


Ask the community...
I just went through this exact situation a few months ago - hours cut from full-time to barely part-time, then got hit with a "voluntary quit" determination. The appeal process was stressful but totally worth it. A few things that really helped my case: 1) I took photos of my work schedule/timesheet showing the dramatic hour reduction over time, 2) I saved any text messages or emails where my supervisor mentioned the cuts were permanent or business-related, and 3) I documented how the reduced income made it impossible to pay basic expenses like rent. The hearing was actually pretty straightforward - the judge asked direct questions about what happened and why I left. My employer didn't even show up to contest it, which happens more often than you'd think. The whole process from appeal to decision took about 6-8 weeks for me. Don't let them intimidate you - if your hours were genuinely cut to the point where you couldn't survive on them, you have every right to those benefits. The system is designed to help people in situations exactly like yours.
This gives me so much hope! The fact that your employer didn't even show up is interesting - I wonder if that happens because they know they don't have a strong case when they've clearly cut someone's hours that drastically. Your point about documenting the financial impact is really smart too. I hadn't thought about gathering evidence showing how the reduced wages affected my ability to pay basic expenses, but that makes total sense for proving the job became unsustainable. Thanks for sharing your timeline too - knowing it might take 6-8 weeks helps me plan better. Did you continue to certify for benefits during the appeal process or do you have to wait until it's resolved?
I went through a similar appeal last year after being wrongly classified as a voluntary quit when my employer cut my hours from 32 to about 6 per week. The whole process was intimidating at first but definitely worth fighting. A couple of additional tips that helped me: Make sure you file your appeal online through my.ny.gov rather than mailing it - the online system gives you a confirmation receipt and tracks your submission. Also, when you write your appeal statement, be very specific about the timeline - include exact dates when your hours were cut, how much they were reduced, and when you ultimately had to leave. I created a simple spreadsheet showing my weekly hours and pay for about 3 months before and after the cuts, which made the impact crystal clear to the judge. One thing I wish someone had told me is that you can continue certifying for benefits during the appeal process even though you're not getting paid yet - this keeps your claim active. If you win the appeal, they'll pay you retroactively for those weeks. The hearing itself was less scary than I expected - just be honest, stick to the facts, and have your documents organized. You've got this!
I went through the exact same thing last year - filed in March and didn't see a penny until July! The "pending determination" status you're seeing is key. In my case, it turned out my former employer had flagged my claim for review but nobody bothered to tell me. What finally worked was calling at exactly 8:00 AM on a Tuesday (they seem to have more staff then) and staying on hold for 2+ hours. Yes, it's brutal, but I finally got through to someone who could see what was holding up my claim. They also backdated everything once the issue was resolved. Don't give up - that money is rightfully yours!
Thanks for sharing your experience! That gives me hope that this will eventually get resolved. I'm going to try calling at 8 AM on Tuesday like you suggested. Two hours on hold sounds awful but if that's what it takes to finally talk to someone, I'll do it. Did they tell you specifically why your employer flagged your claim? I'm wondering if that's what's happening to me too since I see the same "pending determination" status.
In my case, my employer had contested the claim saying I was fired for misconduct (which wasn't true - I was laid off due to budget cuts). But here's the crazy part - NYSDOL never sent me any notice about this dispute! I only found out when I finally got through to an agent. She said there should have been a hearing scheduled but somehow I was never notified. Once I explained my side of the story and provided my layoff documentation, they cleared it up immediately and released all my backpay within 3 days. Definitely try that Tuesday 8 AM call - it's your best shot at getting answers!
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now - filed in late January and still waiting on my first payment! The "pending determination" status is so frustrating because they give you zero information about what's actually wrong. I've been following this thread and trying some of the suggestions people mentioned. One thing that helped me was checking the "Correspondence" section in my online account (not just Messages) - I found a notice there that I had somehow missed before asking for additional wage verification from a previous employer. Maybe check there if you haven't already? Also, I tried the Claimyr service that Sofia mentioned and actually got through to an agent yesterday! Turns out my claim was flagged because my previous employer never responded to their verification request, so it was just sitting in limbo. The agent was able to push it through and said I should see payments within 5-7 business days. Fingers crossed! Keep pushing - it's exhausting but we have to advocate for ourselves since the system won't do it for us. 💪
This is really helpful! I just checked the "Correspondence" section and found a notice I completely missed from 2 weeks ago asking for additional documentation about my job separation. No wonder my claim has been stuck! I'm uploading the requested documents right now. Thanks for mentioning that - I had only been checking the Messages section. Really hoping the Claimyr service works for you and you get your payments soon! It's encouraging to hear someone actually got through to an agent and got some real answers.
@Aria Park Yes, they do charge a fee - I think it was around $20 but honestly worth every penny considering I was about to lose my mind from calling for weeks. They have the pricing on their website. For me it was way better than missing more work to sit on hold all day!
Been lurking here for a while and finally decided to jump in since I'm dealing with the exact same nightmare. Week 2 of trying to reach someone about a payment issue and it's honestly affecting my mental health at this point. Reading through all these comments gives me some hope though - seems like there are actual solutions that work! Going to try that 8am call strategy with the specific number sequence first, and if that doesn't work I'll look into the Claimyr service. Thanks everyone for sharing what's worked for you, this community is a lifesaver when the system is failing us this badly.
@KaiEsmeralda I completely relate to the mental health aspect of this whole ordeal. I went through something similar last year and it was exhausting having to choose between spending entire days on hold or risking missing important calls. One tip that saved my sanity - if you do try the manual calling route, consider using speaker phone and doing other activities while you wait. I actually got through twice by calling while doing household chores, so I wasn't just sitting there getting more frustrated by the minute. The system really shouldn't be this broken, but at least this community has shown there are ways around it. Rooting for you!
@KaiEsmeralda Welcome! You're definitely in the right place - this whole thread has been so helpful for me too. I was literally at my breaking point after 2+ weeks of getting nowhere with the phone system. That feeling of it affecting your mental health is so real and valid - it's incredibly stressful when you need help with your benefits and can't even reach a human being. The 8am strategy with the specific number sequence that @Jay Lincoln shared is definitely worth trying first. If that doesn t'work out, the Claimyr option seems to be working for people even though it costs money. Sometimes you just have to invest in your sanity, you know? Really hoping you get through soon - keep us updated!
The phone system is ridiculous. I've called probably 200 times over the past month trying to get my disqualification explained and I've gotten through TWICE. Both times they told me different things about my appeal process. The whole NYS Department of Labor phone system needs to be completely overhauled.
I feel your pain! I've been dealing with the same issue trying to reach them about my benefit calculation. What worked for me was calling exactly at 8:00 AM on Tuesday - seems like they have more staff available earlier in the week. Also, I noticed that if you select the option for "reporting fraud" (even though that's not what you need), you sometimes get through to a real person faster who can then transfer you to the right department. It's frustrating that we have to use these workarounds just to get basic help with our claims.
That's a smart tip about calling at 8 AM on Tuesday! I never thought about trying different days of the week. The fraud option workaround is clever too - it's sad that we have to game the system just to get help. I'm going to try your Tuesday morning strategy next week. Did you actually get your benefit calculation issue resolved when you finally got through?
Michael Adams
I went through something similar a few months ago and it was nerve-wracking! In my case, the "pending issue/denied" status showed up because NYS Department of Labor needed to verify my reason for leaving my last job - apparently my employer had reported it differently than what I put on my initial application. The whole thing took about 4-5 weeks to resolve, but like others said, I kept filing my weekly claims and got all the back payments once they cleared it up. One thing that helped me was logging into the website daily to check if any new correspondence appeared in my inbox, even though they're supposed to mail stuff too. Sometimes there are additional documents or questionnaires they want you to fill out that only show up online. Hang in there - most of these issues do get resolved eventually!
0 coins
AstroAce
•That's really helpful to know about checking the online inbox daily! I hadn't thought about additional documents only showing up there. Did you get any kind of notification when they finally resolved your case, or did you just notice the status change when you checked? I'm trying to figure out if I should expect some kind of alert or if I need to keep checking manually every day.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
I had the exact same status appear on my claim about 6 months ago and I completely panicked! Turns out it was because I had reported some freelance work income but didn't include all the documentation they needed. The key thing I learned is that "pending issue/denied" doesn't mean you're actually denied yet - it just means they've flagged something that needs review before they can continue payments. Definitely keep filing your weekly claims like others have said, because those weeks will get paid retroactively if the issue gets resolved in your favor. Also, try checking your online account every few days for any questionnaires or document requests that might pop up - sometimes they'll ask for additional info to help resolve the issue faster. The waiting is awful but most of these do get cleared up within a few weeks!
0 coins