Back to Nevada Unemployment

Sadie Benitez

Unemployment employer appeal hearing phone call together with former employer - what to expect at Nevada DETR?

So I'm about two weeks out from my scheduled Nevada DETR appeal hearing and honestly I'm spiraling a bit trying to figure out how this is going to work. Quick background: I got disqualified after my former employer contested my UI claim, saying I quit voluntarily without good cause. That's completely wrong - I left because they cut my hours down to basically nothing and refused to put anything about it in writing. Filed the appeal, got the hearing date, and now I'm staring at this notice that says the hearing will be conducted by phone with both me AND my former employer on the line at the same time. I genuinely did not expect that. I thought it would be like, me presenting my side, then them presenting theirs separately. The idea of being on a live call with the person who basically tried to cut me out of my benefits while a hearing officer asks questions... I don't know how to prepare for that. Do I need an attorney? Can I bring documentation somehow? What actually happens during the call - does the employer go first or do I? And is there anything specific I should know about how Nevada DETR appeal hearings run versus just the general appeals process info you find on Google?

Week three of my own adjudication mess here, waiting on a different issue, but I wanted to jump in on this thread because the phone hearing situation is something I know a bit about AND because I want to mention something that helped me actually get a human at Nevada DETR before my hearing. I'd been trying to call for days to ask procedural questions and kept getting the busy signal loop or disconnected. Someone on another forum mentioned Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY that shows how it works. Basically it holds your place in the phone queue so you're not manually redialing for hours. Got through to an agent in the same day I tried it and was able to ask all my pre-hearing questions directly. For your situation specifically, calling ahead to ask the hearing officer's office about the exact format of the joint call would be really valuable - they can tell you things like whether you'll be muted while the employer speaks, how exhibits get submitted, and what the hearing officer's role is. That's the kind of thing that's hard to find online but easy to get answered if you can actually reach someone.

0 coins

Just pulled up my CSS account to double-check my own hearing notice and yeah mine also says joint phone call format. I've been dreading the same thing. Did calling ahead actually help you feel more prepared or was it still kind of overwhelming when the actual call happened?

0 coins

Genuinely made a difference. The agent I reached explained that the hearing officer controls the whole call - they introduce everyone, set the order, and can interrupt if someone is talking over another person. Knowing that going in took away a lot of the anxiety about the employer dominating the conversation.

0 coins

the claimyr thing sounds useful but does it work for the appeals division number specifically or just the main claims line

0 coins

Main claims line in my experience, but the agent there transferred me to the appeals office directly. So it's worth using just to get a live person who can then connect you.

0 coins

Finishing up week seven since my disqualification notice landed, so I've been deep in this appeals process longer than I'd like. On your specific question about joint hearings - the thing to ask yourself before anything else is: what exactly does the employer claim happened, and do you have anything that contradicts their version in writing? That question matters because the hearing isn't really a conversation, it's more like a mini trial with a very specific structure. The hearing officer runs it, they swear both parties in, and then typically the party who filed the appeal presents first. Since you appealed, that's you. You'll give your account, the employer will give theirs, and the hearing officer can question both sides. You can submit documents - pay stubs showing the reduced hours, any texts or emails about the schedule changes, even a written timeline you prepared. Email them to the appeals office before the hearing and reference them when you speak.

0 coins

Okay this is exactly what I needed. So I go first because I'm the one who filed - that actually makes me feel slightly better because I can set the frame before the employer says anything. I do have some texts where I asked my supervisor about the hours situation and they basically ghosted me. Would that count as documentation?

0 coins

Texts absolutely count. Screenshot them, compile them chronologically, and email the PDF to the appeals office at least a few days before your hearing date. In your opening statement reference them specifically - 'I submitted Exhibit A, which shows my texts from these dates' - so the hearing officer has them pulled up. The employer not responding to your concerns actually supports the 'good cause' argument because it shows you tried to resolve it before leaving.

0 coins

This is solid advice. I'd add that if you have any old pay stubs or a work schedule printout showing the hours before and after the cut, that side-by-side comparison is really powerful evidence. Numbers are hard to argue with.

0 coins

Got my disqualification letter about five weeks back for a totally different reason but I've been lurking appeal threads trying to learn everything I can. One thing I want to flag: I burned almost two weeks trying to call Nevada DETR about my own appeal questions and got nowhere. Hold times were insane and twice I was just disconnected after waiting. A coworker who went through an appeal last year told me about Claimyr - it's at claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY - and I finally got through. The reason I'm mentioning it here specifically is that for a joint hearing there are procedural things you really want to clarify directly with the appeals office, not just rely on forum advice. Like whether your employer has already submitted any documents you're entitled to see before the hearing. That's a real thing - in some cases you can request to review what the employer is planning to present.

0 coins

Wait, I didn't know I might be able to see what documents the employer is submitting ahead of time. Is that standard or do I have to specifically request it?

0 coins

From what I was told, you can ask the appeals office to let you know what's been submitted by either party ahead of time. It's not automatically sent to you. That's another reason to call rather than just wait - proactive beats reactive in these hearings.

0 coins

Checked my own hearing packet this morning and there's no mention of a document exchange process anywhere in the instructions they mailed me. Seems like it varies or maybe you have to specifically ask. Either way good to know this is a thing.

0 coins

my employer submitted like a whole packet of stuff to my hearing and i had no idea until the hearing officer started referencing things i'd never seen. do NOT let that happen to you, call ahead

0 coins

Three letters deep into the appeals process over here - disqualification, appeal confirmation, and now the hearing date notice. The joint call format freaked me out too at first but here's what helped me reframe it: the hearing officer has done hundreds of these. They're not going to let it turn into an argument. What they're listening for is whether your reason for leaving fits the legal definition of 'good cause' under Nevada unemployment rules, which basically means: would a reasonable person in your same situation have felt they had no real choice but to leave? Hour cuts severe enough that you couldn't sustain yourself financially, combined with the employer refusing to address it, fits that standard pretty well. Your job in the hearing is to tell that story clearly and let the documents back it up.

0 coins

That reframe actually helps. I keep thinking of it as me versus my employer but maybe I should think of it as me presenting facts to a neutral third party who's applying a standard I actually meet.

0 coins

Exactly. The hearing officer isn't rooting for anyone. They want to understand what happened factually. Keep your answers direct, don't editorialize, and when the employer says something that's wrong, you'll get a chance to respond - don't interrupt, just note it and address it calmly when it's your turn.

0 coins

this is the most calming advice in this whole thread honestly, saving this for my own hearing coming up

0 coins

The 'reasonable person' standard is key and it's worth actually using that language in your hearing. Saying 'I believe a reasonable person in my position would have felt they had no real option' signals to the hearing officer that you understand what they're evaluating.

0 coins

My appeal hearing was about six weeks ago and I want to share what I wish I'd done differently. I went in without a written opening statement and I fumbled my own timeline. The employer's HR person had clearly prepared and had everything dated and organized. Even though I eventually won, it took longer than it should have because the hearing officer had to ask me follow-up questions to piece together what happened. Write out a one-page chronological summary: when your hours were cut, by how much, what you said to your employer and when, what their response was, and when you ultimately left. Practice reading it out loud so you don't stumble. That two to three minute opening is your best chance to control the narrative.

0 coins

You actually won with an employer who came prepared? That gives me hope. How long after the hearing did you get the decision?

0 coins

About twelve days after the hearing I got the written decision in the mail. They also posted it to my CSS account. The decision letter explains the reasoning, so even if you're anxious during the hearing, you get a clear explanation of what they decided and why afterward.

0 coins

Twelve days sounds fast - mine took almost three weeks. Meanwhile I'd been trying to call Nevada DETR to check status and couldn't get through for most of that time. Eventually tried Claimyr at claimyr.com and finally got a live agent who confirmed my decision had been mailed. Sometimes you just need to hear it from a person rather than stare at your CSS account hoping it updates. There's also a walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY if anyone wants to see how it works before trying it.

0 coins

Just checked my own CSS account after reading this thread and my decision still isn't showing anything even though the hearing was two weeks ago. Sounds like mail might come before the online update does based on what you're saying.

0 coins

Something I don't see mentioned yet: think carefully about whether you want to bring a witness or representative to your hearing. Nevada DETR appeal hearings allow you to have someone speak on your behalf or corroborate your account - like a coworker who witnessed the schedule cuts or someone who heard you raise the issue with management. They'd need to be available on the phone at the same time. If you have anyone like that, it could really strengthen your case since it's not just your word against the employer's.

0 coins

Actually I hadn't thought about witnesses at all. There was another employee who had their hours cut around the same time who I'm still in contact with. Would they testify just by being on the call?

0 coins

Yes, they'd just need to be on the call and the hearing officer would swear them in the same way. You'd want to notify the appeals office in advance that you have a witness so they're expecting it and can allot enough time. Don't surprise anyone with an unexpected voice on the call.

0 coins

former coworker as a corroborating witness is actually a really strong move because it turns 'he said she said' into something more concrete. worth reaching out to them before your hearing date for sure

0 coins

About two months ago I was in almost this exact situation - employer claimed I quit without cause, I said the working conditions made it impossible to stay. Here's what I learned the hard way: Nevada DETR appeal hearings are recorded, and the transcript can matter if you lose and want to escalate further to the Board of Review. So even if you're nervous and stumbling a little on the call, being factually clear is more important than sounding polished. The recording captures what you actually said, not how confident you sounded.

0 coins

Hadn't even considered what happens if I lose the first appeal. Is the Board of Review another phone hearing or is it different?

0 coins

Board of Review is typically a written review - they look at the transcript and evidence from the hearing, they don't usually hold another live proceeding. That's why getting your facts clearly stated at the hearing level matters so much. You're essentially building the record that any future review would be based on.

0 coins

This is a really underrated point. A lot of people think about the hearing in isolation but it's actually the foundation for everything that comes after if the decision goes the wrong way.

0 coins

Read through most of this thread while killing time between claim weeks and wanted to add one practical angle. I had my joint phone hearing about a month ago - the employer-side person tried to talk over me twice and the hearing officer shut it down both times. So the concern about being bulldozed on a joint call is real but the hearing officer really does maintain control. One tactical thing: take notes during the call. Write down anything the employer says that's inaccurate so you can address it in your rebuttal. You'll get a chance to respond. Also - I know someone already mentioned Claimyr earlier in this thread for reaching Nevada DETR by phone, and I'll second it specifically for the pre-hearing prep stage. Getting to actually talk through procedural questions with an agent at claimyr.com before my hearing was probably the most useful thing I did. Knowing what to expect reduced the panic significantly.

0 coins

The note-taking idea is simple but I genuinely wouldn't have thought of it. Having a notepad during the call to jot down inaccuracies so I can address them without interrupting - that's really useful.

0 coins

Exactly, and don't feel weird about brief pauses to finish writing something. The hearing officer will give you time to respond, they're not rushing through it like a game show.

0 coins

Pulled up the CSS portal just now to look at my own hearing notice again after reading this thread - the instructions literally say 'you may take notes' so it's explicitly fine. Somehow I had it in my head that it was more formal than that.

0 coins

i have been dreading my hearing for like two weeks and this thread has genuinely made me feel like it might be survivable lol

0 coins

Eight days out from my hearing date and I want to ask something nobody's addressed directly - what happens if the phone connection is bad or someone gets dropped from the call? I work in a building with spotty cell service and I'm panicking about technical stuff on top of everything else.

0 coins

Worth calling the appeals office ahead of time to get the exact call-in number and backup instructions. Some hearing officers have a process for reconnecting if someone drops - they'll try to call you back directly. Having a landline or going somewhere with reliable signal for the duration of the call is the safest move. Libraries and many community centers have quiet spaces with good reception if home isn't reliable.

0 coins

Looked into this and my local library actually has private study rooms you can reserve. Booked one for the morning of my hearing just in case. Hadn't even occurred to me to do that before but good call.

0 coins

also make sure you have the call-in number written down somewhere physical, not just in your phone, in case your phone dies or restarts during the call. sounds paranoid but hearing day logistics are worth over-preparing for

0 coins

Just wrapped up week nine since my disqualification so I've had time to really dig into how these hearings work. One thing that tripped me up early: 'voluntary quit' and 'quit with good cause' are legally distinct things in how Nevada unemployment rules treat them. Your employer saying you quit doesn't automatically mean you get disqualified - the actual question is whether your quit was for reasons that would qualify as good cause. Reduced hours that weren't addressed when you raised them fits that framework. The burden in the hearing is kind of on both sides - you're explaining your good cause, they're trying to show it wasn't legitimate. Understanding that it's not just 'did you quit' but 'why did you quit and was that reason compelling' changes how you tell your story.

0 coins

This distinction is actually really important for how I frame my opening statement. I shouldn't lead with 'I quit' - I should lead with 'my hours were cut to the point where the job was no longer viable and my employer refused to address it.

0 coins

That's the exact reframe. You're not defending quitting, you're establishing that the circumstances left you without a real alternative. The quit was the result of their actions, not a free choice you made.

0 coins

Legally this falls under what's sometimes called 'constructive discharge' territory - where the working conditions were changed so significantly that a reasonable employee would feel forced out. That's a recognized concept in unemployment law and your situation sounds like it fits.

0 coins

Honestly the joint phone call format sounds scarier than it is. My hearing was me, my former manager, and a witness on my end, all on the same call. The hearing officer set clear expectations at the start - no interrupting, questions get asked through the officer, everyone gets to respond. It ended up being less confrontational than I expected because the format itself keeps it structured. The employer actually got flustered when the hearing officer kept redirecting their vague claims into specific yes/no questions. Specificity is your friend.

0 coins

The image of the employer getting flustered when pushed for specifics is genuinely reassuring. I think my employer was vague in their initial claim too - just 'voluntarily quit' without details.

0 coins

Vague initial claims tend to fall apart when the hearing officer starts asking for dates, written communications, and specific incidents. Your documentation of the texts and the hour reduction timeline is going to be much harder to argue against than a generic 'she quit' statement.

0 coins

This matches my experience too. The structure of the hearing is actually designed to surface specifics, which tends to favor the person with documentation over the person relying on a broad characterization.

0 coins

Somewhere in week five of waiting for a final determination here, different issue but following this thread closely. Quick question for anyone who's been through the joint hearing: does the hearing officer ever tip their hand during the call about which way they're leaning, or is it completely neutral until the written decision?

0 coins

In my experience completely neutral the whole way through. They might ask more follow-up questions of one party than the other but I'd be careful reading into that - it doesn't necessarily mean they're skeptical of that side, just that they need more clarification.

0 coins

Had the same question before mine. The hearing officer I had gave away absolutely nothing. The written decision was actually the first signal I got of which way things went. Frustrating but that's how it's designed to stay impartial.

0 coins

Okay that's what I expected but good to have confirmed. Going to stop trying to decode whatever the hearing officer's tone means and just focus on presenting clearly.

0 coins

Midway through the appeals waiting period myself - filed two weeks ago. Something that might be worth flagging for the original poster: even while you're in the appeal process, keep filing your weekly claims if you haven't stopped. If you win the appeal, the payments for those weeks may become available, but only for weeks where you filed. Missing a weekly certification during the appeal period is a mistake a lot of people make because they assume the whole thing is on hold.

0 coins

I have been filing weekly this whole time but I'm glad you said this because I've seen conflicting info online about whether you're supposed to stop during an appeal. Definitely continuing.

0 coins

Yeah keep filing no matter what. The appeal doesn't pause your obligation to certify and it doesn't guarantee back pay if you stopped certifying midway through. Keep the record clean all the way through.

0 coins

Confirmed this with an agent a while back - weekly certifications should absolutely continue during an appeal. Missing them doesn't just cost you benefits for that week, it can complicate the eventual payment calculation if you win.

0 coins

genuinely did not know this until this thread, was about to stop filing because i thought it was pointless while appealing. thank you

0 coins

One more angle worth thinking through before your hearing: prepare for the possibility that the employer's witness says something unexpected. Sometimes employers bring someone who wasn't your direct supervisor and may be working from secondhand information. If the hearing officer asks you to respond to something the employer's witness says that you can directly refute with your documentation, that's a moment to be clear and factual. 'That's not what the records show - in Exhibit A you can see that my scheduled hours went from X to Y on this specific date' is much stronger than arguing about recollections.

0 coins

Good point about secondhand witnesses. I genuinely don't know who they'll bring on the call. HR, maybe? Preparing to respond to inaccuracies calmly rather than emotionally is something I need to practice.

0 coins

HR is a common choice for employers because they have access to the documentation and can speak to policy. The thing is, they're often less familiar with the day-to-day reality of what actually happened. That gap between policy and practice is often where your strongest arguments live.

0 coins

HR witnesses also often speak in very formal, policy-driven language that can sound authoritative but actually sidesteps the specific facts of your situation. Keeping your responses grounded in the specific facts - dates, numbers, actual conversations - is a good counter to that.

0 coins

About to hit week two post-hearing with no decision yet. For the original poster, I want to come back to something from earlier in this thread about the emotional side of the joint call. I was really scared about being on the phone with my former employer. What actually helped me was thinking of it less like a confrontation and more like deposing someone in front of a neutral referee. You're not there to win an argument with them, you're there to present your version of events clearly. The employer is almost irrelevant to your performance - stay on your facts, your timeline, your documentation.

0 coins

This is probably the mindset shift I needed most. Stop thinking about 'beating' the employer and start thinking about clearly telling my own story. The employer's credibility takes care of itself when my documentation is solid.

0 coins

Exactly. And the hearing officer has heard a thousand of these. They can usually tell when someone is being evasive versus when someone is being direct. Just be the direct one.

0 coins

The 'just be the direct one' advice is deceptively simple but it's honestly the core of it. Rambling or over-explaining backfires. Short, specific, documented answers beat long emotional ones every time.

0 coins

My disqualification letter came about three months ago and my appeal hearing is now in the rearview. Reading this thread and nodding along to so much of it. One thing I haven't seen mentioned: after the hearing closes, the hearing officer may ask if you have any final statement. Have one ready. Even thirty seconds summarizing your key points - hours cut severely, employer notified and unresponsive, left with no viable alternative - can be the last thing the officer hears before writing their decision.

0 coins

Oh that's a good tip - having a brief closing statement prepared rather than just saying 'no, I think that's everything.

0 coins

Even something simple like 'I want to reiterate that I raised this issue with my employer before leaving, received no response, and had no financially viable path to continue at those hours' - short, clear, hits the good cause standard directly.

0 coins

Great point. The final statement is basically your chance to tell the officer exactly what finding should go in the decision. Don't waste it by saying 'I think you have everything you need.

0 coins

Closing statements are underutilized in these hearings in my experience. The people who nail it use that moment to tie their facts back to the standard the officer has to apply. It makes the officer's job easier and signals you understand the process.

0 coins

Coming up on three weeks post-filing, waiting to hear about hearing date scheduling. For anyone still early in this process like me - reading this whole thread end to end has been genuinely valuable preparation. The joint phone call format seems a lot less scary when you understand it's structured, recorded, and run by a neutral officer who controls the pace. OP, good luck with yours - please come back and update the thread when you have a result.

0 coins

Will absolutely update. This thread has been more useful than anything I found through official channels. Feeling much more prepared going into this.

0 coins

That's what these forums are for. The official Nevada DETR documentation tells you what will happen but not what it actually feels like or how to handle the edges cases. Real experience fills in those gaps.

0 coins

Agreed - bookmark this thread if your hearing comes up. The documentation advice, the note-taking during the call, the closing statement prep, the witness option, the weekly certification reminder - these are all things the hearing notice itself won't tell you.

0 coins

Nevada Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure