Back to New York Unemployment

Hassan Khoury

Can I get unemployment if I was fired for performance issues? NYSDOL question

So I got let go from my job last week and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. My employer told HR it was a 'performance-based separation' - basically I had missed some deadlines on a project and they'd given me a written warning two months before. I never did anything dishonest or intentionally wrong, I just struggled with the workload after they restructured my team and doubled my responsibilities without any extra support. I filed my UI claim on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal the day after I was let go. It's showing as 'pending' and I know there's going to be some kind of adjudication because my former employer will probably respond to the claim. I guess my main question is whether NYSDOL considers performance-based terminations the same as misconduct, because I've heard different things from different people. Some say I'll definitely get disqualified, others say performance issues aren't the same as misconduct and I should be fine. Anyone been through something like this?

Went through almost this exact situation about eight months ago. My employer called it 'failure to meet performance standards' on my separation paperwork. Got approved for UI benefits after adjudication, took about 3.5 weeks. The key thing NYSDOL looks at is whether what happened was actual misconduct or just not being good enough at the job - those are legally treated differently in New York.

0 coins

Did they ever ask you to send in any documentation during the adjudication, or did they just review what the employer submitted?

0 coins

my employer fought my claim and said i was fired for misconduct even though it was performance and i still got approved lol so employers saying misconduct doesn't automatically mean nysdol agrees with them

0 coins

Had a similar situation and kept hitting walls trying to get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone to explain what was actually happening with my claim during adjudication. After calling for days and getting cut off or stuck on hold forever, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. Finally got my questions about the adjudication process answered by an actual person. For your situation specifically, being able to ask an agent whether performance vs misconduct matters for your claim could save you a lot of guessing.

0 coins

How long did getting through to an agent actually take when you used it?

0 coins

does it work for people who already filed or only if ur trying to file for the first time

0 coins

i spent like 3 hours on hold twice and got disconnected both times, might give this a shot just to actually talk to someone

0 coins

I used to think getting fired automatically meant no unemployment - took me a whole lost claim to figure out that's not how it works in New York. NYSDOL draws a pretty clear line between firing someone for misconduct versus firing them because their performance wasn't meeting the bar. Misconduct in NY unemployment law basically means you did something deliberately wrong or showed a real disregard for your employer's interests - stealing, repeated policy violations you knew about, that kind of thing. Struggling with a job that got harder isn't that. Performance separations usually don't disqualify you from UI benefits.

0 coins

The written warning they gave me two months before - does that factor in negatively at all, or is it mostly about whether the underlying reason was misconduct?

0 coins

the written warning actually helps you in a weird way because it shows the employer documented a process, not that you did something suddenly wrong or malicious

0 coins

wait so if you get fired for being bad at your job you can still collect unemployment?? i always assumed fired = no benefits no matter what

0 coins

Your employer is going to file a response to NYSDOL during adjudication - pretty standard. What matters is how they characterize the reason. If they write 'terminated for misconduct' on that form, NYSDOL will schedule a phone interview with you to hear your side. If they write 'performance' or 'inability to perform job duties,' your claim will likely move through adjudication faster and cleaner. Either way you should write down everything you remember about the restructuring, the increased workload, and any communications you had with your manager - dates, what was said, emails if you have them.

0 coins

My termination letter says 'separation due to performance' - does that exact wording on the letter matter or is it what the employer puts in their NYSDOL response that counts?

0 coins

both matter honestly, but the NYSDOL employer response form is what adjudication is based on, the termination letter is just supporting documentation you can submit

0 coins

i got a phone interview during adjudication and the rep was actually really fair about listening to my situation, wasn't as scary as i thought it would be

0 coins

My claim went into adjudication after being fired for performance and I panicked thinking I'd get denied. Filed the appeal in my head before they even decided lol. But three weeks later I got approved with no issues. The adjudicator left a note in my account saying something like the separation didn't meet the threshold for disqualifying misconduct. Keep filing your weekly claims during adjudication no matter what - if you stop and then get approved you create a whole mess with backdating.

0 coins

Are you still required to do the three job search activities per week while the claim is in adjudication, or is that only after you're officially approved?

0 coins

yes you do the job search requirements from week one regardless of adjudication status, those are separate from whether ur claim is approved

0 coins

the backdating thing is SO real, my cousin didn't file weekly claims while waiting and lost weeks of benefits even after getting approved

0 coins

Honestly couldn't get a straight answer from the NYSDOL website about how they weigh performance terminations. Called for weeks - either couldn't get through or got hung up on after 45 minutes. A friend told me to try Claimyr and I finally ended up talking to a real agent who explained the whole thing. Apparently the rep told her that if there's no dishonesty, no policy violations, and no intentional harm to the employer, they typically won't classify it as disqualifying misconduct.

0 coins

What specific questions did your friend end up asking the agent - was it mainly about their particular situation or about the general rules?

0 coins

this confirms what i suspected, the phone line is just impossible to get through on normally

0 coins

I thought for the longest time that a formal written warning before termination would basically seal your fate as a misconduct case. Went through adjudication convinced I was done. Turns out what actually matters is whether the warning was for something you intentionally did wrong versus just not hitting performance targets. NYSDOL adjudicators are specifically looking for willful or deliberate behavior, not just an employer who was unhappy with results.

0 coins

My warning mentioned 'failure to meet project deadlines' - does that specific framing push it toward misconduct territory in NYSDOL's eyes?

0 coins

missing deadlines on its own is not misconduct under ny law unless you were deliberately sandbagging or ignoring direct orders, just being overwhelmed or struggling isn't the same thing

0 coins

my adjudicator actually told me straight up that performance and misconduct are evaluated completely differently, it's not a gray area for them

0 coins

UGH this whole thing makes me so angry. I was fired for 'performance' last year and NYSDOL denied me saying my employer claimed misconduct. Had to appeal and go through a hearing before finally getting approved four months later. The appeal process works but it takes forever and you're basically living on nothing while you wait. Fight everything in writing and keep copies of absolutely everything.

0 coins

If the initial adjudication comes back as denied, how quickly do you have to file the appeal? I want to know the deadline ahead of time just in case.

0 coins

you have 30 days from the mailing date on the determination letter, don't wait until the last minute because getting your appeal documents together takes time

0 coins

appeals are nerve wracking but the hearing reps at the unemployment insurance appeals board are actually pretty knowledgeable, way better than trying to explain your situation to a random phone rep

0 coins

Fired for performance here, approved in about 23 days. My situation was similar - manager kept adding responsibilities after a team reduction and I couldn't keep up. What helped me was writing a brief statement in the notes field when I filed explaining the restructuring context. I didn't argue with my employer's characterization, I just laid out the facts of what happened to my workload. Clear and factual, no emotional language.

0 coins

Where exactly do you submit that kind of statement - is there a specific field in the Unemployment Services portal when you first file, or do you have to wait until they contact you?

0 coins

there's a text box during the initial filing where it asks about your separation reason - that's where i put the context, keep it under a few sentences and stick to facts

0 coins

Does anyone know if the industry matters at all? Like are employers in certain fields more likely to successfully argue misconduct? My former job was in finance and they tend to have very specific documented performance standards - wondering if that makes it harder.

0 coins

NYSDOL adjudicators look at the same standard regardless of industry - the documentation the employer has actually works against them if it shows this was about performance benchmarks rather than any willful wrongdoing

0 coins

if anything having everything documented might help you because it makes it clearer what the real reason was

0 coins

oh interesting, i assumed more documentation = worse outcome for the claimant but that actually makes sense

0 coins

i got fired for similar reasons and my employer straight up wrote 'misconduct' on the response form even though it was clearly performance. NYSDOL still scheduled a phone interview and I got to explain everything. The adjudicator asked really specific questions - like whether I had been given the chance to improve, whether I understood what was expected of me, things like that. I passed and got approved.

0 coins

What documentation did you have on hand when they did the phone interview with you, and did they ask you to submit anything beforehand?

0 coins

i had my termination letter, some emails between me and my manager about the workload changes, and my own notes from our meetings - they didn't ask me to submit anything before the call but i referenced stuff during it

0 coins

the fact that they can override what the employer puts on the form is something more people should know, employer word isn't final

0 coins

My neighbor went through this last spring - fired for performance, worried sick about benefits. She'd been trying to reach NYSDOL for two weeks with no luck. I told her about Claimyr and she finally got an agent on the line after all that time stuck on hold. The agent confirmed her firing situation sounded like a performance separation rather than misconduct and told her what to expect during the rest of adjudication. Knowing that ahead of time made the wait much less stressful for her.

0 coins

wait so the NYSDOL agents will actually give you a preview of how they might evaluate your claim? i didn't know they'd be that specific

0 coins

they can't promise an outcome obviously but the agent gave her a pretty clear sense of what matters in those evaluations

0 coins

that's honestly more than i ever got from the NYSDOL website which just has the vaguest possible language about misconduct

0 coins

My performance termination claim took almost five weeks in adjudication because my employer was slow responding to NYSDOL's request for information. The wait was brutal but once the adjudicator had everything they needed it only took about four days to make a decision. Keep filing weekly claims every single week - this is not optional and doesn't affect adjudication, those are just two separate processes running at the same time.

0 coins

If the employer is slow responding and adjudication drags on, is there any way to follow up with NYSDOL to push things along, or is it just a waiting game?

0 coins

you can call NYSDOL to ask about status but they usually just say they're waiting on the employer response - there's not really a way to speed it up from your end

0 coins

five weeks is agony, i don't know how people survive financially during all that waiting

0 coins

The job search activities requirement tripped me up during my adjudication. I assumed that since my claim wasn't approved yet I didn't need to log job searches. Wrong. NYSDOL expects three separate documented work search activities per week from your very first week of claiming, and they can audit those records. Missing that early on cost me some benefits even after I got approved.

0 coins

Are the job search activities supposed to be actual applications or do things like attending a career workshop or updating your resume count too?

0 coins

a mix of things counts - applying for jobs, reaching out to employers directly, attending a workshop at a career center, networking contacts - the NYSDOL site has the full list but actual applications aren't the only option

0 coins

i had no idea workshop attendance counted, i've been doing only applications this whole time

0 coins

Employer appealing your approval is also possible even if you get approved initially - worth knowing. If you get approved and your employer disagrees, they have 30 days to appeal and request a hearing. Hearings are conducted by the Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. At that stage you can present evidence and testimony. Having documented the restructuring and workload changes will matter a lot at that point.

0 coins

If it goes to a hearing, is that something people typically handle on their own or do most people bring a lawyer or advocate?

0 coins

most people represent themselves at hearings and do fine, but there are free legal aid organizations in NY that handle unemployment cases if you want help - worth looking into if yours goes that far

0 coins

i represented myself at my appeal hearing and won, it's not as formal as a real court, more like a structured phone or video call with an administrative law judge

0 coins

ok so reading all this, fired for performance = usually fine for UI, fired for misconduct = usually disqualified, and the difference is whether you intentionally did something wrong. Did i get that right? Because i have a friend in almost this same spot and want to give her accurate info.

0 coins

that's basically the right frame, yes - the burden is actually on the employer to prove misconduct, the default leans toward the claimant being eligible unless there's evidence of willful wrongdoing

0 coins

okay good, telling her to file and not assume the worst

0 coins

Went through adjudication twice - once for a performance firing, once for a voluntary quit. Performance firing got approved in 3 weeks, the voluntary quit is a whole different and much harder situation. If anyone reading this is thinking about quitting instead, do NOT do it without very specific good cause reasons documented beforehand - that's a completely different category with a much higher bar to clear.

0 coins

Good to know there's a distinction - my situation is definitely involuntary so hopefully I'm in the cleaner category here.

0 coins

yes involuntary separation for performance reasons is genuinely the more favorable category from an adjudication standpoint, you're in a better spot than you probably think

0 coins

the voluntary quit rules are brutal, i went through that path and would not recommend to anyone who has any other option

0 coins

Does anyone know if NYSDOL looks at whether the company replaced you after the performance firing? Like does it matter to them whether the job was eliminated versus they just found someone who could do it better?

0 coins

whether they replaced you generally doesn't affect your UI eligibility - the focus is on what you did or didn't do and whether it rises to misconduct, not on what happened to the position afterward

0 coins

yeah i asked an agent about something similar once and they said the job status post-termination doesn't factor into the misconduct vs performance analysis

0 coins

My original claim was denied after my employer claimed misconduct for a performance issue. I was devastated. Filed an appeal and at the hearing the adjudicator asked whether I had been trained adequately and whether my performance issues started before or after my team changed. Those questions are very specific and show that NYSDOL really does dig into the context, not just the employer's label.

0 coins

Those questions about training and when performance problems started - would it help to proactively include that information when I first file, or should I wait until they ask?

0 coins

definitely include it upfront, more context in that initial filing notes field is better than waiting for them to dig it out of you later

0 coins

appeals board hearings are genuinely more thorough than i expected, they actually read the documentation unlike some initial adjudicators who just go off the employer's form

0 coins

Does being fired for performance affect future UI claims? Like if I get a new job and something happens down the road does this termination follow me in the NYSDOL system?

0 coins

your base period wages and claim history are what matter for future claims, not the reason for a past separation - each new claim is evaluated based on its own separation circumstances

0 coins

oh okay that's a relief, was worried about having some kind of permanent mark on my record

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure