge. UI overpayments that resulted from an honest eligibility dispute or even an administrative mix-up tend to fall outside that carve-out, meaning they may be dischargeable. The burden to prove fraud is actually on the creditor - in this case NYSDOL - not on you.

0 coins

Knowing the burden falls on NYSDOL to prove fraud actually makes me feel a little better. My overpayment came from a dispute over whether I was 'available for work' during weeks I was caring for a family member - no false statements involved.

0 coins

The 'available for work' requirement trips up so many people and NYSDOL rarely explains it clearly upfront. I'm sorry you're dealing with this.

0 coins

Courts in New York have handled UI overpayment discharge cases and the outcomes do vary. Having a bankruptcy attorney who knows government debt is worth the extra effort to find.

0 coins

About eight weeks into my payment plan with NYSDOL on an overpayment and I wish I had looked into the bankruptcy question earlier. By the time I signed the repayment agreement I may have weakened any discharge argument. If you're seriously considering chapter 7, do NOT sign a repayment agreement with NYSDOL before talking to your bankruptcy attorney. Some attorneys think agreeing to repay can complicate things.

0 coins

I haven't signed anything with NYSDOL yet - I've been ignoring the repayment demand letters while I figure this out. Is ignoring them going to cause additional problems in the meantime?

0 coins

Ignoring the letters isn't great either because NYSDOL can intercept tax refunds and sometimes flag your ability to file future UI claims. Try to at least let your attorney communicate something to them.

0 coins

My attorney sent a letter to NYSDOL on my behalf that basically put things on pause while we figured out the strategy. Worth asking your attorney if they'd do the same.

0 coins

Last November I had a meeting with a bankruptcy attorney about a different debt situation and while I was there I brought up an old UI overpayment question out of curiosity. She said the case law on discharging state UI overpayments in New York is actually pretty favorable for debtors when fraud isn't involved. The state has to come into bankruptcy court and affirmatively object and prove fraud or willful misrepresentation - and they often don't bother if the amount isn't huge.

0 coins

That 'they often don't bother' part is interesting - does NYSDOL actually show up and fight discharge in bankruptcy court?

0 coins

From what my attorney said, for amounts under around $10,000 it's pretty rare for the state to send attorneys to bankruptcy court to fight discharge. Not impossible but uncommon.

0 coins

My amount is $6,800 so that potentially falls into the range where they might not bother to fight it. This thread is genuinely helping me think through this more clearly.

0 coins

My situation was a little different - I had a mix of regular credit card debt and an NYSDOL overpayment all going into a chapter 7 filing together. The trustee treated the UI overpayment like any other unsecured debt initially. It wasn't until NYSDOL filed an adversary proceeding specifically to challenge discharge that the fraud question became a formal court issue. They didn't file one in my case. Everything got discharged including the overpayment.

0 coins

Yours actually got discharged? That's the most direct answer I've seen in this whole thread. How long ago was this and roughly what amount?

0 coins

About two years ago, and mine was just over $5,000. I know every case is different but it did work out for me.

0 coins

The adversary proceeding is the mechanism NYSDOL would use to challenge discharge. If they don't file one within the deadline, the discharge typically stands even on a debt they could theoretically have challenged.

0 coins

My overpayment case dragged on for months partly because I couldn't get clear information out of NYSDOL about the specifics of how they'd coded the determination in their system. The letter they sent me and what was actually in their system apparently differed. I ended up using Claimyr to get through to an agent who could tell me exactly what codes were on my account - much more useful than the generic letter. That system-level detail was what my attorney actually needed.

0 coins

The idea that the letter and their internal system might show different things is alarming. I definitely need to get someone on the phone now to verify what's actually in my account.

0 coins

The gap between what NYSDOL sends you in the mail and what's coded in their actual system is a real thing. I've heard about this from multiple people in overpayment situations.

0 coins

Your NYSDOL Unemployment Services online account sometimes shows more detail than the letter too - worth logging in and looking at all the determination details there before you even make the call.

0 coins

My cousin went through chapter 7 about 18 months ago with some government debts in the mix. His attorney explained that the category of debt matters more than who it's owed to - a UI overpayment from honest eligibility confusion is treated very differently than, say, student loans or intentional fraud. Government creditor doesn't automatically mean non-dischargeable.

0 coins

People assume anything owed to the government can't be discharged in bankruptcy but that's not accurate at all. Lots of government debts get discharged regularly.

0 coins

That misconception had me worried too - I assumed government debt would automatically be untouchable in bankruptcy. Good to know that's not the rule.

0 coins

Exactly right - the nature of the debt and how it arose matters far more than who the creditor is. UI overpayments from eligibility disputes sit in a genuinely different category than fines or fraud judgments.

0 coins

About a month into researching this same question for myself and I've found the NYSDOL website basically useless for understanding how overpayments interact with bankruptcy. The online FAQ doesn't address it at all. What I did find helpful was the Eastern District of New York bankruptcy court's website - they have self-help resources that explain what kinds of debts are typically challenged by creditors.

0 coins

The Eastern District court site is a good tip - I'm in Queens so that would be my district.

0 coins

Queens is definitely Eastern District. They also have bankruptcy clinics periodically that are free and you can ask questions like yours to actual attorneys.

0 coins

Legal aid organizations also sometimes offer free consultations specifically for bankruptcy questions and they know the local courts well.

0 coins

My overpayment letter came with a repayment schedule attached and I called NYSDOL to ask if bankruptcy discharge was something they'd seen before. The agent I eventually reached - after a very long morning on hold - actually said they're not allowed to give legal advice but that people do file bankruptcy with UI overpayments included all the time. She suggested I get documentation from them in writing about the overpayment basis before proceeding.

0 coins

Getting documentation in writing is coming up repeatedly in this thread as essential. I'm going to try to get a formal determination letter that spells out exactly the basis for the overpayment.

0 coins

You can formally request your claim file from NYSDOL which includes all the determination notices, notes, and basis for any decisions. That's probably more comprehensive than just asking for one letter.

0 coins

The claim file request is actually really useful - my attorney asked me to get mine and there was information in it I hadn't seen in any of the letters NYSDOL sent me.

0 coins

My chapter 7 discharge went through last spring and my NYSDOL overpayment was included. The thing my attorney kept emphasizing was timing - file the bankruptcy before NYSDOL refers the overpayment to the state tax department for collection. Once it moves to tax collection it can get more complicated. So if you're seriously considering this route, the timing matters.

0 coins

The timing point is new information for me. How do you know when NYSDOL is about to refer it to tax collection? Is there a notice?

0 coins

There's usually a final notice before they refer it - it comes by mail and says something about collection action being imminent. If you're past that stage already it's not necessarily too late but act fast.

0 coins

My attorney filed an emergency petition when we found out NYSDOL had already referred my debt to the state revenue department. It was more complicated but still worked out.

0 coins

The first week I got my overpayment notice I went into full panic mode and started reading everything I could find online about NYSDOL overpayments. Most of what I found was either outdated or specific to other states. The bankruptcy angle for NYSDOL overpayments specifically in New York is surprisingly hard to find reliable information about online.

0 coins

The lack of reliable information online about this specific situation is exactly what drove me to post here. Glad to know I'm not the only one who found the existing resources unhelpful.

0 coins

Even some bankruptcy attorney websites had information that seemed to apply to federal unemployment programs rather than state UI - the rules can differ.

0 coins

New York specific bankruptcy attorneys are really the right source for this. General bankruptcy resources online often miss the state-specific nuances.

0 coins

My NYSDOL overpayment was about $3,800 and I spent weeks trying to figure out exactly how it was categorized before my attorney could advise me properly. Eventually I used Claimyr to get through to NYSDOL - honestly one of the more productive conversations I had through this whole process, talking to an actual live agent who could pull up my full account details.

0 coins

Getting a live agent who can pull the full account details sounds like exactly what I need. I'm going to try Claimyr.

0 coins

Having the actual account-level information rather than just what's on the paper notices makes such a difference when you're trying to give your attorney a complete picture.

0 coins

The agents can also tell you whether the overpayment has been referred for collection yet, which based on what someone said upthread is apparently relevant for bankruptcy timing.

0 coins

My attorney has handled several cases involving state agency debts in bankruptcy and what she told me is relevant here: NYSDOL overpayments are treated as general unsecured debts in chapter 7 unless they come with a specific non-dischargeability claim from NYSDOL. Absent that, they go through the standard discharge process like any other unsecured debt. Priority status doesn't apply to state UI overpayments the same way it does to, say, certain taxes.

0 coins

The comparison to taxes is clarifying - I was worried NYSDOL debt might be treated like tax debt which I know is harder to discharge.

0 coins

Tax debt and UI overpayment debt are very different categories in bankruptcy. Tax debt has specific rules around age and filing requirements before it can even be considered for discharge - UI overpayments don't work the same way at all.

0 coins

Exactly this. People conflate 'government debt' into one category but bankruptcy law treats different government debts very differently depending on their nature.

0 coins

My experience with an overpayment dispute taught me that NYSDOL sometimes miscategorizes overpayments internally even when the letter they send you looks straightforward. When I finally got through to an agent and had them walk through my account line by line, we found that one determination had been coded incorrectly. That error actually helped my situation because the corrected coding made the overpayment smaller.

0 coins

The possibility of miscoding hadn't even occurred to me. If the internal records show something different than the letter, that could change things significantly.

0 coins

Worth verifying every detail in their system, not just taking the letter at face value. The agents can see things the letters don't reflect.

0 coins

This is exactly why talking to an actual NYSDOL agent is so important before making big decisions about how to handle the overpayment.

0 coins

My attorney friend told me most chapter 7 cases with UI overpayments discharge just fine in New York because the state's resources for fighting bankruptcy cases are limited. The ones that get challenged are almost always fraud cases. If your situation is a good faith eligibility dispute that just didn't go your way, you're probably in decent shape.

0 coins

The 'good faith eligibility dispute' framing describes my situation pretty well. I genuinely didn't think I was doing anything wrong - I just interpreted the available for work requirement differently than NYSDOL did.

0 coins

That kind of honest interpretive disagreement is very different from, for example, claiming you were unemployed while actually working and concealing wages. Courts and trustees understand that distinction.

0 coins

My bankruptcy judge seemed completely unbothered by the UI overpayment in my file. It went through the process with no special scrutiny that I could see.

0 coins

My path through the NYSDOL overpayment question ended with me deciding not to do bankruptcy and setting up a payment plan instead - but that was because my situation involved a fraud finding which my attorney said made discharge very risky. If yours doesn't have that fraud element, the calculus is completely different.

0 coins

The fraud versus non-fraud distinction keeps coming up as the central dividing line. I appreciate you sharing even though your situation went differently than what I'm hoping for.

0 coins

Even in my case, the payment plan NYSDOL offers isn't terrible - they can stretch it out pretty long and reduce financial pressure without the bankruptcy route if it comes to that.

0 coins

The payment plan option is worth knowing about as a fallback even if you pursue the bankruptcy angle first. NYSDOL does work with people on repayment terms.

0 coins

My chapter 7 filing included an NYSDOL overpayment from 2022 and the whole process took about four months from filing to discharge. The UI overpayment was discharged along with everything else without NYSDOL filing any kind of objection or adversary proceeding. My attorney had been cautious about promising it would work but in the end it went smoothly.

0 coins

Four months start to finish and no NYSDOL objection - that's the most hopeful data point I've seen. Thank you for sharing the actual outcome.

0 coins

Mine was about $5,500 and from an eligibility dispute, not a fraud finding. I think those facts made it less likely NYSDOL would bother fighting it.

0 coins

Outcomes like this are why it's worth at least consulting a bankruptcy attorney about the option even if you're not sure it's right for you. The worst outcome is you spend an hour getting information.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure