Can I collect unemployment if I was fired? What NYSDOL actually looks at
So I got let go from my job at a distribution warehouse last month and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. My supervisor said I was being terminated for 'performance issues' but honestly it was more complicated than that - I had two late arrivals in six months (one because my car broke down, one because my kid was sick) and they used that as the reason. HR gave me a written termination letter that just says 'violation of attendance policy.' I filed my claim with NYSDOL last week and now I'm stressed because everyone keeps telling me different things. Some people say if you're fired you automatically can't get unemployment. Others say it depends on the reason. I really need these benefits because I have rent due in three weeks and I still haven't found a new job yet. Can I collect unemployment if I was fired for attendance? Does NYSDOL look at the specific circumstances or just the fact that I was fired?
81 comments

Jungleboo Soletrain
I went through almost this exact situation about eight months ago and spent two weeks trying to get someone on the phone at NYSDOL to explain my options. Spent hours listening to hold music before getting disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly with a live agent. I finally got an actual person who walked me through everything about my termination claim. For something like your situation where the reason for firing matters a lot, getting a real human at NYSDOL to look at your specific file is way more useful than guessing from forum posts.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorThanks - two weeks of dropped calls sounds like my worst nightmare. Did the agent actually explain what NYSDOL looks for when they're reviewing a termination?
0 coins
Rajan Walker
I burned through so many hours last year trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL by phone. The hold times are brutal and then you just get cut off. Really wish I'd known about something like that when I was fighting my own termination claim.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
My experience with NYSDOL phone lines is exactly the same - you either get an endless busy signal or you hold for 90 minutes and the line drops. Anything that actually gets you to a live agent is worth knowing about when you have a time-sensitive claim situation.
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
The 'fired automatically means no benefits' thing is a really common misconception and I used to believe it too before my own claim. The way it actually works in New York is that NYSDOL looks at whether you were fired for what they call 'misconduct' - and not every reason an employer gives counts as misconduct under unemployment law. Missing work because of a car breakdown or a sick child is usually treated very differently than, say, stealing from the company or deliberately ignoring a direct order. Two late arrivals in six months with legitimate reasons behind them - that's a thin case for misconduct in most adjudicators' eyes.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorOkay that's actually reassuring to hear. I was afraid 'attendance policy violation' on the letter would be enough to disqualify me no matter what.
0 coins
Ev Luca
This is accurate. My cousin got fired for being late three times and still received benefits because she documented the reasons. The circumstances genuinely matter to NYSDOL reviewers.
0 coins
Avery Davis
I'd add that the employer also has to respond to NYSDOL and provide their side, and sometimes employers don't even bother responding or give a vague answer, which can help the claimant's case too.
0 coins
Collins Angel
Your employer's side of this is going to get a lot of weight in the adjudication process, so what they tell NYSDOL matters. When you filed your claim, you should have been able to explain the circumstances in your own words during the initial filing. If you haven't already, write down everything you remember about those two incidents - dates, what happened, whether you notified your supervisor beforehand, whether anyone else with similar situations was treated differently. NYSDOL adjudicators are specifically looking at whether your behavior showed a willful disregard for your employer's rules, not just whether you technically broke a rule.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorI did give a brief explanation when I filed but I wasn't sure how much detail to include. Should I be doing anything else proactively while the claim is in adjudication?
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Writing everything down immediately is the right move. I lost track of some important details between filing and when NYSDOL finally reached out to me for clarification, and I wished I had documented everything right away.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
Your point about willful disregard is the key distinction. I had a situation where my employer said I 'violated company policy' but the adjudicator found that I hadn't intentionally done anything wrong and approved my claim. The intent piece is what NYSDOL zeroes in on.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
wait so they actually investigate why you got fired?? i thought NYSDOL just took whatever the employer said and denied it. my brother in law got denied last year and i always assumed it was just automatic when you get fired
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
They genuinely do look into it. NYSDOL sends a questionnaire to the employer asking for specifics, and the claimant gets a chance to give their version too. It's not instant - there's usually an adjudication period of a couple weeks - but it's not just rubber-stamping the employer's reason either.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
huh that changes things. my brother in law probably should have appealed then. is it too late for him??
0 coins
Collins Angel
Appeals have a strict deadline - 30 days from the date on the determination letter. If his determination was recent it might be worth checking the letter date, but after that window closes it becomes much harder to challenge.
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
I work in HR and I want to clear up something I see misunderstood constantly. When an employer writes 'attendance policy violation' on a termination letter, that is not the same thing as proving misconduct to NYSDOL. Those are two completely different standards. Your employer decides whether to fire you based on their internal policies. NYSDOL decides whether your behavior rises to the level of unemployment-disqualifying misconduct based on New York labor law. An employer can legitimately fire someone for attendance while that same person still qualifies for UI benefits - these outcomes don't contradict each other.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorWow, I genuinely did not know there were two separate standards. So my employer wasn't wrong to fire me by their rules, but that doesn't mean NYSDOL has to agree it was misconduct?
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
Exactly right. The HR department at your old job wasn't thinking about unemployment eligibility when they wrote that letter - they were following their own internal disciplinary process. NYSDOL applies a completely different lens.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
This is the distinction that trips up so many claimants. I've seen people not even bother filing because they assumed the termination letter was the end of the story, when actually the adjudication process is where the real determination happens.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
i had no idea about any of this until i ended up in the situation myself. filed fully expecting to be denied and then got approved. would have never guessed it went that way based on what i thought i knew
0 coins
Vince Eh
NYSDOL took FOUR WEEKS to adjudicate my termination claim and during that entire time I had zero information about what was happening. No updates on my Unemployment Services account, no letters, nothing. I kept filing my weekly certifications like I was supposed to but I had no idea if any of it was even being processed. The uncertainty is the worst part honestly. At least when you know what the decision is you can plan.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorFour weeks - okay I need to mentally prepare for that. My account just shows 'pending' right now and I have no way of knowing if that's normal.
0 coins
Vince Eh
Pending during adjudication is exactly what mine showed. It just sits there. Some people get resolved faster but mine stretched on and there was genuinely nothing I could do to speed it up. Keep filing your weekly claims no matter what - that part is critical.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
My termination adjudication was about three weeks. The waiting is awful but keep those weekly certifications going because if you get approved, you get paid for all the weeks you properly certified during the wait.
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
Something people don't always realize going into this - your job search log has to be active while you're waiting on adjudication. I stopped doing my required job search contacts because I figured the claim was on hold and it didn't matter. Got a nasty surprise when my claim was finally approved but then flagged for not meeting job search requirements during those weeks. Had to deal with that separately and it delayed my actual payments by another couple weeks.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorOh no, I haven't been doing job search activities because I assumed everything was frozen while in adjudication. How many contacts do I need per week?
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
In New York it's three job search activities per week. It can be applications, interviews, attending a career fair, things like that. Keep records of each one with the employer name, contact method, and date. Do not skip this even when your claim status looks like nothing is happening.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Seconding this hard. The job search requirement doesn't pause just because your claim is under review. I learned this the uncomfortable way too.
0 coins
Ezra Beard
three per week sounds like a lot when you're already stressed but honestly once you get into the habit of tracking it it becomes automatic. just keep a simple spreadsheet
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
I was stuck in a similar limbo trying to figure out whether my termination was going to be treated as misconduct or not. After spending multiple mornings dialing NYSDOL and getting nowhere - either a busy signal or a hold that went past two hours - I finally tried Claimyr. Spent way less time dealing with the phone situation and ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent who could look at my specific claim. She told me exactly what documentation would help my case. For a termination claim where the adjudicator might have questions, talking to someone who can actually see your file is a huge advantage.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorReally helpful to hear that an agent could actually see your file and tell you what they needed. Did she give you a sense of how the adjudicator would view your situation?
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
She was pretty straightforward - explained what factors they look at and what documentation would be helpful to have ready. Didn't promise an outcome but at least I understood the process instead of just sitting in the dark.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
getting actual eyes on your specific claim from an agent is so different from getting general information. the general rules are helpful but every termination situation has its own details
0 coins
Avery Davis
The agents do have access to notes and status information that just doesn't show up in your online account. Worth the effort to actually reach one when your claim has complications like this.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
I had my employer flat-out lie about the reason for my termination when NYSDOL contacted them. Said I had a pattern of insubordination when what actually happened was I pushed back once on being asked to work off the clock. NYSDOL sent me a form asking for my response and I submitted written documentation - texts with my manager, my own work schedule records, an email where I had raised the concern to HR. The adjudicator sided with me. The lesson is you have to respond to every single thing NYSDOL sends you and document as much as you can.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorThat's scary that an employer can just say something untrue - glad you had documentation. What form did NYSDOL send you exactly?
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
Mine was a claimant questionnaire asking for my account of what happened leading up to the termination. Answer every question thoroughly and attach anything relevant you have. Don't assume NYSDOL will figure out the employer is wrong - you have to present your case.
0 coins
Ev Luca
Documentation wins these things. I kept every email and text from my last two months at my job just in case and when my termination was disputed I had receipts for everything I said.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
I'll be real - I had my termination claim denied on the first try and I was devastated because I assumed that was the end. Didn't even know I could appeal until a friend mentioned it. Turns out the initial adjudication had gotten some facts wrong about how long I'd worked there and what my actual role was. Filed the appeal, had a phone hearing with an Administrative Law Judge, and got the denial reversed. The appeals process is real and it works if you have your facts straight.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorHow formal was the phone hearing? I'm picturing something really intimidating.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
It's more conversational than you'd expect. The ALJ asked me questions, my former employer's HR rep was on the line too, and I just explained what happened in my own words with my notes in front of me. It's not like being in a courtroom. The whole thing was maybe 25 minutes.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
Appeals reversed my denial too. The first adjudication was clearly done without much attention to the details I had submitted. The ALJ at the hearing level actually read everything and asked intelligent questions about the specific timeline.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
30 days from the determination letter to file the appeal is the window. Mark it on your calendar the day the letter arrives. Miss that and your options get a lot more complicated.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
okay genuine question - does it matter at all that i signed the termination paperwork? like by signing it did i agree that i was fired for misconduct or something? i signed mine and then spent weeks terrified i had waived my right to unemployment
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
Signing termination paperwork just acknowledges you received it - it doesn't mean you agreed with the reason or admitted to anything regarding unemployment benefits. Your right to file a claim and have NYSDOL make its own determination is completely separate from whatever you signed with your employer.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
okay that is such a relief to hear. i wish someone had told me that when i was sitting in that HR office
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
HR offices don't exactly advertise that detail, unsurprisingly. The termination paperwork is an employment document. NYSDOL adjudication is a separate legal process and your signature on an internal company document has no bearing on it.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
My termination was for 'violation of company policy' just like yours and I was absolutely certain I was going to be denied. Filed anyway because I had nothing to lose. NYSDOL determined that a single policy violation without prior warnings or a documented progressive discipline process didn't meet the bar for misconduct. Got approved. The number of warnings and whether the employer actually followed their own discipline procedures matters a lot to adjudicators.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorMine had one verbal warning, then straight to termination. No written warning in between. Does the lack of progressive discipline actually help my case?
0 coins
Tate Jensen
In my situation it did. The adjudicator specifically noted that there was no documented progressive discipline. It's not a guaranteed outcome but it's a factor that works in your favor when it's missing.
0 coins
Collins Angel
Consistency matters too - if your employer disciplined other employees differently for the same type of issue, that inconsistency can also factor into how the adjudicator views whether the firing was truly for misconduct or for some other reason.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
I want to push back a little on the idea that this process is straightforward. My termination adjudication went against me initially even though I genuinely believed I had a good case. The adjudicator made a determination based on a brief employer response that I never got to see before the decision was issued. By the time I got to respond it was already a denial I had to appeal. The system works but it's not always clean on the first pass.
0 coins
Vince Eh
This happened to me too. The initial adjudication felt almost random. Appeal was where my case actually got properly considered.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
Exactly my experience. I'm not saying don't file or don't have hope - absolutely file and fight for it. Just don't treat the first determination as the final word if you believe the facts support your claim.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
the appeals process existing is honestly one of the most important things to know. so many people get denied and just walk away when they had a winnable case
0 coins
Ezra Beard
my first unemployment claim after being fired i didn't document ANYTHING because i thought it was a simple process. the adjudicator had questions, i couldn't answer them well, got denied, missed the appeal deadline because i didn't realize how short the window was. second time this happened to me i kept everything, answered every NYSDOL communication within 24 hours, documented my job search contacts daily, and got approved. night and day experience.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorMissing the appeal deadline sounds awful. Was there any way to reopen it after that?
0 coins
Ezra Beard
There's something called a late appeal but you have to prove really exceptional circumstances - like a medical emergency or something that genuinely prevented you from filing. 'I didn't know' doesn't qualify. Keep track of every date on every letter NYSDOL sends.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
Every NYSDOL letter has a specific date and usually a deadline attached to it. Treat every piece of mail from them as time-sensitive until you've confirmed it isn't.
0 coins
Aria Khan
Tried reaching NYSDOL for three days straight when my termination claim went into adjudication and I wanted to understand the timeline. Phone line was either busy outright or would ring forever and disconnect. A coworker mentioned Claimyr and I figured I had nothing left to lose at that point. Ended up with a live NYSDOL agent on the line who told me exactly where my claim was in the process and what the next steps were. For a termination case where the outcome is uncertain, knowing your actual claim status from someone who can see it is completely different from staring at a 'pending' screen.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorThree days straight and nothing - that's demoralizing. Did the agent give you any sense of what was making your claim take longer?
0 coins
Aria Khan
She explained that my employer had submitted a response that raised additional questions so there was a second review happening. Knowing that made the wait bearable - I understood what was going on instead of just wondering if my claim had fallen into a void.
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
Having context for why something is delayed is so much better than just watching a status screen that never changes. The agents can actually explain the process, they're not just reading from the same FAQ page you can see online.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
for anyone who gets approved after a termination - the benefits don't start from when you got approved, they go back to your first week of eligibility. so all those weeks you were filing your weekly certifications while in adjudication, you get paid for those retroactively once the approval comes through. i was expecting one week of payment and got almost six weeks worth at once.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorThat's genuinely one of the most reassuring things I've read in this thread. Keeping up with the weekly certifications actually pays off.
0 coins
Reginald Blackwell
Don't miss a single week of certification even when it feels pointless. That retroactive payment is real money and it only happens if you filed every week you were eligible.
0 coins
Ev Luca
My lump payment when I finally got approved was more than I expected because I had certified every single week during adjudication. Really glad I didn't give up on it.
0 coins
Vince Eh
The weekly certifications feel like you're just pressing a button into the void but please keep pressing that button. It matters a lot.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
I used to think the fired-equals-denied rule was basically universal until I saw my own claim get approved after a termination. The adjudicator's determination letter actually walked through the specific factors they considered - the nature of the offense, whether it was deliberate, whether I had warning it could lead to termination, my overall work history with the employer. It read like they actually weighed the facts rather than just checking a box. That said, I know other people with similar situations who got denied on the first pass and had to fight through the appeal. It's not perfectly consistent.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorThe inconsistency is worrying. Is there anything that makes an approval more likely beyond just the facts of the situation?
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
Thorough documentation and prompt response to every NYSDOL communication honestly seems to make a real difference. Claims where the claimant provides detailed, specific information seem to fare better than vague or incomplete responses.
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
The quality of your written explanation when you filed and when NYSDOL asks follow-up questions matters more than people realize. Vague answers leave room for interpretation that doesn't always go your way.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
I want to flag something about the employer's response timeline that tripped me up. My former employer submitted their questionnaire response pretty late, which pushed my adjudication out further than average. NYSDOL gives employers a window to respond and there's nothing you can do to speed that part up. I didn't realize the delay was on the employer's end and I was blaming the system when really my old company just took their time submitting their statement.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorIs there any way to find out if the employer has responded yet or not?
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
An actual NYSDOL agent can tell you where things are in the process. The online account just shows 'pending' - it doesn't break down what stage the adjudication is at or who still needs to submit what.
0 coins
Avery Davis
This is exactly why reaching an actual agent is so helpful for termination claims specifically. There are multiple moving pieces and your online portal only shows you a single status word.
0 coins
Ev Luca
My biggest regret from my termination claim was waiting three weeks before filing. I thought I needed to wait until I had a new job lined up to 'see if I needed it' and I lost weeks of potential benefits because of that misunderstanding. File the day you can. Even if you're not sure you'll qualify, even if you think you might find something fast. You can stop certifying if you get a job, but you can't recover those early weeks you didn't file for.
0 coins
Anna Xian
AuthorI actually filed pretty quickly - within the first week. Good to know I didn't cost myself benefits by waiting.
0 coins
Ev Luca
You're in good shape then. The effective date of your claim goes back to the week you filed, so starting promptly means your potential retroactive payment covers more weeks if you get approved.
0 coins
Ezra Beard
filing fast is probably the single best practical step most people delay on. the system doesn't give you back time you lost before you filed, only after.
0 coins