Back to New York Unemployment

Kingston Bellamy

Can I get unemployment if got fired Buffalo - NYSDOL eligibility question

Lost my job at a manufacturing plant outside Buffalo two weeks ago and I'm honestly not sure where I stand with unemployment. My supervisor said I was let go for 'performance issues' but honestly the whole thing felt pretty sudden and I never got any warnings in writing. I'd been there almost 4 years. Filed my UI claim through the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal on the day I was fired but it's been sitting in adjudication ever since with no updates. I keep reading different things online - some say if you're fired you can still get unemployment, others say you get automatically disqualified. I have no idea what 'misconduct' actually means in terms of NYSDOL's rules or how they determine it. Anyone in the Buffalo area or upstate who's dealt with this? Did you end up getting approved when you were fired?

Claimyr (claimyr.com) is worth trying while your claim sits in adjudication - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent who can actually tell you what's happening with your specific case. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - when my own adjudication dragged past 3 weeks I had no idea what the holdup was until I finally got an agent on the line. Turned out there was a questionnaire pending that nobody told me about.

0 coins

That pending questionnaire thing is exactly what happened to my brother - he had no idea NYSDOL was waiting on him to respond and his claim sat frozen for almost a month.

0 coins

My portal doesn't show any questionnaires or tasks pending, so I'm wondering if the hold is on my employer's end rather than mine.

0 coins

Adjudication holds can sit on the employer's response timeline too, so no pending task on your end doesn't mean things are moving.

0 coins

4 years at a job and no written warnings before they fired you - that detail actually matters a lot. NYSDOL looks at whether the employer followed their own progressive discipline policy. If they had a written policy and skipped it, that can work in your favor during adjudication. Pull together anything you have: your employee handbook, any emails from your supervisor, your performance reviews. The more you document now the better your position if this goes to a hearing.

0 coins

Performance reviews were always decent - nothing below satisfactory in the last two years. Would those reviews actually be used as evidence if there's a hearing?

0 coins

Documentation like that is exactly what hearing officers look at. My ex-employer claimed I had repeated issues and I brought in two years of signed reviews that said otherwise - ended up being the key thing in my case.

0 coins

Employer sometimes submits their own version of events first, so getting your documentation together early makes sense rather than waiting to see what they say.

0 coins

Being fired doesn't automatically disqualify you from collecting unemployment in New York - a lot of people think it does but that's not how it works. The question NYSDOL asks is whether you were fired for what they'd call 'misconduct' - basically things like intentionally breaking rules, stealing, or deliberately ignoring clear policies. Getting let go for performance, not meeting quotas, or just not being a good fit is a totally different category and usually doesn't disqualify you. The burden is actually on your former employer to prove misconduct, not on you to prove you didn't commit it.

0 coins

That part about the employer having to prove it is news to me - I assumed I had to defend myself somehow.

0 coins

It shifts to them, yeah. If they can't show documented misconduct NYSDOL tends to side with the claimant. I've seen people approved after being fired with zero issues.

0 coins

Worth knowing though - even if you're approved initially your employer can appeal too, so don't treat approval as the final word until the appeal window closes.

0 coins

Buffalo area here. Went through almost this exact situation about 18 months ago - fired from a logistics company, claim went into adjudication, and I was completely in the dark for almost five weeks. What finally moved things was getting a live NYSDOL agent who could tell me that my former employer had submitted their statement and mine was needed. Nobody sends you an alert when that happens, you just have to somehow know to check.

0 coins

Five weeks in the dark sounds awful. Did you end up getting approved after all that?

0 coins

Approved for the full amount once I submitted my statement within the deadline. Lost those five weeks of benefits though because nobody told me the clock was ticking on my response.

0 coins

That lost-weeks piece is brutal - NYSDOL really should send a notification when employer responses come in and yours is due.

0 coins

30 days is roughly how long you have to appeal if your claim gets denied, and that window runs from the date on the determination letter not from when you read it. Mailed letters especially can eat into that timeline if you're not watching. Set a reminder as soon as any determination arrives.

0 coins

My mailing address is correct on my account but I'll definitely watch for it closely now that I know the window starts from the letter date.

0 coins

Setting up your Unemployment Services account to receive electronic notices rather than mail cuts that delay - worth checking if you haven't done that already.

0 coins

My determination letter sat in my mailbox over a weekend once and I nearly missed my appeal window. Electronic notices are way less stressful.

0 coins

The 'performance issues' label your employer used is vague enough that NYSDOL will almost certainly need to hear from both sides. During adjudication they're essentially investigating whether the reason for termination meets their standard for disqualifying misconduct. Generic performance complaints without documentation to back them up usually don't meet that bar.

0 coins

They never gave me any formal write-ups. Would verbal warnings I never signed anything about matter?

0 coins

Undocumented verbal warnings are really hard for employers to substantiate in adjudication. If your former employer claims they warned you repeatedly but has no paperwork, that tends to hurt their position more than yours.

0 coins

Bring up the lack of written warnings explicitly in your statement if NYSDOL asks for one - don't assume the adjudicator will notice on their own.

0 coins

My adjudication took nearly six weeks and Claimyr is what finally got me actual information - the agent I reached explained that my employer had contested the claim and I had a ten-day window to respond that was almost up. Had no idea. Got my statement in with two days to spare and was approved about three weeks later.

0 coins

Ten-day windows are terrifying when nobody tells you they're running. Really glad that worked out for you.

0 coins

Employer contests happen more often than people expect - companies with HR departments know the process and move fast, so claimants who don't know what's happening end up blindsided.

0 coins

Those tight response deadlines are one of the more stressful parts of adjudication. Getting information early enough to actually act on it makes a real difference.

0 coins

Weekly claims still need to be filed even while your adjudication is pending - I made the mistake of assuming I should wait until everything was resolved before certifying. When my claim was finally approved, the weeks I hadn't certified for were just gone. File every week without fail regardless of what's happening with adjudication.

0 coins

Already been filing weekly since day one, so at least I have that covered. Good warning for anyone else reading this though.

0 coins

This comes up constantly and people lose real money over it. The weekly certification and the adjudication process run completely separately.

0 coins

Filing weekly even with zero payments showing is confusing but yes, absolutely necessary. Those weeks bank up and pay out once approved.

0 coins

My termination also got labeled vaguely by my employer - 'policy violations' with nothing specific listed. What ended up mattering was that I could show I had no written record of any violations before being fired. NYSDOL's adjudicator sided with me pretty quickly once my employer couldn't produce any documentation.

0 coins

Knowing someone got through that exact kind of situation approved is actually reassuring. How long did your adjudication take once both sides responded?

0 coins

About two and a half weeks after I submitted my statement I got the approval notice. The waiting before I even knew to submit anything was the longest part.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks post-statement sounds about right from what I've heard from others - the actual decision period once both sides are in tends to be faster than the initial hold.

0 coins

NYSDOL phone lines out of the Buffalo region are genuinely difficult to get through on. Waiting three or four hours only to get cut off before reaching anyone is not unusual. If your adjudication is active and you need information, early mornings on Tuesday or Wednesday tend to have shorter waits than Monday or Friday - though even then it can still take most of a morning.

0 coins

Tuesday morning noted. I've tried calling twice and given up after two hours each time.

0 coins

Even the 'better' days can run long. The call volume just doesn't match staffing levels for unemployment questions.

0 coins

Upstate lines seem especially rough compared to what people report from downstate. Not sure if it's routing or staffing but Buffalo callers consistently report longer waits.

0 coins

Your job search requirements kick in from day one of your benefit year regardless of whether adjudication has resolved yet. Three employer contacts per week is what NYSDOL requires, and they need to be documented in your job search log. Keep those records organized from the start - if anything gets audited later you'll want them.

0 coins

Three per week - that's what I've been doing but I wasn't totally sure of the number. I've been logging through the portal.

0 coins

Logging through the portal is the right move. Some people keep separate spreadsheets which is fine as backup but the portal log is what NYSDOL actually looks at.

0 coins

Make sure each entry has the employer name, date, method of contact, and the contact person or position if applicable - generic entries sometimes get flagged.

0 coins

Used Claimyr when my adjudication had been sitting for over a month and I genuinely didn't know if my claim even existed anymore. Ended up talking to a live agent who located my file, confirmed my employer had responded two weeks earlier, and walked me through exactly what I needed to submit. Having that conversation was the first time I understood what was actually happening with my case.

0 coins

A whole month without knowing - that sounds incredibly stressful. Glad you got clarity eventually.

0 coins

That 'does my claim even exist' feeling during long adjudications is real. The portal status page isn't always helpful when things are stuck.

0 coins

An agent walking you through what to submit next is genuinely useful because they can see your specific file, not just the general process.

0 coins

Misconduct under NYSDOL's rules is a pretty specific standard - it's not just doing your job badly or having disagreements with management. The employer basically needs to show intentional or repeated deliberate violations of clear workplace rules. Accidental mistakes, honest performance struggles, or being let go because the employer wanted someone different doesn't typically qualify as misconduct. A lot of fired employees end up eligible precisely because employers use 'performance' language when the real reason is just a bad fit.

0 coins

My situation definitely sounds more like a bad fit than intentional rule-breaking. Hoping the adjudicator sees it that way.

0 coins

Bad' fit terminations are actually pretty commonly approved. Employers sometimes'don t realize that framing it as performance without misconduct documentation often results in the claimantwinning.

0 coins

My old HR person told me after the fact that they knew the claim would likely be approved when they filed their response. Some companies just don't contest for that reason.

0 coins

My first time dealing with an adjudication I had no idea that I could call in and ask for a status update at any point - I thought I had to just wait passively for a letter. You can proactively check in on your case, ask what's outstanding, and find out what your employer submitted. You're allowed to know what's in your own file.

0 coins

That's something I genuinely didn't know. I thought I just had to wait it out.

0 coins

Proactively calling to check status is completely within your rights. If your employer submitted a statement that you disagree with, knowing about it early gives you time to prepare your response.

0 coins

The harder part is actually getting someone on the phone to have that conversation - but it's worth the effort once you do.

0 coins

Went through an employer-contested termination claim about two years back and the thing that surprised me most was that the adjudication questionnaire NYSDOL sends isn't always the clearest document. Mine asked questions that felt generic and didn't really let me explain the full context of what happened. I ended up writing a detailed cover letter and attaching it to my questionnaire response.

0 coins

That cover letter idea is smart. The portal forms always feel like they don't have enough space to actually tell your side of things.

0 coins

Attaching additional documentation is fully allowed and often helpful. Adjudicators read supporting materials and they can make a real difference in ambiguous cases.

0 coins

Keeping your additional explanation factual and specific rather than emotional tends to land better with adjudicators - stick to documented facts and timelines as much as possible.

0 coins

After being approved when my company said I was fired for performance, the amount I got was based on my earnings over the base period quarters before I was let go. My weekly benefit rate ended up being higher than I expected because I'd gotten a raise about a year before - worth checking your base period wages to get a rough sense of what your weekly amount might be.

0 coins

Good to know the raise would factor in. I did get a bump about 18 months ago so hopefully that helps.

0 coins

The base period calculation covers roughly the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed, so you can look up your quarterly earnings from that timeframe to estimate.

0 coins

Maximum weekly benefit amount in New York is reasonably high compared to other states - worth checking the current cap because a lot of people assume it'll be lower than it actually is.

0 coins

My adjudication resolved without any letter arriving before the determination - I only found out I was approved because the payment showed up in my bank account. So keep checking your Unemployment Services account and your bank even if you haven't gotten any formal notice, because sometimes the communication side lags behind the actual decision.

0 coins

Checking my account daily at this point. Good to know approvals don't always come with a formal letter arriving first.

0 coins

The portal usually updates before the physical mail does. Checking online is always faster than waiting for paper.

0 coins

My approval showed in the portal at least four days before anything arrived by mail. Worth logging in frequently especially in the first few weeks after adjudication starts.

0 coins

Two years before my Buffalo area claim I had gotten let go from a different job and didn't even try to file because I assumed being fired meant automatic disqualification. Left a lot of money on the table that I would have been fully entitled to. Please do not make the same assumption - file no matter what and let NYSDOL make the determination.

0 coins

Really glad I filed even though I wasn't sure I'd qualify. This whole thread has made me feel better about my chances.

0 coins

So many people lose out on benefits they earned because of that exact misconception about being fired. The 'misconduct' bar is genuinely high.

0 coins

Filing and getting denied is always better than not filing and wondering - you can always appeal a denial but you can't go back and claim weeks you never filed for.

0 coins

Used Claimyr after my fifth failed attempt to reach NYSDOL during my own adjudication - the whole morning gone each time, nothing. Finally ended up speaking to an agent who confirmed my claim was actually flagged for a wage verification issue completely unrelated to the termination reason. Cleared it up in one conversation.

0 coins

Wage verification issue sounds like it could have dragged on forever if you hadn't gotten someone on the line. That whole thing must have been such a relief.

0 coins

Flags like that don't show up clearly in the portal - they just look like a standard pending adjudication from the outside, which is exactly why talking to an agent is worth the effort.

0 coins

Unrelated hold reasons are more common than people realize - your termination reason can be fully fine while something else entirely is what's actually delaying the claim.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure