Can u get unemployment if you quit? My NYSDOL situation explained
So I've been going back and forth on this for weeks and finally pulled the trigger and left my job last month. The working conditions had gotten genuinely unbearable - my manager was scheduling me for shifts that conflicted with a medical appointment I had every week, and when I asked HR about it they basically told me to figure it out myself or find another job. So I did. Found another job. Except the new job fell through two weeks after I quit - they rescinded the offer because of some internal hiring freeze. Now I'm sitting here with no income and I went to file for unemployment on the NYSDOL site and there's this whole section asking why I left my last employer. I put "voluntary quit" and now I'm terrified I just torpedoed my own claim. My question is can u get unemployment if you quit under circumstances like mine, or am I just out of luck? I reported everything honestly. I didn't even realize there were exceptions until I started reading around online. Has anyone navigated this kind of situation with NYSDOL?
76 comments

Jenna Sloan
Week 2 of my own adjudication right now so I've been researching this exact thing obsessively. The short answer is yes, you CAN collect unemployment after quitting in New York, but it depends entirely on your reason. NYSDOL calls it "good cause" and it's a higher bar than people expect. Medical reasons that your employer refused to accommodate? That can qualify. Taking a new job that then evaporates? There's actually a specific provision for that too - if you left for a bona fide job offer that was rescinded through no fault of your own, NYSDOL has sometimes approved those claims. You're not automatically disqualified just because you marked voluntary quit. It goes into adjudication and a rep reviews the circumstances.
0 coins
Christian Burns
My letter from NYSDOL last year said almost this same thing word for word. The adjudicator actually called my former employer to verify what I told them about the scheduling conflicts. They didn't just take my word for it which scared me but it worked out in my favor eventually.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThe rescinded offer angle is what I'm most hopeful about honestly. I have emails from the new company confirming the offer and then the email pulling it back. Keeping all of that in case I need to show documentation.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
the medical accommodation angle is real but make sure u have something in writing showing u asked for it and they said no otherwise its ur word against theirs in adjudication
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Honestly this situation sounds rough and the adjudication process for voluntary quits drags on forever. I was stuck in adjudication for over five weeks on a much simpler case. NYSDOL just does not move fast when there's any question about your separation reason.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
My adjudication went six weeks and nobody told me anything the whole time. I kept checking my Unemployment Services account and it just said pending. No letters, no updates, nothing.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Exactly this. The silence is the worst part. You have no idea if they need more info from you or if they're just processing or what.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
My fourth week in and I stopped stressing about the timeline only after I actually got someone on the phone who told me my case was still being reviewed normally. Getting that verbal confirmation changed everything mentally.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
My claim got stuck the same way yours sounds like it might - voluntary quit flagged, adjudication started, complete radio silence for weeks. I finally got through to an actual NYSDOL agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without spending your whole day on the phone. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - when I finally got an agent they explained exactly what documents I needed to submit for my good cause claim and my adjudication actually moved within days after I sent them in. For a voluntary quit situation specifically, talking to an agent is way more valuable than just waiting because they can flag your case and tell you if anything is missing.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorI tried calling three times this week and either got a busy signal or sat on hold until the system disconnected me. This is exactly what I need to try - thank you for posting this.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
My brother went through something similar last spring. Spent two weeks trying to get through before someone told him about Claimyr. Got his questions answered that same afternoon.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Does it work for checking adjudication status specifically? Mine has been sitting for 4 weeks and I genuinely have no idea if they even have all my info or if something is wrong.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Two months ago I was convinced I was completely disqualified because I quit without having anything lined up - but I had the wrong idea about how the good cause rules actually work. The rule isn't that you had to have another job waiting. It's that your circumstances at the job had to be something a reasonable person couldn't be expected to keep putting up with. Unsafe conditions, documented harassment, medical stuff the employer wouldn't accommodate - those are real examples NYSDOL considers. I had health issues related to my work environment and once I explained that in my adjudication interview I was approved. The key was having records showing I tried to fix it with my employer first before I walked.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThat tracks with what I've been reading. My situation with the medical appointments - I actually have a text thread with my manager where I asked twice and was told no both times. That feels like documentation of trying to resolve it internally first.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
The "reasonable person" standard is what adjudicators actually use to evaluate these cases. It's subjective but it's also more in the claimant's favor than people assume when they're panicking about having quit.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
My HR rep literally told me I could just quit if I didn't like the schedule. I saved that voicemail. Turned out to be the most important piece of evidence I had when adjudication came around.
0 coins
Laila Prince
okay so I'm confused bc my coworker told me if you quit for ANY reason you get automatically denied and there's nothing you can do. But this thread is saying that's not true?? Who is right here I'm in a similar situation and I'm panicking
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Your coworker has the most common misconception about unemployment completely backwards - automatic denial for quitting is not how NYSDOL works. Voluntary quits go into adjudication. Adjudication means a human reviews your specific reason. You are not automatically denied.
0 coins
Laila Prince
oh my god okay. I've been not filing for three weeks because I thought there was no point. filing tonight.
0 coins
Christian Burns
My first week after quitting I almost didn't file for the same reason - someone told me not to bother. File immediately, even if you're not sure. The adjudication process can't help you if you haven't even filed yet. And your benefit year starts from when you file, not when you quit.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
The rescinded job offer angle in your situation is actually the stronger argument than the medical accommodation one, in my opinion. Leaving a job to accept a confirmed written offer that was then pulled through no fault of yours - NYSDOL has a category for this. You voluntarily quit but the reason was objectively reasonable. Keep every email from that hiring process, the offer letter, the rescission notice, any HR correspondence. Submit all of it with your adjudication documents.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorAlready printed everything out and organized it by date. The offer came in writing via email, the acceptance confirmation is there, and the rescission letter specifically says 'internal hiring freeze affecting all open positions' which feels like it makes clear this wasn't performance related or anything on my end.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
That phrasing in their rescission letter is actually ideal documentation. It shows the offer was real and the cancellation was entirely on their side. Keep the original emails - adjudicators sometimes ask for forwarded copies with headers intact.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
My adjudication reviewer told me over the phone that written documentation submitted through the online portal moves cases faster than faxed stuff. Upload directly through your Unemployment Services account if you can.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
NYSDOL adjudication for voluntary quits is BROKEN. I went through this last year and even with solid documentation they still initially denied me. Had to appeal. The appeals process took another 8 weeks. I eventually won but I went almost four months without a single payment while I was doing everything right. The system is designed to make you give up.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
My first claim back in 2022 got denied at adjudication and then approved on appeal too. It's brutal but the appeals do work if your case is legitimate. The ALJ hearing is actually pretty fair in my experience even if getting there is exhausting.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThis is my fear. Four months is a long time. I have some savings but not unlimited patience here. Hoping the documentation I have is strong enough that I don't end up in that situation.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
File your appeal THE DAY you get a denial. Don't wait. You have 30 days but the sooner you file the sooner it moves. I waited two weeks because I was upset and that's two weeks I added to my own wait.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
genuine question - does anyone know if you have to keep doing the weekly certifications while your claim is in adjudication for a voluntary quit? i didn't do mine for two weeks because i assumed there was no point if the claim hadn't been approved yet and then someone told me i was messing myself up
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
My first cycle through adjudication I made exactly this mistake. You have to certify every single week without stopping, even if the claim shows pending or under review. If your adjudication resolves in your favor, they pay retroactively for all the weeks you certified. If you stopped certifying, those weeks may be gone permanently.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
ugh. I stopped for 3 weeks. is there any way to fix that
0 coins
Christian Burns
My NYSDOL rep told me you can sometimes add missed certifications by calling in and explaining the circumstances, but it's not guaranteed and they have discretion on it. This is another reason why getting a live agent on the phone matters so much during adjudication - they can tell you exactly what your options are for missed weeks.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
My situation was identical - I missed two weeks in adjudication. I got it sorted eventually but it required talking to an agent directly. The website gives you no way to fix missed certifications online from what I could find.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
My adjudication took forever and I couldn't get anyone on the phone through the main number for almost two weeks straight. A friend suggested Claimyr after I complained about it enough - once I ended up speaking with an agent at NYSDOL I found out my adjudication had actually been completed but there was a separate issue flagging my account that nobody had notified me about. Without that call I'd have been waiting indefinitely for a problem that was already resolved on their end but was just sitting there. For a voluntary quit claim where timing really matters, being able to reach someone is not optional.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThe idea that my claim could have already been reviewed and there's just some secondary flag I don't know about is making me want to call today. That would be such a NYSDOL thing to happen.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
My cousin had the exact same thing - claim approved, money just sitting there not releasing because of some ID verification step they never sent notice about. Agent found it in two minutes.
0 coins
Laila Prince
My situation cleared up faster than I expected once I actually talked to a person. All those weeks of waiting and refreshing my account and the fix was a five minute phone call.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Can I ask what the job search requirements are while you're in adjudication for a voluntary quit? Like do you still have to log 3 job search activities per week even though your claim isn't approved yet?
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
My file shows I was doing the full three job search activities every week from day one and my adjudicator actually mentioned it positively - like it showed I was genuinely trying to work. NYSDOL requires the job search log regardless of your claim status once you've filed. Keep records of every application, every contact, every job search activity even during adjudication.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
The three activities per week requirement applies from your first week of certification. If your claim gets approved retroactively they can review whether you were meeting that requirement for the weeks you're claiming. Don't skip it.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
My first week I only did two because I didn't realize the requirement started immediately. Going to make sure I hit three every week going forward.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Went through almost this exact sequence eighteen months ago - quit, new job, offer rescinded, applied for UI, adjudication. Here's what actually worked: I wrote a detailed timeline of everything that happened, attached every document, and submitted it proactively through the portal rather than waiting for them to ask. My adjudication was resolved in under two weeks. My friend in a nearly identical situation waited passively and his took eight weeks. Proactive documentation submission seems to make a real difference.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThis is actionable. I've been waiting to see if they contact me for more info but maybe I should just upload everything now.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Upload it. The adjudication mailbox in your Unemployment Services account accepts attachments. Don't wait for them to request things - give them everything upfront with a clear cover note explaining your timeline.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
My case manager specifically told me they appreciate when claimants upload documentation proactively because it means they don't have to open a separate request and wait for a response. It genuinely speeds up processing.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
I'm in week seven of adjudication on a voluntary quit right now and I want to scream. I had a hostile work environment situation - documented, with witnesses - and I've uploaded everything. The online portal just says 'review in progress.' No timeline, no updates, nothing. This is my entire income situation and I can't get any information at all.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
My seventh week was my breaking point too. The lack of communication from NYSDOL during long adjudications is genuinely cruel when you have bills due.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Have you tried calling? I know it's nearly impossible to get through but once you do, the agents can actually tell you where in the review process your case is and whether anything is pending on their end.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
I tried four different mornings this week. Either the line was busy or I was on hold for over an hour and then it disconnected. I'm at the end of my rope with the phone situation as much as the adjudication itself.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
My appeal came back approved after they initially denied my voluntary quit claim and I want to share what the ALJ told me afterward because it's useful. He said the two things that most often sink voluntary quit claims at the initial adjudication level are: not being able to show you tried to resolve the issue with your employer before leaving, and not being able to show the reason was something serious enough that a reasonable worker would have left. Both of those elements matter. The 'reasonable person' standard is real and you have to demonstrate it, not just assert it.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThe part about trying to resolve it first - my text messages with my manager showing me asking for accommodation and being denied should cover that. That's essentially documentation of trying to fix it internally before quitting.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Internal grievance documentation is exactly what adjudicators look for. Emails, texts, HR complaint forms, anything showing you raised the issue and the employer failed to address it.
0 coins
Christian Burns
My ALJ hearing was actually the most fair part of the whole process ironically. The initial adjudication felt like a black box but the hearing was a real conversation where I could explain the situation. If you end up at that stage don't panic - it's more human than the automated parts.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
My fourth week post-quit and I've been reading everything I can about this. Something that tripped me up early on: I initially thought adjudication and appeal were the same thing. They're not. Adjudication is the first review of your claim - you don't have to do anything extra to trigger it, it just happens automatically when NYSDOL sees a voluntary quit. Appeal is what you request if adjudication ends in a denial. Two completely separate stages.
0 coins
Laila Prince
My first read of the NYSDOL website totally confused these two things. I thought I had to appeal right away just to start the process.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
i made this exact same mistake lol thought i needed to do something to appeal when really my claim was just still in the initial adjudication phase. spent a week stressed about nothing
0 coins
Abby Marshall
My NYSDOL paperwork actually doesn't do a great job distinguishing these stages clearly. I only figured it out from reading forums like this one.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
My situation took a turn when I finally got a live NYSDOL agent to review my file directly - I'd been using Claimyr for a few of my more frustrating claim situations and it's become my go-to when the online portal isn't giving me answers. For a voluntary quit with documentation like yours, being able to talk to an agent who can actually see your case notes is worth a lot more than refreshing your account page.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorBetween this and the earlier comment about Claimyr I'm definitely trying it. I need actual information about where my claim stands, not just a pending status screen.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
My situation after weeks of silence - I finally got through to an agent last Thursday and found out there was a question about my last day of work that didn't match what my employer reported. If I hadn't made that call I'd still be waiting with no idea why.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
My former employer contested my claim after I quit, which made everything take longer. If you marked voluntary quit AND your employer submits a response saying you weren't forced out, NYSDOL has to weigh both sides. That's what adjudication is for but it also means your documentation has to be strong enough to counter whatever your employer says.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorThis is a scenario I hadn't fully thought through. My former employer was pretty hostile when I left so I could absolutely see them trying to characterize it as me just walking out without cause.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
My former job tried to say I quit over minor scheduling preferences. I had texts showing the accommodation request was for a medical condition and that they flat out refused it. The more specific your documentation the harder it is for an employer to spin the narrative.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Employer response is part of the standard adjudication process for any disputed separation. NYSDOL weighs both accounts. This is exactly why written evidence matters so much more than verbal claims in these cases.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
My first voluntary quit claim got denied years ago and back then I didn't understand I could appeal. Lost those benefits entirely because I didn't know my rights. Posting this so nobody reading this thread makes the same mistake: if you get a denial letter, you have 30 days from the date on the letter to file an appeal. The date on the letter, not the date you receive it. File as soon as you get it.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorFiling the minute I get a denial if it comes to that. 30 days from the date on the letter, noted.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
My denial letter was dated a Friday and I didn't get it until the following Wednesday. That's already five days burned. The 30 day clock starting from the letter date rather than receipt date is something they should tell you upfront but of course they don't.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Exactly why I always tell people to open those envelopes the day they arrive and act that same day if it's a denial. The administrative law judge hearing is actually your strongest shot at getting a voluntary quit claim approved if you have good documentation.
0 coins
Payton Black
Three weeks since I filed and I want to understand what 'good cause' actually covers in plain language. So far in this thread I've seen: medical accommodation refusal, hostile work environment, rescinded job offer. Are there other reasons NYSDOL recognizes?
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
My claim research turned up several others: substantial reduction in pay or hours (not just a small cut, something significant), unsafe working conditions that weren't fixed after you reported them, being required to do something illegal, domestic violence situations - there's actually more flexibility in the standard than people assume. The common thread is that a reasonable person in your situation would have left.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Relocation for a spouse's job can qualify in some cases. Childcare situations where your employer changed your hours in a way that made your existing childcare impossible have been approved too. The list isn't exhaustive - 'good cause' is meant to be evaluated case by case.
0 coins
Payton Black
This is actually making me feel better about my own situation. I left because they eliminated my entire position and offered me a lateral move at a 30% pay cut. I was honestly not sure if that counted.
0 coins
Harold Oh
My whole read of this thread: document everything, file weekly certifications without stopping, submit your documentation proactively instead of waiting, get an agent on the phone if you can. OP your situation with the medical accommodation denial in writing AND the rescinded offer sounds like a genuinely strong voluntary quit claim. Don't psych yourself out before NYSDOL has even reviewed it.
0 coins
Raul Neal
AuthorAppreciate this summary honestly. It's been a stressful few weeks and reading through everyone's experiences here has given me a clearer picture of what to actually do versus just refreshing my portal and panicking.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
My experience confirms all four of those points. The certification one especially - stopping your certifications during adjudication is the most common self-inflicted wound in these situations.
0 coins
Laila Prince
My trajectory has completely changed from reading this thread. Filed last night, have my first week of job search activities logged, documentation organized. Actually feel like I have a path forward now.
0 coins