Back to New York Unemployment

Royal_GM_Mark

Can I collect unemployment if I quit for medical reasons? NYSDOL situation

I'm in a really tough spot and trying to figure out my options. I was working as a dental hygienist for about 4 years and had to leave my job in January because of a worsening autoimmune condition that made it physically impossible to keep up with patient care. My rheumatologist put me in writing that I needed to stop working in my current role due to the physical demands. I didn't get fired - I resigned. Now I'm wondering if I can collect unemployment if I quit for medical reasons, because I've heard mixed things and I genuinely don't know where I stand. Some people told me quitting disqualifies you automatically, others said there are exceptions. I filed a claim already but it's sitting in adjudication and I have no idea if the medical angle even matters to NYSDOL. I've been without income for almost 6 weeks now and I'm starting to really stress about it. Anyone been through something similar?

Week 3 of adjudication when I'm writing this, same kind of situation, so I've been digging into everything I can find. The medical quit question is complicated and I wish someone had laid it out for me earlier. Before I get into what I learned - getting through to an actual NYSDOL agent on the phone was something I couldn't manage on my own for the first two weeks. I finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. The agent I reached explained that NYSDOL does recognize medically necessitated resignations as potentially qualifying under what's called 'good cause' - but you have to show the condition made it truly impossible to continue in that specific job, not just difficult. The key thing the agent told me is that you need physician documentation that's pretty specific about why that job was not viable. Vague notes saying 'patient needs rest' don't cut it. The more precise your doctor is about the physical or medical incompatibility with your job duties, the better your shot at approval.

0 coins

My rheumatologist actually wrote a detailed letter - listed specific tasks that my condition prevents, the progression timeline, everything. So hopefully that counts as the specific documentation you're describing. Did the agent say anything about how long adjudication typically runs for medical quit claims?

0 coins

The adjudication timeline I went through for a similar good cause claim was about 5 weeks from filing to determination. It varied a lot depending on whether NYSDOL needed to verify with the employer too.

0 coins

My paperwork from the doctor was three sentences and they still approved me, so I think 'specific' means different things to different adjudicators. Worth noting anyway.

0 coins

I used to think quitting was always a death sentence for a UI claim - like a hard rule with no exceptions. I held that belief for years actually, went through a layoff specifically because I was afraid to quit even when my health was deteriorating. What I eventually learned is that NYSDOL has a 'good cause' standard, and medical necessity from an illness or worsening condition that makes your job genuinely unsafe or physically impossible can qualify. The tricky part is that NYSDOL adjudicators are looking for a pretty direct chain: doctor says condition exists → doctor says this specific job aggravates or is incompatible with condition → you had no other reasonable accommodation option → you quit. If you can establish that chain with documentation, the quit becomes much more defensible than a regular voluntary resignation.

0 coins

The accommodation part is what worries me a little - my employer did offer to reduce my hours but my rheumatologist said even reduced hours in that environment wasn't going to be medically safe. I mentioned that in my claim. Does the fact that an accommodation was offered but medically insufficient still work in my favor?

0 coins

My claim involved something similar - offered a modified schedule but my doctor said it wasn't adequate. The adjudicator's notes (which I got to see later in my appeal packet) said the accommodation has to be medically meaningful, not just technically offered. So yes, a doctor saying the offered accommodation was still insufficient should matter.

0 coins

My sister went through this exact thing with a spine condition and they tried to say she should've taken the reduced hours offer. She had to appeal and get a second letter from her specialist saying why that offer didn't address the medical issue. Won on appeal.

0 coins

I'm pretty sure this varies by adjudicator honestly. Some really dig into the accommodation question and some barely look at it.

0 coins

My fourth week trying to get through to NYSDOL on the phone before I found Claimyr - I was losing my mind. I eventually talked to an agent who told me something really important about medical quit claims: you should be filing your weekly certifications the whole time your claim is in adjudication, even if you think you might not qualify. If you stop certifying and the claim eventually gets approved, you can lose those weeks permanently. The agent was clear that medical quit cases often do get approved, especially with solid physician paperwork, but the adjudication process takes longer because someone has to manually review the documentation.

0 coins

I've been certifying every week even during adjudication - good to hear that's the right call. The job search requirement during adjudication is what I'm confused about. Am I supposed to be conducting and logging job searches even though I'm medically unable to work in my previous field?

0 coins

The job search requirement during adjudication is something I got wrong at first. While you're certifying during adjudication you're generally expected to maintain job search activity unless NYSDOL has placed your claim on standby status. For medical situations, the 'able and available to work' question is a whole separate issue - if you're claiming you medically can't work, that potentially affects your eligibility on that basis independently from the quit reason.

0 coins

My claim had a note from my doctor saying I was currently unable to work and NYSDOL flagged that as a separate issue from the good cause quit question. I ended up being denied both for the quit AND for not being able and available. Worth getting clear on whether you're 'unable to work in your previous field' vs 'unable to work at all right now.

0 coins

That's a really important distinction you're making. My doctor's letter said I can't perform the physical duties of dental hygiene specifically - but I could do, say, administrative or desk work. So I am able and available to work, just not in my prior occupation. I need to make sure my claim reflects that correctly.

0 coins

My experience with NYSDOL medical quit adjudication lasted about 7 weeks before I got a determination letter. The determination came by mail - they don't post it in your online account first, at least in my case. I want to flag something that tripped me up: NYSDOL sent my employer a questionnaire as part of the adjudication asking about whether I had been offered accommodations, the nature of my resignation, and whether the medical condition was discussed. My employer's response to that questionnaire significantly influenced my case. If your employer is cooperative and confirms the medical circumstances, that helps a lot. If they push back or frame your resignation differently, that can complicate things. I'd recommend having a clear sense of what your employer is likely to say before your claim is fully adjudicated.

0 coins

My former employer and I parted on decent terms - they were actually pretty understanding about the medical situation. I'll reach out to HR to confirm we're on the same page about how the resignation is characterized.

0 coins

My employer filled out the questionnaire and described my departure as 'voluntary resignation' with no mention of the medical context we'd discussed. It looked bad at first. My determination letter came back denied initially even though I'd had a great relationship with HR. The appeal process is where I had to submit all my medical documentation directly.

0 coins

My situation with the employer questionnaire was similar - the HR person who filled it out wasn't even the person I'd dealt with during my departure. So what gets submitted may not reflect the actual circumstances at all. Document everything you told your employer in writing if you can.

0 coins

My claim was approved under good cause medical quit last spring, so let me break down what I actually submitted. First, a letter from my treating physician on official letterhead that named my specific diagnosis, described the physical requirements of my job, and stated explicitly that continuing in that role posed a risk to my health. Second, copies of any internal communication where I raised the medical issue with my employer before quitting - emails are ideal. Third, a written timeline I created myself summarizing the progression: when symptoms worsened, when I consulted my doctor, when I approached my employer, when I resigned. NYSDOL adjudicators are looking to see that you didn't just quit impulsively but that you explored options first and left only when no medically appropriate alternative existed.

0 coins

I have the physician letter and the email trail. The timeline is a good idea - I hadn't thought to write that up as a standalone document but it makes sense that it would help show I didn't quit impulsively.

0 coins

The email documentation piece is huge. I didn't have emails, just verbal conversations, and my adjudicator specifically noted the lack of written record of the accommodation discussion. I won eventually but it took longer.

0 coins

My determination letter actually cited the email chain I included as a primary reason for approval. Submit everything in writing.

0 coins

My first attempt at calling NYSDOL to ask about my medical quit claim status - I spent over three hours on hold across two separate calls and never reached anyone. I'd read about Claimyr in another forum and tried it. Within the same day I was talking with an actual agent at NYSDOL. She clarified something I had been getting completely wrong: I was treating 'able and available to work' and the 'good cause for quitting' question as the same thing. They are two separate eligibility tests. Good cause addresses WHY you left. Able and available addresses whether you're currently in a position to accept work right now. If your medical condition has improved or if you can do some type of work even if not your former profession, you can still satisfy the able and available test even if the reason you quit was medical. This distinction changed how I answered my weekly certifications.

