Understanding Tax Implications of RSU Settlement - How to Track Taxes Paid
I've been receiving RSUs as part of my compensation package for about 5 years now. Every time they vest, I immediately sell them and invest the proceeds elsewhere since I don't want too much exposure to my company's stock. My employer uses Morgan Stanley to manage these RSUs. Here's what's confusing me: When I sell the vested shares, Morgan Stanley automatically sells enough shares to cover the tax obligation (withholding), but this tax payment doesn't seem to show up on the 1099 they send me at the end of the year. My W-2 shows the RSU proceeds as income, but I can't find where those taxes that were withheld are reflected either on my W-2 or anywhere else. I'm concerned that I'm being double-taxed because I can't show proof that those taxes were already paid when I sold the shares. Am I missing something here? Are those withheld taxes actually documented somewhere on my W-2 that I'm not seeing? Or should Morgan Stanley be providing some other documentation showing those taxes were paid?
18 comments
Join the conversation
Yuki Ito
The taxes withheld when your RSUs vest should definitely be showing up on your W-2, not a 1099. When RSUs vest, they're considered compensation income (just like your regular salary) and your employer should be withholding taxes at that point. When you look at your W-2, check boxes 1, 3, and 5 (for federal, Social Security, and Medicare wages) - these should include the value of your vested RSUs. Then look at boxes 2, 4, and 6, which show the corresponding withholding. The withholding amounts should include the taxes Morgan Stanley retained when your RSUs vested. The 1099 from Morgan Stanley is typically just reporting the sale transaction to the IRS, not the withholding. That's why you won't see the tax withholding there - it's already been handled as payroll withholding on your W-2.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
•This is confusing me too. So if Morgan Stanley sells some shares to cover the tax withholding, wouldn't that need to be reported as a sale somewhere? And does that mean I might be calculating my cost basis wrong when I eventually sell the remaining shares?
0 coins
Yuki Ito
•The shares sold to cover taxes are indeed reported as a sale, but that's separate from the tax withholding. When RSUs vest, there are typically two transactions happening: 1) The vesting itself, which is reported as income on your W-2 with corresponding tax withholding, and 2) The sale of shares, which Morgan Stanley would report on Form 1099-B. For your cost basis question, your basis in RSU shares is the fair market value on the vesting date (the same amount included in your W-2 income). If you sell immediately, there's usually minimal capital gain/loss to report since there's little time for the stock price to change between vesting and selling.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
I dealt with this exact RSU tax confusion last year and finally figured it out after hours of frustration! I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which helped me track down exactly where my RSU withholding was reported. They have a document analyzer that identifies exactly where on your W-2 the RSU income and withholding appears - it was in Box 14 with a special code my company uses for "RSU withholding" that I completely missed! The tool also explained how the withholding from Morgan Stanley flows through to my employer's payroll system and ultimately to my W-2. Apparently this is a super common issue with RSUs that confuses everyone. The analyzer even showed me how to reconcile the Morgan Stanley statements with my W-2 to prove everything matched up correctly.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•Does taxr.ai work for all brokerages or just Morgan Stanley? My company uses E*TRADE and I'm having similar issues finding where the tax withholding shows up.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
•I'm skeptical about these kinds of services. How exactly does it work? Seems like something you could figure out yourself by just calling your company's payroll department.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
•It works with all the major brokerages - Morgan Stanley, E*TRADE, Fidelity, Schwab, you name it. I've used it with both Morgan Stanley and Fidelity accounts when I switched jobs, and it handled both just fine. For skeptics, I totally get it - I tried calling payroll first but got nowhere. The issue is that payroll often doesn't understand the brokerage side, and the brokerage doesn't understand the payroll side. The tool basically analyzes all your documents together and maps out exactly where each number flows between them. It saved me hours of frustration after my payroll department kept transferring me around in circles.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
Just wanted to follow up about taxr.ai - I tried it with my E*TRADE RSU situation and it was actually really helpful! Turns out my company was reporting the RSU withholding in Box 14 of my W-2 with the code "ESTR" which I never would have figured out. The analyzer showed me exactly how to reconcile my brokerage statements with my W-2, and even identified that my company was slightly under-withholding on my RSUs (by about 2.8%) compared to my regular income. This explained why I kept owing a bit at tax time every year. I've adjusted my withholding on my regular paycheck to compensate. Definitely worth checking out if you're dealing with RSU tax confusion!
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
I struggled with this RSU tax withholding mess for years until I finally got through to someone at the IRS who could explain it properly. I wasted SO MUCH TIME on hold trying to get answers. If you're dealing with this and need to speak with the IRS, I'd recommend using Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) - they got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes instead of the usual endless hold times. There's a demo of how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The IRS agent confirmed that RSU withholding should appear on your W-2, not your 1099 from the brokerage. They explained exactly which boxes to check and what codes to look for. Having an actual conversation with someone who could walk me through my specific documents made all the difference.
0 coins
Mei Lin
•How does this Claimyr thing actually work? I thought it was impossible to get through to the IRS without waiting hours. Is it some kind of priority service?
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
•Yeah right. No way any service can get you through to the IRS faster than just waiting on hold yourself. Sounds like a waste of money for something you can do yourself for free.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
•It's not a priority service - they use technology to wait on hold for you, then call you back when an IRS agent answers. It monitors the hold music and detects when a human picks up. For the skeptics - I was exactly like you. I spent over 3 hours on hold multiple times trying to get through about my RSU withholding question. With Claimyr, I put in my number, went about my day, and got a call back when they connected with an agent. Saved me from being stuck listening to that awful hold music and freed me to do other things while waiting. The time savings alone was worth it to me.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
I have to eat my words about Claimyr. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it since I've been trying to reach the IRS about my RSU reporting issues for weeks. Not only did it work, but I got connected to an agent in about 35 minutes when I'd previously waited 2+ hours and still got disconnected. The IRS agent explained that my RSU withholding should be included in Box 2 of my W-2 along with my regular income tax withholding. The specific breakdown of RSU withholding vs. regular paycheck withholding might be listed in Box 14 with a special code, but it all gets lumped together in Box 2 for federal tax withholding. This finally explained why I couldn't "find" my RSU withholding - it was there all along, just combined with my regular withholding!
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
Something else to check - look at your paystub from around the time your RSUs vested. Many companies will show the RSU vesting as a line item on your paystub for that pay period, along with the associated tax withholding. This can help you reconcile everything. Also make sure to check if Morgan Stanley provides a "Supplemental Tax Reporting Statement" - sometimes the withholding information is on that document rather than the regular 1099-B they send.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
•That's a great suggestion about checking my paystubs! I just went back and looked at the pay periods when my RSUs vested, and sure enough, there's a separate line item showing "RSU Income" and corresponding withholding amounts. Everything seems to match up with what Morgan Stanley reported was withheld. I think I was getting confused because I was expecting to see something on the 1099 from Morgan Stanley, but now I understand it all flows through my employer's payroll system instead. Thanks for the help!
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
One thing nobody's mentioned - make sure you're tracking your cost basis correctly for when you sell! Since RSUs are already taxed as income when they vest, your cost basis for capital gains purposes is the fair market value on the vesting date. If you sell immediately, you'll have minimal capital gains/losses, but if you hold them for a while after vesting, you need to use that vesting date value as your basis.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•This is so important! I messed this up my first year with RSUs and accidentally double-paid taxes because I didn't adjust my cost basis correctly. Does anyone recommend a good tracking system for this if you have multiple vesting dates?
0 coins
Douglas Foster
•For tracking multiple vesting dates, I use a simple spreadsheet with columns for: vesting date, number of shares vested, fair market value per share on vesting date, total income reported (shares × FMV), and any shares sold for withholding. This gives me the cost basis for each batch of shares. Most brokerages like Morgan Stanley should also provide this information in their year-end tax documents, but I find it helpful to track it myself throughout the year. That way when I do my taxes, I can easily see which shares I'm selling from which vesting batch if I decide to hold some longer than others. The key thing to remember is that your cost basis is NOT what you originally paid (since RSUs are granted for free), but rather the fair market value when they vested - which is the same amount that got added to your W-2 income.
0 coins