Can sub teachers get unemployment in NY? Confused about NYSDOL eligibility
So I've been working as a substitute teacher for a school district here in New York for the past two years — no contract, no guaranteed hours, just get a text the night before and show up if I want. Some weeks I'm in classrooms four days, other weeks nothing at all. This past summer I filed for unemployment with NYSDOL during the break between school years and my claim got denied. The denial letter mentioned something about 'reasonable assurance' of returning to work in the fall but I never signed anything, nobody gave me a letter saying I'd have work, the principal just said 'we'll see you in September' in the hallway one day. Is that enough to count as reasonable assurance? I genuinely don't know if I'm being wrongly denied or if sub teachers just can't get unemployment benefits at all between school years. Has anyone else gone through this as a sub? Do I appeal or just accept it?
82 comments

Dmitry Kuznetsov
Ugh this reasonable assurance thing catches SO many subs off guard. First thing I'd do in your spot is pull out that denial letter and look for the specific language they used — because 'reasonable assurance' in the context of school employees has a pretty specific legal meaning under NYSDOL rules and a hallway comment absolutely should not meet that standard. The school district has to show there's a genuine expectation you'll return in the same or similar capacity. A passing remark from a principal with no written offer, no contract, no formal notification — that's really thin ground for them to deny your claim. You have 30 days from the date on that denial notice to file an appeal, so don't sit on this.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorOk good to know, the denial letter does say 'reasonable assurance' but it's vague. So you think the hallway thing isn't enough? I'm worried about appealing and making it worse somehow.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Appealing literally cannot make your situation worse — you either get approved or the denial stands. File the appeal.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
Agreed, file it. The worst outcome is exactly where you already are.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
My experience with sub teacher claims at NYSDOL — they almost always deny them first because of that reasonable assurance rule, but a lot of those denials get overturned on appeal when the sub can show there was nothing in writing. Do you have any emails from the district or anything documented about next school year?
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorHonestly nothing in writing at all. The district never gave me any paperwork about returning. Would that actually help my appeal or hurt it?
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
No written offer actually helps you. The burden is on the school district to prove they gave you reasonable assurance — if they can't produce documentation, that weakens their case at the appeal hearing significantly.
0 coins
StarSailor
This. I went through an appeal as a sub aide (not exactly the same but similar) and the lack of any formal written offer was a big part of why I won.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
Have you actually been able to get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone about this? I spent three weeks trying to reach someone when my own claim hit a wall and could never get through — always either a busy signal or they'd drop the call after a long wait. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) — what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking to a live agent yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For my situation I needed to understand exactly what code was on my denial before I could even write a proper appeal, and getting that clarification from an actual NYSDOL agent made all the difference in how I worded everything.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorThree weeks, that sounds like a nightmare. Did you end up getting your issue resolved once you got through?
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
I've been trying to call NYSDOL for two days straight on a different issue and yeah the lines are brutal. Might look into that.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
The phone situation at NYSDOL is genuinely terrible, been there. Good tip.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorAppreciate the suggestion — I haven't been able to get through either and I really need to understand what code they put on my denial.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Let me break down how this actually works because I see a lot of confusion about substitute teachers and UI eligibility in New York. The rule is basically this: if you work for a school or school-related employer, NYSDOL looks at whether you have 'reasonable assurance' of returning to do the same kind of work after a break like summer. If they decide you do, they won't pay you benefits for that break period. But the key word is assurance — there has to be an actual expectation communicated to you, not just a vague hope. Per-diem subs with no guaranteed hours are in a gray zone because the district can't truly promise you work. A lot of these denials get appealed successfully.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorPer diem is exactly what I am, no guaranteed days at all. So the gray zone thing — does that mean I have a decent shot at the appeal?
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
Per diem status is actually one of the strongest arguments in your favor on appeal. Courts have repeatedly found that per-diem subs without guaranteed hours don't have true reasonable assurance. Document your per diem status clearly in your appeal paperwork.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
What they said. The 'no guaranteed hours' piece is crucial. Make sure you say that explicitly in your appeal statement.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
wait so substitute teachers are treated different from regular teachers for unemployment?? I always assumed if you work for a school you just can't get benefits in summer no matter what
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Regular teachers with contracts and reasonable assurance of returning — yes, they're typically denied for the summer break. But per-diem subs without guaranteed hours or written assurance are in a different position. The rule applies differently depending on what kind of assurance actually exists.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
oh wow ok I had no idea that distinction existed. this forum is actually useful sometimes lol
0 coins
Amina Sy
My situation was almost identical to yours — per diem sub, denied for summer, appealed it. At the ALJ hearing the district representative showed up and tried to claim a staff meeting invitation counted as reasonable assurance. The judge didn't buy it. I ended up getting my benefits approved for the break period. The process took about two months from filing the appeal to getting a decision but it was worth every bit of the hassle.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorTwo months is a long wait but that outcome sounds great. Did you have to attend the hearing in person or was it by phone?
0 coins
Amina Sy
Mine was a phone hearing actually, which made it a lot less stressful. You'll get a notice with the date and time and instructions on how to participate. Prepare a clear statement of your per diem status and why you believe no genuine assurance was given.
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
Good to hear a real success story. OP needed to hear this.
0 coins
Natasha Petrova
NYSDOL has been absolutely impossible to reach this year and I say that as someone who spent HOURS on hold about my own adjudication issue before finally giving up. The online portal doesn't give you enough info about denial reasons and you kind of need a human to explain it. Hope OP gets through somehow.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorYeah the portal just shows the denial, no real explanation. I need to find out the specific reason code they used.
0 coins
Javier Morales
I had the same frustration — the online system is basically useless for anything beyond filing your weekly claim. Any real question requires talking to an actual person.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
Their phone system is a disaster honestly. I think they're perpetually understaffed.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
So wait — when you say the principal said 'see you in September,' did anyone else hear that? Do you have any witnesses? That might matter at a hearing because the district will probably try to characterize whatever was said as an offer of assurance.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorIt was just the two of us in the hallway, so no witnesses. Is that a problem?
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Not necessarily a dealbreaker — it becomes your word versus the district's characterization. That's exactly why the lack of anything written is so important to emphasize. A hallway comment with no follow-up paperwork is not reasonable assurance under any reasonable reading of the standard.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Also worth noting: even if the district claims they gave you assurance verbally, the per diem nature of your work still undermines the whole thing. You can't have assurance of work that was never guaranteed to begin with.
0 coins
Emma Davis
I subbed for three different districts simultaneously one year and tried to file for summer unemployment — NYSDOL denied all three separately and I had to file three separate appeals. It was a paperwork nightmare. Just flagging this in case you work for more than one district.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorOnly one district for me thankfully. Three separate appeals sounds absolutely exhausting.
0 coins
Emma Davis
It was a lot but I won two out of three. The one I lost was the district where I had signed a 'preferred sub' agreement — that apparently counted as written assurance. Big lesson learned.
0 coins
StarSailor
Wow never knew signing a preferred sub agreement could hurt you like that. Good to know.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Appeals for school employee denials — do they go to a regular unemployment appeals board or is there a separate process for school-related claims?
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
You appeal to the NYSDOL Appeal Board, same process as any other UI denial. You'll request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. The school-specific reasonable assurance issue will be argued at that hearing just like any other factual dispute in a claim.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Thanks for clarifying that. I was worried there was some separate track for school employees that made it harder.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
Nope, same appeal path. File your appeal request online through your Unemployment Services account or mail it in — just make sure you hit that 30-day deadline.
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
I keep seeing people say 'reasonable assurance' — where does that term even come from, is it in like actual state law or is it NYSDOL policy?
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
It's actually rooted in federal law — there's a federal unemployment standard that all states have to follow for school employees, and New York's rules implement that through the state Labor Law. So it's not just NYSDOL making it up, it has a real legal basis. That's also why appeal hearings on this issue can get pretty detailed.
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
ok that makes it make more sense. so an appeal judge would actually be applying a legal standard not just NYSDOL's interpretation
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Exactly. The ALJ applies the legal standard and looks at the actual facts of what assurance was or wasn't given. That's why the specifics of your situation — per diem, no written offer — matter so much.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
Have you tried sending a message through the Unemployment Services portal about the denial? I know calling is impossible but sometimes the message system gets a response in a week or two, and it at least creates a paper trail showing you tried to get clarification.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorI hadn't thought of that — does the message actually go to someone who can explain the denial code?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
In my experience it goes to a claims specialist eventually. The response is slow but I did get an explanation of my denial reason in writing that way, which I then used as part of my appeal. Having their own explanation in writing can actually be useful ammunition.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
This is a good tip. Getting NYSDOL's reasoning in writing before you finalize your appeal statement lets you address their specific arguments directly.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Honestly for anyone stuck on a denial like this and can't get through on the phone — I used Claimyr after spending an entire morning redialing NYSDOL and getting nowhere. Ended up speaking with a live agent who pulled up my claim and walked me through exactly what code was on my file. That info shaped my whole appeal letter.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorWorth knowing — did the agent give you any hints about whether your appeal had a chance or were they pretty neutral?
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Pretty neutral, as you'd expect — they're not going to predict appeal outcomes. But they did confirm factual details about my claim that I didn't have access to through the portal, which was genuinely valuable.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
Getting the actual denial code from an agent sounds like it could change your whole approach to writing the appeal. That's not nothing.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
My sister — wait I shouldn't start that way. I had a friend who went through sub teacher unemployment and they told me NYSDOL sometimes codes these denials as 'between terms' which is different from a regular disqualification. Apparently knowing which code it is matters for how you frame the appeal.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Your friend is right about that. The 'between terms' denial is specifically the school-employee reasonable assurance denial, and it has its own section in the Labor Law. Knowing the exact basis of the denial helps you cite the right legal standard in your appeal and argue the right facts.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
Good to know that tracks. OP should definitely find out that specific code before writing their appeal statement.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorNoted — finding that code is now my top priority before I draft anything.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
Does filing an appeal affect your ability to continue filing weekly claims while you wait for the hearing?
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
You should keep filing your weekly claims while your appeal is pending — this is really important. If you win the appeal and you haven't been filing, you may not be able to collect for those weeks even if you're approved. Keep filing even though the payments are on hold.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
Didn't realize that was a thing. So you file weekly claims even during a denial period?
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
Yes, file them. Think of it as preserving your eligibility for those weeks in case the appeal goes your way. If you stop filing and then win, those weeks may be gone.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorThis is really critical info I didn't know — I haven't been filing since the denial. Need to find out if I can file retroactively.
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
Wait OP said they haven't been filing weekly claims since the denial — can you file retroactively for missed weeks?
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Retroactive filing for missed weeks is tricky — NYSDOL generally wants you to file weekly claims in real time. If you've missed weeks, you should contact NYSDOL directly and explain the situation. In some cases they can allow late filing if there was good cause, but it's not guaranteed and you need to address it quickly.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorOk so I need to contact NYSDOL about this immediately. The portal won't let me file for past weeks on its own right?
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Correct, the online system won't let you go back and file missed weeks on your own. You'll need to speak with a claims specialist to address those weeks. Don't wait on this.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
For getting that NYSDOL agent conversation OP needs about the missed weeks — Claimyr worked for me when I was in a similar phone-tree nightmare. I ended up talking directly with a NYSDOL agent who was actually able to note my account about the late filing issue. Way better than just hoping the portal message gets answered.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorAt this point I'll try anything. I need to sort out both the appeal AND the missed weeks situation.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
My advice — prioritize the missed weeks call first since that's time-sensitive, then work on the appeal statement. Agents can flag your account to help address the gap.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
Two separate issues to resolve and a 30-day appeal deadline — OP's plate is very full right now. Hope things work out.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
Rooting for you OP, this whole situation sounds incredibly stressful but it sounds like there's a real path forward.
0 coins
StarSailor
How does the actual ALJ hearing work for a sub teacher appeal? Like do you have to present evidence formally or is it more conversational?
0 coins
Amina Sy
Mine was pretty conversational honestly. The judge asked me questions about my employment arrangement, I explained the per diem setup, they asked the district's rep questions too. I had my pay stubs showing no guaranteed hours and that helped make my case concrete. It's not like a courtroom drama — judges on these cases handle them all the time and they're familiar with the sub teacher issue.
0 coins
StarSailor
That's reassuring. I always imagined unemployment appeals as super formal but that sounds manageable.
0 coins
Amina Sy
Bring documentation of your per diem status, any (or lack of) written offers, your pay history showing variable hours. That's really all you need. The lack of a written assurance letter is your strongest exhibit.
0 coins
Javier Morales
What happens if OP wins the appeal — do the benefits get paid out all at once for the whole summer period or in installments?
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
If the appeal is approved, NYSDOL typically processes the back payments as a lump sum for all the weeks you were eligible and filed for. That's another reason why filing those weekly claims during the pending period matters — only the weeks with filed claims get paid out.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Got it. So the weekly filing is basically creating the record of which weeks you're owed payment for.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorThis whole thread has been eye opening. I had no idea weekly filing during a denial was even a thing you could do.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
OP, you have more options here than the initial denial made it seem. Per diem status with no written assurance is genuinely a defensible appeal situation. The 30-day clock is your biggest constraint right now — file the appeal first, then work on the missed weeks and phone contact issues in parallel.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
AuthorYou're right, I think I was just stunned by the denial and kind of froze. Filing the appeal is the move.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
Totally understandable reaction. These denials are worded in a way that feels final even when they're not. Good luck — come back and update us on how the hearing goes.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Agreed, would genuinely like to hear how this plays out. Sub teacher appeals with per diem status have a real track record of success.
0 coins