0 coins

This actually cleared up something I've been confused about for days. I can do other types of work - my condition specifically limits dental hygiene duties, not all employment. So when certifying, I should be indicating I am able and available to work, correct?

0 coins

My understanding of this is exactly what the person above described. When you certify weekly and check 'able and available,' you're affirming you can accept suitable work - not necessarily that you're able to do your prior exact job. As long as you're genuinely open to work within your physical capabilities, you can honestly certify as able and available.

0 coins

My claim had me confused on this for weeks because every resource I read conflated the two. The NYSDOL website isn't super clear about it either.

0 coins

My confusion on this exact point led me to undercertify - I said I was NOT able and available because I thought I had to be consistent with the medical quit story. That got my claim flagged for a whole additional issue. Don't make that mistake.

0 coins

My determination came through two weeks ago - approved, medical good cause quit. I want to share what the determination letter actually said because it might help people understand what NYSDOL is looking for. The language in my approval was essentially that the claimant established that continued employment would have been detrimental to health, that the claimant made reasonable attempts to maintain employment through accommodation, and that quitting was the only reasonable option remaining. That's the formula. I also want to say that I used Claimyr after my initial determination and needed to ask a follow-up about retroactive payment timing - getting to an agent quickly made a real difference in getting that sorted out without waiting another three weeks for a letter response.

0 coins

Seeing the actual language from an approval letter is incredibly helpful - thank you for sharing that. 'Continued employment would have been detrimental to health' - that's literally what my rheumatologist's letter says in almost exactly those words. I'm feeling cautiously more optimistic.

0 coins

My approval letter had nearly identical language. The 'reasonable attempts to maintain employment through accommodation' line is the one that some people get tripped up on - if you never raised the issue with your employer before quitting, that element is harder to establish.

0 coins

My rejection actually cited that exact accommodation element as the reason - I didn't document that I'd asked for an accommodation before quitting. Even though I had asked verbally, without written proof it basically didn't count in adjudication.

0 coins

My benefits got denied on the first determination even with solid medical documentation. I want people in this thread to know that a denial is NOT the end of the road. The appeal process exists specifically for contested medical quit situations and appeals are won all the time. You have 30 days from the determination date to file your appeal and you can do it online through your Unemployment Services account. The appeal hearing is conducted by phone with an Administrative Law Judge - you can present additional evidence and testimony. I brought my treating physician's expanded letter and won on appeal.

0 coins

The 30-day window to appeal - that's good to know now rather than after I get a determination letter. I'll keep that in mind regardless of which way my adjudication goes.

0 coins

My appeal hearing was actually pretty straightforward. The ALJ asked direct questions about the medical situation, what accommodation was offered, and why it was insufficient. Having my doctor on a letter that addressed those exact points made it manageable.

0 coins

My first claim I didn't know about the appeal option and just accepted the denial. Lost out on weeks of benefits I probably would've gotten. Always appeal if you think your case is valid.

0 coins

The appeal success rate for medical quit claims with physician documentation is reportedly pretty decent, though I've never seen official NYSDOL statistics on it.

0 coins

My cousin works in HR and says they see NYSDOL questionnaires constantly and most of their responses don't include medical details even if the employee and HR discussed it in person. Basically the standard HR response is to list the resignation as voluntary and leave it at that, which does not help the former employee's claim at all. It's not malicious - it's just form-completion behavior. This is why having written communication from before you resigned matters so much.

0 coins

This confirms what someone said earlier about reaching out to HR proactively. I'm going to send an email summarizing our prior conversation about the medical situation so there's a written record now, even though it's after the fact.

0 coins

Doing it after resignation is better than nothing, though the stronger evidence is what was written before you left. An email you send now creates a record but NYSDOL may note the timing.

0 coins

My first week after filing I made the mistake of NOT checking my Unemployment Services account daily. NYSDOL had sent me an online message asking for additional information about my resignation, and I missed the response window. The claim was then determined without my additional input. If you're in adjudication, check your online account messages every single day - not just your certifications. They may send document requests or questionnaires through the portal.

0 coins

Noted - I've been checking maybe every few days. I'm setting a daily reminder now.

0 coins

My missed message situation almost cost me my claim too. The deadline on those portal requests can be short - sometimes only 10 days.

0 coins

My portal had a message I missed that asked me to clarify my last day of work. Because I didn't respond they used the date my employer listed which was different. Created a whole mess to untangle.

0 coins

My physical therapy appointments ran 3 times a week when I was going through my claim, and I wondered if that affected my 'able and available' certification. What I eventually learned from an agent is that scheduled medical appointments don't automatically disqualify you from certifying as able and available - as long as you're available for work during hours outside those appointments and genuinely willing to accept suitable employment. It's similar to how having a part-time job doesn't disqualify you, you just report the earnings. Medical appointments are not earnings but the same general logic applies.

0 coins

I have regular specialist visits and was wondering about this exact issue. Good to know that having medical appointments doesn't by itself affect the able and available certification.

0 coins

My understanding matches this. The 'able and available' question is about your genuine willingness and capacity to accept suitable work, not about whether your schedule has any occupied time slots.

0 coins

I think people stress too much about the able and available thing. As long as you're not literally bedridden and refusing all jobs, you're probably fine to certify yes.

0 coins

My determination letter had a line about 'compelling necessity' that I didn't see discussed much online. NYSDOL used that term alongside 'good cause' - seems like they're essentially the same standard but applied differently depending on whether your condition was pre-existing versus something that developed during employment. If your autoimmune condition was disclosed to your employer at hiring, they may look at whether the job was always incompatible or whether conditions changed. Worth understanding which category your situation falls into before your determination comes.

0 coins

My condition was actually diagnosed during my employment - it developed over the past two years while I was working there. So conditions definitely changed during employment, they didn't hire me knowing I had this condition.

0 coins

My claim also involved a condition that developed during employment and that timeline worked in my favor - it showed I didn't take the job under false pretenses and that the medical situation genuinely arose from circumstances during the job.

0 coins

My wife is an attorney who handles employment cases and I've picked up some things from her about NYSDOL adjudication. The standard NYSDOL uses for medical quit situations essentially asks: did a reasonable person in the same medical circumstances have any other choice but to quit? It's an objective-ish test, not purely based on how the claimant felt. That's why the physician documentation is so important - it moves the question from 'you felt sick' to 'a medical professional determined you could not safely continue.' If your doctor can frame the letter around medical necessity and the specific job tasks involved, you're presenting the case in the most favorable terms.

0 coins

My rheumatologist specifically listed the physical demands of dental hygiene - sustained awkward postures, repetitive fine motor tasks, aerosol exposure - and said each of those is specifically contraindicated by my condition. That sounds like it fits what you're describing about specificity to job tasks.

0 coins

My denial was partly because my doctor's letter talked about the condition generally but didn't connect it specifically to what my job required. The connection between diagnosis and job duties is the critical link.

0 coins

My doctor was actually willing to revise the letter when I explained what NYSDOL needed. It's worth talking to your physician about framing the letter around your job duties specifically, most doctors aren't thinking about unemployment insurance requirements when they write those letters initially.

0 coins

My determination arrived on a Thursday, a denial, and I had exactly 30 days to file the appeal. I want to walk through the appeal process because I think a lot of people give up at this stage unnecessarily. You file online through your Unemployment Services account under the Appeals section. You write a brief statement explaining why you disagree. You don't need to submit all your evidence at the initial filing - you'll have the opportunity to present evidence at the actual hearing which is scheduled separately. The hearing notice comes by mail and gives you the date and time. The hearing itself is conducted by phone with an ALJ who reads the case record and then asks questions of both you and sometimes a representative from your former employer.

0 coins

If I end up needing to appeal, is there any way to have legal representation at the hearing or is it always just you vs. the system?

0 coins

You absolutely can have legal representation - an attorney or even a non-attorney representative can appear with you. Many legal aid organizations handle unemployment appeals at no cost. The employer can also have a representative, often an HR person or a third-party employer service.

0 coins

My appeal hearing my former employer didn't even participate. The ALJ told me that happens fairly often for small employers. It made the hearing feel more like a conversation than an adversarial proceeding.

0 coins

My claim experience taught me to keep a paper file of absolutely everything related to the claim. Every determination letter, every message from the portal, every certification receipt, every piece of documentation submitted. NYSDOL's online system can be inconsistent about what stays visible in your account history. I've had document submissions seemingly disappear from my portal view. Physical copies of everything gave me a complete record when I needed to reference prior submissions during my appeal.

0 coins

This is a really practical tip. I've been screenshotting portal pages but haven't been printing them. I'll start keeping a physical folder.

0 coins

My appeal packet included references to documents I had no memory of submitting. Having your own organized record means you can quickly identify what NYSDOL has versus what they're missing.

0 coins

week 8 no determination yet and my savings are almost gone. does anyone know if theres a way to expedite adjudication for financial hardship? i cant find anything about it on the NYSDOL site

0 coins

My understanding is that NYSDOL doesn't have a formal hardship expedite process for adjudication the way some agencies do. What you can do is request a status update through your online account messages or by phone. If a determination is unreasonably delayed, there is an option to contact the NYSDOL ombudsman - that sometimes moves things. Also look into emergency assistance programs through your county's Department of Social Services while the claim is pending.

0 coins

My claim took 9 weeks and I know that doesn't help you feel better right now. The only thing I could do was keep certifying weekly so the payments would start immediately once approved, covering all the pending weeks.

0 coins

My county has a one-shot emergency assistance program through social services that helped tide me over. It doesn't affect unemployment eligibility. Worth checking what your county offers.

0 coins

My situation ended up being more complicated than I initially understood: I had to deal with both the good cause quit question AND a separate issue about whether I was medically able to work at all. Those are two different boxes NYSDOL has to check to pay benefits. Somebody mentioned this upthread but I want to really emphasize it because I didn't take it seriously enough. Even if NYSDOL finds you had good cause to quit, they can still deny benefits if they determine you're not currently able and available for work. For people leaving due to medical conditions, those two issues often get tangled together in ways that require careful separation.

0 coins

What ended up resolving your able and available question? Did you need additional documentation from your doctor specifically addressing current work capacity versus the past medical necessity of the quit?

0 coins

My doctor wrote a second letter that specifically said 'as of [date], patient is able to perform sedentary and light duty work and is available for employment not requiring [specific limitations].' That document addressing current status separately from the original resignation-focused letter is what ultimately resolved that part.

0 coins

My claim required two separate letters too - one about why I had to leave the prior job and a second one focused on what I can do now. NYSDOL treats them as separate questions even if they both involve the same medical condition.

0 coins

My claim got approved about two months ago and I want to share the final practical thing that made a difference for me after approval: the first payment sometimes takes an additional week beyond the determination because of a one-week waiting period that NYSDOL applies to most new claims. That week is typically non-compensable - you don't get paid for it. It's not a processing delay, it's by design. So if you get approved and your first payment seems like it's missing a week, that's likely what's happening. Worth knowing so you don't panic and think something went wrong after finally getting the approval.

0 coins

I had no idea about a waiting week. That's a really useful thing to know in advance rather than after the fact.

0 coins

My first payment was confusing because of this exact thing. The determination letter does mention it but in fairly small print that I initially glossed over.

0 coins

My waiting week ended up being the week I filed, which I hadn't certified for initially. The agent I spoke with helped me sort it out but it took a few calls to fully understand what weeks mapped to what payments.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure