Back to IRS

Zoe Papadakis

W2 box 19 has two numbers FreeTaxUSA — which one do I enter?

Filing my 2025 return through FreeTaxUSA and I hit a wall at the local tax section. My W-2 has box 19 filled in twice — there are literally two separate lines there, each with a different number and each paired with a box 20 entry that shows a different locality name. I work in a city that has its own local income tax on top of state, so I'm guessing that's why there are two entries. FreeTaxUSA is asking me for box 19 but only seems to want one figure. Do I add them together? Enter them separately somehow? I don't want to mess this up and have to file an amended return down the road. Anyone dealt with this?

My W-2 had the exact same two-line situation in box 19 last year. FreeTaxUSA actually lets you add a second locality row — there's an option to add another local tax entry once you've filled in the first one. You don't combine the two amounts; you enter each line separately, matching each box 19 amount to its box 20 locality name and the corresponding box 18 wages. The form itself has room for two W-2 localities and that's exactly what that feature covers.

0 coins

Your box 19 had the same two-line thing — did FreeTaxUSA make that second row obvious or did you have to hunt for it? I keep seeing only one field on my screen.

0 coins

The add-another-locality option in FreeTaxUSA is easy to miss because it shows up after you complete the first locality row. Scroll down past the first set of boxes and there should be a link or button to add a second local entry.

0 coins

Agreed — I entered mine the same way, separately, and both locality amounts showed up correctly on my state return too.

0 coins

Two entries in box 19 is completely normal if you paid local taxes to two different jurisdictions from the same employer. The W-2 instructions from the IRS say an employer can list up to four W-2 items on a single form by using multiple columns in boxes 15 through 20. Each column is its own set: box 18 wages for that locality, box 19 tax withheld for that locality, and box 20 the locality's name. You never add the two box 19 numbers together — that would overstate your withholding for one jurisdiction and understate it for the other.

0 coins

The employer filling multiple columns thing — does that mean box 19 line 1 goes with box 18 line 1 and box 20 line 1, all matched to the same locality?

0 coins

Exactly right. Each row is a matched set. Box 18, 19 and 20 on the same line all belong to the same locality, so you pair them that way when you enter them in FreeTaxUSA.

0 coins

Had a coworker who added both box 19 numbers together thinking it was one total. He ended up with a local tax credit that was way off and had to refile his city return. Definitely enter them as two separate entries.

0 coins

A year behind on a state filing messed up my federal return for 2024, and by October of this year the amended return I'd sent in had no status showing anywhere. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the IRS for you so you end up talking to a live agent — and the agent pulled up my account and confirmed the amended return's received date, which was about six weeks before I called. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. Knowing the IRS had the 1040-X in hand meant I could stop worrying it got lost and just wait out the processing window.

0 coins

Your amended return situation — did the agent say anything about how long processing was expected to take after they confirmed receipt?

0 coins

The agent said to allow up to 16 weeks from the received date, which is what the IRS's own site says. No estimate beyond that, just confirmed receipt and said a notice would come once it processed.

0 coins

Six weeks in with no status showing sounds terrifying. Good to know you got confirmation of the received date at least.

0 coins

FreeTaxUSA's local tax section can be a little awkward to navigate but it does handle multiple localities. The key thing I learned the hard way: when you get to the local tax screen, fill in everything for locality one completely before moving to add locality two. If you tab through and leave a field blank, the software sometimes won't show the add-a-second-locality option at all.

0 coins

Filling out locality one completely before adding the second — does that include entering the box 20 locality name, not just the numbers?

0 coins

Yes, the locality name from box 20 goes in too. FreeTaxUSA needs the name to separate the two entries properly. Fill in box 18 wages, box 19 withheld and box 20 name for the first locality, then the option to add the second one should appear.

0 coins

My box 20 had one entry that just said the city name and another that said the county. I filled them in exactly as printed and both pulled through to the right lines on the city return.

0 coins

Looked at this wrong the first time I had two box 19 entries — I thought box 19 was just a running total and the second number replaced the first. That's not it at all. Each row is a separate withholding for a separate taxing body. Your employer withheld local tax for two different places and reported each one on its own line. You owe each jurisdiction its own filing if they require one, and each gets credited only with what box 19 shows on its own row.

0 coins

Your point about separate filings — does that mean I might need to file two local returns, one for each locality in box 20?

0 coins

Whether each locality requires its own return depends on that jurisdiction's rules, which the local tax office or a tax professional would know. FreeTaxUSA usually prompts you if a local return is needed based on what you enter. The IRS side just cares that you're reporting each withholding correctly.

0 coins

My city required a separate local return but the county just reconciled through the state. It totally depends on where you are. Best to check with each locality directly if FreeTaxUSA doesn't prompt you.

0 coins

Went through this exact W-2 box 19 two-number situation last filing season. The thing that confused me first was that my box 18 also had two numbers, one for each locality's wage base. Those don't have to match each other or match box 1 wages, because some localities tax a different portion of your earnings. FreeTaxUSA matched each box 18 to the right box 19 and 20 when I entered them as two separate rows.

0 coins

Your box 18 numbers were different from each other — did FreeTaxUSA flag anything or accept both without an issue?

0 coins

Accepted both without flagging. The software just treats each locality row independently. As long as each box 18, 19 and 20 set matches what's printed on your W-2, you're entering it correctly.

0 coins

My box 18 numbers were the same on both rows but the box 19 amounts were different. Still entered them separately and it worked fine.

0 coins

A CP2000 notice showed up in my IRS Online Account in September for my 2024 return — it said income I'd reported didn't match what an employer had on file. The notice itself wasn't entirely clear on what it was asking for, so I used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with an IRS agent who read me the notice's exact date and what it was asking for: a response with a corrected W-2 from my second job, which my payroll office had reported under a slightly wrong EIN. The agent confirmed the notice date and the deadline to respond, and I sent the corrected document in before that date.

0 coins

Your CP2000 situation with the wrong EIN — did correcting the W-2 through the payroll office fix the mismatch automatically, or did you have to send something to the IRS directly?

0 coins

Had to send the corrected W-2 directly to the IRS at the address on the notice, along with a written explanation of the EIN error. The payroll office corrected it on their end too, but the IRS needed my response to close out the notice.

0 coins

An EIN error causing a CP2000 is more common than people think. My old employer filed a corrected W-2 for me one year and I never got a notice at all — maybe because they caught it before the IRS matched it.

0 coins

My FreeTaxUSA return rejected on the first try last spring because I'd entered my two box 19 amounts added together in one field. The rejection message wasn't specific about which field caused it, so I had to go back through the whole W-2 section. When I found the second locality entry option and split them out correctly, it accepted on the second submission. Saved me from having to paper-file, which I was about to do out of frustration.

0 coins

Your return rejected because of the combined amount — do you remember which field FreeTaxUSA flagged, or did it just say the whole W-2 section had an error?

0 coins

The rejection message was vague, just said there was a discrepancy in the local tax section. No specific field highlighted. I only found the problem by going back and reading each box carefully against my actual W-2.

0 coins

Vague rejection messages from FreeTaxUSA on the local section are frustrating. Matching every field exactly to what the W-2 shows, number by number, is really the only way to catch those.

0 coins

Before FreeTaxUSA I used a different software that didn't even have a second locality field, and I ended up only reporting one of my two box 19 amounts. Got a letter from my city's tax office the following year saying I'd under-reported local withholding. It wasn't a huge deal to fix but it meant filing an amended local return and explaining the difference. FreeTaxUSA at least has the dual-entry option, which is more than I can say for the one I used before.

0 coins

An amended local return because of a software gap sounds like a real headache. Did your city's letter give you a deadline to respond?

0 coins

The letter had a 30-day response window. I filed the corrected local return within that and paid the small difference, and that was the end of it. The city's process was actually straightforward once I knew what they needed.

0 coins

Software that only gives one local tax field is a real problem for anyone with two localities on their W-2. FreeTaxUSA at least handles it, even if finding the second-entry option takes some searching.

0 coins

Tripped over the two-number box 19 thing my first year living in a city with its own local tax. What helped me was printing the W-2 and physically drawing lines connecting each box 18, 19 and 20 on the same row before I started entering anything. That way I never accidentally mixed up which locality's tax amount went with which locality's wages. Low-tech but it kept me from making an entry error.

0 coins

Printing and drawing lines to match the rows — did you do that because the two rows were visually close together and easy to mix up on screen?

0 coins

Exactly. On a printed W-2, the two rows in box 19 are very close together and both have similar-looking numbers if the two localities happen to have similar withholding amounts. Drawing the lines made it impossible to mix up which number belonged where.

0 coins

Low-tech is sometimes the most reliable. I do something similar — I highlight each row in a different color on the paper copy before entering anything.

0 coins

Worth knowing: if you're unsure which locality's name in box 20 matches which number in box 19, your employer's payroll office can tell you exactly how the W-2 was prepared. They're the ones who set up the two-locality reporting, and they should be able to send you a breakdown if the W-2 itself isn't clear enough.

0 coins

Reaching out to payroll for a breakdown — would they typically send something in writing, or is it usually just a phone explanation?

0 coins

In my experience payroll usually just explains it verbally, but you can ask them to email you a summary of how the two entries break down. Having something in writing is useful if a question ever comes up later.

0 coins

My payroll office actually sent me a corrected W-2 one year when I pointed out the box 20 names were too abbreviated to know which was city and which was county. They reissued it with clearer labels.

0 coins

FreeTaxUSA's W-2 entry screen walks you through boxes in order, so when you get to the local section it starts with one row. After you enter all three fields for the first locality — box 18, 19 and 20 — look right below that row for a small text link that says something like 'Add another locality.' It's not a big button, so it's easy to scroll past. That second click opens an identical set of three fields for your second locality.

0 coins

Your description of the 'add another locality' link — is it visible immediately after entering box 20 for the first locality, or do I have to save that row first?

0 coins

In my experience it appears right after you fill in the box 20 field, without needing to save separately. But FreeTaxUSA's layout has changed slightly between years, so if it doesn't appear, try tabbing through once more or clicking outside the last field to trigger it.

0 coins

Had to click outside the box 20 field to get the add-link to appear. Small interface thing but it threw me off the first time.

0 coins

An offset had me worried about my 2025 refund — Where's My Refund showed 'refund sent' but the deposit was smaller than my return showed. I used Claimyr and ended up talking to an IRS agent who pulled up my account and told me the exact refund amount the IRS had issued and the date it was sent. The agent also confirmed there was an offset on the account from a prior federal debt, which explained the difference. I hadn't gotten the Bureau of the Fiscal Service's notice yet, but the agent confirmed the offset was on record.

0 coins

Your offset situation — did the agent say which agency received the offset amount, or just that one existed?

0 coins

The agent confirmed there was an offset on the account but said to wait for the Bureau of the Fiscal Service's notice for the breakdown of which agency received what. The notice came about a week later and had all the details.

0 coins

An offset that shows on the IRS record before the BFS notice arrives is exactly why it helps to call when the deposit amount is off. At least you knew what happened before the paper notice got there.

0 coins

My box 19 had two numbers and I genuinely panicked thinking the W-2 was wrong. Called my employer's HR line before filing and they confirmed both entries were correct — one was city withholding and the other was a school district tax my city participates in. I had no idea school districts could have their own income tax until that call. Entered both separately in FreeTaxUSA and everything matched up.

0 coins

Your employer confirmed a school district tax in box 19 — did FreeTaxUSA have a specific field for school district, or did you just enter it the same as any other locality?

0 coins

Entered it exactly the same way as any other locality — box 18, 19 and 20 as a matched row. FreeTaxUSA didn't treat it differently just because box 20 said a school district name instead of a city name.

0 coins

School district taxes in box 19 are more common than most people expect, especially in certain states. The entry process in tax software is the same regardless of what type of local jurisdiction it is.

0 coins

Went back and forth with FreeTaxUSA support chat one year because I couldn't figure out the second locality entry. The support person walked me through it and told me the two-locality setup is intentional and fully supported — the software just doesn't make it obvious on the first pass. If you're stuck, their chat support responds pretty quickly and can point you to exactly where the second entry option is for your screen.

0 coins

FreeTaxUSA support chat — do they also handle questions about whether each locality in box 20 requires a separate local return, or just questions about data entry?

0 coins

The support chat is focused on how to use FreeTaxUSA's software, not on what each locality's tax rules require. For questions about whether a city or county needs its own return, they usually say to check with that jurisdiction directly or ask a tax professional.

0 coins

That's the right boundary for software support. FreeTaxUSA can get the data into the right fields but the jurisdiction-specific filing requirements are on the taxpayer or a local preparer.

0 coins

Had a moment of doubt about my W-2 when I saw two lines in box 19 and thought my employer had made an error. Asked HR, confirmed both were correct, but then I also noticed my box 12 had two entries too. None of that is unusual on a W-2 — the form is designed to hold multiple entries in several boxes. It only feels wrong if you've never seen it filled out that way before.

0 coins

Your box 12 had two entries too — were those different codes, like a 12a and 12b situation, or the same code reported twice?

0 coins

Different codes — one was for a health savings account contribution and one was for a dependent care benefit. Both showed up with their letter codes in box 12 and both needed separate entries in FreeTaxUSA, same idea as the box 19 situation.

0 coins

Multiple entries in box 12 and box 19 on the same W-2 are both normal. The W-2 form has space for them precisely because many employees have more than one entry in those boxes.

0 coins

My tax situation this year involved remote work for a company based in another city, and my W-2 ended up with box 19 entries for both the city where the company is located and the city where I actually worked from home. Didn't know remote work could create a two-locality W-2 situation. Had to look up whether my home city required a local return, which it did, and whether the other city gave a credit for taxes paid to my home city, which it did partially.

0 coins

Your remote work creating two box 19 entries — did your employer set up the dual-locality withholding automatically, or did you have to request it?

0 coins

My employer's payroll system picked it up automatically when HR updated my work location as remote. I didn't have to request anything, but I also had no idea it was happening until I saw the W-2 at filing time.

0 coins

Remote work and local taxes is one of those situations where the W-2 can look confusing even when everything is set up correctly. Good that your employer's payroll caught it.

0 coins

W-2 box 19 entries having two separate lines really is just a reflection of local tax complexity, not an error. The underlying rule is that box 15 through 20 on a W-2 can carry up to four entries total if needed, though two is more common. FreeTaxUSA, like most major tax software, is built to handle that — the extra entry just isn't the default view when you first arrive at the local section.

0 coins

Up to four entries in boxes 15 through 20 — does that mean some people could have three or four different localities on a single W-2?

0 coins

Technically yes, though in practice three or four is unusual. Someone who worked across multiple jurisdictions for a single employer, or whose employer operates in a complex multi-locality area, could see more than two. Most software handles up to four, though the entry process gets more involved.

0 coins

Four locality entries on one W-2 sounds like a nightmare to enter in any software, but it's good to know it's supported. Most people will never see more than two.

0 coins

After getting my W-2 sorted with the two box 19 entries in FreeTaxUSA, I realized I'd also misread box 18 the first time — I thought the second box 18 amount was a continuation of box 17, which is state income tax withheld. The state and local sections are close together on the form and easy to confuse at a glance. Boxes 15-17 are the state block and boxes 18-20 are the local block; they're separate and need to be entered in their own sections in FreeTaxUSA.

0 coins

Mixing up box 17 and box 18 by looking at them too fast — did FreeTaxUSA put state and local in separate screens, or were they on the same page where the confusion could happen again?

0 coins

They're on the same W-2 entry page in FreeTaxUSA, one section below the other. The state section comes first and the local section is right beneath it, so it's easy to glance at the wrong line. Slower and more careful entry with the W-2 right next to the screen is the only real fix.

0 coins

The state and local sections running together on one screen is a known source of entry errors. Treating each numbered box on the W-2 as its own distinct field, rather than reading across a row visually, helps avoid that mix-up.

0 coins

Ended up filing a 2025 return with two box 19 amounts entered in FreeTaxUSA without any issue. The key confirmation for me was that my total local tax credit on the state return matched the sum of both box 19 entries — the state return was pulling both locality withholding amounts and crediting them correctly. If your state return's local credit section shows the right total, you know both entries came through correctly from the W-2 screen.

0 coins

Checking that the state return's local credit matches the sum of both box 19 entries — is that something you can verify within FreeTaxUSA before submitting, or only after you review the final return?

0 coins

You can check it in FreeTaxUSA before submitting by going to the review or summary screen for your state return. The local credit section should itemize what it's pulling in. If both locality amounts show there, the W-2 entries came through correctly.

0 coins

That state return cross-check is a good habit for anyone with two box 19 entries. Catching a missing locality amount there is much easier than dealing with it after filing.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure